Arkady
President
Well, they're all based on total BS. But what's interesting is how their BS seems to coincide with positive outcomes more than nearly all other forms of supernatural BS.Indeed the Mormons are interesting. Who'd have thought a religion built on total BS would end up with Mormon people doing pretty decently overall. It's definitely a tough one to figure out.
I have a theory about that, which I'll admit is only half baked. It involves religions going through a pattern over time. Early on, for the first century or two, they are peopled with true believers. They view themselves as the "city on a hill," in the words of John Winthrop, who led one such group, in Puritan Massachusetts. That metaphor was about the whole world's eyes being on them -- and, as a community, they saw the test of their religious beliefs being in the outcome of their social experiment. Social failure would have meant they followed a false religion, and they couldn't allow that. So, as a community, they worked harder than others, and were willing to sacrifice far more, at the individual level, for the sake of the community. And so the community prospered. The Mormons are still in that stage. They're living like they have something to prove, as a community.
The next stage is when the religion loses its ability to focus people on the social experiment. People are no longer willing to give up anything, personally, for the community, and they no longer think of their society's prosperity as being a proof or disproof of the rightness of their religion. Yet, the religion still has enough emotional impact that there are religious energies that need an outlet, and that outlet comes in doubling down on punishing those who aren't members of their religion, and rallying behind the worst people who take up their religion's banner. I think evangelical Protestantism in the US, and both Islam and Judaism in the Middle East are in that stage.
The third stage is when religion has been compartmentalized into little more than a ceremonial cultural function. People don't really believe in the supernatural elements, any more, and they're not willing to kill and die for the faith, but they still find its traditions comforting, and will use its symbols and metaphors to the extent they fit with what is, at a deeper level a humanistic conception of morality. I think New England Catholics, American Jews, and nearly all the Christians of Western Europe are in that stage.
I think religion and civilization go well together if the religion is in the first or third stage -- when either religion is helping to organize people around the project of civilization, or religion's getting out of the way and letting that project move on without it. But I think that second stage is a tough one to move through. Things tend to suck until either there's some great religious figure who bumps the religion back to the first stage, or until there's an enlightenment that moves it along to the third. Since the first stage tends to devolve into the second with time, I think societies are better off with the third stage, which can be more stable.
Obviously, that's an over-simplified framework, but I think it helps to explain why, say, the states of the Northeast tend to be in pretty good shape (with their complement of cultural Catholics and Jews, along with plenty of non religious people), as is Utah (with its true-believing Mormons), while the Bible Belt is in such rough shape (with a bunch of Baptists and Methodists who believe enough to make other people's lives hell, but not enough to rally the community towards any socially productive goal). The Bible Belt form of religion is kind of the worst of both worlds, since it still has remnants of homophobia and religious intolerance from the first stage, while productive aspects of that religious enthusiasm have been drained by the "prosperity Gospel" and similar decadence.
Last edited: