New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

should republicans testify?

There is not enough members on the committee according to their own rules. 7 democrats and 2 republicans. Yeah that's a real fair panel. The question of whether the committee has the legal authority to force sitting lawmakers to comply with its requests is expected to be the subject of court battles in the coming months. Not to mention executive power that comes into play about any conversations held with the president.

There is no executive privileged that attaches itself to criminal acts. There is also no privilege to be expected for non-Executive branch employees...like anything Trump had to say to members of Congress, Roger Stone, Bannon, the leaders of the Oathkeepers or Proud Boys...etc....

Yes, the guidelines for the committee did suggest 5 republicans. McCarthy pulled three out. If that is a new rule, that if the opposition pulls party members from an investigation the other party can't investigate...then there will be no oversight by congress over the executive branch.
 
Democrats threw that baby out with the bathwater when Holder was held in contempt for not testifying. Dems can't whine when they set the precedent.

1. Issa subpoenaed documents related to conversations between the White House and DOJ AFTER the Fast and Furious ATF operation. He was not attempting to say the WH was responsible for the ATF actions...they were trying to get at conversations that the administration had about how to respond.

2. Holder was not accused of conspiring to hide information related to the administration breaking the law.

Did you happen to notice that there was no attempt to get documents from Operation Wide Receiver (2006 thru 2008)?
 
Same thing now. Democrats are trying to get at conversations that fall under executive privilege. Holder didn't testify, so now you don't have republicans answering to a mocked up witch hunt.
 
Same thing now. Democrats are trying to get at conversations that fall under executive privilege. Holder didn't testify, so now you don't have republicans answering to a mocked up witch hunt.

The Jan 6 committee is trying to get at conversations planning a riot...a criminal act.

The republicans were not investigating criminal actions by the administration.
 
Same thing now. Democrats are trying to get at conversations that fall under executive privilege. Holder didn't testify, so now you don't have republicans answering to a mocked up witch hunt.

BY the way...do you really think every conversation the president has with anyone falls under executive privilege? Are you in favor of making the White House immune to congressional oversight?
 
Back
Top