New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

SNOPES

The Depression did, and that is what led to WWII. And it wasn't just Hitler, it was all the despots, like Mussolini and Hirohito. So it really doesn't matter if Hitler had "power over" or just partnered with them. It was all an outgrowth of the depression. Isolationism and nationalism were direct outgrowths of the Great Depression and that was what led to WWII.

Just because this doesn't comport with the liberal progressive version of history you subscribe to doesn't mean the idea is "desperate." Just not "conventional wisdom." And, as we've seen again and again and again, the liberal progressive "conventional wisdom" is, quite simply, propaganda.

The Great Depression was already a fait accompli by the time Roosevelt was elected.
 
The Great Depression was already a fait accompli by the time Roosevelt was elected.

Then why did it persist throughout his time in office (not coincidently, like the current one lasted throughout Obama's)?

The timing of the Great Depression varied across nations; in most countries it started in 1929 and lasted until 1941.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Great_Depression

Again, when this kind of shit show economy happens, it's not because of what wasn't done, but rather what was...
 
Then why did it persist throughout his time in office (not coincidently, like the current one lasted throughout Obama's)?

The timing of the Great Depression varied across nations; in most countries it started in 1929 and lasted until 1941.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Great_Depression

Again, when this kind of shit show economy happens, it's not because of what wasn't done, but rather what was...

Because the crisis for capitalism of abundance was particularly sharp and the markets could not clear until war destroyed huge stocks of wealth. Why did things immediately get better in the U.S. as his New Deal policies took effect, and only take a turn for the worse when his government cut spending and debt? And why did every other nation also suffer from the Depression, with the sole exception of the booming USSR?
 
You can decide for yourself, just like everyone else. Some might think a company that is engaging in tax avoidance is less-than-ethical, but that's for each individual decide for themselves.

That's not an attack, it's public knowledge. I'm all for people deciding for themselves - If you're not, well, then you're not.
Some might also think that a man who avoids releasing his taxes is less than ethical. But you call him your president.
 
Because the crisis for capitalism of abundance was particularly sharp and the markets could not clear until war destroyed huge stocks of wealth. Why did things immediately get better in the U.S. as his New Deal policies took effect, and only take a turn for the worse when his government cut spending and debt? And why did every other nation also suffer from the Depression, with the sole exception of the booming USSR?

You mean like this?

Screen Shot 2017-09-29 at 4.44.34 PM.png

The markets could have cleared, if the government got out of the way and let it happen. Like during the "depression we never hear about:"

https://mises.org/library/forgotten-depression-1920

What happens is the big government "stimulus" crowds out the private sector, which suffers from a lack of market clearing "creative destruction" and, worse yet, the anti-capitalist policies these leftist central planners always foist upon the private sector. The economy appears to be improving, but only because of all the government (deficit) spending, while the private economy shrinks under the weight of all those leftist "good intentions." Look at that chart above. What do you think would happen now if the government stops borrowing and spending? It should have let the markets clear in 2008 by getting out of the way - no bail outs, no "stimulus," no "capitalism fixing" regulations. Just let the economy heal, as it always does, without government interference.
 
You mean like this?

View attachment 37413

The markets could have cleared, if the government got out of the way and let it happen. Like during the "depression we never hear about:"

https://mises.org/library/forgotten-depression-1920

What happens is the big government "stimulus" crowds out the private sector, which suffers from a lack of market clearing "creative destruction" and, worse yet, the anti-capitalist policies these leftist central planners always foist upon the private sector. The economy appears to be improving, but only because of all the government (deficit) spending, while the private economy shrinks under the weight of all those leftist "good intentions." Look at that chart above. What do you think would happen now if the government stops borrowing and spending? It should have let the markets clear in 2008 by getting out of the way - no bail outs, no "stimulus," no "capitalism fixing" regulations. Just let the economy heal, as it always does, without government interference.

I think millions would become homeless. 1920 recession=American monetary recession caused by hard-money policies, high interest rates, and the quick mobilization of large numbers of workers for war followed by throwing them back on the rolls of the unemployed ... alleviated by cutting tariff and interest rates and providing emergency relief to the impoverished. 1929=worldwide depression caused by competition - driven "overproduction." Apples and oranges.
 
I think millions would become homeless. 1920 recession=American monetary recession caused by hard-money policies, high interest rates, and the quick mobilization of large numbers of workers for war followed by throwing them back on the rolls of the unemployed ... alleviated by cutting tariff and interest rates and providing emergency relief to the impoverished. 1929=worldwide depression caused by competition - driven "overproduction." Apples and oranges.

