New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Settled Science Update

holy sh*t, Arkady, what did you just admit? You don't believe the lie either? Yes the oceans are warmed by sunlight, but that's not what your theory says

Yes it is. You just didn't understand the theory due to your lack of any science education. When you rely on right-wing blogs to inform you about what the mainstream science say, you end up with some pretty wacky ideas about the mainstream science. What you're failing to grasp is that the whole system interacts -- the warmth that its the oceans will leave the oceans more quickly if the air around them is colder than if it's warmer, in the same way that the warmth in your body leaves faster on a cold day than a hot one.

yes the heat from the sun evaporates ocean water, but that's not what your theory

Of course it is. Everyone knows that heat from the sun evaporates ocean water. What on Earth would make you imagine there's a theory that says otherwise?

yes, the heat from the water is transferred into the air through evaporation, but that's not what your theory says

Of course the theory says that. Again, you're just laboring under a pretty bizarre idea of what mainstream climate science says, presumably because everything you learned about it you got second-hand through right-wing climate blogs aimed at the scientifically illiterate.
 
There's a wonderful reason to believe geo-thermal activity kicked up; the ice cap melted.

Ah, the circle is complete. Increased geo-thermal activity melted the ice cap, and we know geo-thermal activity increased because the ice cap melted. I could as easily claim that alien space ships with heat rays melted the ice cap, and then claim there's a wonderful reason to believe in those alien space ships and their heat rays, because the ice cap melted.

We have a good explanation for the ice cap melt-off -- anthropogenic greenhouse gas-induced global warming. It was predicted the the ice caps would dwindle long before we knew anything significant about that ridge beneath the Arctic -- just as it was correctly predicted that other parts of the cryosphere would be melting (glaciers retreating, permafrost thawing, etc.) There's no big mystery calling out for a novel explanation here. It's all consistent with the measurable global warming and the mainstream explanation for why. If you want to claim that the ice cap retreat isn't due to the most obvious likely cause --the cause suggested by those experts who correctly predicted it would happen-- then you need more than circular reasoning to justify that. You need to actually show there was a big increase in geo-thermal activity in that area, and that the increase in heat output was somewhere on the order of magnitude needed to melt a substantial share of that ice. So far, all you've got is the existence of some sub-sea vents along a ridge that's been there for millions of years.

In fact, you can measure what it took to melt the ice cap (like you did in earlier posts) and that will effectively show you what the uptick in geo-thermal activity was

Again, the silly circle: assume all the ice meltage was due to a geothermal heat increase, and you can estimate how much the geothermal heat increase was. In EXACTLY the same way, I can estimate the output of those heat rays on the alien space ships by measuring what it would take to melt the ice cap, if I start with the assumption that's what caused the ice to melt. Don't you see how ridiculous your rhetoric is?

so bloody easy, if you didn't have this completely insane greenhouse gas claim, demanding that all the ice was melted by carbon dioxide.

Nobody at all is demanding that all the ice was melted by carbon dioxide. First, obviously, there are other greenhouse gases. Second, scientists are completely open to other contributing factors -- for example, soot in the ice lowering the albedo and thus causing more meltage from the sun than when the albedo was higher. Undersea geo-thermal heating might conceivably be another contributor. There's just no reason to think it's anything other than a very small contributor, at this point, given the absence of evidence of any large amount of heat energy from those vents reaching the ice, much less there having been a big uptick in that heat energy coinciding with the melt-off.

No ice was melted by carbon dioxide, carbon dioxide doesn't melt ice any differently than the other 99.5% of the atmosphere

Incorrect. Carbon dioxide is a greenhouse gas. You can perform this experiment on your own if you like in your own backyard, showing how ice can melt faster in a CO2-rich atmosphere than in air, when exposed to sunlight, due to the CO2 preventing as much infrared radiation from radiating away.

if the air temps were 40 degrees below freezing on average, there was zero NET melting due to carbon dioxide

That doesn't follow, obviously. The relevant data isn't what the average air temperature is at a given spot. It's a global matter, because air temperatures in other areas influence what water temperatures in a given spot will be. The warmer it is in the air between the tropics and the arctic circle, the warmer the gulf stream will remain when it reaches the arctic circle.

I've only said that 100 or more times now

Yes. That's why people laugh at you.
 
Air temperatures in the Arctic do get that warm, every year.
In the summertime, yes... but you have to take the average air temp; the year round average. If the year round average is just one degree below freezing, then the net effect of air temps was to add ice. (it is about ten degrees below freezing) So, maybe the average temp rose to 9 degrees below freezing; or 8 or 7 degrees below freezing, and I'm sure it fluctuates a tiny from year to year... so maybe there was some warming there, but in no way does that mean that greenhouse gases melted the ice in the Arctic Circle; it simply could not have happened, because the average air temps are still adding ice; that's how I knew that the heat was coming from the water... where else? It had to be the water. Then I discovered the thermals coming up from the Arctic floor, and today, everyone agrees the ice was melted by the water, but when I first said that 7 years ago, you guys thought I was merely arguing with you.
 
