New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Setting the record straight...

Yes...I am free to make up my own version of God, just as the 35,000+ Christian sects do...just as Shinto and Buddhist and Jains and Sikhs and Pagans and every other spiritual path does. I find it difficult to believe any reasonable person could examine the way Amish live...and Catholics live...and worship...yet are considered the "same" due to the belief that Jesus is savior They clearly don't "worship" and "value" the same aspects of the religion, one building giant monuments, one eschewing such extravagance. Someone is wrong, no?

If you keep insisting on the rigid point of view as supplied by a Western dictionary, then you do. It merely reinforces my point concerning your rigid outlook.

http://content.time.com/time/interactive/0,31813,1549628,00.html

I've posted that info-graphic before...as I find it useful to delineate exactly how folks perceive "God".
Note that all religions which have a "god" fit the Merriam-Webster definition.

As for Buddhism, there are three major sects. While they don't have a "god" per se, they do believe in a spiritual afterlife. Especially the Tibetan Buddhists with Buddha being reborn in the Dalai Lama.

You don't believe in an afterlife, just the cycle of matter and energy. Is this correct?
 
Note that all religions which have a "god" fit the Merriam-Webster definition.

As for Buddhism, there are three major sects. While they don't have a "god" per se, they do believe in a spiritual afterlife. Especially the Tibetan Buddhists with Buddha being reborn in the Dalai Lama.

You don't believe in an afterlife, just the cycle of matter and energy. Is this correct?

The cycle of matter and energy could manifest itself in an afterlife.

Funny. "all religions which have a god", followed by "they don't have a god per se"...

Yes...those which have a human vision of "God".

I make no assertions as to how the energy gets into the many various life forms. The renewal of energy can be in any form. Sometimes the energy is rather ephemeral; wind for one example. Electricity another. These forms exist, yet only help humans when harnessed. Nature deals with such energy in different ways. Strong winds can both tear down and strengthen a tree. Lightning can bring fire, which can destroy some life and then prepare the soil for renewal. Sequoia trees only reproduce when fire opens their cones and releases the seeds into the now burnt and bare soil.

All sorts of other considerations come into play, like the idea of cosmic consciousness. We might all have the knowledge of the Dalai Lama.
 
The cycle of matter and energy could manifest itself in an afterlife.

Funny. "all religions which have a god", followed by "they don't have a god per se"....
Matter and energy are not spiritual, they are physical. A religion or spiritual beliefs are, by definition, spiritual.

Note those two comments are in two different sentences about two different types of religions. Why do you find it funny?
 
Matter and energy are not spiritual, they are physical. A religion or spiritual beliefs are, by definition, spiritual.

Note those two comments are in two different sentences about two different types of religions. Why do you find it funny?

Energy is not physical.

To you, matter and energy are not spiritual. To me, they are. They affect my soul, my spirit.
 
Energy is not physical.

To you, matter and energy are not spiritual. To me, they are. They affect my soul, my spirit.
Energy is part of the physical universe and subject to universal laws such as the Laws of Thermodynamics.

Again, you are free make up your own definitions of "spiritual", but I'll stick with Merriam-Webster. http://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/spiritual
1: of, relating to, consisting of, or affecting the spirit : incorporeal
 
Yes, you are...

King James Bible

Matthew 6:5, 6:6...

And when thou prayest, thou shalt not be as the hypocrites are: for they love to pray standing in the synagogues and in the corners of the streets, that they may be seen of men. Verily I say unto you, They have their reward.

But thou, when thou prayest, enter into thy closet, and when thou hast shut thy door, pray to thy Father which is in secret; and thy Father which seeth in secret shall reward thee openly.

Yes, Jesus who went to temple, and who prayed in public told everyone else to pray in the closet. Do you think we believe Jesus is a hypocrite? That He wanted only to be seen? In his letters St. Paul discusses worship as well.

See, this is what I mean, Craig. You parse and pick for things you can twist because in your ignorance, you have no clue what Christ is teaching here. Note the first line.....".........thou shalt not be as the hypocrites are. They love to stand praying in the temples and on the street so that they may be seen by men."

The teaching here is humility. Don't go praying to be witnessed so that others think well of you.

And in my Bible, it's "room" not closet.

