New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Some questions about DACA

Boltlady

Governor
All kinds of people from both main parties keep talking like the DACA people are victims. Seems to see that they've made out pretty well for themselves. There is also talk about how they'll have to re-apply for their benefits.

Why am I paying them benefits?

We're told about what great lives they've created for themselves but I wonder about what they've used for identification for all of the services that they've been able to take advantage of. Quite a few of them seem to have achieved higher education that somebody has to pay for. At the very least, they've attended our schools, gotten medical care of some kind and a number of them may even get things like disability or some other income from us.

Their status may have been beyond their control but then so is that of pretty much every kid that is actually raised by their parents. My parents took me to Wisconsin when I was a baby and I would have preferred someplace much warmer. As it was I had to be a young adult before I was able to move elsewhere. Those 'kids' are mostly young adults now too. They can use whatever they've learned from being here to start their new life in their 'home' country.

As for our laws breaking up families, is anybody going to mention that their status was created by their very own parents? It's their parents who put them in a situation that allowed for a very unstable family future. How did that get to be our fault?
 
Then you have this in New York. These people have more rights than you and I.

Some of the arrested during the day are DACA recipients. The NYPD says the protesters arrested outside Trump Tower won't have to be fingerprinted if they provide their information willingly -- no fingerprints means no arrest information transmitted to Immigration and Customs Enforcement.

The Mayor's Office confirmed those arrested at Brooklyn Bridge who cooperate with police will be ticketed and released. No fingerprinting would be done, to avoid alerting state or federal government to those arrested who are undocumented.



Source: Thousands March Brooklyn Bridge in New York to Protest DACA Announcement - NBC New York http://www.nbcnewyork.com/news/loca...-York-New-Jersey-442737903.html#ixzz4rueYm89R
Follow us: @nbcnewyork on Twitter | NBCNewYork on Facebook
 
this is classic wedge issue where the media isn't giving us a complete set of facts. here are some considerations:

  • virtually every dreamer has "citizen siblings" who were born in America after the dreamer and mom arrived. the siblings are citizens by birth
  • The mothers (and fathers?) are not applyling for green cards/citizen status, even though their kids are a sponsorship/legal supporting criteria. that's because many of them have outstanding warrants for identity theft, auto accidents while uninsured, financial crimes, welfare benefits fraud, etc.
  • the real key to turning off the spigot of these sorts of arrivals is amending the constitution to discontinue granting citizenship on birth. that might have been a good policy in 1784, when the US population about 1 person per 10 square miles, but it's completely inappropriate in a densely populated welfare state. citizenship should depend on the citizenship of your parents. if you want to apply for citizenship here, fill out the forms, take the test, and raise your right hand. if you came here against your will as a toddler, I'm sorry your mom used you as a pawn, but that doesn't mean I'm obligated to support you for the rest of your life.
 
this is classic wedge issue where the media isn't giving us a complete set of facts. here are some considerations:

  • virtually every dreamer has "citizen siblings" who were born in America after the dreamer and mom arrived. the siblings are citizens by birth
  • The mothers (and fathers?) are not applyling for green cards/citizen status, even though their kids are a sponsorship/legal supporting criteria. that's because many of them have outstanding warrants for identity theft, auto accidents while uninsured, financial crimes, welfare benefits fraud, etc.
  • the real key to turning off the spigot of these sorts of arrivals is amending the constitution to discontinue granting citizenship on birth. that might have been a good policy in 1784, when the US population about 1 person per 10 square miles, but it's completely inappropriate in a densely populated welfare state. citizenship should depend on the citizenship of your parents. if you want to apply for citizenship here, fill out the forms, take the test, and raise your right hand. if you came here against your will as a toddler, I'm sorry your mom used you as a pawn, but that doesn't mean I'm obligated to support you for the rest of your life.

As for the children who are citizens because they were born here.....if they are under 18 they should have to go wherever their parents get deported to if the parents are illegal.
Once they turn 18 and were actually born here then there could be some legal thing for the kid to return as a citizen. That would not need to (or should), include his family.

If this whole process causes a problem for the employers who will lose all of those workers, well they shouldn't haven hired undocumented people to start with. Their dilemma is their own fault.
 
As for the children who are citizens because they were born here.....if they are under 18 they should have to go wherever their parents get deported to if the parents are illegal.
Once they turn 18 and were actually born here then there could be some legal thing for the kid to return as a citizen. That would not need to (or should), include his family.

