Obviously there's a ridge there, and if there's a ridge there, it must have pushed up at some point. Also, portions of it are venting. What I'm saying is that you haven't presented the slightest evidence that the heat output of those vents is within even an order of magnitude of what would be needed to account for the meltage much less that a substantial portion of the heat from those vents actually reaches the ice. If you have evidence to support any of those ideas, just present it. None of the links you presented showed how much heat was being put out, total, by those vents, much less estimated what portion was reaching the surface. What we have been able to find are links where the actual scientists who are actively studying the ridge and the vents have dismissed the probability of it having played any substantial role in the melting.
No. That's just the straw man you'd like to refute. But what's a "real volume of heat"? If the goal is to warm up a bathtub or even a sizable lake, I have no doubt the total heat output of that ridge is more than enough. I wouldn't even be surprised if the heat output today, relative to in earlier times when the ice wasn't retreating fast, was substantial relative to what would be needed to heat a bathtub or a lake. But we're not talking about a small-order task like that. We're talking about the heat needed to melt an average of 42,700 square kilometers of ice year after year for the last couple decades. The heat requirements for that are LITERALLY astronomical. It dwarfs the heat output from even the most dramatic volcanoes of modern times.
That would make perfect sense if what the ridge looked like was one Mt. St. Helens-size eruption after another, the entire way down the ridge, constantly. But, of course, that's not remotely what it looks like. The ridge may be 1100 miles long, but most of it is quiet. It looks like this:
It took work to find the actual vents, even after they located the most likely place along the ridge where vents might be located. This wasn't like finding 1100 exploding Mt. St. Helens end to end. It was like trying to find a needle in the haystack. Here's a video where they describe using water sampling to narrow down the most likely place along the ridge to find vents, and then using a robotic explorer to run a search pattern through that area until it found something.
Keep in mind that the scientists who actually went there, and spent months of their lives studying it, are convinced it hasn't played any significant part in the ice melting. If you can produce evidence that says they're wrong, do so.
Also, you seem to be under the impression that ridge just appeared. It didn't. It's was discovered in 1950 and has been there for something like 28 million hears (see 3:20 here:
) The only thing that happened recently is they found the ridge is more volcanically active than the old theories would have predicted. That doesn't mean it's more volcanically active, overall, than it was 100 years ago or a 1000 years ago, etc. It just means it's more volcanically active than we previously realized. So, not only would one need to show that the heat output is anything like what would be needed to melt that much ice, one would also need to show that's significantly higher heat output than in the past (otherwise, why did we have so much ice in polar regions before, compared to now?) A few recent volcanic eruptions there won't do that, since we don't know how many volcanic eruptions there were previously.
Yes.
Depends where and when, obviously.
To take one example, consider Tromso, which is well within the Arctic Circle (latitude 69.65, compared to a little over 66 for the Arctic circle). Here's Tromso's record:
https://www.seatemperature.org/europe/norway/tromso-april.htm
As you'll see, it's currently averaging 4.6 degrees Celsius, which rises gradually to 11.3 degrees Celsius in August. That's 52.3 degrees Fahrenheit. That's brutally cold water by human standards, obviously, but it'll melt ice fast. To put it in perspective, right now we have water temperatures of 48 degrees Fahrenheit here in Boston, and we're not exactly fighting icebergs.
No, but that can change. Do some remedial science reading. Get yourself a geophysics textbook and power through it. It needn't be anything terribly advanced. An intro text will do. Try this, for example:
https://www.amazon.com/Fundamentals...TF8&qid=1493422252&sr=8-2&keywords=geophysics
When your done, it should be easier for you to get where I'm coming from.
You're confused. What's happening is that the sun is hitting open water (which has a very low albedo), and that's warming the water. That warm water from the equator is carried along oceanic currents towards the pole. How much heat it loses along the way has a great deal to do with how cold the water around the current is (since where the current meets colder surrounding water, heat will tend to flow from the current outward), as well as how cold the surrounding air is. Evaporation also factors in -- the drier the air, the faster the evaporation for a given heat level, and the more heat it loses in the process. Eventually, that warm current arrives north. The hotter it was when it started, and the warmer the water it passed along the way, and the warmer and moister the air it passed under, the warmer it will be at its end destination and the more ice it will melt. Meanwhile, the air currents will do much of the same -- carrying warmth from the equator northward, and the more warmth they retain when they get there, the more ice they'll melt (once they're above the freezing point, which they are for a significant chunk of the year)..