New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

SNOPES

Well the communist agrees with you, so, hey, at least you have that. So you keep agreeing with commies (and laughing at me) and I'll keep posting facts (the stuff the communists disagree with) - I'm okay with that.

Guys like you (leftist propagandists) create false narratives like the one you put up here, that are designed to insulate progressive policies from the historical failures they create. These events you list are not just random discrete occurrences. There is a theme that runs through them, and it is failed progressivism. It is widely acknowledged that the world wide depression, and the isolationism that went along with it, created the conditions that led to WWII. That's a fact. And there are plenty of indications that suggest FDR's policy agenda prolonged (and, in fact, put the "great" in) the Great Depression. I readily admit that it isn't the "majority view" but I don't hew to the leftist progressive recounting of history that dooms us to repeat the same failures again and again and again.

The idea that your left wing (anti-capitalist) hero FDR is completely without any blame for the war is typical of this progressive (sanitized) version of history that absolves anti-capitalism from all responsibility for the failures it engenders. But the real takeaway here is your ridiculous assertion that the completely unreliable (and irrelevant) measure of "unemployment" is the sole indicator of the quality of economic policy outcomes, and in fact, renders you completely unserious in any and all discussions regarding economics.

Your tendency to try to make a square peg fit in a round hole is idiotic at best. I've asked several times now for you to be specific as to what FDR could have done at any time to prevent Hitler's rise to power...especially since Hitler was in power already when FDR was sworn an and you have failed completely. Instead you make the goofy claim that if only FDR had done something different the German people would have somehow thrown Hitler out. When would that have happened? What year would the US recovery have somehow zoomed to prosperity from 25% unemployment in 1933 and had any influence at all in the rise of fascism?

You argue that unemployment statistics are somehow irrelevant in terms of gauging the depth of the depression and the recovery....that, all by itself, shows how desperate your argument is. Of course unemployment is useful in that measure. You don't like it, but that is because it makes you unserious in terms of any actual discussion. I never said that unemployment is the sole measure of policy outcomes, but you have yet to offer anything else that would supersede it as the most relevant. I've included information on bank failures as well. Societal stability is clearly affected more by the impact on the average worker than anything else. Germans approved of Hitler's policies because they immediately improved prospects for the average worker. Bankers and industrialists approved of Hitler's policies because their businesses improved.

Nothing FDR did or could have done would have changed that.
 
Your tendency to try to make a square peg fit in a round hole is idiotic at best. I've asked several times now for you to be specific as to what FDR could have done at any time to prevent Hitler's rise to power...especially since Hitler was in power already when FDR was sworn an and you have failed completely. Instead you make the goofy claim that if only FDR had done something different the German people would have somehow thrown Hitler out. When would that have happened? What year would the US recovery have somehow zoomed to prosperity from 25% unemployment in 1933 and had any influence at all in the rise of fascism?

You argue that unemployment statistics are somehow irrelevant in terms of gauging the depth of the depression and the recovery....that, all by itself, shows how desperate your argument is. Of course unemployment is useful in that measure. You don't like it, but that is because it makes you unserious in terms of any actual discussion. I never said that unemployment is the sole measure of policy outcomes, but you have yet to offer anything else that would supersede it as the most relevant. I've included information on bank failures as well. Societal stability is clearly affected more by the impact on the average worker than anything else. Germans approved of Hitler's policies because they immediately improved prospects for the average worker. Bankers and industrialists approved of Hitler's policies because their businesses improved.

Nothing FDR did or could have done would have changed that.

And your tendency to make my argument into something it isn't is idiotic at best. I never said FDR caused Hitler to come to power. Your refusal to acknowledge that says more about you than it does about me. What I have said was that his policies were responsible for WWII. Hitler organized the Axis Powers (and, yes, started his invasions of neighboring countries) on the back of economic strife and the isolationism and nationalism those conditions engendered. And the European nations were too economically weak to resist. What FDR could have done is what Harding did - get government out of the way and let the markets clear. Then the world economy would have followed the US economically (as it always has since the Industrial revolution).

The simple logic that says the economy was incapable of recovering throughout the 30s is shown lacking by the fact that the economy eventually did recover. Either the recovery was possible or it wasn't. The notion that it was possible in the fifties but not the 30s is quite frankly absurd. Something kept the recovery from occurring earlier - and that something was FDR's massive government interventions in the economy (which prevented the creative destruction necessary for recovery). It's not a coincidence that the same thing happened when Obama followed suit on the heals of the Bush recession. Using the economic downturn as a reason to implement a government dominated central economic planning regime that never has worked anywhere it has been implemented.

"Unemployment" is a irrelevant statistic for the purposes of measuring an economic recovery because it doesn't take into effect changes in the labor force participation rate. Nor does it measure the quality of the jobs being filled. And the fact that the calculation has changed over the years certainly makes it laughable to suggest it be used to compare the relative strength of various recoveries that occurred decades apart. The same goes for GDP (and the price level), for that matter. There's only a few measures that you can use that really are comparable. The employment population ratio is one. The number of full time jobs is another, but needs to be coupled with median income to be truly meaningful. But "unemployment" is simply not a meaningful statistic for the purposes of this discussion. The fact that you don't innately get that is rather telling...
 
There isn't a post rating "funny" enough to properly characterize the notion that you are the arbiter of what the economic facts are.

You've expressed opinions. Nothing more. I find it funny that you think your opinions are factual. You can't even quote facts that support those opinions.
 
You've expressed opinions. Nothing more. I find it funny that you think your opinions are factual. You can't even quote facts that support those opinions.

An opinion is the interpretation of facts. I'm making a logical case based on facts. You are resisting by suggesting that all these events and occurrences in the 1930s were all discrete and completely unrelated. I've explained my reasoning and backed it up with examples and at least one academic study. Your argument (in all these discussions) is that the "official" version of the situation is 100% correct when it supports the Democrats' narrative and completely wrong when it supports the Republicans' narrative, regardless of what we know or don't know about the facts supporting that narrative. Mine is that neither is 100% accurate and that we should look at the underlying data and make a logical case based on what we know is factual vs. what we don't know. That means one of us is what is commonly referred to as a "stooge" and I'll leave it to our readers to determine which of us it is...
 