If this whole process causes a problem for the employers who will lose all of those workers, well they shouldn't haven hired undocumented people to start with. Their dilemma is their own fault.

They can do like my mother and apply for citizenship...The Democrats voter drive/errr citizenship grab without the effort is disrespectful to those who come here the right way.

It tells us a few things

1. Democrats think Mexicans are stupid.

2. Mexicans do not deserve a full days wages

3. Democrats are still pissed off that Republicans took away their slave labor.

4. If The parents go but the children stay...Democrats have no use for them as real citizens.
 
All kinds of people from both main parties keep talking like the DACA people are victims. Seems to see that they've made out pretty well for themselves. There is also talk about how they'll have to re-apply for their benefits.

Why am I paying them benefits?

We're told about what great lives they've created for themselves but I wonder about what they've used for identification for all of the services that they've been able to take advantage of. Quite a few of them seem to have achieved higher education that somebody has to pay for. At the very least, they've attended our schools, gotten medical care of some kind and a number of them may even get things like disability or some other income from us.

Their status may have been beyond their control but then so is that of pretty much every kid that is actually raised by their parents. My parents took me to Wisconsin when I was a baby and I would have preferred someplace much warmer. As it was I had to be a young adult before I was able to move elsewhere. Those 'kids' are mostly young adults now too. They can use whatever they've learned from being here to start their new life in their 'home' country.

As for our laws breaking up families, is anybody going to mention that their status was created by their very own parents? It's their parents who put them in a situation that allowed for a very unstable family future. How did that get to be our fault?
Many of them are kids who have known no other country. They came here as infants or toddlers. Some of them weren't even told by their parents that they weren't citizens until they reached maturity. Some speak no language but English. It would be brutal to uproot these people and send them to a country they don't know. And it would be economically stupid to do so, for obvious reasons:

https://krugman.blogs.nytimes.com/2017/09/05/the-very-bad-economics-of-killing-daca/?mcubz=1

Our country is already headed on a course for demographic disaster, thanks to having too few young workers per retiree. Just about the stupidest thing we could do is uproot a bunch of immigrant kids, of precisely the age-range that we need more of, and send them away.
 
They can do like my mother and apply for citizenship...The Democrats voter drive/errr citizenship grab without the effort is disrespectful to those who come here the right way.

It tells us a few things

1. Democrats think Mexicans are stupid.

2. Mexicans do not deserve a full days wages

3. Democrats are still pissed off that Republicans took away their slave labor.

4. If The parents go but the children stay...Democrats have no use for them as real citizens.

It's not just Mexicans that all of this applies to.
 
  • the real key to turning off the spigot of these sorts of arrivals is amending the constitution to discontinue granting citizenship on birth.
Amending the Constitution is extremely hard. I just don't see there being a core of extremely racist people even remotely large enough to push such an amendment through. So, it's not worth discussing.

But there are other obvious ways to turn the spigot, if you're interested. The first thing is to recognize this is a demand-side problem, not a supply-side one. Supply of potential illegal immigrants is always going to be effectively limitless, and with a permeable open society like ours, attempts to seal off from that supply are doomed to ultimate failure. But we can impact the demand that draws them here: the demand for unskilled, low-wage workers.

Step one is greatly boosting legal immigration. The more of those job slots are filled up by people who are here legally, the fewer such slots will be left to lure people here illegally. We could get started by simply giving the dreamers and their immediate family members citizenship, since they're a particularly well-integrated immigrant population. They're also disproportionately young, which is the group we want to be growing in this country, in order to support all the old folks who are on the dole. Give those DACA workers citizenship and we're helping to make sure they stick around to work long, productive lives, counter-balancing the burden the Baby Boomers are going to put on us.

Step two is punishing those who offer illegal employment. Start seizing the properties of people who have undocumented gardeners and nannies. Impose criminal penalties on executives who do not insist on legal documentation for people their companies hire. And use sting operations to find them. You can even make the immigrants themselves part of the solution: any undocumented worker who provides evidence leading to the conviction of an illegal employer could be given a long-term green card or even citizenship. Dry up those illegal jobs, and there's little incentive to come here without documentation.
 