I beg to differ. There's way more similarities than differences between the two depressions. Even beyond the fact that they happened to occur under the two most anti-capitalist Presidents in American history...
 
The Great Depression did, and his policies are what caused (or at least extended) the Great Depression. QED.

full circle....did the great depression lead to a rise in fascism in Spain, Italy and Germany? Yes. Did FDR have anything to do with creating the great depression? No. Did the rise of isolationism aid in Hitler gaining power? No. The economic conditions in Germany led to a near civil war between the right and left....the right (Nazism) won and Hitler became chancellor...but that was before FDR was sworn in. The US was ranked somewhere behind Finland in military power and our international trade was miniscule. WWI and the republican policies of the 1920s led to the Wall Street crash.

Nothing FDR could have done would have changed the course of events in Germany unless he was willing to confront Hitler over Czechoslovakia in 1938. Germany was recovering much more quickly than the US was and largely due to Hitler's military spending and public works projects. FDR started spending on public works projects in 1933, but didn't start a military buildup until later.

You want to blame FDR for extending the great depression, but every major country was suffering from the depression, not just the US and all reached the bottom in about the same time frame and began their recovery on pretty much the same trajectory as the US.
France suffered far less of a hit than the US did. Japan had hardly any economic down turn at all.
 
I beg to differ. There's way more similarities than differences between the two depressions. Even beyond the fact that they happened to occur under the two most anti-capitalist Presidents in American history...

I'd say the 2 most anti-capitalist presidents were Jefferson and Monroe, both of whom attacked capitalism from the right. If talking about left-wing critics of unfettered capitalist rule, the honors undoubtedly go to Grant and Lincoln.

Calling Hoover one of the two most anti-capitalist presidents in history is definitely going off the deep end.
 
I beg to differ. There's way more similarities than differences between the two depressions. Even beyond the fact that they happened to occur under the two most anti-capitalist Presidents in American history...
Herbert Hoover and George W. Bush were anti-capitalist? It is not a coincidence that both happened while republicans were in control of the congress and the White House.
 
I'd say the 2 most anti-capitalist presidents were Jefferson and Monroe, both of whom attacked capitalism from the right. If talking about left-wing critics of unfettered capitalist rule, the honors undoubtedly go to Grant and Lincoln.

Calling Hoover one of the two most anti-capitalist presidents in history is definitely going off the deep end.

I've heard many refer to Teddy Roosevelt as anti-capitalist because of his efforts to break up monopolies.
 
No one with any brains has believed Snopes in a very long time.

In the absence of one single item from Snopes which you can offer as proof of their false reporting...why in hell would any objective poster believe you?
 
Then why did it persist throughout his time in office (not coincidently, like the current one lasted throughout Obama's)?

The timing of the Great Depression varied across nations; in most countries it started in 1929 and lasted until 1941.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Great_Depression

Again, when this kind of shit show economy happens, it's not because of what wasn't done, but rather what was...

1. FDR wasn't president in 1929. The economy improved every year from 1933 on until an attempt to rein in the deficit spending threw a lot of people out of work and the unemployment rate jumped (and GDP dropped).
2. Reagan's recession hit 10.8% unemployment and took 4 years to improve. Why was his shit show better than either Obama or FDR? FDR started off with 25% unemployment. Reagan started off with 7%. Reagan made it go to 10.8%. FDR made the unemployment rate improve...not get worse.
 
1. FDR wasn't president in 1929. The economy improved every year from 1933 on until an attempt to rein in the deficit spending threw a lot of people out of work and the unemployment rate jumped (and GDP dropped).
2. Reagan's recession hit 10.8% unemployment and took 4 years to improve. Why was his shit show better than either Obama or FDR? FDR started off with 25% unemployment. Reagan started off with 7%. Reagan made it go to 10.8%. FDR made the unemployment rate improve...not get worse.

Your repeating this propaganda doesn't make it true. "Unemployment" is a) a flawed statistic and b) not measured the same way across time. I reject your silly notion that the "unemployment rate" is the only relevant measure of the economy.

I'm not blaming FDR for the stock market crash, I'm saying he delayed the economic recovery (and set the stage for WWII); just as Obama wasn't responsible for the banking crisis, but he did deploy a policy agenda that prevented a normal recovery:

The Federal Reserve data base (drawing on U.S. Bureau of Labor Statics) tells us there were 121,875,000 people employed with full time jobs in November of 2007 (just before the 2008 crises). As of August 2017 there were 125,755,000 people with full time jobs. That means our economy has added a paltry 3,880,000 full time jobs in almost 10 years as the population grew by about 23 million.

