New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Should Three Strikes Laws apply

degsme

Council Member
So if I plead guilty to 11 Felonies, should the Three Strikes laws apply to me? Should I go to jail for life?

Should I at least have to go to jail?


Seems to me the answer is clearly yes.



So riddle me this. For those of you who assert that Corporations are People and should have the same RIGHTS as persons...
What should we do with BP? http://www.reuters.com/article/2012/11/15/us-bp-spill-statement-idUSBRE8AE19G20121115

After all, it JUST PLEADED GUILTY TO 11 CRIMINAL FELONIES.

When is it going to jail?
For how long is BP going to jail?
Will it lose business while it is in jail?

OR is it that "corporations are people" means its shareholders? If so, are all of BP's shareholders going to jail? For how long?


Of course all of the above is not happening. Which only underscores the ludicrous nature of Citizens United
 
Did ACORN ever serve time?

Seems the members of the organization at fault should serve the time, if they had no legal defense for their actions.

Who was put on trial here?
 
Mr. D,

You can't send an inanimate object to jail.

And if there wasn't the legal established principle of Corporate personhood (not corporation are people, which of course is solely a liberal platitude), then BP would not be liable for the fines will now have to pay.

And the Ruling on Citizens United has nothing to do with this discussion, a non sequitur, as it were
 
The idea of criminal punishment for a corporation strikes me as ridiculous. There should be civil penalties to compensate victims, but the criminal repercussions should be for the actual human beings responsible. The abstract "person" of BP didn't decide to break those laws. Individual people did, either alone or as part of a criminal conspiracy with other individual people. We should be throwing senior execs behind bars, not just fining the company.
 
Mr. D,

You can't send an inanimate object to jail.

And if there wasn't the legal established principle of Corporate personhood (not corporation are people, which of course is solely a liberal platitude), then BP would not be liable for the fines will now have to pay.

And the Ruling on Citizens United has nothing to do with this discussion, a non sequitur, as it were

It was Mitt Rmoney who said "Corporations are people, my friend". Was Mitt uttering a "liberal platitude"?? Do you think Mitt Rmoney is a liberal???

You are right that corporations are 'inanimate'. That's precisely why they can't be people. People are not inanimate objects. Hey, next time you get a chance, explain that to Mitt Rmoney.
 
We seem to've settled upon "going to jail", as some sort of absolute and perhaps "god given" baseline for meting out justice, such that anything different is "less than", or some sort of compromise.

If someone were to walk up to on the street and punch you in the face, and you were offered the alternative of his going to jail for a year or paying you $1 Million, which would you choose? Which would better balance your scales? I think most of us - assuming the puncher had the resources to do so - would opt for the $1 Million. We would feel that THAT better balanced the scales. And in that case - since we presumably opted for more justice - how could anyone argue that was a miscarriage of justice?

Of course if the guy didn't have a $Million, the option wouldn't exist. He'd have to go to jail. In that case, I'd be sorta screwed because I'd rather have the $Million and he'd be screwed, because he'd rather not go to jail. But.....does that mean the former case - with the dude paying me $1 Million, represents INjustice?

The same should apply in the case of the BP-ers. Is justice necessarily BETTER served, by sending people to jail?
 
Mr. Leroy,

He was referring to, after be challanged about Corporate taxes, that corporations are made up of people who pay taxes, not the legal definition of Corprate personhood, as Mr. D was discussing.

Liberals were the ones who turned that into a platitude because they unwashed masses they pander to can only understand simple issues.

By the by, very nice red herring. It got me to bite.
 
Mr. Leroy,

He was referring to, after be challanged about Corporate taxes, that corporations are made up of people who pay taxes, not the legal definition of Corprate personhood, as Mr. D was discussing.

If you don't think Mitt Rmoney was defending the legal definition of corporate personhood, you're a funny guy. Just personally, I think we should have a constitutional amendment to clearly specify that corporations are NOT 'legal persons'.
 
Mr. Leroy,

I don't think, I know. But then again, I'm a critical thinker who researches as subject rather than letting others do my thinking for me.

As for your other point, so you feel that Corporations should not have to abide by environmental, zoning, nor labor laws, Corprations should not be taxed, and that Corporations should not be able to be sued if they violate a contract or other wise injure someone?

Wow, while I thought you were a liberal, turns out you are an out of bounds liberatarian.
 
Mr. Leroy,

I don't think, I know. But then again, I'm a critical thinker who researches as subject rather than letting others do my thinking for me.

As for your other point, so you feel that Corporations should not have to abide by environmental, zoning, nor labor laws, Corprations should not be taxed, and that Corporations should not be able to be sued if they violate a contract or other wise injure someone?