Many of them are kids who have known no other country. They came here as infants or toddlers. Some of them weren't even told by their parents that they weren't citizens until they reached maturity. Some speak no language but English. It would be brutal to uproot these people and send them to a country they don't know. And it would be economically stupid to do so, for obvious reasons:

https://krugman.blogs.nytimes.com/2017/09/05/the-very-bad-economics-of-killing-daca/?mcubz=1

Our country is already headed on a course for demographic disaster, thanks to having too few young workers per retiree. Just about the stupidest thing we could do is uproot a bunch of immigrant kids, of precisely the age-range that we need more of, and send them away.

Since we obviously educated all these young folks they should have no problem qualifying for H-1B visas. They should apply now.

The employers that will have such problems should all have to pay a fine for having hired the undocumented people in the first place. They could then sponsor them for employment for those visas.

We would probably have enough young workers if we would teach them responsibility, how to eat properly instead of strictly fast/junk food and encourage them to exercise to get used to actually moving around.
 
I agree. They deserve no benefits except a one-way ticket home.

One of the many oddities (irony) about the DACA group...

DJDnV1MVAAAKCPa.jpg
 
As for the children who are citizens because they were born here.....if they are under 18 they should have to go wherever their parents get deported to if the parents are illegal.
Once they turn 18 and were actually born here then there could be some legal thing for the kid to return as a citizen. That would not need to (or should), include his family.

If this whole process causes a problem for the employers who will lose all of those workers, well they shouldn't haven hired undocumented people to start with. Their dilemma is their own fault.
I'm not sure you can legally deport a US citizen anywhere, irrespective of age, parent's nationality, or criminal status. the left has traditionally argued that it is 'cruel" to deport adult illegal aliens if the kids are US citizens (or dreamers).

this is akin to saying its cruel to jail hardcore criminals if they contribute to the financial support of minors. how can they earn a living while in prison? don't laugh - this comes up ENDLESSLY in Baltimore's courts, when "baby daddies" charged with narcotics, drug crimes, and gang activity appear in court.
 
All kinds of people from both main parties keep talking like the DACA people are victims. Seems to see that they've made out pretty well for themselves. There is also talk about how they'll have to re-apply for their benefits.

Why am I paying them benefits?

We're told about what great lives they've created for themselves but I wonder about what they've used for identification for all of the services that they've been able to take advantage of. Quite a few of them seem to have achieved higher education that somebody has to pay for. At the very least, they've attended our schools, gotten medical care of some kind and a number of them may even get things like disability or some other income from us.

Their status may have been beyond their control but then so is that of pretty much every kid that is actually raised by their parents. My parents took me to Wisconsin when I was a baby and I would have preferred someplace much warmer. As it was I had to be a young adult before I was able to move elsewhere. Those 'kids' are mostly young adults now too. They can use whatever they've learned from being here to start their new life in their 'home' country.

As for our laws breaking up families, is anybody going to mention that their status was created by their very own parents? It's their parents who put them in a situation that allowed for a very unstable family future. How did that get to be our fault?
Saw this on Peter's blog this morning; https://bayourenaissanceman.blogspot.com/2017/09/daca-law-politics-and-reality.html
 
Since we obviously educated all these young folks they should have no problem qualifying for H-1B visas. They should apply now.

Why bother with all that extra paperwork? Wouldn't it be more efficient just to grant them citizenship?

The employers that will have such problems should all have to pay a fine for having hired the undocumented people in the first place.

You misunderstood what I was saying. The problems won't just be experienced by whatever employers were employing undocumented people. They'll be experienced by the society as a whole -- the more young workers we ship away, even as more and more aging Boomers go on the dole, the worse our budget situation will get. It's a "dependency ratio" problem, and we'd be exacerbating it for no better reason than that some people think there are too many brown people around.

We would probably have enough young workers if we would teach them responsibility, how to eat properly instead of strictly fast/junk food and encourage them to exercise to get used to actually moving around.

No clue what you're talking about here. Keep in mind that the young people we're talking about here are, for the most part, healthier than the country as a whole. Latinos live 3.9 years longer, on average, than whites, and 8.2 years longer than blacks. One of the side benefits of having more Latinos is having a healthier population overall -- both directly, by way of their numbers averaging in, and indirectly by way of their healthier lifestyles and eating choices influencing US culture. And even within the Latino community, the immigrants outlive native-born Latinos by a few years. So, if you want to fret about people who eat too much junk food and don't exercise, start with native-born people, and non-Latinos in particular.
 
Why bother with all that extra paperwork? Wouldn't it be more efficient just to grant them citizenship?