You get miffed because people call you ignorant, but you continue to pretend to know the faith when you clearly don't. IT doesn't matter where you played basketball or went to boy scouts.
 
ebbs and flows through all life forms.

If you weren't so insistent on editing and removing context, perhaps you'd understand the words before you.

Clearly a case of the pot calling the kettle rusty. You do this often and you just did it above. Context, Craig....it matters.
 
Clearly a case of the pot calling the kettle rusty. You do this often and you just did it above. Context, Craig....it matters.

Good Lord...That's a clarification from a previous edit of another poster.

Yes, we all sometimes edit a line. There are differing reasons for doing so. Max asked many questions, and some had nothing to do with life forms...hence, my reposting of the one line for clarification.
 
Yes, Jesus who went to temple, and who prayed in public told everyone else to pray in the closet. Do you think we believe Jesus is a hypocrite? That He wanted only to be seen? In his letters St. Paul discusses worship as well.

And in my Bible, it's "room" not closet. Yet...you challenge that.

See, this is what I mean, Craig. You parse and pick for things you can twist because in your ignorance, you have no clue what Christ is teaching here. Note the first line.....".........thou shalt not be as the h; it is clypocrites are. They love to stand praying in the temples and on the street so that they may be seen by men."

The teaching here is humility. Don't go praying to be witnessed so that others think well of you.

You get miffed because people call you ignorant, but you continue to pretend to know the faith when you clearly don't. IT doesn't matter where you played basketball or went to boy scouts.

Quite amazing. I have the King James...it is closet. I POSTED that passage. Now you attack the King James Bible...It's amazing, truly...truly...amazing.

Yes...it is about humility, which you do not display (as you AGAIN call me ignorant while disputing MY Bible)...which the coffee cup guy does not display...which not a single person on this board claiming to be Christian...displays....exactly what I said. It is NOT about screeching and acting as if you have the correct answer. Really...how can one say the Amish and Catholics have the "same" religion?

Why no comment on any of the guts of my tp? Why no comment on the vast difference between the way Christian sects operate? Because you'd rather attack me as ignorant, of course. This goes to my distaste for Western Religion...it requires a feeling of superiority.
 
Last edited:
Good Lord...That's a clarification from a previous edit of another poster.....
Which Gigi responded too. I'm guessing I'm not the only one who thinks your constant complaints about "edit(ing)" your posts (meaning taking only a single comment or paragraph) is egotistical and silly.

My questions have to do with exploring this "belief" you have about "god" and the universe. You believe "god" is the universe, but this god isn't alive, intelligent, animate or anything else. It's just the total physical composition of our Universe and operates strictly in accordance with natural laws. When and if the universe dies, then your god dies. Speaking of dying, you believe nothing of you or anyone else transcends death other than the atoms and energy which compose your body. Is this all correct?
 
Which Gigi responded too. I'm guessing I'm not the only one who thinks your constant complaints about "edit(ing)" your posts (meaning taking only a single comment or paragraph) is egotistical and silly.

My questions have to do with exploring this "belief" you have about "god" and the universe. You believe "god" is the universe, but this god isn't alive, intelligent, animate or anything else. It's just the total physical composition of our Universe and operates strictly in accordance with natural laws. When and if the universe dies, then your god dies. Speaking of dying, you believe nothing of you or anyone else transcends death other than the atoms and energy which compose your body. Is this all correct?

Yeah...she failed to follow your edit...and attacked me for it.

Is your God alive?
 
Yeah...she failed to follow your edit...and attacked me for it.

Is your God alive?
Quit being such a lightweight. She commented, she didn't attack you for it.

I believe in a force, an entity that is both intelligent and transcends the natural Universe. As such this entity is not alive as we know it since it cannot die. It has will and exists eternally. You choose to believe in a physical god, one tied to the existence of our Universe. It had a beginning and it will have an end. The entity I'm talking about is beyond time and space. It exists in the eternal now; not time or space.
 
Quit being such a lightweight. She commented, she didn't attack you for it.

I believe in a force, an entity that is both intelligent and transcends the natural Universe. As such this entity is not alive as we know it since it cannot die. It has will and exists eternally. You choose to believe in a physical god, one tied to the existence of our Universe. It had a beginning and it will have an end. The entity I'm talking about is beyond time and space. It exists in the eternal now; not time or space.