In the summertime, yes... but you have to take the average air temp; the year round average. If the year round average is just one degree below freezing, then the net effect of air temps was to add ice. (it is about ten degrees below freezing) So, maybe the average temp rose to 9 degrees below freezing; or 8 or 7 degrees below freezing, and I'm sure it fluctuates a tiny from year to year... so maybe there was some warming there, but in no way does that mean that greenhouse gases melted the ice in the Arctic Circle; it simply could not have happened, because the average air temps are still adding ice; that's how I knew that the heat was coming from the water... where else? It had to be the water. Then I discovered the thermals coming up from the Arctic floor, and today, everyone agrees the ice was melted by the water, but when I first said that 7 years ago, you guys thought I was merely arguing with you.
Try rereading reading the post directly above yours.
 
Try rereading reading the post directly above yours.
I tried reading it, but really, do you recognize bullshit when you see it? I don't have enough breath in me to reply to a full sheet of BS, let's look at the last 2 answers because those address the idea of air temps melting ice in the Arctic...

me: No ice was melted by carbon dioxide, carbon dioxide doesn't melt ice any differently than the other 99.5% of the atmosphere

Arkady:Incorrect. Carbon dioxide is a greenhouse gas. You can perform this experiment on your own if you like in your own backyard, showing how ice can melt faster in a CO2-rich atmosphere than in air, when exposed to sunlight, due to the CO2 preventing as much infrared radiation from radiating away.


Okay, I obviously meant that the presence of carbon dioxide in the air does not cause more melting by the atmosphere than when it isn't present. The point being, if air temps are not melting the ice caps to begin with... and they are not... then the presence of carbon dioxide is not changing that. Carbon dioxide does not act like salt on ice, it doesn't have special properties different from nitrogen or oxygen or water vapor; the contention by global warming religious nuts is that carbon dioxide releases more heat into the air; so stop and think about it; if the Arctic air has carbon dioxide in it and it still is not reaching a yearly average temp that melts ice; then the air with carbon dioxide is still not melting any ice. Here's the situation: the average air temps in the Arctic Circle are well below freezing; so the air is not melting ice, it is instead freezing water; you can do this experiment in your own backyard; go outside in the dead of winter when the temp is in single digits; I don't care if you live in NYC or Chicago where there is a ton of carbon dioxide in the air (even more than at the north pole) - now bring a cup of water outside together with a cup of solid ice; place both on your frozen picnic table you didn't bring in last November, now watch what happens; does the ice melt or does the water freeze?

The plain fact is; no ice was melted by carbon dioxide, yes they found carbon dioxide in the air, and no it didn't melt the ice cap. When you are so far gone into the land of stupid, that you really think hot air doesn't rise or that 10 degrees farenheit is melting ice... it is really hard swallowing smart alec one liners from geniuses like that... (see below)



me: if the air temps were 40 degrees below freezing on average, there was zero NET melting due to carbon dioxide

Arkady: That doesn't follow, obviously. The relevant data isn't what the average air temperature is at a given spot. It's a global matter, because air temperatures in other areas influence what water temperatures in a given spot will be. The warmer it is in the air between the tropics and the arctic circle, the warmer the gulf stream will remain when it reaches the arctic circle.


So, this genius is telling us that the air is melting ice, even when it is 40 degrees below freezing. Stop and think how incredibly idiotic this argument is; what he is saying is that water warmed at the equator is flowing to the Arctic (it doesn't do that) and that's how air is melting the ice. Never mind that he just admitted that the ice is really being melted by water, not air, look at the way he cheats the argument; we are talking about air temps in the Arctic not being responsible for melting the ice cap and he tries to say that air temps in the tropics are indirectly responsible for melting the ice. He's wrong, he must not know about the polar vortex, but look at the way he is being dishonest; he is supposedly disproving that air temps 40 degrees below freezing are not melting ice; but instead of addressing those Arctic air temps he uses tropical air temps, and not even tropical air temps but actually tropical waters absorbing radiation from the sun - which he is claiming is goosed by carbon dioxide - can you see how this has nothing to do with the air temps in the Arctic being too cold to melt ice? How on earth does this guy think he has science on his side?

I've only said that 100 or more times now
Yes. That's why people laugh at you.
I guess that's why I'm still here and you aren't.
 
I tried reading it, but really, do you recognize bullshit when you see it? I don't have enough breath in me to reply to a full sheet of BS, let's look at the last 2 answers because those address the idea of air temps melting ice in the Arctic...

me: No ice was melted by carbon dioxide, carbon dioxide doesn't melt ice any differently than the other 99.5% of the atmosphere

Arkady:Incorrect. Carbon dioxide is a greenhouse gas. You can perform this experiment on your own if you like in your own backyard, showing how ice can melt faster in a CO2-rich atmosphere than in air, when exposed to sunlight, due to the CO2 preventing as much infrared radiation from radiating away.