An opinion is the interpretation of facts. I'm making a logical case based on facts. You are resisting by suggesting that all these events and occurrences in the 1930s were all discrete and completely unrelated. I've explained my reasoning and backed it up with examples and at least one academic study. Your argument (in all these discussions) is that the "official" version of the situation is 100% correct when it supports the Democrats' narrative and completely wrong when it supports the Republicans' narrative, regardless of what we know or don't know about the facts supporting that narrative. Mine is that neither is 100% accurate and that we should look at the underlying data and make a logical case based on what we know is factual vs. what we don't know. That means one of us is what is commonly referred to as a "stooge" and I'll leave it to our readers to determine which of us it is...

1. No, I did not say that that the depression had nothing to do with fascism gaining power in Germany or Italy. I've said that fascisms rise in Germany and Italy were not related to anything FDR did or did not do. Fascism was well entrenched in Italy and had been for years before FDR was elected. Hitler was chancellor before FDR was president.

2. You are making vague statements about some democratic or republican narrative...the fact is that you are so far out in right field you don't even represent a republican narrative.

What we know is that Hitler was working towards domination of Europe starting in 1935 at least. His buildup of the German military was not a secret by 1936, since he sent forces to fight in Spain for practice. Britain began a buildup but too slowly....France suffered the least in the depression and had a huge military in 1939. So which European countries are you now saying were weaker because of FDR's policies?

The fact here is that you've presented the strangest argument ever in an attempt to claim FDR somehow caused WWII. You first claimed Hitler came to power and then that he consolidated power because of FDR....you clearly argued that the only way the German people accepted his militarism because of the depression....and that that was FDR's fault.

On a good day you aspire to being a stooge. On a bad day you are simply a goofy right winger with a homespun version of history...all because you want to discredit FDR.
 
An opinion is the interpretation of facts. I'm making a logical case based on facts. ..

just to remind you of what you wrote:

The German economy was already struggling under the weight of the WWI reparations
during the "roaring 20s." Once the depression set in the strain on the Germans
became immeasurable. And the UCLA professors are correct.

If FDR hadn't put his anti-capitalist, big government, interventionist agenda
smack dab in the way of the economy's natural tendency to recover, the Nazi
movement would have either petered out, or at least have been marginalized
(by a recovering economy).


The idea that Hitler would have lost popularity based on any policy FDR could have implemented is nuts.
 
1. No, I did not say that that the depression had nothing to do with fascism gaining power in Germany or Italy. I've said that fascisms rise in Germany and Italy were not related to anything FDR did or did not do. Fascism was well entrenched in Italy and had been for years before FDR was elected. Hitler was chancellor before FDR was president.

2. You are making vague statements about some democratic or republican narrative...the fact is that you are so far out in right field you don't even represent a republican narrative.

What we know is that Hitler was working towards domination of Europe starting in 1935 at least. His buildup of the German military was not a secret by 1936, since he sent forces to fight in Spain for practice. Britain began a buildup but too slowly....France suffered the least in the depression and had a huge military in 1939. So which European countries are you now saying were weaker because of FDR's policies?

The fact here is that you've presented the strangest argument ever in an attempt to claim FDR somehow caused WWII. You first claimed Hitler came to power and then that he consolidated power because of FDR....you clearly argued that the only way the German people accepted his militarism because of the depression....and that that was FDR's fault.

On a good day you aspire to being a stooge. On a bad day you are simply a goofy right winger with a homespun version of history...all because you want to discredit FDR.

First off, FDR discredited himself. The left wing apologencia (of which you are obviously a member) demands that we pretend the Great Depression either a) was a time of tremendous economic strength after "Hoover's Depression" (a suggestion that refutes itself) or b) had nothing whatsoever to do with the President who held power for the majority of its existence. There's been no effort spared to tut tut any suggestion that the economy should have recovered long before it finally did, but what's clear is the fact that it since it didn't, that suggests there was something done that prevented it (which would only make sense if the Administration in power took a "hands off" approach, kind of like Harding's approach a decade earlier that DID, in fact lead to a rapid snap back from a would be depression) not the absence of some even more massive intervention that should have been done but wasn't.

What I would nominate as "the strangest argument ever" is the one you subscribe to, whereby FDR was most definitely NOT an "anti-capitalist" who over managed the economy, and thereby caused a long delay in the natural tendency for the economy to snap back after a downturn, but then turns around and claims FDR's massive efforts to control the markets "saved capitalism" and "fixed the depression." Well which one is it? You guys can't have it both ways. Me pointing out that inconsistency isn't "strange," it's rather effective (which is why you must at all cost pretend to discredit it).

As for what my argument is, well, it isn't (and never was) that FDR led to Hitler coming to power. I said the Depression led to that (which, in fact, as you admit, it did). So we agree on that much. I said FDR was (largely) responsible for the entire world descending into war. You claimed Japan was largely unscathed by the Depression, and that may well be true (at least at the beginning), but the Japanese economy, as it does today, relied greatly on imports for raw materials, and was adversely impacted by the trade wars that resulted from the growing isolationism that attended the ongoing depression.

The fact is that FDR had been supporting the Brits in their fight with the Germans, and had been waging an increasing economic war with Japan, for some time before war was declared (and the Japanese attacked Pearl Harbor). And, in fact, the Japanese really didn't want to go to war with America, because they expected to lose. So they kept offering the US concessions and FDR kept moving the goal posts by demanding ever more (in effect daring them to attack us). By the time he dealt an overt body blow to their economy by embargoing all US trade with Japan in 1940, the die was cast. Frankly I don't know if FDR really just wanted the war as a diversion from the ongoing failure of his economic policies, or if he was just a war mongering dirt bag. I don't really care, for that matter. But the idea that FDR had nothing to do with the instigation of WWII is propaganda (as is the false meme that he "fixed" the depression). I realize all this ruffles the feathers of you left wing bird brains, but the facts are there - you just refuse to acknowledge them.
 