Yes...I choose, just as everyone does. Note: you believe that.
 
Quite amazing. I have the King James...it is closet. I POSTED that passage. Now you attack the King James Bible...It's amazing, truly...truly...amazing.

Yes...it is about humility, which you do not display (as you AGAIN call me ignorant while disputing MY Bible)...which the coffee cup guy does not display...which not a single person on this board claiming to be Christian...displays....exactly what I said. It is NOT about screeching and acting as if you have the correct answer. Really...how can one say the Amish and Catholics have the "same" religion?

Why no comment on any of the guts of my tp? Why no comment on the vast difference between the way Christian sects operate? Because you'd rather attack me as ignorant, of course. This goes to my distaste for Western Religion...it requires a feeling of superiority.

Please don't lie.
I didn't dispute your Bible. I simply said that in my Bible it's "room". Just a difference in translation that I thought was interesting and thought you would, too. But I think you knew that. No sane person could look at "BTW, in my bible its'"room" and suspect an attack.

And I didn't call you ignorant because of "your" bible. I called you ignorant because you are ignorant of what that passage is teaching us. You completely ignored or were honestly unaware of the facts that Jesus prayed in public, that St. Paul discussed the methods of public worship. If it's not ignorance, then it's a deliberate stab at pulling a line or two out of context to tell us we're doing something wrong.

In your book, Christians discussing our faith and what the Bible teaches us in response to your false statements, constitutes a lack of humility. That's your opinion and you're welcome to it.

I didn't comment on the guts of your top post because these are your beliefs and you shared them. Did you expect me to debate them with you? It's what you believe. I found it interesting to read. I will only debate you when you tell me what I should be believing or doing, if I disagree with what you say....like above.

I live among the Amish. They're good people. What do you feel is so unique about what they believe?
 
Please don't lie.
I didn't dispute your Bible. I simply said that in my Bible it's "room". Just a difference in translation that I thought was interesting and thought you would, too. But I think you knew that. No sane person could look at "BTW, in my bible its'"room" and suspect an attack.

And I didn't call you ignorant because of "your" bible. I called you ignorant because you are ignorant of what that passage is teaching us. You completely ignored or were honestly unaware of the facts that Jesus prayed in public, that St. Paul discussed the methods of public worship. If it's not ignorance, then it's a deliberate stab at pulling a line or two out of context to tell us we're doing something wrong.

In your book, Christians discussing our faith and what the Bible teaches us in response to your false statements, constitutes a lack of humility. That's your opinion and you're welcome to it.

I didn't comment on the guts of your top post because these are your beliefs and you shared them. Did you expect me to debate them with you? It's what you believe. I found it interesting to read. I will only debate you when you tell me what I should be believing or doing, if I disagree with what you say....like above.

I live among the Amish. They're good people. What do you feel is so unique about what they believe?

Yes...do not lie. I never told you to do anything. I commented to CJ...about what my Bible says....and you...again...called me ignorant.

In my Bible...it's closet. To argue that, to even mention that, is to challenge it. I know what the passage is teaching. It's obvious. And so...screeching about things like coffee cups...doesn't fit the bill. Also...obvious.

I never told you to do anything...and it's far..FAR...FAR more than "discussing" faith. It's screeching about it as if you have the only correct knowledge....as the coffee cup man does. It's the lack of humility...

The Amish do not go to war. The Amish do not build cathedrals. The Amish do not engage with society as a whole. The Catholic do. The Amish imbue their lives with an attitude of austerity. Others imbue themselves with an attitude of material wealth. Entirely differing outlooks and not comapatible in my view.

Again...with 35,000+ sects, I find it laughable that each and every one picks and chooses, yet each and every one believes they have the "correct" answer.

Every President has claimed to be Christian. The Pope claims the same.

A quick review...

I wrote this to CJ...


Not always. Mostly.

You're also told to pray in the closet.

I made this post due to the responses in the Starbucks thread. The man in the video is a loud obnoxious phony. THAT is the type of "Christian" I'm talking about.


And you shot this back...

No, we're not told to pray in the closet.


