New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Simple Gil Collar question

Spamature

President
Did the case of Gil Collar deserve to be heard before a judge and jury ?

Please give an honest answer .
 
So that means what ? The shooting was justified ?

It means they must have thought it was, and I am fine with that. From what I have read on the case, it was similiar in that he faced off against the officer, and appeared to the officer to be advancing on him. The officer has a right to defend himself, with lethal force if necessary if that is his reasonable perception of the situation.
 
why didn't gil collar's family and friends burn the town to the ground?

it would seem to be the thing to do.

Who said anyone's "family and or friends" burned anything to the ground ? Do you have video of family or friends actually participating in these crimes.
 
It means they must have thought it was, and I am fine with that. From what I have read on the case, it was similiar in that he faced off against the officer, and appeared to the officer to be advancing on him. The officer has a right to defend himself, with lethal force if necessary if that is his reasonable perception of the situation.

So you feel that there is nothing for anyone to be upset about in this case ?
 
You haven't posted and opinion of the circumstances ?

Sure, since it came up here recently. I had an opinion on it when it happened, too. Is there some rule about discussing things that happened in the past? If so, I'll remember it next time your Bush Derangement Syndrome acts up...
 
So you feel that there is nothing for anyone to be upset about in this case ?

Well, I am sure his parents are upset, I am sure his family is upset. I am sure the officer' is upset that he took a life, no matter how justified he thought it was at the moment.

There is certainly nothing for me to be upset about. The Cop reacted to what he perceived as a threat of physical violence with physical violence. I am not going to play armchair quarterback, and sit here from my nice safe office and say, well.. you could have done something differently when he had moments to react in what he likely felt was self defense.

It is certainly unfortunate that this young man is dead. It is certainly unfortunate that the cop will have to live with that guilt. But, as in the Michael Brown case, it could have been completely avoided if the suspect had listened to the instructions of the officer, and maintained a submissive response and surrendered completely.
 
Sure, since it came up here recently. I had an opinion on it when it happened, too. Is there some rule about discussing things that happened in the past? If so, I'll remember it next time your Bush Derangement Syndrome acts up...

Nothing wrong with discussing things in the past. Especially when things that happened in the past keep creating new consequences for the present. But anyway, that means you have raised it here. Remember I asked you to be honest.
 
Nothing wrong with discussing things in the past. Especially when things that happened in the past keep creating new consequences for the present. But anyway, that means you have raised it here. Remember I asked you to be honest.

No, I didn't raise it here. I commented on it after someone else did. You're starting to sound crazy like Bugsy now...you can do better than that.
 
Well, I am sure his parents are upset, I am sure his family is upset. I am sure the officer' is upset that he took a life, no matter how justified he thought it was at the moment.

There is certainly nothing for me to be upset about. The Cop reacted to what he perceived as a threat of physical violence with physical violence. I am not going to play armchair quarterback, and sit here from my nice safe office and say, well.. you could have done something differently when he had moments to react in what he likely felt was self defense.

It is certainly unfortunate that this young man is dead. It is certainly unfortunate that the cop will have to live with that guilt. But, as in the Michael Brown case, it could have been completely avoided if the suspect had listened to the instructions of the officer, and maintained a submissive response and surrendered completely.

Well I mean people without a personal involvement. I'm a sure Manson's friends and families will be upset about his death. But outside that circle we see that opinions do differ. Anyway since none of us are actually on that judicial playing field in Ferguson we are all armchair quarterbacks when it comes to our opinions. None of us know what it was like to in those moments get into a struggle with an armed Darren Wilson and to be shot by him or to be shot at by him while fleeing or to be shot multiple times in the head and chest by him. Which is factually the most dangerous thing that happened in this situation. So making any kind of judgements about the participants is about as armchair as you can get. Wouldn't you agree ?
 
No, I didn't raise it here. I commented on it after someone else did. You're starting to sound crazy like Bugsy now...you can do better than that.

And you are being pedantic. Raising verse commenting ? Really ? This thread was not about who top posted what. If you participated in the conversations on the subject you are just as much part of it as the subject's top poster. Remember , be honest !
 
Did the case of Gil Collar deserve to be heard before a judge and jury ?

Please give an honest answer .


A Grand Jury in Alabama decided not to bring forth an indictment in that case. Since they reviewed all the evidence and I am in no position to do the same, how could I object?
 
Back
Top