First off, FDR discredited himself. The left wing apologencia (of which you are obviously a member) demands that we pretend the Great Depression either a) was a time of tremendous economic strength after "Hoover's Depression" (a suggestion that refutes itself) or b) had nothing whatsoever to do with the President who held power for the majority of its existence. There's been no effort spared to tut tut any suggestion that the economy should have recovered long before it finally did, but what's clear is the fact that it since it didn't, that suggests there was something done that prevented it (which would only make sense if the Administration in power took a "hands off" approach, kind of like Harding's approach a decade earlier that DID, in fact lead to a rapid snap back from a would be depression) not the absence of some even more massive intervention that should have been done but wasn't.

What I would nominate as "the strangest argument ever" is the one you subscribe to, whereby FDR was most definitely NOT an "anti-capitalist" who over managed the economy, and thereby caused a long delay in the natural tendency for the economy to snap back after a downturn, but then turns around and claims FDR's massive efforts to control the markets "saved capitalism" and "fixed the depression." Well which one is it? You guys can't have it both ways. Me pointing out that inconsistency isn't "strange," it's rather effective (which is why you must at all cost pretend to discredit it).

As for what my argument is, well, it isn't (and never was) that FDR led to Hitler coming to power. I said the Depression led to that (which, in fact, as you admit, it did). So we agree on that much. I said FDR was (largely) responsible for the entire world descending into war. You claimed Japan was largely unscathed by the Depression, and that may well be true (at least at the beginning), but the Japanese economy, as it does today, relied greatly on imports for raw materials, and was adversely impacted by the trade wars that resulted from the growing isolationism that attended the ongoing depression.

The fact is that FDR had been supporting the Brits in their fight with the Germans, and had been waging an increasing economic war with Japan, for some time before war was declared (and the Japanese attacked Pearl Harbor). And, in fact, the Japanese really didn't want to go to war with America, because they expected to lose. So they kept offering the US concessions and FDR kept moving the goal posts by demanding ever more (in effect daring them to attack us). By the time he dealt an overt body blow to their economy by embargoing all US trade with Japan in 1940, the die was cast. Frankly I don't know if FDR really just wanted the war as a diversion from the ongoing failure of his economic policies, or if he was just a war mongering dirt bag. I don't really care, for that matter. But the idea that FDR had nothing to do with the instigation of WWII is propaganda (as is the false meme that he "fixed" the depression). I realize all this ruffles the feathers of you left wing bird brains, but the facts are there - you just refuse to acknowledge them.

I have little desire to expend any effort in fixing your lack of knowledge about WWII. You are truly a moron. I had simply thought you were so partisan you were working at reshaping events to fit your view of left vs right economics. Now I realize you are so dishonest that you will pretend that your partial replay of events is all that matters.

Japan invaded China in 1931. FDR shut off exports of oil and other products to Japan until they withdrew from occupied lands. You seem to think FDR was wrong. He wasn't. He should have done more. The Japanese offered no concessions at all.

By the time the US became involved...December 7, 1941....we were the last major country to join in the fight, yet you imply that war only broke out because of FDR. You ignore that Italy was involved in war in 1935 in Ethiopia. Germany was involved in the Civil war in Spain in 1936. Japan was involved in war with China as of 1931.

Ok...what did FDR have to do with the invasion of Poland in 1939? Even better tell us what FDR could have done to prevent the Munich agreement that allowed Hitler to take control of half of Czechoslovakia, Be specific.
 
Last edited:
Hoover (like Bush) was a big government (progressive) interventionist. I'm not suggesting either was "anti-capitalist," I'm suggesting FDR and Barack Obama were anti-capitalist (and there's plenty of evidence to back that up). Hoover and Bush were anti-market (and pro-government) in their approaches. I mean Bush made his fortune through eminent domain confiscations of the private property around Arlington Stadium - that ain't free market in any way shape or form.

The "free market" has always depended on government intervention. For example in the Harding administration with the Black Hills oil leases.
 
And your tendency to make my argument into something it isn't is idiotic at best. I never said FDR caused Hitler to come to power. Your refusal to acknowledge that says more about you than it does about me. What I have said was that his policies were responsible for WWII. Hitler organized the Axis Powers (and, yes, started his invasions of neighboring countries) on the back of economic strife and the isolationism and nationalism those conditions engendered. And the European nations were too economically weak to resist. What FDR could have done is what Harding did - get government out of the way and let the markets clear. Then the world economy would have followed the US economically (as it always has since the Industrial revolution).

The simple logic that says the economy was incapable of recovering throughout the 30s is shown lacking by the fact that the economy eventually did recover. Either the recovery was possible or it wasn't. The notion that it was possible in the fifties but not the 30s is quite frankly absurd. Something kept the recovery from occurring earlier - and that something was FDR's massive government interventions in the economy (which prevented the creative destruction necessary for recovery). It's not a coincidence that the same thing happened when Obama followed suit on the heals of the Bush recession. Using the economic downturn as a reason to implement a government dominated central economic planning regime that never has worked anywhere it has been implemented.

"Unemployment" is a irrelevant statistic for the purposes of measuring an economic recovery because it doesn't take into effect changes in the labor force participation rate. Nor does it measure the quality of the jobs being filled. And the fact that the calculation has changed over the years certainly makes it laughable to suggest it be used to compare the relative strength of various recoveries that occurred decades apart. The same goes for GDP (and the price level), for that matter. There's only a few measures that you can use that really are comparable. The employment population ratio is one. The number of full time jobs is another, but needs to be coupled with median income to be truly meaningful. But "unemployment" is simply not a meaningful statistic for the purposes of this discussion. The fact that you don't innately get that is rather telling...

1) You said Roosevelt caused the Depression.
2) The recovery had to await the war ... war is the only means by which capitalism can extricate itself from its self-imposed crises.
 
You mean like this?