Okay, I obviously meant that the presence of carbon dioxide in the air does not cause more melting by the atmosphere than when it isn't present. The point being, if air temps are not melting the ice caps to begin with... and they are not... then the presence of carbon dioxide is not changing that. Carbon dioxide does not act like salt on ice, it doesn't have special properties different from nitrogen or oxygen or water vapor; the contention by global warming religious nuts is that carbon dioxide releases more heat into the air; so stop and think about it; if the Arctic air has carbon dioxide in it and it still is not reaching a yearly average temp that melts ice; then the air with carbon dioxide is still not melting any ice. Here's the situation: the average air temps in the Arctic Circle are well below freezing; so the air is not melting ice, it is instead freezing water; you can do this experiment in your own backyard; go outside in the dead of winter when the temp is in single digits; I don't care if you live in NYC or Chicago where there is a ton of carbon dioxide in the air (even more than at the north pole) - now bring a cup of water outside together with a cup of solid ice; place both on your frozen picnic table you didn't bring in last November, now watch what happens; does the ice melt or does the water freeze?

The plain fact is; no ice was melted by carbon dioxide, yes they found carbon dioxide in the air, and no it didn't melt the ice cap. When you are so far gone into the land of stupid, that you really think hot air doesn't rise or that 10 degrees farenheit is melting ice... it is really hard swallowing smart alec one liners from geniuses like that... (see below)



me: if the air temps were 40 degrees below freezing on average, there was zero NET melting due to carbon dioxide

Arkady: That doesn't follow, obviously. The relevant data isn't what the average air temperature is at a given spot. It's a global matter, because air temperatures in other areas influence what water temperatures in a given spot will be. The warmer it is in the air between the tropics and the arctic circle, the warmer the gulf stream will remain when it reaches the arctic circle.


So, this genius is telling us that the air is melting ice, even when it is 40 degrees below freezing. Stop and think how incredibly idiotic this argument is; what he is saying is that water warmed at the equator is flowing to the Arctic (it doesn't do that) and that's how air is melting the ice. Never mind that he just admitted that the ice is really being melted by water, not air, look at the way he cheats the argument; we are talking about air temps in the Arctic not being responsible for melting the ice cap and he tries to say that air temps in the tropics are indirectly responsible for melting the ice. He's wrong, he must not know about the polar vortex, but look at the way he is being dishonest; he is supposedly disproving that air temps 40 degrees below freezing are not melting ice; but instead of addressing those Arctic air temps he uses tropical air temps, and not even tropical air temps but actually tropical waters absorbing radiation from the sun - which he is claiming is goosed by carbon dioxide - can you see how this has nothing to do with the air temps in the Arctic being too cold to melt ice? How on earth does this guy think he has science on his side?

I've only said that 100 or more times now
Yes. That's why people laugh at you.
I guess that's why I'm still here and you aren't.

We all agreed the water was melting ice. He pointed out that you were ignoring the way heat always flows from areas with more heat to those with less. In the water this happens for example by conduction through the water as well as radiation from the air to the water.
 
We all agreed the water was melting ice. He pointed out that you were ignoring the way heat always flows from areas with more heat to those with less. In the water this happens for example by conduction through the water as well as radiation from the air to the water.
locally. yes.
globally. no.
there simply is no conduit of water running from tropical regions into the polar ice cap. Closest you get is Gulf Stream hitting the northern Atlantic. Don't forget, those waters are being cooled by the cold water in the northern Atlantic. No heat whatsoever is reaching the ice cap, I've never even heard of the Gulf Stream having enough heat left to melt the many ice bergs flowing in the northern Atlantic. This was a last gasp effort to somehow cling to the idea that greenhouse gases were responsible for the ice melt on the ice caps. My very first response to that idea - many years ago, now - was that the angle of the sun at the poles is going to make air temps a non-starter. You guys came back with the science of heat diffusion due to radiation; in essence, you kept pointing to the idea that there was more heat being produced in the air by carbon dioxide. And I kept responding with "so what? It isn't enough to matter. After all is said and done, the average air temp at the poles is still freezing water, not melting ice." I am still wondering if you get that.

The heat that melted the ice cap came from an uptick in Arctic floor thermals. The air temps are still freezing water, so that ice is slowly being replaced. Realize for a moment that the entire ice cap was dissolved 12,000 years ago ... so what ice cap we do have today is the result of refreezing. The ice cap is formed in the first place by the water being frozen by the cold air temps. The Arctic ocean is not frozen ice, only the surface is frozen.
 
