New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Settled Science Update

Not only do I deny that, I think that saying it's a hoax is a sure-fire sign that a person is mentally ill. It's one thing to take the view that the vast majority of climate scientists are getting things wrong. That might be arrogant (for a lay person who has made no serious effort to study the matter), but it's at least not insane. But imagining a hoax that pulls in tens of thousands of experts from every major nation on earth, working for a wide variety of employers, with dramatically different prejudices and incentives, takes a special kind of paranoia. Anyone who really thinks climate change is a hoax (as opposed to anyone who just says it to troll or to accomplish some cynical political goal) is suffering from serious mental issue and should probably be medicated before he harms himself or others.

Anyway, do you see how your Grist article clearly contradicts your claim about Gore saying he exaggerated negative effects? You quote him saying that he relies on FACTUAL presentations about how dangerous it is. He doesn't say anything about exaggerating. He's answering a specific question about whether the science education should focus on scaring people about what's going wrong, or giving them hope about what can be done. He comes down on the side of leaning more towards scaring them. Although he sticks to factual presentations, he over-represents the discussion of the danger relative to the hopeful messaging. He thinks that in the future, when there's broader understanding of how big the risk is, you can change to a mix where you over-represent the discussion of the solutions.
How would you describe a person who, after every prediction made to advance the global Warming hoax, has not only failed but laughingly failed and made fools of the hoaxers, still spews the political party line?
I'd call that person a f**king idiot, but that's just me.
 
Have to ask, cuz you won't come out and say it on your own. So let's see how much I have pulled from your hen's teeth...

The CO2 carbon isotope achieved by burning oil - since the industrial revolution - 1700? - has produced global warming in ice cores - since 1700? Is that your position? And that is mainstream position? Go ahead and tell us exactly which Carbon isotope has such a dramatic effect on global warming versus which carbon isotope that has never had such an effect... what are you saying, are you saying Carbon 12 isotope produces global warming versus Carbon 14 doesn't? And that's proven by the ice cores since when, exactly?
No. That's not my position. Again, it's odd you'd think it was. My position is that fossil fuel burning since the start of the industrial revolution raised greenhouse levels in the atmosphere setting off a cycle of global warming that is now occurring at an unprecedented pace .
 
a few years ago, "climate science" people observed that "it's as hot now as it was 2,000 years ag0, when Jesus lived"

Ok - lets set aside any questions on how we know the temperature 2000 years ago (tree rings? fossilized coral?)

instead - let's ask the unobvious question: since there were no SUVs 2000 year ago, what made it so hot? What made it cool down 1,000 years later in the mini ice age? clearly 99.9% of earth's temperature fluctuations have zero to do with fossil fuels.
Who are you quoting specifically?
 
I'm not entrenched. My views have developed over time, with the science. Can you say the same?

I have an open mind on the subject of climate change. I am open to new possibilities, and do not consider it 'settled science'. That position is the essence of closed-minded thinking, and the side of the fence you plant yourself squarely on.
 
How would you describe a person who, after every prediction made to advance the global Warming hoax, has not only failed but laughingly failed and made fools of the hoaxers, still spews the political party line?
I'd call that person a f**king idiot, but that's just me.

Can you name any other agency or realm of belief that has engaged in laughingly failed predictions over the course of years?

And if so, how does one refer to those folks?
 
JackDallas said: ↑
How would you describe a person who, after every prediction made to advance the global Warming hoax, has not only failed but laughingly failed and made fools of the hoaxers, still spews the political party line?
I'd call that person a f**king idiot, but that's just me.

Can you name any other agency or realm of belief that has engaged in laughingly failed predictions over the course of years?

And if so, how does one refer to those folks?
Yes I can, read Zam Zam's top post again.
 
No. That's not my position. Again, it's odd you'd think it was. My position is that fossil fuel burning since the start of the industrial revolution raised greenhouse levels in the atmosphere setting off a cycle of global warming that is now occurring at an unprecedented pace .
That's just plain bullshit.
 
JackDallas said: ↑
How would you describe a person who, after every prediction made to advance the global Warming hoax, has not only failed but laughingly failed and made fools of the hoaxers, still spews the political party line?
I'd call that person a f**king idiot, but that's just me.


Yes I can, read Zam Zam's top post again.

So...do.
 