Screen Shot 2017-09-29 at 4.44.34 PM.png

http://www.zerohedge.com/news/2017-09-28/we-are-already-depression-if-borrowing-money-not-income

Anyone who suggests that Obama's is a "normal" or "adequate" or even "acceptable under the conditions" recovery, well, they shouldn't be going around rating other posters' posts "funny" because that poster is the real joke here.
 
full circle....did the great depression lead to a rise in fascism in Spain, Italy and Germany? Yes. Did FDR have anything to do with creating the great depression? No. Did the rise of isolationism aid in Hitler gaining power? No. The economic conditions in Germany led to a near civil war between the right and left....the right (Nazism) won and Hitler became chancellor...but that was before FDR was sworn in. The US was ranked somewhere behind Finland in military power and our international trade was miniscule. WWI and the republican policies of the 1920s led to the Wall Street crash.

Nothing FDR could have done would have changed the course of events in Germany unless he was willing to confront Hitler over Czechoslovakia in 1938. Germany was recovering much more quickly than the US was and largely due to Hitler's military spending and public works projects. FDR started spending on public works projects in 1933, but didn't start a military buildup until later.

You want to blame FDR for extending the great depression, but every major country was suffering from the depression, not just the US and all reached the bottom in about the same time frame and began their recovery on pretty much the same trajectory as the US.
France suffered far less of a hit than the US did. Japan had hardly any economic down turn at all.

Well the communist agrees with you, so, hey, at least you have that. So you keep agreeing with commies (and laughing at me) and I'll keep posting facts (the stuff the communists disagree with) - I'm okay with that.

Guys like you (leftist propagandists) create false narratives like the one you put up here, that are designed to insulate progressive policies from the historical failures they create. These events you list are not just random discrete occurrences. There is a theme that runs through them, and it is failed progressivism. It is widely acknowledged that the world wide depression, and the isolationism that went along with it, created the conditions that led to WWII. That's a fact. And there are plenty of indications that suggest FDR's policy agenda prolonged (and, in fact, put the "great" in) the Great Depression. I readily admit that it isn't the "majority view" but I don't hew to the leftist progressive recounting of history that dooms us to repeat the same failures again and again and again.

The idea that your left wing (anti-capitalist) hero FDR is completely without any blame for the war is typical of this progressive (sanitized) version of history that absolves anti-capitalism from all responsibility for the failures it engenders. But the real takeaway here is your ridiculous assertion that the completely unreliable (and irrelevant) measure of "unemployment" is the sole indicator of the quality of economic policy outcomes, and in fact, renders you completely unserious in any and all discussions regarding economics.
 
Herbert Hoover and George W. Bush were anti-capitalist? It is not a coincidence that both happened while republicans were in control of the congress and the White House.

They sure weren't "free market" capitalists. They were both big government progressive republicans, who failed to follow the lead of President Harding, who deftly avoided a depression in 1920-21 by getting government out of the way (he ended the era of big government before ending the era of big government was cool). What Hoover and Bush's policy failures did was result in the subsequent election of anti-capitalist candidates in FDR and Barack Obama. Both were openly hostile to business and markets. You might not like me pointing it out, but that is a fact.
 
I'd say the 2 most anti-capitalist presidents were Jefferson and Monroe, both of whom attacked capitalism from the right. If talking about left-wing critics of unfettered capitalist rule, the honors undoubtedly go to Grant and Lincoln.

Calling Hoover one of the two most anti-capitalist presidents in history is definitely going off the deep end.

Hoover (like Bush) was a big government (progressive) interventionist. I'm not suggesting either was "anti-capitalist," I'm suggesting FDR and Barack Obama were anti-capitalist (and there's plenty of evidence to back that up). Hoover and Bush were anti-market (and pro-government) in their approaches. I mean Bush made his fortune through eminent domain confiscations of the private property around Arlington Stadium - that ain't free market in any way shape or form.
 
They sure weren't "free market" capitalists. They were both big government progressive republicans, who failed to follow the lead of President Harding, who deftly avoided a depression in 1920-21 by getting government out of the way (he ended the era of big government before ending the era of big government was cool). What Hoover and Bush's policy failures did was result in the subsequent election of anti-capitalist candidates in FDR and Barack Obama. Both were openly hostile to business and markets. You might not like me pointing it out, but that is a fact.

You still don't know the difference between your opinions and facts.
 
Back
Top