New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

SNOPES

My views don't diverge from the facts. Your opinion that if the US economy had been left alone to recover that it would have prevented WWII. It is your opinion and lacks any supporting facts at all.

The facts as interpreted by the progressive, Keynesian, Marxist "intelligensia." The FACT is the Great Depression lasted until at least the US entrance into WWII, or more correctly, until after the war ended and actual production (not war spending induced production) regained its prior trajectory. Your 3rd world "investment" web site's views, notwithstanding.

And, while I've got the opportunity, I'll point out once again how the economy today is echoing the Great Depression, as a result of Barack Obama's FDR like anti-capitalist (and power mad) economic policies:

Screen Shot 2017-09-02 at 5.31.23 PM.png

You keep telling us how great the economy was in the 30s (and is today) and I'll keep throwing out the charts that prove otherwise, and we'll just let the chips fall where they may...
 
The facts as interpreted by the progressive, Keynesian, Marxist "intelligensia." The FACT is the Great Depression lasted until at least the US entrance into WWII, or more correctly, until after the war ended and actual production (not war spending induced production) regained its prior trajectory. Your 3rd world "investment" web site's views, notwithstanding.

And, while I've got the opportunity, I'll point out once again how the economy today is echoing the Great Depression, as a result of Barack Obama's FDR like anti-capitalist (and power mad) economic policies:

View attachment 37550


You keep telling us how great the economy was in the 30s (and is today) and I'll keep throwing out the charts that prove otherwise, and we'll just let the chips fall where they may...

why lie...no post of mine claims the economy was great in the 30's.

I posted facts...which you have failed to refute. you continue to post opinions that you pretend prove FDR started ww2 to bail out his economy...forgetting that war in europe started in 1939 and the US stayed out until Hitler declared war on us. War in Asia started in 1931 and we stayed out until attacked...
 
Last edited:
As Europe still does. As many countries do -------- so what?

And the conscription was not just for the military - it was two years in service for your country - and still is.

The military, under Hitler, went from 100,000 to 1 million men. You're nuts to try to claim that Hitler wanted peace. Why did he send troops to Spain? Why did the German air force bomb Guenica? Why did he threaten war if Czechoslovakia didn't surrender their western third of the country?
 
why lie...no post of mine claims the economy was great in the 30's.

I posted facts...which you have failed to refute. you continue to post opinions that you pretend prove FDR started ww2 to bail out his economy...forgetting that war in europe started in 1939 and the US stayed out until Hitler declared war on us. War in Asia started in 1931 and we stayed out until attacked...

Are you willing to at least admit you were wrong about the Great Depression having "ended" in 1933? Maybe then we can start making progress on your (flawed) definition of what a "depression" actually is. And THEN we can move on to a discussion of the reasons why a very powerful, egotistical and strong willed (some might say bull headed) President, when confronted by his Treasury Secretary with the failure of his economic policies:

http://dailysignal.com/2009/01/14/were-spending-more-than-ever-and-it-doesnt-work/

Might come to the conclusion that the only way out of a legacy of economic failure is one of wartime success.
 
The military, under Hitler, went from 100,000 to 1 million men. You're nuts to try to claim that Hitler wanted peace. Why did he send troops to Spain? Why did the German air force bomb Guenica? Why did he threaten war if Czechoslovakia didn't surrender their western third of the country?

We were talking about conscription, as is still in situ, in Europe.
 
I beg to differ. There's way more similarities than differences between the two depressions. Even beyond the fact that they happened to occur under the two most anti-capitalist Presidents in American history...

Herbert Hoover and George W. Bush?
 
Are you willing to at least admit you were wrong about the Great Depression having "ended" in 1933? Maybe then we can start making progress on your (flawed) definition of what a "depression" actually is. And THEN we can move on to a discussion of the reasons why a very powerful, egotistical and strong willed (some might say bull headed) President, when confronted by his Treasury Secretary with the failure of his economic policies:

http://dailysignal.com/2009/01/14/were-spending-more-than-ever-and-it-doesnt-work/

Might come to the conclusion that the only way out of a legacy of economic failure is one of wartime success.

The NBER definition shows a depression or recession is ended when the GDP begins to grow. That definition shows the depression ended and the recovery began in 1933. We lost something like 30% of the GDP from 1929 and 1933.

You have a different definition. That doesn't mean the NBER is wrong.

Again, your conclusions are your opinions. None of which are supported by fact. There is nothing that FDR could have done to recover a drop of 30% GDP and 25% unemployment in time to change Hitler & Germany's path to war.

sos_line.php
 
The NBER definition shows a depression or recession is ended when the GDP begins to grow. That definition shows the depression ended and the recovery began in 1933. We lost something like 30% of the GDP from 1929 and 1933.

You have a different definition. That doesn't mean the NBER is wrong.