View attachment 37413

The markets could have cleared, if the government got out of the way and let it happen. Like during the "depression we never hear about:"

https://mises.org/library/forgotten-depression-1920

What happens is the big government "stimulus" crowds out the private sector, which suffers from a lack of market clearing "creative destruction" and, worse yet, the anti-capitalist policies these leftist central planners always foist upon the private sector. The economy appears to be improving, but only because of all the government (deficit) spending, while the private economy shrinks under the weight of all those leftist "good intentions." Look at that chart above. What do you think would happen now if the government stops borrowing and spending? It should have let the markets clear in 2008 by getting out of the way - no bail outs, no "stimulus," no "capitalism fixing" regulations. Just let the economy heal, as it always does, without government interference.

In your mind all depressions and recessions are identical. They are not. While you think the only real solution is to do nothing and "let the market clear", the fact is that Hoover did nothing and unemployment climbed to 25%. FDR signed legislation that pretty much killed Smoot Hawley in early 1934...and that was about the only destructive policy Hoover and the republicans pushed through. While some administration follows the policies you favor...millions of people are out of work. The murder rate quadrupled during the great depression. People starved.

Bush did nothing during the run up to his own disaster....finally signing Tarp in 2008...while we were losing 750,000 jobs per month.
 
I have little desire to expend any effort in fixing your lack of knowledge about WWII. You are truly a moron. I had simply thought you were so partisan you were working at reshaping events to fit your view of left vs right economics. Now I realize you are so dishonest that you will pretend that your partial replay of events is all that matters.

Japan invaded China in 1931. FDR shut off exports of oil and other products to Japan until they withdrew from occupied lands. You seem to think FDR was wrong. He wasn't. He should have done more. The Japanese offered no concessions at all.

By the time the US became involved...December 7, 1941....we were the last major country to join in the fight, yet you imply that war only broke out because of FDR. You ignore that Italy was involved in war in 1935 in Ethiopia. Germany was involved in the Civil war in Spain in 1936. Japan was involved in war with China as of 1931.

Ok...what did FDR have to do with the invasion of Poland in 1939? Even better tell us what FDR could have done to prevent the Munich agreement that allowed Hitler to take control of half of Czechoslovakia, Be specific.

A "moron" is anyone who takes the government approved (and sanitized) version of historical and/or economic events as gospel. A "dishonest" person is someone who demands we only consider one half of the equation, and that any attention whatsoever paid to the other side is, say, "moronic." That would describe you, not me.

I've backed up everything I said. The developed nations have been at war somewhere on the planet almost continuously since the dawn of the industrial revolution. Citing a selection of them as "proof" that the US had no role in instigating and/or no choice but to "enter" World War II is disingenuous at best. I'm still waiting for you to give us the reason why suddenly, and coincidently after a decade of economic depression (and the attendant global strife), it became incumbent to our national security to goad Japan into attacking us so we could join the rest of the world in their increasingly strident bellicosity. There is ample evidence that FDR wasn't dragged kicking and screaming into WWII, do you at least acknowledge that? That is simply an accepted historical premise, whether you care to subscribe to it or not. And there is also the academic economic analyses that indicate his polices prolonged the economic downturn that is given responsibility for much of the unrest, a point of view given even more credence today, now that we have lived through another decade of non-recovery as a result of a Barack Obama Presidential agenda every bit as anti-market and pro-government interventionist as FDR's (and with its own similar record of increasing social unrest). The parallels are simply too striking to ignore (although you and your communist friend here will certainly try).

Unfortunately for you, and despite your smug (and faux superior) incredulity, there's plenty of historical evidence that the US depression was the genesis of much of the economic upheaval that drove the increasingly violent reactionary movements taking place within and among the nations that ended up taking up sides against each other in WWII:

By 1933 unemployment rates in Europe were soaring. Of the available workforce in each country, unemployment rates were 26.3 percent in Germany, 23.7 percent in Sweden, 14.1 percent in Britain, 20.4 percent in Belgium, and 28.8 percent in Denmark. In France social unrest was escalating with the effects of unemployment in addition to the rise of the Nazi Party in neighboring Germany. Political leaders of the various nations were coming under increased pressure to adopt forceful policies to end the Depression. Seeking solutions to the world crisis, more than 60 nations met at the 1933 World Economic Conference in London. When cooperative international solutions proved futile and the conference collapsed, the world seemed sentenced to a prolonged economic depression. Each nation was largely left to recover on its own.

Of even greater consequence to the world, the economic hardships of the Great Depression led to destabilization of European politics. The nations one by one, led first by the United States and then Britain, turned inward to try to solve their problems apart from other nations. The lack of economic and political cooperation fueled the growth of nationalism. Nationalism is when a nation places its needs significantly over the interests of other nations. This trend had major effects for the world economy and politics. Most notably the National Socialist party grew rapidly in Germany bringing with it a new ruler, Adolf Hitler. The global economic crisis and the world's poorly organized response to it in part led to the outbreak of World War II in Europe in 1939.


http://www.encyclopedia.com/education/news-and-education-magazines/global-impact-1929-1939

So who are we going to believe, you? Or the encyclopedia? I think I'll go with the encyclopedia (no offense; wait, never mind, offense intended).

I never said FDR was responsible for every little war, just WWII. Nor did I say he was responsible for the (initial) rise of the despots who conducted and drew their power from them. His economic policies, however, did contribute to the economic conditions that prolonged the protectionism and isolationism that drove the geopolitical aggression that occurred around the world during his time in office. Again, it is no coincidence that Obama's anti-market and interventionist policy agenda resulted in the same kind of conditions that produced a prolonged failure of the economy to fully recover from an economic downturn (when every other time the economy fully recovered after months, not years). And again, you may not like that but it's certainly not "moronic" to suggest it.

You can certainly console yourself with the fact that there are a large number of "experts" (not to mention your communist supporter here) who claim that it is, in fact, just a "coincidence" and would have occurred even if a pro-market agenda had been employed (LOL). The fact that they are all true believers in the notion that the government is the solution to every problem shouldn't deter you; after all, if you guys can't make up "facts" that support your ideological agenda, then you are (lets face it) stuck with an ideology that possesses a pretty freaking sorry record.