Last edited:
locally. yes.
globally. no.
there simply is no conduit of water running from tropical regions into the polar ice cap. Closest you get is Gulf Stream hitting the northern Atlantic. Don't forget, those waters are being cooled by the cold water in the northern Atlantic. No heat whatsoever is reaching the ice cap, I've never even heard of the Gulf Stream having enough heat left to melt the many ice bergs flowing in the northern Atlantic. This was a last gasp effort to somehow cling to the idea that greenhouse gases were responsible for the ice melt on the ice caps. My very first response to that idea - many years ago, now - was that the angle of the sun at the poles is going to make air temps a non-starter. You guys came back with the science of heat diffusion due to radiation; in essence, you kept pointing to the idea that there was more heat being produced in the air by carbon dioxide. And I kept responding with "so what? It isn't enough to matter. After all is said and done, the average air temp at the poles is still freezing water, not melting ice." I am still wondering if you get that.

The heat that melted the ice cap came from an uptick in Arctic floor thermals. The air temps are still freezing water, so that ice is slowly being replaced. Realize for a moment that the entire ice cap was dissolved 12,000 years ago ... so what ice cap we do have today is the result of refreezing. The ice cap is formed in the first place by the water being frozen by the cold air temps. The Arctic ocean is not frozen ice, only the surface is frozen.

The scientists who have actually done the math say the added heat equivalent of 4 Hiroshima bombs per second due to increased CO2 concentrations is sufficient to have melted the ice, while the much lower heat gradient due to geothermal activity is not even close.
 
locally. yes.
globally. no.
The Arctic ocean is not frozen ice, only the surface is frozen.
Let's understand once and for all why there is no greenhouse effect. The idea that heat is leaving the system slower - and therefore building up in the system - is complete nonsense. The reason being, the heat is still leaving the system. As heat rises, all sorts of behavior can happen, yes, you could even get heat to temporarily return to the surface, but in very short order, that same heat will rise again and dissipate in the upper atmosphere. The big picture is that of a cooling machine; heat from the surface (mostly generated by absorbing the rays of the sun) rises through the atmosphere and dissipates in the upper atmosphere. 100% of the sun's radiation is absorbed and it doesn't matter what processes are involved in that, because you can not get more than 100%, you can not multiply energy, you can only get 100% of the energy; chemical reactions from earth elements add to the energy, but they do not multiply the energy coming from the sun. The biggest energy being added by the earth is volcanic activity. But whatever heat is produced on the surface, from whatever source, as that heat reaches a temp hotter than the air temp in the atmosphere above, the gas at the surface expands and as it expands, it pushes upward; watch a thunderhead form in the sky, the expanding hot air pushes upward. Heat always rises in the atmosphere. Heat is not retained in the atmosphere. Heat is constantly rising from the surface and dissipating in the upper atmosphere; that's how we get rain, 75% of the surface is covered with water, so 75% of the heat rising in the atmosphere is being carried by water vapor, there is also dry heat, hot air that is dry, and it rises also and it dissipates in the upper atmosphere also. So the big picture is a cooling machine. The sun warms the earth's surface and that heat then warms the air in contact with the surface, expanding the gas, which then rises through the atmosphere into the higher cold air where it cools. All day long, all around the earth, where ever the sun's rays strike the surface, that heat rises, and what does it give us? It gives us weather. Sum total of weather over a long period of time = climate.

So would if the earth is adding an extra degree or two to the weather? ... so what, it all exits the system. The air temps at the equator are 100 degrees warmer than at the poles, and it doesn't matter; heat still rises and exits the system at the equator the same as it does at the poles. The cooling machine still works... there is variations galore, there is weather galore, we even get hurricanes, which, a hurricane digs down into surface water and sucks the heat out, feeds on heat in surface waters, but in the end, it is always the same, eventually, all the heat rises and exits the system. There is no glass ceiling separating the biosphere from the rest of the stratosphere, when you see a thunderhead forming, that happens because the hot water vapor is rising into such cold air, the water vapor condenses, so you are watching the heat dissipate into the upper atmosphere, that is what forms the rain. Don't forget, that the rain then drops back down to the earth, so it carries the cold back down to the surface, completing the cooling process. Bottom line, the heat is always in transition, it is constantly moving, and it varies in temp tremendously, but it still exits the system; hot air rises, cools, and returns.