Again, your conclusions are your opinions. None of which are supported by fact. There is nothing that FDR could have done to recover a drop of 30% GDP and 25% unemployment in time to change Hitler & Germany's path to war.

sos_line.php

So then find me a historical account of the Great Depression that says it ended in 1933. Not one parsed from a debatable economic definition. I linked you to a NBER published paper that specifically stated that the Depression endured until (I think it was) 1939. Are they arguing with themselves?

Do you or don't you agree with the conventional wisdom that the Great Depression lasted until at least 1939? That is a pretty simple, yes or no, question.
 
So then find me a historical account of the Great Depression that says it ended in 1933. Not one parsed from a debatable economic definition. I linked you to a NBER published paper that specifically stated that the Depression endured until (I think it was) 1939. Are they arguing with themselves?

Do you or don't you agree with the conventional wisdom that the Great Depression lasted until at least 1939? That is a pretty simple, yes or no, question.

https://www.nber.org/cycles.html
 

Hmmm. I went to your link and searched the page for "Great Depression" but got zero results. Shouldn't a link purporting to confirm that the Great Depression was over by the end of 1933 use the term at least once?

This is the same crap you guys are trying to pull with Obama's (failed) economic legacy. You point to the fact that the economy stopped dropping soon after he was elected as "proof" that he "fixed" the Bush recession, as if the economy was destined to continue down until everyone was unemployed and GDP equaled zero, if not for his "steady hand" taking the tiller. That, of course, is absurd. The economy has never continued downward without end, and always, even when big government interventionists weren't conveniently in place to end the economic spiral to economic oblivion by vastly growing government and its control over the economic course, a downward trend ends at some point (IOW with or without government intervention). In fact, there is little that government can do to affect when and how that downward process ends. Remember how Obama suggested he had indeed done exactly that with the Administration's announcement of the "summer of recovery." A boast that soon morphed into "we didn't know how bad things actually were." And then later "we obviously should have done even more." LOL! That right there should tell you they were bullshitting their way through the entire ordeal. In fact, it is well regarded conventional wisdom that the deeper the downturn the sharper the rebound. The very fact that such a snap back eluded these two big government economic interventionists should tell you all you need about the efficacy of these kinds of Keynesian policy agendas that place the economic fate of intricately intertwined markets and hundreds of millions of people in the hands of bumbling bureaucrats. Anyone (and that would include you) who thinks these two Presidents actually produced better economic results than would have occurred in a less interventionist environment is simply showing their ideological stripes, rather than their understanding of actual economic history.
 
The military, under Hitler, went from 100,000 to 1 million men. You're nuts to try to claim that Hitler wanted peace. Why did he send troops to Spain? Why did the German air force bomb Guenica? Why did he threaten war if Czechoslovakia didn't surrender their western third of the country?

What he wanted (in all likelihood) was to put them to work (military Keynesianism). As usual, failed Keynesian policies usually lead to war...
 
Herbert Hoover and George W. Bush?

Yep - neither one was a free market capitalist. Bush made his frigging fortune through eminent domain where the Ranger's stadium authority was able to take the land around the new stadium and award it to the team's owners (including one George W. Bush). The idea that those guys somehow exposed the failures of capitalism says more about your "implicit Marxism" than it does about your knowledge of the historical facts surrounding these depressions.
 
Hmmm. I went to your link and searched the page for "Great Depression" but got zero results. Shouldn't a link purporting to confirm that the Great Depression was over by the end of 1933 use the term at least once?

This is the same crap you guys are trying to pull with Obama's (failed) economic legacy. You point to the fact that the economy stopped dropping soon after he was elected as "proof" that he "fixed" the Bush recession, as if the economy was destined to continue down until everyone was unemployed and GDP equaled zero, if not for his "steady hand" taking the tiller. That, of course, is absurd. The economy has never continued downward without end, and always, even when big government interventionists weren't conveniently in place to end the economic spiral to economic oblivion by vastly growing government and its control over the economic course, a downward trend ends at some point (IOW with or without government intervention). In fact, there is little that government can do to affect when and how that downward process ends. Remember how Obama suggested he had indeed done exactly that with the Administration's announcement of the "summer of recovery." A boast that soon morphed into "we didn't know how bad things actually were." And then later "we obviously should have done even more." LOL! That right there should tell you they were bullshitting their way through the entire ordeal. In fact, it is well regarded conventional wisdom that the deeper the downturn the sharper the rebound. The very fact that such a snap back eluded these two big government economic interventionists should tell you all you need about the efficacy of these kinds of Keynesian policy agendas that place the economic fate of intricately intertwined markets and hundreds of millions of people in the hands of bumbling bureaucrats. Anyone (and that would include you) who thinks these two Presidents actually produced better economic results than would have occurred in a less interventionist environment is simply showing their ideological stripes, rather than their understanding of actual economic history.

I provided a link with the dates of the depression and you couldn't find it...showing once and for all, you couldn't find your ass with both hands and a flashlight.

1. No, nobody said that the economy was destined to continue down until everyone was unemployed...but it certainly could have continued to 25% unemployment as it did until 1933.