So that's my argument - FDR's policies dragged out the depression, and he then used the growing international aggression as an excuse to engineer a world war. That much is well supported regardless of your weightless claims to the contrary. Which then begs the question - why? The only reason I can think of would be to create a huge diversion to deflect attention from a legacy of economic failure. If it hadn't been for the war, FDR would have gone down in history as a magnificent failure. Like I always say, war is the last refuge of failed Keynesians. When you get to the point where it is becoming increasingly obvious that your Keynesianism hasn't worked, isn't working, and is never going to work, "War President" starts looking way better to you than "failed President."

Oh, and by the way, here's another definition for you - a "dickwad" is a PJ poster who resorts to name calling and denigration as a debate tactic and thinks it makes their argument appear better than the facts (or lack thereof) contained in their posts actually support.
 
Last edited:
In your mind all depressions and recessions are identical. They are not. While you think the only real solution is to do nothing and "let the market clear", the fact is that Hoover did nothing and unemployment climbed to 25%. FDR signed legislation that pretty much killed Smoot Hawley in early 1934...and that was about the only destructive policy Hoover and the republicans pushed through. While some administration follows the policies you favor...millions of people are out of work. The murder rate quadrupled during the great depression. People starved.

Bush did nothing during the run up to his own disaster....finally signing Tarp in 2008...while we were losing 750,000 jobs per month.

They most certainly are - the economy is markets and markets need to clear or you get a downturn. The sooner and quicker they clear the sooner the downturn ends. When the government intervenes excessively, as it did during the Great Depression and the Obama Depression, that prevents markets from clearing, which prolongs the downturn. It is simple math.

Hoover did NOT "do nothing." I have repeatedly shown you the contemporaneous news headline that called him the "Father of the New Deal." He was a big government republican, exactly like George Bush is. Both grew government in the face of sluggish economies. And both were (not coincidently) followed by big government (and anti-market) progressives, who were able to successfully (and falsely) define their predecessors as "free market maniacs."

The murder rate "quadrupled" doing the great depression? How much of that increase came after Hoover was out of office? And again, Hoover wasn't running a "do nothing" policy agenda. He was running what is widely viewed as a pre-cursor to the "New Deal" interventionism. So the facts are just not as you portray them. I'd accuse you of lying on purpose but I suspect you are just (mindlessly) parroting the lies that the progressive "historians" created. You aren't smart enough to come up with your own lies...
 
They most certainly are - the economy is markets and markets need to clear or you get a downturn. The sooner and quicker they clear the sooner the downturn ends. When the government intervenes excessively, as it did during the Great Depression and the Obama Depression, that prevents markets from clearing, which prolongs the downturn. It is simple math.

Hoover did NOT "do nothing." I have repeatedly shown you the contemporaneous news headline that called him the "Father of the New Deal." He was a big government republican, exactly like George Bush is. Both grew government in the face of sluggish economies. And both were (not coincidently) followed by big government (and anti-market) progressives, who were able to successfully (and falsely) define their predecessors as "free market maniacs."

The murder rate "quadrupled" doing the great depression? How much of that increase came after Hoover was out of office? And again, Hoover wasn't running a "do nothing" policy agenda. He was running what is widely viewed as a pre-cursor to the "New Deal" interventionism. So the facts are just not as you portray them. I'd accuse you of lying on purpose but I suspect you are just (mindlessly) parroting the lies that the progressive "historians" created. You aren't smart enough to come up with your own lies...

You are mindlessly parroting the meme that the great depression was the same as the depression of 1920...it wasn't. Why? Because you can't stand the idea that FDR actually improved conditions for those hit the worst. He put people back to work and you seem to think that their suffering was less important than your right wing ideal that all that had to happen was the market cleared itself...which would have meant that more people went unemployed....and there was no safety net then... My relatives, who were alive then, tell me just how bad it was. People starving to death. People losing everything. Banks going under by the thousands and taking everything the depositors had.

Your version of history is easily disguarded because it is false. It isn't just "progressive" historians and your categorizing them as such is simply another tactic you and other right wingers here use to dismiss opinions you don't like.
 
A "moron" is anyone who takes the government approved (and sanitized) version of historical and/or economic events as gospel. A "dishonest" person is someone who demands we only consider one half of the equation, and that any attention whatsoever paid to the other side is, say, "moronic." That would describe you, not me.

I've backed up everything I said. The developed nations have been at war somewhere on the planet almost continuously since the dawn of the industrial revolution. Citing a selection of them as "proof" that the US had no role in instigating and/or no choice but to "enter" World War II is disingenuous at best. I'm still waiting for you to give us the reason why suddenly, and coincidently after a decade of economic depression (and the attendant global strife), it became incumbent to our national security to goad Japan into attacking us so we could join the rest of the world in their increasingly strident bellicosity. There is ample evidence that FDR wasn't dragged kicking and screaming into WWII, do you at least acknowledge that? That is simply an accepted historical premise, whether you care to subscribe to it or not. And there is also the academic economic analyses that indicate his polices prolonged the economic downturn that is given responsibility for much of the unrest, a point of view given even more credence today, now that we have lived through another decade of non-recovery as a result of a Barack Obama Presidential agenda every bit as anti-market and pro-government interventionist as FDR's (and with its own similar record of increasing social unrest). The parallels are simply too striking to ignore (although you and your communist friend here will certainly try).

Unfortunately for you, and despite your smug (and faux superior) incredulity, there's plenty of historical evidence that the US depression was the genesis of much of the economic upheaval that drove the increasingly violent reactionary movements taking place within and among the nations that ended up taking up sides against each other in WWII:

By 1933 unemployment rates in Europe were soaring. Of the available workforce in each country, unemployment rates were 26.3 percent in Germany, 23.7 percent in Sweden, 14.1 percent in Britain, 20.4 percent in Belgium, and 28.8 percent in Denmark. In France social unrest was escalating with the effects of unemployment in addition to the rise of the Nazi Party in neighboring Germany. Political leaders of the various nations were coming under increased pressure to adopt forceful policies to end the Depression. Seeking solutions to the world crisis, more than 60 nations met at the 1933 World Economic Conference in London. When cooperative international solutions proved futile and the conference collapsed, the world seemed sentenced to a prolonged economic depression. Each nation was largely left to recover on its own.

Of even greater consequence to the world, the economic hardships of the Great Depression led to destabilization of European politics. The nations one by one, led first by the United States and then Britain, turned inward to try to solve their problems apart from other nations. The lack of economic and political cooperation fueled the growth of nationalism. Nationalism is when a nation places its needs significantly over the interests of other nations. This trend had major effects for the world economy and politics. Most notably the National Socialist party grew rapidly in Germany bringing with it a new ruler, Adolf Hitler. The global economic crisis and the world's poorly organized response to it in part led to the outbreak of World War II in Europe in 1939.


http://www.encyclopedia.com/education/news-and-education-magazines/global-impact-1929-1939

So who are we going to believe, you? Or the encyclopedia? I think I'll go with the encyclopedia (no offense; wait, never mind, offense intended).

I never said FDR was responsible for every little war, just WWII. Nor did I say he was responsible for the (initial) rise of the despots who conducted and drew their power from them. His economic policies, however, did contribute to the economic conditions that prolonged the protectionism and isolationism that drove the geopolitical aggression that occurred around the world during his time in office. Again, it is no coincidence that Obama's anti-market and interventionist policy agenda resulted in the same kind of conditions that produced a prolonged failure of the economy to fully recover from an economic downturn (when every other time the economy fully recovered after months, not years). And again, you may not like that but it's certainly not "moronic" to suggest it.

You can certainly console yourself with the fact that there are a large number of "experts" (not to mention your communist supporter here) who claim that it is, in fact, just a "coincidence" and would have occurred even if a pro-market agenda had been employed (LOL). The fact that they are all true believers in the notion that the government is the solution to every problem shouldn't deter you; after all, if you guys can't make up "facts" that support your ideological agenda, then you are (lets face it) stuck with an ideology that possesses a pretty freaking sorry record.

So that's my argument - FDR's policies dragged out the depression, and he then used the growing international aggression as an excuse to engineer a world war. That much is well supported regardless of your weightless claims to the contrary. Which then begs the question - why? The only reason I can think of would be to create a huge diversion to deflect attention from a legacy of economic failure. If it hadn't been for the war, FDR would have gone down in history as a magnificent failure. Like I always say, war is the last refuge of failed Keynesians. When you get to the point where it is becoming increasingly obvious that your Keynesianism hasn't worked, isn't working, and is never going to work, "War President" starts looking way better to you than "failed President."

Oh, and by the way, here's another definition for you - a "dickwad" is a PJ poster who resorts to name calling and denigration as a debate tactic and thinks it makes their argument appear better than the facts (or lack thereof) contained in their posts actually support.

So while you associate my opinions with someone you refer to as my communist friend...it is you and your holocaust denier pal who hold that the US somehow instigated the war.

Your erratic arguments and constant insults do not help you make your case. You have offered opinions on the depression and backed those opinions up with the opinions of others....you have no facts to support your opinions.

I have offered a timeline that disputes your opinions as to FDR's blame in starting WWII. The US was the last to become a belligerent. That is a fact. The Axis powers were at war with various other countries starting in 1931. You claim that FDR's policies made the depression worse or at least kept the world wide economy from improving and that made the European powers too weak to resist Germany...or something to that effect. That is so far from reality as to be laughable. France had a very large army and a bunch of incompetent generals who failed to develop strategies that would have contained Germany....that is a fact. Germany bluffed the British and French into surrendering the Sudetenland and a huge cache of weapons, nearly half of the Czech military arsenal. That had nothing at all to do with FDR.

There was an arms race that began probably in about 1934...when the Germans began to rearm. The British recognized the German buildup too late to have been ready for war and the result was that they went to war with inferior tanks and too few planes. The French air force was large, but inferior. Germany's ME 109 first flew in early 1935. Britain's Spitfire first flew in 1936. Just anecdotal evidence of the lag in Britain's preparations.

I never claimed FDR was dragged into the war. He clearly felt and rightly so, that we would be at war eventually and that it should happen sooner rather than later. So f*cking what? It was better to go to war while we would have allies rather than wait until Britain was forced to surrender.

The only way FDR could have had any impact on preventing the war would have been if he'd begun a large military buildup as soon as he walked in the door and that would have required an ability to see Hitler as a threat in 1933....when that wasn't evident until probably 1936 when the Germans became part of the Spanish civil war on the Fascist side.

The bottom line is this...the depression, which was at it's worst in 1933, was certainly a factor in bringing both Hitler and Mussolini to power. Nothing FDR could have done or did do, would have diminished Hitler's power in Germany. FDR had no ability to influence the internal politics in Germany or the coming conflict between Poland and Germany on one side and Russia on the other. The British and French thought they could bluff Hitler into backing down from an invasion of Poland by signing a mutual defense treaty with Poland and that was obviously an inept attempt that was too little and too late.
 
Last edited:
You are mindlessly parroting the meme that the great depression was the same as the depression of 1920...it wasn't. Why? Because you can't stand the idea that FDR actually improved conditions for those hit the worst. He put people back to work and you seem to think that their suffering was less important than your right wing ideal that all that had to happen was the market cleared itself...which would have meant that more people went unemployed....and there was no safety net then... My relatives, who were alive then, tell me just how bad it was. People starving to death. People losing everything. Banks going under by the thousands and taking everything the depositors had.

Your version of history is easily disguarded because it is false. It isn't just "progressive" historians and your categorizing them as such is simply another tactic you and other right wingers here use to dismiss opinions you don't like.