The scientists who have actually done the math say the added heat equivalent of 4 Hiroshima bombs per second due to increased CO2 concentrations is sufficient to have melted the ice, while the much lower heat gradient due to geothermal activity is not even close.
They can say that, but where's the proof?
If you believe that, then it follows that the ice cap is being melted by air temps.
And if you believe that, then it follows that the average air temps above the ice caps are above freezing.
And what is the average air temp at the poles?
Really cold, or really, really cold? (Link)
Time of year Average (mean) temperature

North Pole
Summer .......... 32° F (0° C)
Winter .......... −40° F (−40° C)

South Pole
Summer .......... −18° F (−28.2° C)
Winter ............ −76° F (−60° C)
 
Last edited:
Let's understand once and for all why there is no greenhouse effect. The idea that heat is leaving the system slower - and therefore building up in the system - is complete nonsense. The reason being, the heat is still leaving the system. As heat rises, all sorts of behavior can happen, yes, you could even get heat to temporarily return to the surface, but in very short order, that same heat will rise again and dissipate in the upper atmosphere. The big picture is that of a cooling machine; heat from the surface (mostly generated by absorbing the rays of the sun) rises through the atmosphere and dissipates in the upper atmosphere. 100% of the sun's radiation is absorbed and it doesn't matter what processes are involved in that, because you can not get more than 100%, you can not multiply energy, you can only get 100% of the energy; chemical reactions from earth elements add to the energy, but they do not multiply the energy coming from the sun. The biggest energy being added by the earth is volcanic activity. But whatever heat is produced on the surface, from whatever source, as that heat reaches a temp hotter than the air temp in the atmosphere above, the gas at the surface expands and as it expands, it pushes upward; watch a thunderhead form in the sky, the expanding hot air pushes upward. Heat always rises in the atmosphere. Heat is not retained in the atmosphere. Heat is constantly rising from the surface and dissipating in the upper atmosphere; that's how we get rain, 75% of the surface is covered with water, so 75% of the heat rising in the atmosphere is being carried by water vapor, there is also dry heat, hot air that is dry, and it rises also and it dissipates in the upper atmosphere also. So the big picture is a cooling machine. The sun warms the earth's surface and that heat then warms the air in contact with the surface, expanding the gas, which then rises through the atmosphere into the higher cold air where it cools. All day long, all around the earth, where ever the sun's rays strike the surface, that heat rises, and what does it give us? It gives us weather. Sum total of weather over a long period of time = climate.

So would if the earth is adding an extra degree or two to the weather? ... so what, it all exits the system. The air temps at the equator are 100 degrees warmer than at the poles, and it doesn't matter; heat still rises and exits the system at the equator the same as it does at the poles. The cooling machine still works... there is variations galore, there is weather galore, we even get hurricanes, which, a hurricane digs down into surface water and sucks the heat out, feeds on heat in surface waters, but in the end, it is always the same, eventually, all the heat rises and exits the system. There is no glass ceiling separating the biosphere from the rest of the stratosphere, when you see a thunderhead forming, that happens because the hot water vapor is rising into such cold air, the water vapor condenses, so you are watching the heat dissipate into the upper atmosphere, that is what forms the rain. Don't forget, thjat rain then drops back down to the earth, so it carries the cold back down to the surface, completing the cooling process. Bottom line, the heat is always in transition, it is constantly moving, and it varies in temp tremendously, but it still exits the system; hot air rises, cools, and returns.


They can say that, but where's the proof?
If you believe that, then it follows that the ice cap is being melted by air temps.
And if you believe that, then it follows that the average air temps above the ice caps are above freezing.
And what is the average air temp at the poles?
Really cold, or really, really cold? (Link)
Time of year Average (mean) temperature

North Pole
Summer ......... 32° F (0° C)
Winter .......... −40° F (−40° C)

South Pole
Summer .......... −18° F (−28.2° C)
Winter ............. −76° F (−60° C)

1. The whole issue is the balance between the rate of heat absorption and the (now lower) rate of heat radiation, and the higher average temperatures and increased opportunities for hot air to circulate that result.
2. Melting is not taking place at the North Pole or the South Pole but rather on the edges of the glacier. And it is due primarily not to air temperatures but to local water temperatures as those temperatures have been heated up by heat diffusing from warmer air and water from lower latitudes.
3. The proof is the quantitative equations on the basis of which the melting was confidently predicted before scientists ever even knew about volcanos in the area, and the insufficiency of the energy measured from those volcanos to come close to accounting for the melt.
 
1. The whole issue is the balance between the rate of heat absorption and the (now lower) rate of heat radiation, and the higher average temperatures and increased opportunities for hot air to circulate that result.
2. Melting is not taking place at the North Pole or the South Pole but rather on the edges of the glacier. And it is due primarily not to air temperatures but to local water temperatures as those temperatures have been heated up by heat diffusing from warmer air and water from lower latitudes.
3. The proof is the quantitative equations on the basis of which the melting was confidently predicted before scientists ever even knew about volcanos in the area, and the insufficiency of the energy measured from those volcanos to come close to accounting for the melt.
1. Except that the rate of heat absorption is a non-factor. 100% of the energy from the sun is absorbed through one fashion or another. You can not multiply that energy, you can not absorb more than 100% of the energy.

2. The ice cap is not a glacier. It is a contiguous structure of ice two miles high... whatever air temp is at the pole is also the temp of the ice at the pole. The ice transmits that temp throughout the structure. So, while the ice may melt at the edges of the ice cap, the air temps at the pole is still part of the equation. Again, the waters at the edge of the ice cap are not in circulation with lower latitudes... that's just wrong.

3. Yeah, all kinds of equations and predictions were put out - including all kinds of predictions headed in the other direction... toward a colder earth. TIME magazine featured those predictions as the most prominent. Going back and cherry picking the predictions for more heat and then asserting that they were correct based upon melting that didn't even result from "greenhouse" gases... not very convincing.
 
1. Except that the rate of heat absorption is a non-factor. 100% of the energy from the sun is absorbed through one fashion or another. You can not multiply that energy, you can not absorb more than 100% of the energy.

2. The ice cap is not a glacier. It is a contiguous structure of ice two miles high... whatever air temp is at the pole is also the temp of the ice at the pole. The ice transmits that temp throughout the structure. So, while the ice may melt at the edges of the ice cap, the air temps at the pole is still part of the equation. Again, the waters at the edge of the ice cap are not in circulation with lower latitudes... that's just wrong.

3. Yeah, all kinds of equations and predictions were put out - including all kinds of predictions headed in the other direction... toward a colder earth. TIME magazine featured those predictions as the most prominent. Going back and cherry picking the predictions for more heat and then asserting that they were correct based upon melting that didn't even result from "greenhouse" gases... not very convincing.

1. You are ignoring the other part of the balance ... radiation of heat by the Earth and the rate at which it occurs.
2. The ice does not have a single uniform temperature. And water and air currents definitely carry heat from lower latitudes to higher, as heat always flows from areas of more heat to areas of less heat.
3. Not a single year went by that projections of global warming didn’t outnumber projections of cooling more than 4:1 in the scientific literature. It is not “cherry picking” to point out that the vast majority of scientists were right all along. And no other plausible cause for the melting has been advanced (as pointed out to you above, for volcanic activity to be melting the ice this rapidly you would need the energy equivalent of 2 Krakatoa eruptions per day, every day, and that we don’t have any evidence for; and volcanoes wouldn’t account for the seasonal periodicity of ice melt the way the greenhouse warming theory does).
 
1. You are ignoring the other part of the balance ... radiation of heat by the Earth and the rate at which it occurs.
2. The ice does not have a single uniform temperature. And water and air currents definitely carry heat from lower latitudes to higher, as heat always flows from areas of more heat to areas of less heat.
3. Not a single year went by that projections of global warming didn’t outnumber projections of cooling more than 4:1 in the scientific literature. It is not “cherry picking” to point out that the vast majority of scientists were right all along. And no other plausible cause for the melting has been advanced (as pointed out to you above, for volcanic activity to be melting the ice this rapidly you would need the energy equivalent of 2 Krakatoa eruptions per day, every day, and that we don’t have any evidence for; and volcanoes wouldn’t account for the seasonal periodicity of ice melt the way the greenhouse warming theory does).
1. I covered it in one of my replies on this page, this morning... but you said "rate of absorption" which I understood as absorption of the sun's rays. Why don't you break down those two for us... how much energy does the earth's surface absorb from the sun's radiation versus absorbed from the earth's own radiation? Let's get a comparison.

2. I said temps at the pole are part of the equation, not that they are carried uniformly throughout the ice cap, but my point was that the ice cap is also a thermally connected structure... so you can't ignore air temps at the pole. Remember, the ice is formed by the air temps acting on the surface of the water; it is a surface action. The Arctic ocean is water from end to end, submarines sail everywhere under the ice cap. The ice is melting at the edge of the ice where ever it is in contact with water... or it is freezing that water and adding ice, depending on the net resultant temp between the ice cap and the water. That is happening between the ice cap and the water... across the entire ice cap, when you say the ice melts on the edges... well it does that (or freezes) everywhere the ice is in contact with water, including the poles. Think of the ice cap as a giant cube of ice floating on top of water... the entire bottom of the ice cap is in contact with the Arctic ocean... air temps are driving the formation of ice; and that is being applied across the entire bottom of the ice cap; that's the edge of the ice cap where interaction with the surface transmits air temps above to the water below. It isn't merely the outer horizontal edges of the ice cap. So, air temps at the pole are as much a part of the equation as air temps anywhere else above the ice cap. Understand the dynamic at work.

Water and air currents around the Arctic and Antarctic circle travel in a circular motion. The polar vortex (Link). It creates a barrier between the climate at the poles and the climate (and currents) of more central latitudes. The poles have their own special climate. Polar climate affects all the regions in contact with the polar vortex. This is more a case of the cold touching the warm than the other way around. At any rate, there is no warm water crossing the polar vortex, get that nonsense out of your head. At the same time, take note: why are scientists peddling total lies like that?

3. You are talking recent projections, under 40 years old. Since they changed directions when the earlier projections of a returning ice age didn't happen.
 
Polar vortex (Link)
METEOROLOGY
WRITTEN BY:
See Article History
Alternative Titles: circumpolar vortex, circumpolar whirl, polar cyclone, polar low, polar winter vortex

Polar vortex, also called circumpolar vortex, polar low, or polar cyclone, large area of persistent low pressure generally located above each of Earth’s polar regions and containing a mass of extremely cold air. The altitude of this cyclone extends from the middle of the troposphere (the lowest level of Earth’s atmosphere, which spans the region from the surface up to 10–18 km [6–11 miles] high) into the stratosphere (the atmospheric layer extending from 10–18 km to about 50 km [30 miles] high). Cold air is contained within the polar vortex by the polar-front jet stream (an eastward-moving belt of strong stratospheric winds that separates warm tropical air from cold polar air in the midlatitudes). The strength of the polar vortex varies with the season, but it is strongest during the winter season in each hemisphere, when the temperature contrast between the pole and the Equator is greatest. It may weaken or disappear entirely during the warmer months of the year.


Rossby wave patterns over the North Pole depicting the formation of an outbreak of cold air over Asia.Encyclopædia Britannica, Inc.

Over the Northern Hemisphere in the winter season, the polar-front jet stream is located above the midlatitudes (areas located between 30° and 60° N), with wind speeds varying between 193 and 402 km (120 and 250 miles) per hour. If this jet stream’s circulation is strong, the polar vortex maintains a roughly circular shape with a centre at or very near to the North Pole. Undulations in the circulation of the polar-front jet stream (called Rossby waves) can result from incursions of energy generated by land-ocean contrasts in temperature and air deflected by large mountain ranges into the path of the jet stream in the stratosphere. These waves can weaken the circulation around the polar vortex and make the polar vortex more susceptible to disruptions by northward-moving warm air masses and high pressure systems. Disruptions in the polar vortex can push part of the main region of frigid Arctic air southward thousands of kilometres, which produce wide-ranging “cold-air outbreaks” or “cold waves” that can decrease air temperatures to dangerous levels over populated areas of Eurasia or North America. For example, a cold-air outbreak in early January 2014 caused surface air temperatures in the eastern United States to plunge roughly 20 °C (36 °F) below average. In addition, a cold wave that struck Europe in March 2013 caused temperatures to fall more than 10 °C (18 °F) below average in parts of Germany, Russia, and Eastern Europe. Such cold waves often result in losses of crops and livestock and even human fatalities.


The polar vortex over Antarctica and its adjacent seas is isolated from air outside the region by the polar-front jet stream in the Southern Hemisphere, which circulates between approximately 50° and 65° S over the Southern Ocean. The Antarctic polar-front jet stream is more uniform and constant than its Arctic counterpart, because Antarctica is surrounded by ocean rather than a mix of land and water. As a result, land-ocean temperature contrasts underneath the jet stream in the Antarctic are not as great as those in the Arctic. In addition, mountains capable of deflecting energy into the jet stream are fewer and distant, so the development of large Rossby waves is less frequent than in the Northern Hemisphere. As a result the Antarctic polar vortex is more resistant than the Arctic polar vortex to incursions made by outside air masses, and it tends to break up only during the onset of spring. Cold-air outbreaks, however, do occur in the Southern Hemisphere, but they are less frequent and strike heavily populated areas less frequently.
 
Polar vortex (Link)
METEOROLOGY
WRITTEN BY:
See Article History
Alternative Titles: circumpolar vortex, circumpolar whirl, polar cyclone, polar low, polar winter vortex

Polar vortex, also called circumpolar vortex, polar low, or polar cyclone, large area of persistent low pressure generally located above each of Earth’s polar regions and containing a mass of extremely cold air. The altitude of this cyclone extends from the middle of the troposphere (the lowest level of Earth’s atmosphere, which spans the region from the surface up to 10–18 km [6–11 miles] high) into the stratosphere (the atmospheric layer extending from 10–18 km to about 50 km [30 miles] high). Cold air is contained within the polar vortex by the polar-front jet stream (an eastward-moving belt of strong stratospheric winds that separates warm tropical air from cold polar air in the midlatitudes). The strength of the polar vortex varies with the season, but it is strongest during the winter season in each hemisphere, when the temperature contrast between the pole and the Equator is greatest. It may weaken or disappear entirely during the warmer months of the year.


Rossby wave patterns over the North Pole depicting the formation of an outbreak of cold air over Asia.Encyclopædia Britannica, Inc.

