New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Should personal drones be regulated?

There are calls for the government to regulate personal drones by requiring they be registered. Drone companies of course aren't exactly happy about it, but what do you think?
 
There are calls for the government to regulate personal drones by requiring they be registered. Drone companies of course aren't exactly happy about it, but what do you think?
By "the government" you mean Left Wing authoritarians?

I have no problem with drones, guns, cars, drugs or anything else unless it adversely or unwantedly impacts the rights of others.

For example, you have a right to blast your stereo as loud as you like until it annoys my ears. You have a right to shoot your gun until it endangers my family. You have a right to drive as fast as you like (without a seatbelt!) until you endangers others on the road.

Drones are fine, but if they endanger others or violate the privacy of others, then that's where one's freedom to fly one ends.
 
By "the government" you mean Left Wing authoritarians?

I have no problem with drones, guns, cars, drugs or anything else unless it adversely or unwantedly impacts the rights of others.

For example, you have a right to blast your stereo as loud as you like until it annoys my ears. You have a right to shoot your gun until it endangers my family. You have a right to drive as fast as you like (without a seatbelt!) until you endangers others on the road.

Drones are fine, but if they endanger others or violate the privacy of others, then that's where one's freedom to fly one ends.
Like when they fly close to airliners and around air ports? It is happening several times each day. Kind of dangerous if they fly into a airplane's engine on take off. I don't think that is a liberal or conservative problem, but all of ours.
 
Like when they fly close to airliners and around air ports? It is happening several times each day. Kind of dangerous if they fly into a airplane's engine on take off. I don't think that is a liberal or conservative problem, but all of ours.

From what I've heard they get regulated real well with a shotgun.
 
Like when they fly close to airliners and around air ports? It is happening several times each day. Kind of dangerous if they fly into a airplane's engine on take off. I don't think that is a liberal or conservative problem, but all of ours.

How many drones have come near airplanes on takeoff?
 

Washington Post cut me off. I wasn't even staggering or slurring, I swear it!!!! ;)

For now, I'll try and surmise. I'm aware there have been close calls. However, to my knowledge, none have been on the airport itself. I am certainly not against regulating drones. However, I am curious as to the supposed "Independent" in Wisconsin's logic in only addressing personal drones. Well, that and I would be curious to see how much of an issue drones on airports are.

In the end, it's probably a moot point as any regulation would probably entail something like the current airspace rules with regards to regulating traffic, i.e. within a certain number of miles from an airport and a certain altitude. What we need is an FAA controller or a pilot who could address the specifics.
 
Washington Post cut me off. I wasn't even staggering or slurring, I swear it!!!! ;)

For now, I'll try and surmise. I'm aware there have been close calls. However, to my knowledge, none have been on the airport itself. I am certainly not against regulating drones. However, I am curious as to the supposed "Independent" in Wisconsin's logic in only addressing personal drones. Well, that and I would be curious to see how much of an issue drones on airports are.

In the end, it's probably a moot point as any regulation would probably entail something like the current airspace rules with regards to regulating traffic, i.e. within a certain number of miles from an airport and a certain altitude. What we need is an FAA controller or a pilot who could address the specifics.

They cut you off? You didn't pay your subscription?

If it's not drones, it'll be laser pointers. "Hey, I was just playing around."
 
They cut you off? You didn't pay your subscription?

If it's not drones, it'll be laser pointers. "Hey, I was just playing around."

Apparently without a subscription, you can only view a certain number of articles per month. They said I've exceeded my limit. Now I do admit I've heard that before a time or two in my heyday. ;)

I think drones should be taken very seriously. Same with laser pointers. As with anything, the devil is in the details. However, air travel is pretty safe in the US so I'm going to guess this will be handled fairly well.
 
Apparently without a subscription, you can only view a certain number of articles per month. They said I've exceeded my limit. Now I do admit I've heard that before a time or two in my heyday. ;)

I think drones should be taken very seriously. Same with laser pointers. As with anything, the devil is in the details. However, air travel is pretty safe in the US so I'm going to guess this will be handled fairly well.

Interesting, I guess I don't read their articles that much.

They can be very safe. It's the idiots who will make them dangerous.
 
https://www.rt.com/usa/312400-faa-drone-sightings-rise/

Just one of several articles about drones sighted by air planes. Pretty damn scary. I can just hear the right wing yelling about freedom and "stuff happens".

