New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Setting the record straight...

Craig

Senator
Supporting Member
I believe in God. Probably just not the same God you believe in. My God is distant and does not give a withered fig about you or your games. My God is, simply, energy. It, not He...and certainly not Jesus, ebbs and flows through all life forms.

I am pantheistic...Yes, a treehugger who finds little more amazing than a bird on the wing...

Pantheism is the view that God is everything and everyone and that everyone and everything is God.

How did I get there?

I was not fully schooled, or as many like to say when applied to any other form of learning, indoctrinated, into Christianity. I was baptized in the United Methodist Church and attended Sunday School for a few years. But the family moved...and stopped going to that church...and never picked up a new one. The old man found his faith on the golf course.

Now...understand that this is suburban Baltimore in the 50's and 60's...and it's not as if Christianity wasn't a major aspect of our culture. We had blue laws. Very little shopping could be done on Sunday; no liquor, no cars, no department stores. My neighborhood was chock a block with churches of various Christian sects...and we lived quite close to the main Jewish population, so synagogues were also part of the religious landscape. All of the variation in the belief of "God" imbued me with a skepticism of massive proportion. Teen dances were at the Lutheran Church...Boy Scouts at the Episcopal Church. Basketball at The Catholic School gym...Across from my high school was a Christian Science Church.

In one north Baltimore neighborhood, you'll find a massive Cathedral, right across the street is a large Methodist Church, and just down the road is a large Episcopal Church...along with a Friends Meeting House and school...and a Catholic Seminary. Seriously...like in two blocks. Travel down the road a bit and lo and behold...a Jewish Hospital and synagogues appear. With all of this apparent contention regarding belief, I was not able to find truth in the standard arguments, nor do I do so today. There was no unity, no one could agree on these matters, yet all seemed to claim metaphysical certitude. I was a doubter.

With the cultural turmoil of the 60's in full roil and our leaders, nearly all claiming Christianity and/or the "Judeo-Christian" outlook, went about slaughtering thousands upon thousands of people from both the US and throughout Southeast Asia. I began to see religion not as a protection or sanctuary, but as a shroud for poor behavior, not as a helpful force in dealing with one's internal problems. The times lead me to Eastern philosophies as folks were getting into yoga and transcendental meditation. The Beatles had joined with Maharishi Mahesh Yogi and over the next few years long philosophical and theological discussions occurred on a regular basis as folks were seeking something that made sense to them in the middle of all the mess that was taking place. The Buddhist outlook of cyclical aspect of decay and rebirth struck me. That made sense, as I could see the renewal; The basic concept I followed was...and is...Life Causes Death, Death Brings Life.

Today, I am pantheistic. I love the cycle of life and the immense variety of it. My little rural plot is home to deer, squirrel, groundhogs, cats, cardinals, crows, bluejays, house wrens, black snakes, blue skinks, sparrows, chickedees, nuthatches and woodpeckers, just to name a few and...all are god to me.

Also today, I have many members of my family who belong to a very...very...VERY...conservative Evangelical Apostolic Church. They say...Catholics are not Christian. The women can't cut their hair and wear long dresses. The Pastor wears a Rolex and drives a Cadillac. They drive me kinda crazy...

I have no animosity toward any religion, although the Islamists are getting a bit annoying, I must say. But I do see Christianity as a heavily divided religion that is supposed to be, imo, humble, quiet, helpful, loving and forgiving. So..when I encounter folks who claim to be Christian, yet seem entirely unfamiliar with the precepts above, I reject them. I chastise them. I mock them. They are the bitter fruit spoken of. So...hence the Starbucks coffee cup guy...who does not, in any way, speak for any save himself, is a target of my opprobrium. Christmas coffee cups? It's so far removed from the "reason for the season" it disgusts me.

Now you know.

So...Happy Thanksgiving, Merry Christmas, Happy Hanukkah...and bon hiver.
 
Okay. Pantheistic. So, as a Pantheistic, what motivates you toward kindness toward others? Toward putting anyone's desires or needs ahead of your own? Toward being able to experience any sort of love (since love implies caring for another entity at least almost as much as you care for yourself?