Ice core data prove conclusively that global temps produce higher carbon levels

The darkly humorous things about the least educated denialists, like you, is that they're utterly incapable of thinking through the implications of their own points. If we didn't have ice core data showing how higher global temps can boost CO2, we'd actually be at liberty to be a lot less worried about global warming. After all, in that situation we could expect that once things start to get unacceptably warm, we can reign in our greenhouse gas emissions, and things will just stop there. One of the reasons the stakes are so high is that we have plenty of evidence, including that ice core data, telling us that isn't true: that higher temps can result in more greenhouse gas emissions, independent from direct human causes. That means there's a likelihood that the feedback loops will tend to amplify, rather than muffle, the impacts of our actions. Even after we put on the brakes, we may well see CO2 levels in the atmosphere continuing to rise, as a result of the heat we caused, and that will mean even more heat. It's a vicious cycle, and it's all the more reason to apply the brakes early, rather than waiting until things are already to an unacceptable level. But, of course, that never occurs to the least educated of the denialists.

(more heat = more life = more carbon)

That's not how it works. More life doesn't mean more carbon. What happens with warming is that CO2 gets less soluble in water at higher temperatures, meaning the oceans hold less of it, putting more of it in the atmosphere. Warming also melts permafrost, which currently holds a huge amount of carbon.

but they also prove conclusively that the higher carbon levels do not produce higher temps

They do nothing of the sort. There's a reason that nearly all leading experts on this topic believe higher carbon levels produce higher temps, and it's not because they don't know about the ice core data. It's because they understand the data better than you do.

Greenhouse gases have not done anything to global temps forever

Wrong. They're doing something to global temperatures right now.
 
That's just plain bullshit.
Most educated people, a huge majority of people with science educations, and very nearly all of the leading experts on climate science agree with me. But you've got your right-wing blogs to tell you what to think, so how can mere facts hope to compete with that?
 
How would you describe a person who, after every prediction made to advance the global Warming hoax, has not only failed but laughingly failed and made fools of the hoaxers, still spews the political party line?
That hasn't happened in the real world, obviously.

Here's a simple thought experiment. Imagine it's the mid-1980s. Average global temperatures have been rising a bit. A theory has taken hold among the majority of experts about why that is: anthropogenic emissions of certain gases are resulting in a strengthening greenhouse effect in the atmosphere. They predict that if we keep dumping CO2 into the atmosphere at high rates, atmospheric CO2 will keep rising, and the world will keep warming. In fact, they predict the rate of warming will accelerate, such that within about 20 years global temperatures will be a degree Celsius warmer than in pre-industrial times, with things getting even hotter after that.

At the time, others were doubtful about those predictions. They were, after all, based on fairly preliminary data and analysis, back then. From the perspective of the doubters, there was no reason to believe warming would keep happening, much less that it would accelerate, since there was no proposed mechanism for that other than anthropogenic greenhouse gases. In fact, the default hypothesis would be "regression to the mean." Absent something driving ongoing warming, one would expect a period of unusual warmth to be followed by cooling back towards more typical levels.

So, who was right? Did temperatures regress to the mean? Or did they continue to rise? Were they about a degree higher, globally, twenty years after that? Did they rise faster and faster each subsequent decade?

It turns out the scientists who proposed the anthropogenic warming mechanism were correct in their big-picture predictions. They didn't have all the details right, in their more tentative guesses about what places would warm at what speed and what secondary impacts it would have. But they nailed the overall process within a surprisingly small margin of error. And, to this day, there remains no plausible alternate mechanism to explain what has been an unprecedented rise in global temperatures.
 
Last edited:
I have an open mind on the subject of climate change. I am open to new possibilities, and do not consider it 'settled science'. That position is the essence of closed-minded thinking, and the side of the fence you plant yourself squarely on.
Have your views on it changed over time?

For example, 2016 was the hottest year on record, beating 2015, the previous record holder. The most recent decade is the hottest one on record, beating the prior decade, the previous record holder, which beat the one before that, the prior record holder. The pace at which the warming is occurring has accelerated. During that time, the breadth of the scientific consensus on the topic has grown, as has the confidence with which the majority of scientists are expressing their views (e.g., the IPCC officially going from "likely" to "highly likely" in stating key positions, to reflect the expanding depth of the supporting research and analysis and the impact it has had on the majority of expert's opinions.)

Those developments altered my views over time, because I have an open mind. Like the majority within the scientific community, I went from a very tentative assumption that AGW was real, a few decades ago, to a high degree of confidence in it. What I'm asking is whether your views changed, too, in light of those decades of increasingly dramatic warming, increasing amounts of exhaustive research, and increasingly convinced experts? It's one thing to assert that your mind is open. But if such incredibly dramatic external changes do not actually impact your opinions on a topic, how open can your mind be?
 
That hasn't happened in the real world, obviously.