So did Obama - and we see what the result is (the same non-recovery). There is absolutely no principle in capitalism (or free markets, for that matter) that requires people to starve in order for the recovery to occur. My parents lived through the depression too, and while they were destitute, they didn't starve. And they didn't take handouts either. They took whatever work they could find. And shared what they had with the rest of the family. It's not that I "can't stand that FDR actually improved conditions for those hit the worst." It's that I just can't ignore the fact that most of his policies were antithetical to an organic (and robust) economic recovery. He excoriated business and lauded unions. His policies were designed so that wages, which needed to come down, were mandated to be kept above the market value. Prices were controlled. Trade was restricted. Markets were prevented from clearing.

People "lose everything" all the time (even now) - look at the bankruptcy stats! They pick themselves up and start over, at the bottom, if necessary. They don't (or shouldn't) expect big government to step in and make everything exactly the way it was. Is there any wonder that when you have a federal policy agenda that does step in and (try to) make everything the way it was, that it fails? That it causes prolonged economic sluggishness? You act like markets have no function, no purpose, no value. And then you wonder why everything you believe is wrong? Sheesh!
 
So while you associate my opinions with someone you refer to as my communist friend...it is you and your holocaust denier pal who hold that the US somehow instigated the war.

Your erratic arguments and constant insults do not help you make your case. You have offered opinions on the depression and backed those opinions up with the opinions of others....you have no facts to support your opinions.

I have offered a timeline that disputes your opinions as to FDR's blame in starting WWII. The US was the last to become a belligerent. That is a fact. The Axis powers were at war with various other countries starting in 1931. You claim that FDR's policies made the depression worse or at least kept the world wide economy from improving and that made the European powers too weak to resist Germany...or something to that effect. That is so far from reality as to be laughable. France had a very large army and a bunch of incompetent generals who failed to develop strategies that would have contained Germany....that is a fact. Germany bluffed the British and French into surrendering the Sudetenland and a huge cache of weapons, nearly half of the Czech military arsenal. That had nothing at all to do with FDR.

There was an arms race that began probably in about 1934...when the Germans began to rearm. The British recognized the German buildup too late to have been ready for war and the result was that they went to war with inferior tanks and too few planes. The French air force was large, but inferior. Germany's ME 109 first flew in early 1935. Britain's Spitfire first flew in 1936. Just anecdotal evidence of the lag in Britain's preparations.

I never claimed FDR was dragged into the war. He clearly felt and rightly so, that we would be at war eventually and that it should happen sooner rather than later. So f*cking what? It was better to go to war while we would have allies rather than wait until Britain was forced to surrender.

The only way FDR could have had any impact on preventing the war would have been if he'd begun a large military buildup as soon as he walked in the door and that would have required an ability to see Hitler as a threat in 1933....when that wasn't evident until probably 1936 when the Germans became part of the Spanish civil war on the Fascist side.

The bottom line is this...the depression, which was at it's worst in 1933, was certainly a factor in bringing both Hitler and Mussolini to power. Nothing FDR could have done or did do, would have diminished Hitler's power in Germany. FDR had no ability to influence the internal politics in Germany or the coming conflict between Poland and Germany on one side and Russia on the other. The British and French thought they could bluff Hitler into backing down from an invasion of Poland by signing a mutual defense treaty with Poland and that was obviously an inept attempt that was too little and too late.

You refute my opinions with opinions and claim that yours are facts. It's not a "fact" that FDR "fixed" the depression. It is a widely held belief, but it is the kind of "fact" that refutes itself - if he "fixed" the depression, why is it widely considered to have lasted until we entered WWII? These are the kinds of silly progressive "truths" that make rational, logical people scratch their heads.

The bottom line is this - the depression dragged on throughout FDR's time in office (until he successfully masked it with WWII), whether you care to acknowledge it or not. Furthermore, the economic conditions associated with it are credited with causing much of the strife that caused the pre-cursor conflicts throughout the decade that led to WWII. There is a prima facie case to be made that if FDR hadn't been so ardently anti-capitalist, and overly interventionist in his policy approach, that the US economy would have been able to lead the world economy into a robust recovery, which would have begun diffusing the tensions that festered and grew into WWII. War isn't the answer (unless the question is "what do I do to mask the fact that my policies aren't fixing the economy?") and never was. The fact that you keep insisting that the war was a policy "success" says all we need to know about your ideological bankruptcy.
 
A "moron" is anyone who takes the government approved (and sanitized) version of historical and/or economic events as gospel. A "dishonest" person is someone who demands we only consider one half of the equation, and that any attention whatsoever paid to the other side is, say, "moronic." That would describe you, not me.

I've backed up everything I said. The developed nations have been at war somewhere on the planet almost continuously since the dawn of the industrial revolution. Citing a selection of them as "proof" that the US had no role in instigating and/or no choice but to "enter" World War II is disingenuous at best. I'm still waiting for you to give us the reason why suddenly, and coincidently after a decade of economic depression (and the attendant global strife), it became incumbent to our national security to goad Japan into attacking us so we could join the rest of the world in their increasingly strident bellicosity. There is ample evidence that FDR wasn't dragged kicking and screaming into WWII, do you at least acknowledge that? That is simply an accepted historical premise, whether you care to subscribe to it or not. And there is also the academic economic analyses that indicate his polices prolonged the economic downturn that is given responsibility for much of the unrest, a point of view given even more credence today, now that we have lived through another decade of non-recovery as a result of a Barack Obama Presidential agenda every bit as anti-market and pro-government interventionist as FDR's (and with its own similar record of increasing social unrest). The parallels are simply too striking to ignore (although you and your communist friend here will certainly try).