Do you experience love? Where do you think that might come from (assuming you do experience love at all)?

You've noted that when you do encounter folks who claim to be Christian, they don't seem to be familiar with the precepts which - lumped into one word - are "love". So from that I assume you understand that Christians are supposed to be loving and the normal state of humanity without Christianity backing a person would not be loving.

So where, if you have love in your life, do you think it comes from?

Interesting post, Craig.
 
So then....you think if someone says they're a Christian, then they MUST always be humble, quiet, helpful, loving & forgiving? I agree on some of that. I think it's ALWAYS necessary to forgive. I don't believe a Christian should be a bragger either. Jesus taught to be loving (love your enemy)....but he didn't teach us to be suckers. I also agree we should be helpful. But we must be "quiet" too? I hadn't heard that one before! So we shouldn't speak up for our beliefs, just stand back quietly? That's pretty funny. We're taught to spread the Word...and that's what many do. I think it's you and others like you that just wish we'd be quiet! Lol!
 
Okay. Pantheistic. So, as a Pantheistic, what motivates you toward kindness toward others? Toward putting anyone's desires or needs ahead of your own? Toward being able to experience any sort of love (since love implies caring for another entity at least almost as much as you care for yourself?

Do you experience love? Where do you think that might come from (assuming you do experience love at all)?

You've noted that when you do encounter folks who claim to be Christian, they don't seem to be familiar with the precepts which - lumped into one word - are "love". So from that I assume you understand that Christians are supposed to be loving and the normal state of humanity without Christianity backing a person would not be loving.

So where, if you have love in your life, do you think it comes from?

Interesting post, Craig.

The desire to do good comes from the desire to do good. It is its own reward. The Golden Rule is far older than Christianity.

You misread...horribly. Then you assume terribly. There is a YET...yet do not appear familiar...and that takes you down the wrong path.

You've noted that when you do encounter folks who claim to be Christian, they don't seem to be familiar with the precepts which - lumped into one word - are "love". So from that I assume you understand that Christians are supposed to be loving and the normal state of humanity without Christianity backing a person would not be loving.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Jen
So then....you think if someone says they're a Christian, then they MUST always be humble, quiet, helpful, loving & forgiving? I agree on some of that. I think it's ALWAYS necessary to forgive. I don't believe a Christian should be a bragger either. Jesus taught to be loving (love your enemy)....but he didn't teach us to be suckers. I also agree we should be helpful. But we must be "quiet" too? I hadn't heard that one before! So we shouldn't speak up for our beliefs, just stand back quietly? That's pretty funny. We're taught to spread the Word...and that's what many do. I think it's you and others like you that just wish we'd be quiet! Lol!

Not always. Mostly.

You're also told to pray in the closet.

I made this post due to the responses in the Starbucks thread. The man in the video is a loud obnoxious phony. THAT is the type of "Christian" I'm talking about.
 
I've agreed on the stupidity of the starbucks cup issue! If they'd put something derogatory on the cup that was anti-christian or anti-christmas then I could understand the rants. But they didn't so the whole thing is just stupid.
 
The desire to do good comes from the desire to do good. It is its own reward. The Golden Rule is far older than Christianity.

You misread...horribly. Then you assume terribly. There is a YET...yet do not appear familiar...and that takes you down the wrong path.

You've noted that when you do encounter folks who claim to be Christian, they don't seem to be familiar with the precepts which - lumped into one word - are "love". So from that I assume you understand that Christians are supposed to be loving and the normal state of humanity without Christianity backing a person would not be loving.

It wasn't my intention to misread and then assume wrong.
I do agree with you that many (dare I say "most"?) Christians use their religion as a weapon. And no Christian I have ever met is perfect. That is why I have walked away from religions. That said, I'm certainly not perfect.

I am Christian because I believe that Jesus is the "son" (the humanification) of the Entity we call "God". Jesus came to show us that we are Spirits that live beyond death.