Here's a simple thought experiment. Imagine it's the mid-1980s. Average global temperatures have been rising a bit. A theory has taken hold among the majority of experts about why that is: anthropogenic emissions of certain gases are resulting in a strengthening greenhouse effect in the atmosphere. They predict that if we keep dumping CO2 into the atmosphere at high rates, atmospheric CO2 will keep rising, and the world will keep warming. In fact, they predict the rate of warming will accelerate, such that within about 20 years global temperatures will be a degree Celsius warmer than in pre-industrial times, with things getting even hotter after that.

At the time, others were doubtful about those predictions. They were, after all, based on fairly preliminary data and analysis, back then. From the perspective of the doubters, there was no reason to believe warming would keep happening, much less that it would accelerate, since there was no proposed mechanism for that other than anthropogenic greenhouse gases. In fact, the default hypothesis would be "regression to the mean." Absent something driving ongoing warming, one would expect a period of unusual warmth to be followed by cooling back towards more typical levels.

So, who was right? Did temperatures regress to the mean? Or did they continue to rise? Were they about a degree higher, globally, twenty years after that? Did they rise faster and faster each subsequent decade?

It turns out the scientists who proposed the anthropogenic warming mechanism were correct in their big-picture predictions. They didn't have all the details right, in their more tentative guesses about what places would warm at what speed and what secondary impacts it would have. But they nailed the overall process within a surprisingly small margin of error. And, to this day, there remains no plausible alternate mechanism to explain what has been an unprecedented rise in global temperatures.

when global warming alarmists serve up convoluted "regression" explanations, it's best to return to the basics -

- NYC is not under water
- Florida has not been flooded
- Venice and the Netherlands are doing just fine
- winter snows are not "a thing of the past". in fact, Britain and California have had unexpected record setting snowfalls recently
 
="Days, post: 1855551, member: 8860"]Have to ask, cuz you won't come out and say it on your own. So let's see how much I have pulled from your hen's teeth...

The CO2 carbon isotope achieved by burning oil - since the industrial revolution - 1700? - has produced global warming in ice cores - since 1700? Is that your position? And that is mainstream position? Go ahead and tell us exactly which Carbon isotope has such a dramatic effect on global warming versus which carbon isotope that has never had such an effect... what are you saying, are you saying Carbon 12 isotope produces global warming versus Carbon 14 doesn't? And that's proven by the ice cores since when, exactly?
I couldn't help but notice how you asked @Arkady 6 very specific questions in that posting and the only one he answered was "Is that your position?"

Seems he doesn't have the answers .......just obfuscation.
 
Have your views on it changed over time?

For example, 2016 was the hottest year on record, beating 2015, the previous record holder. The most recent decade is the hottest one on record, beating the prior decade, the previous record holder, which beat the one before that, the prior record holder. The pace at which the warming is occurring has accelerated. During that time, the breadth of the scientific consensus on the topic has grown, as has the confidence with which the majority of scientists are expressing their views (e.g., the IPCC officially going from "likely" to "highly likely" in stating key positions, to reflect the expanding depth of the supporting research and analysis and the impact it has had on the majority of expert's opinions.)

Those developments altered my views over time, because I have an open mind. Like the majority within the scientific community, I went from a very tentative assumption that AGW was real, a few decades ago, to a high degree of confidence in it. What I'm asking is whether your views changed, too, in light of those decades of increasingly dramatic warming, increasing amounts of exhaustive research, and increasingly convinced experts? It's one thing to assert that your mind is open. But if such incredibly dramatic external changes do not actually impact your opinions on a topic, how open can your mind be?


They continue to evolve. In fact, the only thing I can say with certainty is that the scientific community has failed to convince me either way. I'm keeping an open mind
and have not settled on a position.

You appear to be all settled in, and have concluded that the way to deal with this issue is to give money and power to your preferred political party. You will in all likelihood hold that position, and no other, on this issue for the remainder of your earthly existence. Intellectually, you're all done with this issue, save for regurgitating anything that reinforces what you've already concluded.

Now if you prefer to stay that way, that's fine with me. I'll continue to keep an open mind, and that should be fine with you. If it isn't, that's a you problem, and you'll have to deal with that yourself.
 
No. The quote you provided was "it's as hot now as it was 2,000 years ag0, when Jesus lived." I searched the link and there was no mention of Jesus. As far as I can tell, you invented the quotation. The closest I could find to that in a real quotation, in your source, was "you can go back nearly 2,000 years and the conclusion still holds—the current warmth is anomalous."

Anyway, it's true that as of nine years ago, a study showed that you could reconstruct temperatures going back nearly 2000 years, using various methods, and that despite the uncertainty inherent in those kinds of reconstructions, we could state with confidence that at no point in that timeline had temperatures been as high as today. Since then, news studies have come out that refine the techniques to let us look back still farther, and now it looks like at least 115,000 to 120,000 years without temperatures this high:

https://www.theguardian.com/environ...mperature-climate-change-highest-115000-years
http://www.cbsnews.com/news/earth-warmest-in-120000-years-climate-change-study/

But, your question can still be applied even with that new data, with a little modification (since there were no SUVs 120,000 year ago, what made it so hot?) So, I'll answer that.