Wow, while I thought you were a liberal, turns out you are an out of bounds liberatarian.

I've seen the video of Mitt Rmoney's faux pas a half-dozen times, Mr. Ya-Ta-Hey. I saw the question that preceded it. I know you enjoy trying to pull a fast one on people, but it won't work with me.

As for your other points, I'd be perfectly willing to end the corporate profits tax, in exchange for substantially higher taxes on wealthy individuals. Of course corporations should have to abide by environmental, zoning, and labor laws. If they don't, their EXECUTIVES should be charged with crimes. Because their executives, you know, are PEOPLE.
 
You can't send an inanimate object to jail.
Mr A-Na-Ye that's hardly critical thinking. That's called understanding the obvious point

And if there wasn't the legal established principle of Corporate personhood (not corporation are people, which of course is solely a liberal platitude), then BP would not be liable for the fines will now have to pay.[/qote]
That of course is not true. Because Corporations are subject to whatever rules and regulations their creative authority (Congress) requires of them. Not very "critically reasoned" by you

And the Ruling on Citizens United has nothing to do with this discussion, a non sequitur, as it were
and now you confirm that you are anything but a "critical thinker"... see I would expect a critical thinker to be able to understand that the common principle underpinning Citizens United was the notion that Corporations have the Consitutional Rights of citizens. And yet somehow they are immune from the OBLIGATIONS of citizenship... hmm how does that work?
 
Well actually I think Criminal Punishment would be just fine. But it would be exactly as the civillian version is. Namely that BP's assets would be "frozen" and Held by The Government, until their "sentence" is served. That would put a HUGE incentive pressure by the shareholders on the management to NOT violate the law.

Note that in this case, individuals who are criminally culpable have also been charged.
 
You are conflating Courts of Equity with Courts of the Crown.

The punch in the face is BOTH an tort for your (recompense of harm to you) with is a Court of Equity issue
and
it is ALSO an offense against the good order of society - a Court of the Crown issue.


Courts of the Crown are CRIMINAL COURTS...

Typically when someone punches you in the face, you BOTH GET

  • Restitution for the harm done (ie $1 mill or whatever the CIVIL court awards you)
    and
  • THEY Go to Jail for violating THE LAW.


but somehow magically being a "corporate person" inures you to the latter.
 
Did ACORN ever serve time?
ACORN has never been found guilty of a Felony

Seems the members of the organization at fault should serve the time, if they had no legal defense for their actions.

Who was put on trial here?
BOTH
BP employees are facing jail time for their criminal acts.
Why does the "corporate person" of BP not face the same?

Why are Corporate Persons immune from the obligations Born Persons face?
 
You are conflating Courts of Equity with Courts of the Crown.

The punch in the face is BOTH an tort for your (recompense of harm to you) with is a Court of Equity issue
and
it is ALSO an offense against the good order of society - a Court of the Crown issue.


Courts of the Crown are CRIMINAL COURTS...

Typically when someone punches you in the face, you BOTH GET

  • Restitution for the harm done (ie $1 mill or whatever the CIVIL court awards you)
    and
  • THEY Go to Jail for violating THE LAW.


but somehow magically being a "corporate person" inures you to the latter.

Your meaningless blah-blah-blah isn't the least bit germane to my point. I'm aware of the distinction between criminal and civil and if it were the least bit relevant, I would've suggested it.
I prefer to dispense with the superfluous, because it tends to be distracting.
 
Ok except it IS germane to your point.

Your point posited a FALSE dichotomy a consequence of a punch in your face: EITHER criminal or Civil consequences.

When in fact BOTH would apply to a born person.
 
Ok except it IS germane to your point.

Your point posited a FALSE dichotomy a consequence of a punch in your face: EITHER criminal or Civil consequences.

When in fact BOTH would apply to a born person.

Bullshit....you misred the dichotomy, so your flatulation that it's "false", is false. My premise assumed the civil/criminal distinction and thus, wasn't the least bit dependent upon it. I'm suggesting an alternative view of the concept of justice, that assumes the current distinction. I assume my "readers" are aware of that distinction, and don't need an insulting recitation of the distinction they're already aware of.
 
Bullshit....you misred the dichotomy, so your flatulation that it's "false", is false. My premise assumed the civil/criminal distinction and thus, wasn't the least bit dependent upon it. I'm suggesting an alternative view of the concept of justice, that assumes the current distinction.
No you offered a tradeoff BETWEEN

  • The criminal consequence (puncher goes to jail)
    and
  • The Civil consequence (Puncher pays restitution)

yet under the CURRENT system of jurisprudence BOTH APPLY.
 
Back
Top