I am fine with (agree with) your definition of God at the top of the OP as far as it goes. Religions and politics have corrupted what God is to the point where it's barely recognizable.
 
It wasn't my intention to misread and then assume wrong.
I do agree with you that many (dare I say "most"?) Christians use their religion as a weapon. And no Christian I have ever met is perfect. That is why I have walked away from religions. That said, I'm certainly not perfect.

I am Christian because I believe that Jesus is the "son" (the humanification) of the Entity we call "God". Jesus came to show us that we are Spirits that live beyond death.

I am fine with (agree with) your definition of God at the top of the OP as far as it goes. Religions and politics have corrupted what God is to the point where it's barely recognizable.

Thanks.

I simply believe the energy recycles into differing life forms. You're a gardener, I believe. Compost is a real life manifestation of this energy transfer. What was once alive has been used to our benefit, tossed...and the remaining energy and nutrients slowly become nutrient rich soil that feeds the plants...that feed the animals...that feed us...and then the cycle repeats. This is a true fact recognized in The Book of Common Prayer...we commit his body to the ground; earth to earth; ashes to ashes, dust to dust.

I don't expect perfection, but I do expect some attempt at adherence to what I believe are the basic principles of the religion. As one who gets attacked from various quarters whenever I discuss the subject, I felt the need to be clear about my feelings, beliefs and motivations.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Jen
I've agreed on the stupidity of the starbucks cup issue! If they'd put something derogatory on the cup that was anti-christian or anti-christmas then I could understand the rants. But they didn't so the whole thing is just stupid.

I know you agreed about the cups. But in that one regard, I'm talking about the personality...the "type" of noisy, self righteous person exposed in that video. He isn't "spreading the word". He's the "hate-theist"...Pat Robertson is a "hate-theist". These are nasty, judgmental people who use the "faith" not to help, but to bludgeon.

For me, it extends to real life...sort of...as I get called an atheist, a hate-theist, and ignorant...because of people like that guy in the video. The bitter fruit guy. So...I took the time to lay it out. I believe in God...just not the Christian God folks conjure due to one book. This will not satisfy those with overly rigid points of view.
 
Thanks.

I simply believe the energy recycles into differing life forms. You're a gardener, I believe. Compost is a real life manifestation of this energy transfer. What was once alive has been used to our benefit, tossed...and the remaining energy and nutrients slowly become nutrient rich soil that feeds the plants...that feed the animals...that feed us...and then the cycle repeats. This is a true fact recognized in The Book of Common Prayer...we commit his body to the ground; earth to earth; ashes to ashes, dust to dust.

I don't expect perfection, but I do expect some attempt at adherence to what I believe are the basic principles of the religion. As one who gets attacked from various quarters whenever I discuss the subject, I felt the need to be clear about my feelings, beliefs and motivations.
Thank you for doing that.
I believe what you have said here regarding our bodies but I believe our spirits live on. It's not a "if you have done enough good in your life" thing. We can't earn anything. It just is what it is. Our true "home" is in that spiritual form. We're just here to experience and learn. Not sure what it gains us in that spirit form, but I do believe there is a purpose.
 
Not always. Mostly.

You're also told to pray in the closet.

I made this post due to the responses in the Starbucks thread. The man in the video is a loud obnoxious phony. THAT is the type of "Christian" I'm talking about.

No, we're not told to pray in the closet.
 
No, we're not told to pray in the closet.

Yes, you are...

King James Bible

Matthew 6:5, 6:6...

And when thou prayest, thou shalt not be as the hypocrites are: for they love to pray standing in the synagogues and in the corners of the streets, that they may be seen of men. Verily I say unto you, They have their reward.

But thou, when thou prayest, enter into thy closet, and when thou hast shut thy door, pray to thy Father which is in secret; and thy Father which seeth in secret shall reward thee openly.