There are a great many different things that can influence global temperatures that have nothing to do with humans. There are changes in the Earth's orbit, for example, and changes in how hot the sun is burning at a given time. There are major geological events (e.g., the Siberian traps exploding). There are evolutionary changes (e.g, the evolution of lignin, which, during the Carboniferous, meant trees were sequestering vast amounts of carbon, long-term, because organisms hadn't evolved to break down wood efficiently yet, resulting in it getting turned into coal rather than put back in the atmosphere). There's even continental drift, which alters currents around the Earth, as well as altering where land masses are located. Some of those factors leave a clear geological trace. Some don't. So it can be hard to say with certainty what caused various periods of warming and cooling in the past.

What we can say with certainty, though, is that at no point in the last 120,000 years have we seen warming as rapid as we're seeing now. It's not even close, in fact -- not within an order of magnitude. It can't be plausibly explained by any observed changes other than anthropogenic greenhouse gases. We've been measuring the sun and it hasn't suddenly been putting out a lot more energy:

Solar-cycle-data.png

We also can monitor the Earth's orbit now and there's been no change that would explain the warming. Nor can it plausibly be explained by continental drift, given how very slowly that would be expected to factor in, versus how very fast this warming has been. And there's been no increase in volcanic activity to explain it, either. As far as we've been able to observe, there's one very big change that has happened as fast as this extraordinarily fast warming: the increase in human greenhouse gas emissions. And since those emissions are well-known for their ability to absorb infrared radiation that would otherwise radiate into space, it's not hard to connect the dots between that massive, uncontrolled experiment in atmospheric chemistry and the unprecedented warming that has been happening alongside it.

What we have here is kind of like the world's silliest murder mystery. The detective walks into the drawing room and observes the suspect firing bullet after bullet into the body of the victim, who keels over and dies. So, the detective starts checking whether the victim's tea was poisoned, checking the victim's neck for ligature marks, speculating whether it was possibly a suicide or accidental overdose, or maybe a bad heart, etc. He just directly observed an extremely dramatic act that had a compellingly plausible connection to the death, and yet he's looking absolutely everywhere for another explanation. Finally he throws up his hands and declares that it couldn't possibly be the gunman who did it, because 2000 years ago people were dying and there were no guns back when Jesus was alive. Even the broadest of bumbling whodunit inspectors couldn't adequately satirize the sheer absurdity of climate change denialist behavior.
 
when global warming alarmists serve up convoluted "regression" explanations, it's best to return to the basics -

- NYC is not under water

As you'll recall, the idea that some climate change scientist predicted it would be, by this point, is just a lie you enjoy telling.

- Florida has not been flooded

Parts of it have.

- Venice and the Netherlands are doing just fine

They are not. They are both spending vast amounts of money to deal with the rising sea levels. The MOSE project in Venice is going to cost about five and a half billion euros, but they're willing to spend it because scenes like this are becoming more and more common in recent years:

square_1124142i.jpg


- winter snows are not "a thing of the past"

Nor are they likely to be a thing of the past for thousands of years, at least. There are places where it will keep on snowing even when the world as a whole is many degrees warmer than today. But, overall, there's less snow fall over time and retreating glaciers.
 
I couldn't help but notice how you asked @Arkady 6 very specific questions in that posting and the only one he answered was "Is that your position?"

Seems he doesn't have the answers .......just obfuscation.
The questions were all predicated on contradicting what he wrongly thought was my position. Once I made it clear that wasn't my position, it would make no sense to follow up on the questions related to that.

This isn't a hard concept to master. Imagine I asked you the following:

"So, is it your position that human beings don't need to consume calories to survive? Where do you think the energy for bodily activities would come from? Do you think they can just photosynthesize energy from the sun?"

If you answer "no, that's not my position" to the first absurd question, would it really make sense for you to go on and answer the next two questions, as well?
 
The questions were all predicated on contradicting what he wrongly thought was my position. Once I made it clear that wasn't my position, it would make no sense to follow up on the questions related to that.

This isn't a hard concept to master. Imagine I asked you the following:

"So, is it your position that human beings don't need to consume calories to survive? Where do you think the energy for bodily activities would come from? Do you think they can just photosynthesize energy from the sun?"

If you answer "no, that's not my position" to the first absurd question, would it really make sense for you to go on and answer the next two questions, as well?
Dodge noted
 
Back
Top