Over the Northern Hemisphere in the winter season, the polar-front jet stream is located above the midlatitudes (areas located between 30° and 60° N), with wind speeds varying between 193 and 402 km (120 and 250 miles) per hour. If this jet stream’s circulation is strong, the polar vortex maintains a roughly circular shape with a centre at or very near to the North Pole. Undulations in the circulation of the polar-front jet stream (called Rossby waves) can result from incursions of energy generated by land-ocean contrasts in temperature and air deflected by large mountain ranges into the path of the jet stream in the stratosphere. These waves can weaken the circulation around the polar vortex and make the polar vortex more susceptible to disruptions by northward-moving warm air masses and high pressure systems. Disruptions in the polar vortex can push part of the main region of frigid Arctic air southward thousands of kilometres, which produce wide-ranging “cold-air outbreaks” or “cold waves” that can decrease air temperatures to dangerous levels over populated areas of Eurasia or North America. For example, a cold-air outbreak in early January 2014 caused surface air temperatures in the eastern United States to plunge roughly 20 °C (36 °F) below average. In addition, a cold wave that struck Europe in March 2013 caused temperatures to fall more than 10 °C (18 °F) below average in parts of Germany, Russia, and Eastern Europe. Such cold waves often result in losses of crops and livestock and even human fatalities.


The polar vortex over Antarctica and its adjacent seas is isolated from air outside the region by the polar-front jet stream in the Southern Hemisphere, which circulates between approximately 50° and 65° S over the Southern Ocean. The Antarctic polar-front jet stream is more uniform and constant than its Arctic counterpart, because Antarctica is surrounded by ocean rather than a mix of land and water. As a result, land-ocean temperature contrasts underneath the jet stream in the Antarctic are not as great as those in the Arctic. In addition, mountains capable of deflecting energy into the jet stream are fewer and distant, so the development of large Rossby waves is less frequent than in the Northern Hemisphere. As a result the Antarctic polar vortex is more resistant than the Arctic polar vortex to incursions made by outside air masses, and it tends to break up only during the onset of spring. Cold-air outbreaks, however, do occur in the Southern Hemisphere, but they are less frequent and strike heavily populated areas less frequently.
Think of the polar vortex as a giant cold air hurricane. It blows year round. Like a hurricane it weakens and strengthens, but unlike warm weather hurricanes it never travels or disappears. The low pressure zone in the center is always there. Again, it weakens and strengthens, but it never disappears.

Now, let's look at the two major ocean currents that front the Arctic...
  • In the Pacific, it flows in an east-west horizontal elipse, from Tokyo to San Francisco, down to Peru and across to New Zeakand and back up to Tokyo. Sometimes it reverses direction but it flows in the same circuit. The Pacific is virtually blocked off from the Arctic by Alaska and Russia; there is zero chance of warm water flowing into the Arctic from the Pacific Ocean.
  • In the Atlantic, it flows in a northeast-southwest horizontal elipse, from Cuba up the US eastern seaboard onto England down to Mauritania across to Brazil and back up to the Caribbean. The current doesn't divert northward past Iceland, past Greenland, up to the Berents Sea, and into the Arctic Ocean. The only possible affect on that region would be to draw down current.
Can we dismiss this mythological water current bringing hot water from the gulfstream into the Arctic? It simply does not happen.
 
1. I covered it in one of my replies on this page, this morning... but you said "rate of absorption" which I understood as absorption of the sun's rays. Why don't you break down those two for us... how much energy does the earth's surface absorb from the sun's radiation versus absorbed from the earth's own radiation? Let's get a comparison.

2. I said temps at the pole are part of the equation, not that they are carried uniformly throughout the ice cap, but my point was that the ice cap is also a thermally connected structure... so you can't ignore air temps at the pole. Remember, the ice is formed by the air temps acting on the surface of the water; it is a surface action. The Arctic ocean is water from end to end, submarines sail everywhere under the ice cap. The ice is melting at the edge of the ice where ever it is in contact with water... or it is freezing that water and adding ice, depending on the net resultant temp between the ice cap and the water. That is happening between the ice cap and the water... across the entire ice cap, when you say the ice melts on the edges... well it does that (or freezes) everywhere the ice is in contact with water, including the poles. Think of the ice cap as a giant cube of ice floating on top of water... the entire bottom of the ice cap is in contact with the Arctic ocean... air temps are driving the formation of ice; and that is being applied across the entire bottom of the ice cap; that's the edge of the ice cap where interaction with the surface transmits air temps above to the water below. It isn't merely the outer horizontal edges of the ice cap. So, air temps at the pole are as much a part of the equation as air temps anywhere else above the ice cap. Understand the dynamic at work.

Water and air currents around the Arctic and Antarctic circle travel in a circular motion. The polar vortex (Link). It creates a barrier between the climate at the poles and the climate (and currents) of more central latitudes. The poles have their own special climate. Polar climate affects all the regions in contact with the polar vortex. This is more a case of the cold touching the warm than the other way around. At any rate, there is no warm water crossing the polar vortex, get that nonsense out of your head. At the same time, take note: why are scientists peddling total lies like that?

3. You are talking recent projections, under 40 years old. Since they changed directions when the earlier projections of a returning ice age didn't happen.
https://earthobservatory.nasa.gov/features/EnergyBalance/page4.php

link to “earlier projections of a returning ice age” by credible scientists.
 
Back
Top