New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

SNOPES

Sheesh, you are making the same asinine wrong interpretation of what I said that @middleview did. I said the depression helped bring Hitler to power, not FDR. I said FDR's failed economic policies (which extended the depression by almost a decade) allowed Hitler to consolidate power, and also led to WWII. There's a pretty big nuance there and I'd appreciate it if you circle back and get it...

Feel free to make the case ... the U.S. recovered a lot faster than the UK though.
 
Sheesh, you are making the same asinine wrong interpretation of what I said that @middleview did. I said the depression helped bring Hitler to power, not FDR. I said FDR's failed economic policies (which extended the depression by almost a decade) allowed Hitler to consolidate power, and also led to WWII. There's a pretty big nuance there and I'd appreciate it if you circle back and get it...

Bullshit. Hitler was in power before FDR took office. When Hindenburg died Hitler became the defacto dictator. Hindenburg's death was not caused by FDR's policies.

The depression was far worse than the economy Reagan dealt with and yet Reagan's recovery was from 7% unemployment to 10.8% in 18 months...and above 7% until 1986...5 years. FDR's economy provided improving unemployment numbers every year from 1933 on (1937 took a hit)....Germany's economy recovered more quickly than the US economy did after 1933.

By the way, you made the comment that FDR did not repeal Smoot Hawley. What he did do was sign the Reciprocal Trade Agreements Act which substantially reduced tariffs..that was in 1934.
 
I don't applaud McCain or Graham as heroes. The Republican Party nominated warmonger McCain for president if you'll recall. War is part of the process by which capitalism maintains itself (and would be even if socialism didn't exist) as well as part of the process by which it will be destroyed.

Which is why communist regimes never engage in war…oops! War is the last refuge of failed Keynesians (and the first refuge of warmongers like John McCain). Capitalists just want to do business with everybody - and war gets in the way of that.
 
Bullshit. Hitler was in power before FDR took office. When Hindenburg died Hitler became the defacto dictator. Hindenburg's death was not caused by FDR's policies.

The depression was far worse than the economy Reagan dealt with and yet Reagan's recovery was from 7% unemployment to 10.8% in 18 months...and above 7% until 1986...5 years. FDR's economy provided improving unemployment numbers every year from 1933 on (1937 took a hit)....Germany's economy recovered more quickly than the US economy did after 1933.

By the way, you made the comment that FDR did not repeal Smoot Hawley. What he did do was sign the Reciprocal Trade Agreements Act which substantially reduced tariffs..that was in 1934.

"1937 took a hit" ... because the government cut taxes and spending ... btw
 
Which is why communist regimes never engage in war…oops! War is the last refuge of failed Keynesians (and the first refuge of warmongers like John McCain). Capitalists just want to do business with everybody - and war gets in the way of that.

"Communist regimes" engage in war against capitalism to put an end to war and other social evils of class society. "If you want peace, you have to be willing to fight for it."-Bobby Seale

Business requires war to maintain profitability under circumstances of irrational competition and oversaturation of markets.
 
By 1933 Hitler's regime was already in place ... only overthrowing him could have stopped him ... the improving world economy only gave him more weapons to work with.

We're both speculating here but if the German people weren't pissed off about two decades of deteriorating economic conditions, they likely would have overthrown him themselves.
 
Except that he announced that aim in Mein Kampf well in advance. And that that's how the logic of imperialism (and, yes, Keynesianism in particular) works.

Yes, the aim to reclaim Germany's century old tradition of military strength (not unlike what Reagan did after the post-Vietnam decline in US military prowess. I don't believe he announced he planned to start WWII...
 
The famine happened...where is the evidence that Churchill was to blame?

He looted their crops and stockpiled them.

''Mukerjee, a Bengali herself, has conducted extensive research to document what she writes, and also interacted with those who survived the holocaust and lost their parents, children, and other relatives. In Bengal, millions were dying because of food shortages caused by British looting to feed the troops engaged in World War II, and partly due to nature’s fury in the midst of a well-developed independence movement, which led to the end of the British rule in 1947. She documents the British War Cabinet’s role, Churchill’s, in particular, in exacerbating the food shortages, stonewalling attempts to send food from other countries to alleviate the crisis, and, in fact, justifying the necessity to cull those who are not only ‘inferior,’ but who breed likerabbits.



The author points out that Churchill, explaining why he defended the stockpiling of food within Britain, while millions died of starvation in Bengal, told his private secretary that ‘the Hindus were a foul race, protected by their mere pullulation from the doom that is their due.’ Pullulation, Mukerjee notes, means rapid breeding.''

http://www.vijayvaani.com/ArticleDisplay.aspx?aid=1396

''Churchill, as part of the Western war effort, ordered the diversion of food from starving Indians to already well-supplied British soldiers and stockpiles in Britain and elsewhere in Europe, including Greece and Yugoslavia. And he did so with a churlishness that cannot be excused on grounds of policy: Churchill's only response to a telegram from the government in Delhi about people perishing in the famine was to ask why Gandhi hadn't died yet.

http://content.time.com/time/magazine/article/0,9171,2031992,00.html
 
"Communist regimes" engage in war against capitalism to put an end to war and other social evils of class society. "If you want peace, you have to be willing to fight for it."-Bobby Seale

Business requires war to maintain profitability under circumstances of irrational competition and oversaturation of markets.

Which only happens as a result of big government central planning. Big government requires war, not capitalism.
 
Bullshit. Hitler was in power before FDR took office. When Hindenburg died Hitler became the defacto dictator. Hindenburg's death was not caused by FDR's policies.

The depression was far worse than the economy Reagan dealt with and yet Reagan's recovery was from 7% unemployment to 10.8% in 18 months...and above 7% until 1986...5 years. FDR's economy provided improving unemployment numbers every year from 1933 on (1937 took a hit)....Germany's economy recovered more quickly than the US economy did after 1933.

By the way, you made the comment that FDR did not repeal Smoot Hawley. What he did do was sign the Reciprocal Trade Agreements Act which substantially reduced tariffs..that was in 1934.
main-qimg-658250197fe36bf5f8acd109a5f50606.webp
 
We're both speculating here but if the German people weren't pissed off about two decades of deteriorating economic conditions, they likely would have overthrown him themselves.

Wouldn't being pissed off at Germany's economic state make them more likely to want to overthrow the government? Anyway, what did Roosevelt do to make economic conditions in Germany worse? He lowered tariffs, which improved Germany's outlook ... otherwise his policies had little effect on Germany afaict.
 
And when did that take a real hold?

I would say around the turn of the 19th century ... the construction of transcontinental railroads is a big turning point for both the U.S. and Europe as are the Franco-Prussian War, Spanish-Cuban-American War, Boer War, and Russo-Japanese War.
 
Wouldn't being pissed off at Germany's economic state make them more likely to want to overthrow the government? Anyway, what did Roosevelt do to make economic conditions in Germany worse? He lowered tariffs, which improved Germany's outlook ... otherwise his policies had little effect on Germany afaict.

Hitler was probably the most loved leader that the world has ever know = why they had to vilify him.
 
I would say around the turn of the 19th century ... the construction of transcontinental railroads is a big turning point for both the U.S. and Europe as are the Franco-Prussian War, Spanish-Cuban-American War, Boer War, and Russo-Japanese War.

Another class was born -
 
Back
Top