Ummm... your article states drones are already regulated.

As I stated in another post, though to a rational poster, I think the FAA will handle things just fine. Keep being scared if it's somehow cathartic for you.
 
Interesting, I guess I don't read their articles that much.

They can be very safe. It's the idiots who will make them dangerous.

BINGO. This is one of the areas I was thinking about. When something is used responsibly, there is rarely an issue or problem. I suspect in the end it will take a few idiots being made a good example of. If that takes prison sentences, so be it. I believe it is taking such measures to deal with laser pointers.
 
There are calls for the government to regulate personal drones by requiring they be registered. Drone companies of course aren't exactly happy about it, but what do you think?


So, lets get this straight. There are already rules about drone usage - in so far as they can't be flown near airports and other regulations around security.

But, - and imagine this... SOME people break the law... so the authoritarian knee jerk reaction is - to burden everyone else who is NOT breaking the law... in order to deal with the few who are.

Gee - where have we hear that bass ackwards logic before???:rolleyes:

Absolutely the Gov't has the right for public safety reasons to put reasonable restrictions on the usage of drones, just like any other commercial product. They have done so. The solution then when people break those rules, is to track them down and prosecute them to the fullest extent of the law and make sure it is well publicized, so that other idiots... can get the hint.

The solution is NOT to force law abiding drone users to register their drones and otherwise engage in other practices designed merely to make us "feel safer". And, which burden otherwise law abiding citizens.

So that yes, if God forbid some idiot's drone takes out a plane on take-off that idiot should go to jail for a very very very long time. I fail to see however, exactly how registering one's drone is going to prevent such idiocy from happening. The only thing it seems would possibly do is make it easier for the cops to find them. In which case, our system of Governance, isn't exactly designed, nor should it be to make sure the cops have an easy time finding criminals. And, indeed our personal effects are to be secure against unreasonable search. And, I fail to see how the Gov't having a list of the drones I may have, does not give them an ability to "search" in my possessions by using the list that they have. They should have to get a warrant if they believe the drone that broke the law is mine, to link it to me.

connie
 
Like when they fly close to airliners and around air ports? It is happening several times each day. Kind of dangerous if they fly into a airplane's engine on take off. I don't think that is a liberal or conservative problem, but all of ours.
That would fit under the idea of endangering others.
 
Ummm... your article states drones are already regulated.

As I stated in another post, though to a rational poster, I think the FAA will handle things just fine. Keep being scared if it's somehow cathartic for you.
The problem is, even if they shoot down a drone, how do they find out who was flying it so they can take legal action against the idiot that was flying it in an area they shouldn't for safety's sake. That is why they want to have them registered.
 
So, lets get this straight. There are already rules about drone usage - in so far as they can't be flown near airports and other regulations around security.

But, - and imagine this... SOME people break the law... so the authoritarian knee jerk reaction is - to burden everyone else who is NOT breaking the law... in order to deal with the few who are.

Gee - where have we hear that bass ackwards logic before???:rolleyes:

Absolutely the Gov't has the right for public safety reasons to put reasonable restrictions on the usage of drones, just like any other commercial product. They have done so. The solution then when people break those rules, is to track them down and prosecute them to the fullest extent of the law and make sure it is well publicized, so that other idiots... can get the hint.

The solution is NOT to force law abiding drone users to register their drones and otherwise engage in other practices designed merely to make us "feel safer". And, which burden otherwise law abiding citizens.

So that yes, if God forbid some idiot's drone takes out a plane on take-off that idiot should go to jail for a very very very long time. I fail to see however, exactly how registering one's drone is going to prevent such idiocy from happening. The only thing it seems would possibly do is make it easier for the cops to find them. In which case, our system of Governance, isn't exactly designed, nor should it be to make sure the cops have an easy time finding criminals. And, indeed our personal effects are to be secure against unreasonable search. And, I fail to see how the Gov't having a list of the drones I may have, does not give them an ability to "search" in my possessions by using the list that they have. They should have to get a warrant if they believe the drone that broke the law is mine, to link it to me.

connie
Again, how do you know who owns the drone if you don't have them registered. That is even if you can shoot them down.
 
Back
Top