New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Settled Science Update

When the warmies' weird weather panic religion requires them to equate fighting diseases like HIV and cancer with fighting "global warming", it's time to abandon rational discussion and call the cult deprogrammers.
The comparison is a strong one. In both cases, it came down to how public policy should be set in the face of a problem that experts were predicting would get much worse. In one case, we listened to the experts and got things under control (even as they raged out of control elsewhere, thanks to the experts being largely ignored). In the other case, we're going down a path where we refuse to let the science guide policy, much like South Africa in the face of the AIDS crisis.
 
Not only do I deny that, I think that saying it's a hoax is a sure-fire sign that a person is mentally ill. It's one thing to take the view that the vast majority of climate scientists are getting things wrong. That might be arrogant (for a lay person who has made no serious effort to study the matter), but it's at least not insane. But imagining a hoax that pulls in tens of thousands of experts from every major nation on earth, working for a wide variety of employers, with dramatically different prejudices and incentives, takes a special kind of paranoia. Anyone who really thinks climate change is a hoax (as opposed to anyone who just says it to troll or to accomplish some cynical political goal) is suffering from some serious mental issue and should probably be medicated before he harms himself or others.

Anyway, do you see how your Grist article clearly contradicts your claim about Gore saying he exaggerated negative effects? You quote him saying that he relies on FACTUAL presentations about how dangerous it is. He doesn't say anything about exaggerating. He's answering a specific question about whether the science education should focus on scaring people about what's going wrong, or giving them hope about what can be done. He comes down on the side of leaning more towards scaring them. Although he sticks to factual presentations, he over-represents them relative to the hopeful messaging. He thinks that in the future, when there's broader understanding of how big the risk is, you can change to a mix where you over-represent the discussion of the solutions.
What?? What a clear misrepresentation of what he said.

He clearly means he over-states the possible effects in order to grab people's attention and make them more afraid of what wouldn't sound scary if he just told the truth.

Now we're seeing the effects of that on the public. Too bad for your bogus science side The leftists are perpetrating a hoax to spread their anti-capitalist agenda. This is done by twisting and manipulating the numbers, leaving science out of the picture. That's the hoax.
 
as the enclosed link clearly shows -

85% of the "record highs" (all 50 states) happened before 1950.

and half of the "record lows" (again, all 50 states), happened after 1950

some tidbits:

- America's all time high - 134 degrees - july 1913, death valley California
- America's record low - minus 80 degrees - January 1971, prospect creek Alaska
- Alaska's all time high - June 1915 - 100 degrees, fort Yukon
- Hawaii's all time low - January 1975, moana kea, 15 degrees
- lower 48 states all time low - January 1954 - minus 70 - rogers pass, Montana
- Montana's all time high - 117 degrees - july 1937, medicine lake

and so on and so forth

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/U.S._state_temperature_extremes
 
The comparison is a strong one. In both cases, it came down to how public policy should be set in the face of a problem that experts were predicting would get much worse. In one case, we listened to the experts and got things under control (even as they raged out of control elsewhere, thanks to the experts being largely ignored). In the other case, we're going down a path where we refuse to let the science guide policy, much like South Africa in the face of the AIDS crisis.

I'm proud of you for not editing out the parts of my post that hurt your feelings. That's progress!
 
What?? What a clear misrepresentation of what he said.

Yes, you clearly misrepresented what he said. So are you going to apologize? As you can see, he never said a thing about exaggerating the dangers. In fact, he very clearly specified that he was talking about the factual dangers. The context makes it very clear that he was simply talking about the proper mix of the two types of messages: communicating the risks, and communicating the hope for change. He believes you should overrepresent the former in your presentations today, though he believes in the future a different mix would make sense.

Anyway, I'm curious -- do you find yourself believing in a lot of conspiracy theories, or is it just the climate change "hoax"? The nutjobs I know in real life who believe climate change is a hoax are generally conspiratorial minded across a wide array of topics -- e.g., believing Obama was born in Kenya, or that JFK was killed by the FBI, or the WTC was brought down by planted explosives, or that the government is using fluoride to control our minds, etc. It seems to be part of a broad-based mental illness, rather than something specific to the topic. How about you? Is this a narrow bit of paranoia, or something that plays out in your belief system repeatedly?
 
No. As you can see, that won't help. Even surprisingly accurate predictions, like the one I discussed from Hansen above (where he correctly predicted that over the next 20 years the warming would become great enough to overwhelm short-term variability) will simply be taken by stupid and/or dishonest people and misrepresented to be an inaccurate prediction. They need there to be inaccurate predictions, because they're emotionally wedded to the idea that global warming isn't happening. So, if they can look through millions of statements and find a few genuine inaccuracies, they'll do that, and trumpet those endlessly, but even if they were denied that, they'd just make something up. When you're facing off against horrible people like that, it really doesn't matter how scrupulous and careful you are -- they'll either fixate on a rare mistake or they'll invent one for you.

You discussed one, at great length, as always. I posted several, which of course you dismissed out of hand. This is what passes as intellectual honesty for you.

The climate does change, always has and always will. A certain political party tells us that it is very bad now, and that we are doomed unless we - Surprise! - give money and power to them. They know best, and they have charts and graphs to show that they know best. Never question their charts and graphs, ever.

Now, if something they asserted proves not be be true, don't worry about that -The science is settled. That is the nature of science after all - Start with the conclusion, accept only facts that support the conclusion, and then it is settled and should never be revisited. The important thing is make sure the right people are in charge and have the power. Oh, and funding, lots and lots of funding, can't forget about that. And while the science is settled, the problem (that we're all doomed unless the right people are in charge) never goes away. Not ever. Funding and power in perpetuity.

That, of course, is good enough for you. Any dissenters are labeled as "Deniers" (that fits conveniently on a bumper sticker) and are marginalized as dangerous heretics - The infallible graphs and charts prove that they are.

Very important to remind people that if they do not get in line and conform to what that certain political party says they must do unquestioningly, that they are horrible ignorant people that hate the earth. Their place is to obey and nod in assent. The science is settled, because they say so.
 
as the enclosed link clearly shows -

85% of the "record highs" (all 50 states) happened before 1950.

and half of the "record lows" (again, all 50 states), happened after 1950

some tidbits:

- America's all time high - 134 degrees - july 1913, death valley California
- America's record low - minus 80 degrees - January 1971, prospect creek Alaska
- Alaska's all time high - June 1915 - 100 degrees, fort Yukon
- Hawaii's all time low - January 1975, moana kea, 15 degrees
- lower 48 states all time low - January 1954 - minus 70 - rogers pass, Montana
- Montana's all time high - 117 degrees - july 1937, medicine lake

and so on and so forth

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/U.S._state_temperature_extremes
You seem to be in the wrong thread. This one is about global warming.
 
You discussed one, at great length, as always.

I discussed two. I suppose I could go down through them all, but it took me far longer with each of those to respond than it took you to mindlessly cut and paste the whole list. So if I get in the habit of becoming our resident "Gish Gallop" debunker, I'm setting myself up for a contest that's impossible to win. By the time I could post a solid debunking of ten points, you could mindless cut and paste another hundred points from the various right-wing propaganda sites that tell you what to believe.

So, instead, I stick to a more targeted approach: doing enough to show any rational people that they'd be wise to double-check the claims from a given source before relying on them. Given that the source was not reliable on either of the two claims I checked, people would be foolish to believe it's a reliable source overall. Possibly some of the claims aren't flawed that way. Possibly all of them are. People should double check with a more credible source before relying on it.

The climate does change, always has and always will

Yes. And going back at least 150,000 years, it has never changed at anywhere near the current pace -- in fact, warming has never, in all that time, been within an order of magnitude of the current pace. A certain political party tells the dummies that this unprecedented warming is no big deal, and SURPRISE, the fossil fuel industries hand them enormous amounts of money for that. Meanwhile, the actual experts believe it's a very big deal.

The infallible graphs and charts prove that they are.
When you come up for air from wrestling that straw man you've constructed, think about the fact that nobody has ever claimed the graphs and charts are infallible. In fact, if you see above, I discussed how Hansen's 1986 prediction missed slightly (predicting 1 degree of total global warming by 2006, whereas it was actually 0.93 degrees). There's always going to be some fallibility in the field. But the question is whether we fixate on that fallibility as an excuse to believe crap we want to believe for reasons totally unrelated to the science. That's what the right-wing wants us to do. They like the idea of unfettered greenhouse gas emissions, so they embrace as a religious doctrine that human greenhouse gas emissions aren't going to be a problem, and the more evidence piles up saying they're wrong, the more desperately they'll fixate on any tiny error to try to excuse complacency. The science can never be settled enough to inform public policy choices, in their minds, because they know what it'll mean if it does.
 
