New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Simple question on 14th Amendment...

As you know, I answered that question already. Those words were put there to exclude those over whom the US did not have jurisdiction, such as diplomats.

Do you have anything new to say in support of your oddball position?

And people here without permission would certainly fit that same restriction.
 
Where have I been rigid? All I did was question your understanding of parentage in regards to international law. Surely a lawyer would understand this.

Who said I was a lawyer?

And I'm sorry you didn't understand that it is up to Mexico to determine who their citizens are much like we do. They choose to make the children of their citizens born abroad to also be citizens. They may well choose not to accept that anymore.

We'd be stuck with the child and by international law we would not be able to send the parents back, duh.
 
Where have I been rigid? All I did was question your understanding of parentage in regards to international law. Surely a lawyer would understand this.

You should ignore that tangential drivel. It has nothing to do with what the 14th Amendment says.
 
The US has no jurisdiction over illegal aliens or their children born here?

Wow, the wacky shit you people are willing to say to flack for your GOP cult.

;-)

Of course not - they don't even know they are here!!! Duh!

Having "jurisdiction" over them means they are here LEGALLY. Period!
 
You should ignore that tangential drivel. It has nothing to do with what the 14th Amendment says.
Agreed, but to be fair, I pay occasional attention to your tangential drivel, so it's just fair that I do the same for your polar opposite.

Do you know that you and @resident_evil are two sides of the very same coin?

35i9elt.jpg
 
Supreme Court activisim.

Plain and simple.

TBH - I do not understand why it was ever interpreted to include just anyone. It should have at least been interpreted to include only the children of legal residents. It is completely ridiculous that someone could be vacationing here, give birth and then that child is a citizen here, for later which if they go home would have to revoke citizenship potentially down the line for opportunities in their home country, etc.
It never meant that someone could just run across the border and have a baby so that that baby would be a citizen.

However, the make up of our SCOTUS now would probably support that fallacy. Supreme Court activism has screwed us more than once.
 
It never meant that someone could just run across the border and have a baby so that that baby would be a citizen.

However, the make up of our SCOTUS now would probably support that fallacy. Supreme Court activism has screwed us more than once.

Agreed! How is someone who the feds have no idea is here "subject to the jurisdiction" of the US? By definition they are hiding from the jurisdiction of the US.

The idea that that clause applies to illegal immigrants is absurd.
 
Of course not - they don't even know they are here!!! Duh!

Having "jurisdiction" over them means they are here LEGALLY. Period!

That's by and large false of course - most illegals either work, or go to school, or get medical attention, or any number of other things that bring them to the attention of the government. We know most of them are here.

But whether or not we know they are here, they are within the jurisdiction of the US, and the US has jurisdiction over them. They cannot act here with impunity.

Again, you reveal the depths to which GOP cultists will say dopey shit to flack for your cult.
 
McGoo, Maxr, and Middler share the same proclivity to demand answers to questions that you have already received. It is such a feeble gambit. Very strange.

Nah, as you very well know, you dodge my questions. It pretty much squares your lameness when you dodge my questions and then falsely claim you answered them. Your dodges are right here - plain to see. You just can't lie about it.

But lie you nevertheless will.

Pathetic. And VERY lame.

;-)
 
Nah, as you very well know, you dodge my questions. It pretty much squares your lameness when you dodge my questions and then falsely claim you answered them. Your dodges are right here - plain to see. You just can't lie about it.

But lie you nevertheless will.

Pathetic. And VERY lame.

;-)
Mr. McGoo is a good name for you. Speaks to your blindness and blind luck.

 
Back
Top