 
....My God is, simply, energy......
....I simply believe the energy recycles into differing life forms. You're a gardener, I believe. Compost is a real life manifestation of this energy transfer. What was once alive has been used to our benefit, tossed...and the remaining energy and nutrients slowly become nutrient rich soil that feeds the plants...that feed the animals...that feed us...and then the cycle repeats.......
Is this energy intelligent? Is it "alive" in that it moves at will? Is it sentient? Or is is inanimate like rock? Just a chemical/physical reaction like the Sun?
 
Is this energy intelligent? Is it "alive" in that it moves at will? Is it sentient? Or is is inanimate like rock? Just a chemical/physical reaction like the Sun?

ebbs and flows through all life forms.

If you weren't so insistent on editing and removing context, perhaps you'd understand the words before you.
 
ebbs and flows through all life forms.

If you weren't so insistent on editing and removing context, perhaps you'd understand the words before you.
You're dodging the question as expected, Craig. Energy and atoms ebb and flow through all life forms just as they do rocks and stars.

Please answer the questions: Is your god intelligent? Alive? Self-Aware? Or is it just energy like heat and as intelligent as a rock?
 
You're dodging the question as expected, Craig. Energy and atoms ebb and flow through all life forms just as they do rocks and stars.

Please answer the questions: Is your god intelligent? Alive? Self-Aware? Or is it just energy like heat and as intelligent as a rock?

I said, ALL LIFE FORMS...

My god is energy.
 
I said, ALL LIFE FORMS...

My god is energy.
Your continued refusal to answer a simple question tells me all I need to know. You're "god" is no more alive or intelligent than rock. You claim you're not an atheist, yet you obviously don't believe our intelligence transcends death nor that your "god" fits the definition of a god:

http://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/god
God : the perfect and all-powerful spirit or being that is worshipped especially by Christians, Jews, and Muslims as the one who created and rules the universe

: a spirit or being that has great power, strength, knowledge, etc., and that can affect nature and the lives of people : one of various spirits or beings worshipped in some religions
 
Your continued refusal to answer a simple question tells me all I need to know. You're "god" is no more alive or intelligent than rock. You claim you're not an atheist, yet you obviously don't believe our intelligence transcends death nor that your "god" fits the definition of a god:

http://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/god
God : the perfect and all-powerful spirit or being that is worshipped especially by Christians, Jews, and Muslims as the one who created and rules the universe

: a spirit or being that has great power, strength, knowledge, etc., and that can affect nature and the lives of people : one of various spirits or beings worshipped in some religions

I answer the question, you simply don't like it.

This will not satisfy those with overly rigid points of view.

As expected...

I never claimed my god was alive, nor that my god was intelligent. You simply can't get beyond your indoctrination...and your narrow and rigid point of view.
 
....I never claimed my god was alive, nor that my god was intelligent. You simply can't get beyond your indoctrination...and your narrow and rigid point of view.
Yeah, my "narrow and rigid point of view" is strictly according to Merriam-Webster.

Yes, you are free to make up your own words, your own definitions and to declare up is down, left is right and whatever else suits your fancy while declaring me to be "narrow and rigid". Just don't expect me to respect you as an intelligent, reasonable person when you do so.
 
Yeah, my "narrow and rigid point of view" is strictly according to Merriam-Webster.

Yes, you are free to make up your own words, your own definitions and to declare up is down, left is right and whatever else suits your fancy while declaring me to be "narrow and rigid". Just don't expect me to respect you as an intelligent, reasonable person when you do so.

Yes...I am free to make up my own version of God, just as the 35,000+ Christian sects do...just as Shinto and Buddhist and Jains and Sikhs and Pagans and every other spiritual path does. I find it difficult to believe any reasonable person could examine the way Amish live...and Catholics live...and worship...yet are considered the "same" due to the belief that Jesus is savior They clearly don't "worship" and "value" the same aspects of the religion, one building giant monuments, one eschewing such extravagance. Someone is wrong, no?

If you keep insisting on the rigid point of view as supplied by a Western dictionary, then you do. It merely reinforces my point concerning your rigid outlook.

http://content.time.com/time/interactive/0,31813,1549628,00.html

I've posted that info-graphic before...as I find it useful to delineate exactly how folks perceive "God".
 
Back
Top