Last edited:
I discussed two. I supposed I could go down through them all, but it took me far longer with each of those to respond than it took you to mindlessly cut and paste the whole list. So if I get in the habit of becoming our resident "Gish Gallop" debunker, I'm setting myself up for a contest that's impossible to win. By the time I could post a solid debunking of ten points, you could mindless cut and paste another hundred points from the various right-wing propaganda sites that tell you what to believe.

So, instead, I stick to a more targeted approach: doing enough to show any rational people that they'd be wise to double-check the claims from a given source before relying on them. Given that the source was not reliable on either of the two claims I checked, people would be foolish to believe it's a reliable source overall. Possibly some of the claims aren't flawed that way. Possibly all of them are. People should double check with a more credible source before relying on it.



Yes. And going back at least 150,000 years, it has never changed at anywhere near the current pace -- in fact, warming has never, in all that time, been within an order of magnitude of the current pace. A certain political party tells the dummies that this unprecedented warming is no big deal, and SURPRISE, the fossil fuel industries hand them enormous amounts of money for that. Meanwhile, the actual experts believe it's a very big deal.

When you come up for air from wrestling that straw man you've constructed, think about the fact that nobody has ever claimed the graphs and charts are infallible. In fact, if you see above, I discussed how Hansen's 1986 prediction missed slightly (predicting 1 degree of total global warming by 2006, whereas it was actually 0.93 degrees). There's always going to be some fallibility in the field. But the question is whether we fixate on that fallibility as an excuse to believe crap we want to believe for reasons totally unrelated to the science. That's what the right-wing wants us to do. They like the idea of unfettered greenhouse gas emissions, so they embrace as a religious doctrine that human greenhouse gas emissions aren't going to be a problem, and the more evidence piles up saying they're wrong, the more desperately they'll fixate on any tiny error to try to excuse complacency. The science can never be settled enough to inform public policy choices, in their minds, because they know what it'll mean if it does.

See how deeply entrenched you are? No I suppose not.

A true believer, who will never question anything he has already decided to believe in. He's all done thinking, he's arrived.....:>)
 
Rather than responding to the entire "Gish Gallop" here, I'll focus on just one of the persistent lies that keeps making the rounds:

Two years later, Dr. Hansen told an interviewer that in 20 years, the area below his New York City office would be completely changed, most notably that “the West Side Highway [which runs along the Hudson River] will be under water.”
​
So, did Hansen actually tell an interviewer that in 20 years the West Side Highway would be under water? Check your own link, embedded in the bolded, blue text, for an answer. According to that link, both of those involved in the conversation report that Hansen had been asked to speculate about what would happen in forty years, if CO2 doubled.

So, the prediction is based on what things would look like in 2028 if CO2 reached 560 ppm. Right now CO2 is about 407 ppm and increasing about 2.11 ppm per year. So by 2028, it'll be around 430.21 ppm. If the rate keeps going up by 2.11/year, we'd be at the 560 ppm mark by 2089. Will the West Side Highway be under water by then? No clue. But if you're going to fault Hansen, obviously you should do so based on what he actually said, not some claim you are putting into his mouth.
If Co2 doubled, it would not raise global temps and so no flooding of the West Side Highway, anyway.

But don't let me ruin your fun, keep on speculating.
 
If Co2 doubled, it would not raise global temps and so no flooding of the West Side Highway, anyway.
The world's leading experts disagree with you, based on their many years of advanced education on the topic, and long careers engaged in studying it. But, you've got a few links to right-wing websites run by non-scientists, so surely you know better, right?
 
The world's leading experts disagree with you, based on their many years of advanced education on the topic, and long careers engaged in studying it. But, you've got a few links to right-wing websites run by non-scientists, so surely you know better, right?
I've got 800,000 years of ice core data that tells us rising CO2 levels is produced by rising global temps... but rising CO2 levels do not produce rising global temps.

You have the same ice core studies, so do all the scientists ... whether their politics are on the right or the left.
 
I've got 800,000 years of ice core data that tells us rising CO2 levels is produced by rising global temps... but rising CO2 levels do not produce rising global temps.