So...I did not tell you what to do. Yes...yes, you are told to pray in the closet. Your response was to call me ignorant. Humility.
 
Yes...do not lie. I never told you to do anything. I commented to CJ...about what my Bible says....and you...again...called me ignorant.

In my Bible...it's closet. To argue that, to even mention that, is to challenge it. I know what the passage is teaching. It's obvious. And so...screeching about things like coffee cups...doesn't fit the bill. Also...obvious.

I never told you to do anything...and it's far..FAR...FAR more than "discussing" faith. It's screeching about it as if you have the only correct knowledge....as the coffee cup man does. It's the lack of humility...

The Amish do not go to war. The Amish do not build cathedrals. The Amish do not engage with society as a whole. The Catholic do. The Amish imbue their lives with an attitude of austerity. Others imbue themselves with an attitude of material wealth. Entirely differing outlooks and not comapatible in my view.

Again...with 35,000+ sects, I find it laughable that each and every one picks and chooses, yet each and every one believes they have the "correct" answer.

Every President has claimed to be Christian. The Pope claims the same.

A quick review...

I wrote this to CJ...





And you shot this back...




So...I did not tell you what to do. Yes...yes, you are told to pray in the closet. Your response was to call me ignorant. Humility.


I didn't attack your Bible or dispute it. I commented on your culling out two lines to support your error. It's becoming quite clear to me that you view any disagreement with your opinion and any discourse on interpretation as a failure to exercise humility. Just an FYI because it's a common mistake anti-Christian folks love to make: Turn the other cheek doesn't mean shut up, sit down, and let the world mock you and misrepresent what you believe is true. It means to stand up and continue speaking what you know to be the truth and doing what you know to be the right thing, regardless of who attacks you. So if you're expecting to use our own vocal disagreements with your mischaracterizations against us, it won't work out for you.
I didn't call you ignorant because you said we're told to pray in a closet. I called you ignorant because while you admit that you left the Christian faith as a child and never went back, you make pronouncements on what Christ teaches us . That's not only ignorant, it's arrogant. Your geographic proximity to various churches growing up makes you no more learned in the faith than growing up near an airport makes me qualified to fly a plane.

I find it not laughable but unfortunate that there are so many Christian sects that vary in belief. But that's Protestantism. Take it up with them. However, most Christians, Protestant and Catholic recognize and celebrate the common beliefs we share that Christ is our Savior, who suffered and died for us and rose again on the third day, who paid the debt for our sins, who opened the gates of heaven for us where He wants to spend eternity with us in the Kingdom, that God loves us and that through Him all things are possible. That's how it is that we can sit beside each other and pray. If you had an inkling how precious those truths are to us and how common the joy is among people who accept them, then you'd understand how it is that they trump the differences we experience. And you would understand how we recognize each other as brothers and sisters in Christ.

The cathedrals that you mention were built by people so in love with God that they wanted to build the most beautiful place they could to house His Tabernacle and worship Him.
I live in Amish country. Again, nice people...but 'austere" is not the word we'd use to describe their way of life.
 
I didn't attack your Bible or dispute it. I commented on your culling out two lines to support your error. It's becoming quite clear to me that you view any disagreement with your opinion and any discourse on interpretation as a failure to exercise humility. Just an FYI because it's a common mistake anti-Christian folks love to make: Turn the other cheek doesn't mean shut up, sit down, and let the world mock you and misrepresent what you believe is true. It means to stand up and continue speaking what you know to be the truth and doing what you know to be the right thing, regardless of who attacks you. So if you're expecting to use our own vocal disagreements with your mischaracterizations against us, it won't work out for you.
I didn't call you ignorant because you said we're told to pray in a closet. I called you ignorant because while you admit that you left the Christian faith as a child and never went back, you make pronouncements on what Christ teaches us . That's not only ignorant, it's arrogant. Your geographic proximity to various churches growing up makes you no more learned in the faith than growing up near an airport makes me qualified to fly a plane.