You misunderstood what I was saying. The problems won't just be experienced by whatever employers were employing undocumented people. They'll be experienced by the society as a whole -- the more young workers we ship away, even as more and more aging Boomers go on the dole, the worse our budget situation will get. It's a "dependency ratio" problem, and we'd be exacerbating it for no better reason than that some people think there are too many brown people around.



No clue what you're talking about here. Keep in mind that the young people we're talking about here are, for the most part, healthier than the country as a whole. Latinos live 3.9 years longer, on average, than whites, and 8.2 years longer than blacks. One of the side benefits of having more Latinos is having a healthier population overall -- both directly, by way of their numbers averaging in, and indirectly by way of their healthier lifestyles and eating choices influencing US culture. And even within the Latino community, the immigrants outlive native-born Latinos by a few years. So, if you want to fret about people who eat too much junk food and don't exercise, start with native-born people, and non-Latinos in particular.
I'm fretting more about the folks who don't pay income tax but drive on the roads, and go to the schools, my taxes pay for.
 
Amending the Constitution is extremely hard. I just don't see there being a core of extremely racist people even remotely large enough to push such an amendment through. So, it's not worth discussing.

But there are other obvious ways to turn the spigot, if you're interested. The first thing is to recognize this is a demand-side problem, not a supply-side one. Supply of potential illegal immigrants is always going to be effectively limitless, and with a permeable open society like ours, attempts to seal off from that supply are doomed to ultimate failure. But we can impact the demand that draws them here: the demand for unskilled, low-wage workers.

Step one is greatly boosting legal immigration. The more of those job slots are filled up by people who are here legally, the fewer such slots will be left to lure people here illegally. We could get started by simply giving the dreamers and their immediate family members citizenship, since they're a particularly well-integrated immigrant population. They're also disproportionately young, which is the group we want to be growing in this country, in order to support all the old folks who are on the dole. Give those DACA workers citizenship and we're helping to make sure they stick around to work long, productive lives, counter-balancing the burden the Baby Boomers are going to put on us.

Step two is punishing those who offer illegal employment. Start seizing the properties of people who have undocumented gardeners and nannies. Impose criminal penalties on executives who do not insist on legal documentation for people their companies hire. And use sting operations to find them. You can even make the immigrants themselves part of the solution: any undocumented worker who provides evidence leading to the conviction of an illegal employer could be given a long-term green card or even citizenship. Dry up those illegal jobs, and there's little incentive to come here without documentation.
Step 2 would be the hardest one to implement. Here in California, the farmers depend on illegal immigrant labor to harvest their crops. The farmers have lots of influence with the politicians. (Democrats and Republicans). So, the politicians aren't going to hurt their friends by imposing criminal penalties on them.
 
I'm fretting more about the folks who don't pay income tax but drive on the roads, and go to the schools, my taxes pay for.
Well, generally speaking schools are funded by property taxes and roads by gas taxes, so those are bigger consideration than income taxes here. As for income taxes, many are paid by undocumented workers. Undocumented workers are really helping us out when it comes to Social Security, for example, since employers will often withhold payroll taxes for them, even though they'll never get the benefits:

https://www.theatlantic.com/business/archive/2016/09/undocumented-immigrants-and-taxes/499604/

But, if the concern is that undocumented workers are more likely not to pay taxes that are owed than documented workers, that's all the more reason not to want to see DACA go away. DACA-eligible immigrants get work permits, which means fewer would be working "under the table" and more taxes would be collected. If they go back to working under the table, the issue you are fretting about will get worse.
 
Step 2 would be the hardest one to implement. Here in California, the farmers depend on illegal immigrant labor to harvest their crops. The farmers have lots of influence with the politicians. (Democrats and Republicans). So, the politicians aren't going to hurt their friends by imposing criminal penalties on them.
Well, that's our immigration issue in a nutshell: politicians on the right don't actually want to do anything to restrict that labor supply, because doing so would be bad economics and would hurt their constituents, but they also want to feed off xenophobia. So, they direct public hate towards the little guy: the hard-working immigrants just trying to make a brighter future for their families. And, at the same time, they divert attention from those luring the undocumented migrants to America with the offers of employment. From a purely political perspective, it works for them: they keep the farmers and other employers happy with cheap labor, they keep the bigots happy with immigrant-bashing, and the longer their actions are ineffectual, the bigger the undocumented immigrant pool gets, and the more they benefit from xenophobia.
 
Back
Top