No. What those cores tell you is that in past cycles, warming preceded CO2 increases. Back then, there was no species digging up vast amounts of ancient hydrocarbons from deep beneath the earth and burning them, so there wasn't a mechanism by which the CO2 could be the start of the process. Instead, it was part of a positive feedback loop that made the process worse. This time around, the CO2 increases have preceded the warming, as confirmed by the ice cores. CO2 levels rose at an unprecedented pace starting with the industrial revolution, and more recently temperatures started rising at an unprecedented pace. The data is clear, but it's uncomfortable for you from a political perspective, so you try to jam it into a nonsensical interpretation.
 
No. What those cores tell you is that in past cycles, warming preceded CO2 increases. Back then, there was no species digging up vast amounts of ancient hydrocarbons from deep beneath the earth and burning them, so there wasn't a mechanism by which the CO2 could be the start of the process. Instead, it was part of a positive feedback loop that made the process worse. This time around, the CO2 increases have preceded the warming, as confirmed by the ice cores. CO2 levels rose at an unprecedented pace starting with the industrial revolution, and more recently temperatures started rising at an unprecedented pace. The data is clear, but it's uncomfortable for you from a political perspective, so you try to jam it into a nonsensical interpretation.
that is some kind of goofy science, Ark.

CO2 produced by burning oil raised global temps in the ice cores? Because CO2 produced by burning oil is different from CO2 produced by burning wood? Is that what you just said?

When did ice core data reverse itself on CO2 spikes lagging temp spikes? "this time around" = when, exactly?

Are you saying that CO2 did not result in rising global temps since the dawn of time, for tens of millions of years, but all that changed 50 years ago?
 
that is some kind of goofy science, Ark.

Nope. It's entirely mainstream.

CO2 produced by burning oil raised global temps in the ice cores?

Yes.

CO2 produced by burning oil is different from CO2 produced by burning wood?

Yes, of course it is. Were you not aware of that? Research isotope ratios.

When did ice core data reverse itself on CO2 spikes lagging temp spikes? "this time around" = when, exactly?

With the industrial revolution.

Are you saying that CO2 did not result in rising global temps since the dawn of time, for tens of millions of years, but all that changed 50 years ago?

No, I'm not saying that. How odd that you'd imagine I was.
 
Nope. It's entirely mainstream.



Yes.



Yes, of course it is. Were you not aware of that? Research isotope ratios.



With the industrial revolution.



No, I'm not saying that. How odd that you'd imagine I was.
Have to ask, cuz you won't come out and say it on your own. So let's see how much I have pulled from your hen's teeth...

The CO2 carbon isotope achieved by burning oil - since the industrial revolution - 1700? - has produced global warming in ice cores - since 1700? Is that your position? And that is mainstream position? Go ahead and tell us exactly which Carbon isotope has such a dramatic effect on global warming versus which carbon isotope that has never had such an effect... what are you saying, are you saying Carbon 12 isotope produces global warming versus Carbon 14 doesn't? And that's proven by the ice cores since when, exactly?
 
Have to ask, cuz you won't come out and say it on your own. So let's see how much I have pulled from your hen's teeth...

The CO2 carbon isotope achieved by burning oil - since the industrial revolution - 1700? - has produced global warming in ice cores - since 1700? Is that your position? And that is mainstream position? Go ahead and tell us exactly which Carbon isotope has such a dramatic effect on global warming versus which carbon isotope that has never had such an effect... what are you saying, are you saying Carbon 12 isotope produces global warming versus Carbon 14 doesn't? And that's proven by the ice cores since when, exactly?

a few years ago, "climate science" people observed that "it's as hot now as it was 2,000 years ag0, when Jesus lived"

Ok - lets set aside any questions on how we know the temperature 2000 years ago (tree rings? fossilized coral?)

instead - let's ask the unobvious question: since there were no SUVs 2000 year ago, what made it so hot? What made it cool down 1,000 years later in the mini ice age? clearly 99.9% of earth's temperature fluctuations have zero to do with fossil fuels.
 
a few years ago, "climate science" people observed that "it's as hot now as it was 2,000 years ag0, when Jesus lived"

Ok - lets set aside any questions on how we know the temperature 2000 years ago (tree rings? fossilized coral?)

instead - let's ask the unobvious question: since there were no SUVs 2000 year ago, what made it so hot? What made it cool down 1,000 years later in the mini ice age? clearly 99.9% of earth's temperature fluctuations have zero to do with fossil fuels.
Ice core data prove conclusively that global temps produce higher carbon levels (more heat = more life = more carbon) ... but they also prove conclusively that the higher carbon levels do not produce higher temps. There does seem to be a trend of higher carbon levels followed by dropping temps, but I haven't heard any convincing theories explaining how that would work. I don't think higher carbon levels have any effect of temps, either way, the temps go up and down on their own and the carbon levels follow the temps.