I find it not laughable but unfortunate that there are so many Christian sects that vary in belief. But that's Protestantism. Take it up with them. However, most Christians, Protestant and Catholic recognize and celebrate the common beliefs we share that Christ is our Savior, who suffered and died for us and rose again on the third day, who paid the debt for our sins, who opened the gates of heaven for us where He wants to spend eternity with us in the Kingdom, that God loves us and that through Him all things are possible. That's how it is that we can sit beside each other and pray. If you had an inkling how precious those truths are to us and how common the joy is among people who accept them, then you'd understand how it is that they trump the differences we experience. And you would understand how we recognize each other as brothers and sisters in Christ.

The cathedrals that you mention were built by people so in love with God that they wanted to build the most beautiful place they could to house His Tabernacle and worship Him.
I live in Amish country. Again, nice people...but 'austere" is not the word we'd use to describe their way of life.


"...if you had an inkling..."

Yes..I cut the line...because it again says...you're ignorant. You can't help yourself. I have an "inkling". I know what the passage means. Your arrogance astounds, you don't try to teach, you lecture. Just as the other noisy Christians here lecture.

You also tell me that all my discussions and explorations into faith and the folks I've met of differing faiths over the years of various faith is meaningless, like living next to an airport. Astounding.

Then, you tell me the story of Christ, as if I haven't heard it. Astounding.

Then you tell me that folks built Cathedrals to show their love. Astounding.

Then...you also tell me I don't what austere means. Astounding.

aus·tere
ôˈstir/
adjective
  1. severe or strict in manner, attitude, or appearance.
    "an austere man, with a rigidly puritanical outlook"
    synonyms: severe, stern, strict, harsh, steely, flinty, dour, grim, cold, frosty,unemotional, unfriendly; More



Plain...unadorned...modest...is how the Amish near me live...and they too, love God, yet built not one Cathedral.
 
"...if you had an inkling..."

Yes..I cut the line...because it again says...you're ignorant. You can't help yourself. I have an "inkling". I know what the passage means. Your arrogance astounds, you don't try to teach, you lecture. Just as the other noisy Christians here lecture.

You also tell me that all my discussions and explorations into faith and the folks I've met of differing faiths over the years of various faith is meaningless, like living next to an airport. Astounding.

Then, you tell me the story of Christ, as if I haven't heard it. Astounding.

Then you tell me that folks built Cathedrals to show their love. Astounding.

Then...you also tell me I don't what austere means. Astounding.

aus·tere
ôˈstir/
adjective
  1. severe or strict in manner, attitude, or appearance.
    "an austere man, with a rigidly puritanical outlook"
    synonyms: severe, stern, strict, harsh, steely, flinty, dour, grim, cold, frosty,unemotional, unfriendly; More



Plain...unadorned...modest...is how the Amish near me live...and they too, love God, yet built not one Cathedral.

We all lecture, Craig. It's the nature of a message board. It's not a chat room where we would converse. We all write out what we want to say and leave it for each other to read or not. But yes, we've already covered the fact that Christians who stand up to your false statements and misrepresentations are "noisy" as far as you're concerned. So what? We've also already covered the fact that your constant accusations of such aren't going to shut anyone down.

I didn't say your exploration was meaningless. I said that living near churches doesn't make you learned in the faith that you parse on. And by the way, let's look at what you said there.

You say that Jesus wants us to pray in closets. To support your claim that you know what you're talking about when you discuss Christianity, you discuss the people you've met from the various CHURCHES in your neighborhood. Are we to understand that these people from these CHURCHES told you Jesus doesn't want us worshiping in churches?

Jesus said "On this rock (Peter) I build My Church." He didn't say "On this rock I build My closet." He said "wherever two or more of you are gathered, I will be there among you." He didn't say "You have to be alone in your closet if you want to commune with Me." Two or more...How many people fit in the average closet, Craig?

Jesus told the apostles to go out into the world and teach. He didn't say go drop off some writing and leave it to the people to figure it out on their own. And from those earliest days Christians risked their lives to worship and pray together. Try reading the Acts.

Come to church, have a listen before you decide what everyone else's motives are. Or don't and just accept that you don't know what we believe or why we believe what we do.
From your top post it seemed like this thread was going to be about you and your experiences and beliefs. But then you had to pounce out at a Christian with "Jesus told you to pray in closets". And now you're just astounded that a Christian is arguing with you about your error. You've abandoned the discussion you started in favor of naming my flaws and the "errors" you perceive in the practice of a faith you....don't have an inkling about.
 
Back
Top