Unfortunately for you, and despite your smug (and faux superior) incredulity, there's plenty of historical evidence that the US depression was the genesis of much of the economic upheaval that drove the increasingly violent reactionary movements taking place within and among the nations that ended up taking up sides against each other in WWII:

By 1933 unemployment rates in Europe were soaring. Of the available workforce in each country, unemployment rates were 26.3 percent in Germany, 23.7 percent in Sweden, 14.1 percent in Britain, 20.4 percent in Belgium, and 28.8 percent in Denmark. In France social unrest was escalating with the effects of unemployment in addition to the rise of the Nazi Party in neighboring Germany. Political leaders of the various nations were coming under increased pressure to adopt forceful policies to end the Depression. Seeking solutions to the world crisis, more than 60 nations met at the 1933 World Economic Conference in London. When cooperative international solutions proved futile and the conference collapsed, the world seemed sentenced to a prolonged economic depression. Each nation was largely left to recover on its own.

Of even greater consequence to the world, the economic hardships of the Great Depression led to destabilization of European politics. The nations one by one, led first by the United States and then Britain, turned inward to try to solve their problems apart from other nations. The lack of economic and political cooperation fueled the growth of nationalism. Nationalism is when a nation places its needs significantly over the interests of other nations. This trend had major effects for the world economy and politics. Most notably the National Socialist party grew rapidly in Germany bringing with it a new ruler, Adolf Hitler. The global economic crisis and the world's poorly organized response to it in part led to the outbreak of World War II in Europe in 1939.


http://www.encyclopedia.com/education/news-and-education-magazines/global-impact-1929-1939

So who are we going to believe, you? Or the encyclopedia? I think I'll go with the encyclopedia (no offense; wait, never mind, offense intended).

I never said FDR was responsible for every little war, just WWII. Nor did I say he was responsible for the (initial) rise of the despots who conducted and drew their power from them. His economic policies, however, did contribute to the economic conditions that prolonged the protectionism and isolationism that drove the geopolitical aggression that occurred around the world during his time in office. Again, it is no coincidence that Obama's anti-market and interventionist policy agenda resulted in the same kind of conditions that produced a prolonged failure of the economy to fully recover from an economic downturn (when every other time the economy fully recovered after months, not years). And again, you may not like that but it's certainly not "moronic" to suggest it.

You can certainly console yourself with the fact that there are a large number of "experts" (not to mention your communist supporter here) who claim that it is, in fact, just a "coincidence" and would have occurred even if a pro-market agenda had been employed (LOL). The fact that they are all true believers in the notion that the government is the solution to every problem shouldn't deter you; after all, if you guys can't make up "facts" that support your ideological agenda, then you are (lets face it) stuck with an ideology that possesses a pretty freaking sorry record.

So that's my argument - FDR's policies dragged out the depression, and he then used the growing international aggression as an excuse to engineer a world war. That much is well supported regardless of your weightless claims to the contrary. Which then begs the question - why? The only reason I can think of would be to create a huge diversion to deflect attention from a legacy of economic failure. If it hadn't been for the war, FDR would have gone down in history as a magnificent failure. Like I always say, war is the last refuge of failed Keynesians. When you get to the point where it is becoming increasingly obvious that your Keynesianism hasn't worked, isn't working, and is never going to work, "War President" starts looking way better to you than "failed President."

Oh, and by the way, here's another definition for you - a "dickwad" is a PJ poster who resorts to name calling and denigration as a debate tactic and thinks it makes their argument appear better than the facts (or lack thereof) contained in their posts actually support.

By the time the Depression brought Hitler to power in 1933 ... FDR was not even president yet. The Depression was 4 years old and deepening ... the recovery started with the New Deal.

Obama had one of the least interventionist responses to an economic downturn in recent decades ... very small spending increases, low deficits, no major expansion of government programs except for Obamacare. If anything, his conservatism (and the underlying seriousness of the crisis) helps explain why the recovery was slow.

Few objective economic analyses (you know, ones that use actual numbers) blame Roosevelt's policies for the depth of the Depression.
 
They most certainly are - the economy is markets and markets need to clear or you get a downturn. The sooner and quicker they clear the sooner the downturn ends. When the government intervenes excessively, as it did during the Great Depression and the Obama Depression, that prevents markets from clearing, which prolongs the downturn. It is simple math.

Hoover did NOT "do nothing." I have repeatedly shown you the contemporaneous news headline that called him the "Father of the New Deal." He was a big government republican, exactly like George Bush is. Both grew government in the face of sluggish economies. And both were (not coincidently) followed by big government (and anti-market) progressives, who were able to successfully (and falsely) define their predecessors as "free market maniacs."

The murder rate "quadrupled" doing the great depression? How much of that increase came after Hoover was out of office? And again, Hoover wasn't running a "do nothing" policy agenda. He was running what is widely viewed as a pre-cursor to the "New Deal" interventionism. So the facts are just not as you portray them. I'd accuse you of lying on purpose but I suspect you are just (mindlessly) parroting the lies that the progressive "historians" created. You aren't smart enough to come up with your own lies...

Or the government can cause the markets to clear faster, as in the New Deal and WWII, or avoid the boo.-bust cycle of the market economy in the first place, as in the USSR.
 
So did Obama - and we see what the result is (the same non-recovery). There is absolutely no principle in capitalism (or free markets, for that matter) that requires people to starve in order for the recovery to occur. My parents lived through the depression too, and while they were destitute, they didn't starve. And they didn't take handouts either. They took whatever work they could find. And shared what they had with the rest of the family. It's not that I "can't stand that FDR actually improved conditions for those hit the worst." It's that I just can't ignore the fact that most of his policies were antithetical to an organic (and robust) economic recovery. He excoriated business and lauded unions. His policies were designed so that wages, which needed to come down, were mandated to be kept above the market value. Prices were controlled. Trade was restricted. Markets were prevented from clearing.

People "lose everything" all the time (even now) - look at the bankruptcy stats! They pick themselves up and start over, at the bottom, if necessary. They don't (or shouldn't) expect big government to step in and make everything exactly the way it was. Is there any wonder that when you have a federal policy agenda that does step in and (try to) make everything the way it was, that it fails? That it causes prolonged economic sluggishness? You act like markets have no function, no purpose, no value. And then you wonder why everything you believe is wrong? Sheesh!

Yes there is ... the principle of supply and demand.
 
Back
Top