Greenhouse gases have not done anything to global temps forever, but Arkady seems to think they have. I'm still waiting to be enlightened by him on ice core data that backs up his theory, I have not seen or heard any ice core data that would prove carbon dioxide of any isotope produces global warming,
 
A look back at what they said, and who said it:

Wisconsin Senator Gaylord Nelson, the father of Earth Day said before the first Earth Day in 1970 that “the secretary of the Smithsonian Institute believes that in 25 years, somewhere between 75 and 80 percent of all the species of living animals will be extinct.”

Not to be outdone, Life Magazine reported that same year that “Scientists have solid experimental and theoretical evidence to support…the following predictions: In a decade, urban dwellers will have to wear gas masks to survive air pollution…by 1985 air pollution will have reduced the amount of sunlight reaching earth by one half….”

Stanford biologist Paul Ehrlich, the celebrated author of The Climate Bomb, wrote in 1971 that "by the year 2000 the United Kingdom will be simply a small group of impoverished islands, inhabited by some 70 million hungry people … If I were a gambler, I would take even money that England will not exist in the year 2000.”

In 1975 Newsweek ran a now-infamous article entitled “The Cooling World,” which cited several climate scientists in concluding that “the central fact is that…the earth’s climate seems to be cooling down…If the climate change is as profound as some of the pessimists fear, the resulting famines could be catastrophic.”

Global famine was a popular prediction in the 70’s. North Texas State professor Pete Gunter summed up the prevailing sentiment when he wrote in “The Lving Wilderness” that by “by the year 2000...the entire world, with the exception of Western Europe, North America, and Australia, will be in famine.”

In 1986, NASA scientist James Hansen testified before Congress that “global temperatures should be nearly 2 degrees higher in 20 years, ‘which is about the warmest the earth has been in the last 100,000 years.’”

Two years later, Dr. Hansen told an interviewer that in 20 years, the area below his New York City office would be completely changed, most notably that “the West Side Highway [which runs along the Hudson River] will be under water.”

Even the great Carl Sagan predicted in 1990 that “the planet could face an ‘ecological and agricultural catastrophe’ by the next decade if global warming trends continue.”

That same year, Dr. Michael Oppenheimer with The Environmental Defense Fund wrote:

By 1995, the greenhouse effect would be desolating the heartlands of North America and Eurasia with horrific drought, causing crop failures and food riots…”(By 1996) The Platte River of Nebraska would be dry, while a continent-wide black blizzard of prairie topsoil will stop traffic on interstates, strip paint from houses and shut down computers…The Mexican police will round up illegal American migrants surging into Mexico seeking work as field hands.

As recently as the last decade, both Dr. Hansen and Peter Wadhams, the head of the Polar Ocean Physics Group at the University of Cambridge, believe “that the Arctic is likely to become ice-free...as early as 2015.”

That’s actually two years later than Al Gore predicted in 2007, 2008, and 2009, when he cited what he called a scientific consensus to claim that the North Pole would be “ice free by 2013.”

That’s good, because Pentagon scientists sure weren’t in 2003, when their report “An Abrupt Climate Change Scenario and its Implications for United States National Security” warned that within 10 years, “it was not implausible” that parts of California would be flooded, parts of the Netherlands would be uninhabitable, and an unprecedented rise in hurricanes, tsunamis, and tornadoes would spark wars across the globe as people fought for increasingly scarce resources.

Not to be outdone, scientists with the United Nations Environment Programme warned in 2005 that man-made global warming would so decimate coastal areas as well as the Caribbean and Pacific islands that there would be upwards of 50 million “climate refugees by 2010.”

Of course, none of these scientific predictions—from Earth Day straight through today—have ever actually been right, but more predictions keep coming...along with more admonitions that the science is settled.


http://newstalk1130.iheart.com/onai...rief-history-of-fantastically-wrong-15767677/


I can't wait for the next round of predictions....:>)
Settled Bullshit is a more accurate term.
 
Back
Top