2. Nobody suggested Obama "fixed" the Bush recession....you continue to misrepresent and misquote what others post. Proof you are losing the debate when you can't even be honest about the contents of the posts in the thread.

3. The most meaningful measure of a recession or depression and the recovery is unemployment...which you discount as meaningless. In fact, if the unemployment rate stayed at 5% or less...a recession would go by without any real negative impact to the population. The real pain is to those who have lost their jobs and their homes....Both FDR and Obama made the impact to the population less.
 
Yep - neither one was a free market capitalist. Bush made his frigging fortune through eminent domain where the Ranger's stadium authority was able to take the land around the new stadium and award it to the team's owners (including one George W. Bush). The idea that those guys somehow exposed the failures of capitalism says more about your "implicit Marxism" than it does about your knowledge of the historical facts surrounding these depressions.

Bush was a thief and broke the law in the insider trading case...He absolutely violated the intent of eminent domain laws to make himself wealthy, but he certainly wasn't a Marxist.

By the way....the Eminent Domain case involving the Mathes family (and others) didn't "award" the land to the stadium authority. If forced the owners to sell at a FMV determines by the authority...which was substantially less than the real value of the land. The stadium authority later lost a law suit that forced a fair value to be placed on the land. I think Bush got away with not paying anything towards the judgment.
 
Bush was a thief and broke the law in the insider trading case...He absolutely violated the intent of eminent domain laws to make himself wealthy, but he certainly wasn't a Marxist.

By the way....the Eminent Domain case involving the Mathes family (and others) didn't "award" the land to the stadium authority. If forced the owners to sell at a FMV determines by the authority...which was substantially less than the real value of the land. The stadium authority later lost a law suit that forced a fair value to be placed on the land. I think Bush got away with not paying anything towards the judgment.

I didn't say he was. I said YOU were for suggesting he was a free market laissez faire economic policy President.
 
I provided a link with the dates of the depression and you couldn't find it...showing once and for all, you couldn't find your ass with both hands and a flashlight.

1. No, nobody said that the economy was destined to continue down until everyone was unemployed...but it certainly could have continued to 25% unemployment as it did until 1933.

2. Nobody suggested Obama "fixed" the Bush recession....you continue to misrepresent and misquote what others post. Proof you are losing the debate when you can't even be honest about the contents of the posts in the thread.

3. The most meaningful measure of a recession or depression and the recovery is unemployment...which you discount as meaningless. In fact, if the unemployment rate stayed at 5% or less...a recession would go by without any real negative impact to the population. The real pain is to those who have lost their jobs and their homes....Both FDR and Obama made the impact to the population less.

That's ridiculous! I went to the page and searched for the term "great depression" with zero results. You are conflating the dates of the recession with the dates of the depression, which even NBER does not do. So I think we all know who can't find his ass with both hands and a flashlight.

You have to clear the markets, including the labor markets, in order to get a full and robust recovery. Trying to interfere with that process produces a dysfunctional labor market, such as we have now, where the total number of full time jobs, almost a decade later, are barely above the number there were before the recession started. You look at that as success, particularly since your preferred measure, "unemployment" makes that labor market look way better than it is. We've been around and around about the LFPR decline, which you seem to think is some sort of bonus from the Obama depression (people free to sit in their parents' basement playing video games rather than getting a real job, but not counting as "unemployed" because they gave up looking for jobs that don't exist). Which is why your suggestion that it is the "most meaningful measure of a recession" simply shows either your naiveté or your deceit in this effort.
 
That's ridiculous! I went to the page and searched for the term "great depression" with zero results. You are conflating the dates of the recession with the dates of the depression, which even NBER does not do. So I think we all know who can't find his ass with both hands and a flashlight.

You have to clear the markets, including the labor markets, in order to get a full and robust recovery. Trying to interfere with that process produces a dysfunctional labor market, such as we have now, where the total number of full time jobs, almost a decade later, are barely above the number there were before the recession started. You look at that as success, particularly since your preferred measure, "unemployment" makes that labor market look way better than it is. We've been around and around about the LFPR decline, which you seem to think is some sort of bonus from the Obama depression (people free to sit in their parents' basement playing video games rather than getting a real job, but not counting as "unemployed" because they gave up looking for jobs that don't exist). Which is why your suggestion that it is the "most meaningful measure of a recession" simply shows either your naiveté or your deceit in this effort.

The link showed that the economy was growing again in 1933. The symptoms of the depression, the number of failing banks, the unemployment numbers and business failures were all getting worse up until 1933 when FDR took over. The decline in GDP had been more than 30%...and was not showing any sign of improving on it's own.

The depression of 1920 was entirely related to factory shutdowns that were voluntary as they shifted back to non-military production. As soon as they were done with that the workers would all come back to work and the production would go back to normal or even better, since demand would have been there the entire time. No "market clearing" was needed.

The depression of 1929 was world wide...the depression of 1920 was not.
 
Back
Top