New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Sounding like a conservative.

Arkady

President
As long as I'm posting about college costs, I'll mention an issue where I come down on the side more common for conservatives.

Often, in liberal outlets, you'll hear sports writers and cultural commentators fretting about the plight of the scholarship athlete in college sports.... usually with a side order of racial guilt. For example, Slate's Josh Levin says college sports are fundamentally unjust, since the athletes get such a small slice of the multi-billion-dollar industry they make possible. He goes on to call the NCAA the nation's worst workplace, since at least they pay you something at Wal-Mart:

http://www.slate.com/articles/sport..._block_their_former_players_from_getting.html

I just can't see it. Sure, student athletes make a lot of fortunes possible and don't get paid for their work. But let's look at what they do get. For starters, they typically get full tuition and room and board, often at a university they could never get into without the special consideration given to athletes. For any athlete who takes his education seriously (and even some who don't) that has huge value. Someone playing at Duke, for example, would be getting the equivalent of just under $60,000 per year in assorted costs.

In fact, that doesn't even cover the real value. For starters, to earn enough to pay that $60,000 cost, you'd need to earn considerably more than $60,000 before taxes, whereas student athletes aren't taxed on the value of those scholarships. Between state and federal income taxes, you'd need to be earning around $70,000 to be getting equivalent value. How many other opportunities does someone with only a high school diploma have for a job paying 70,000?

What does the athlete need to do for that value? They can only practice with the team a maximum of 20 hours per week during the season, and 8 hours per week in the off-season. Sure, they typically put in more effort on their own (as do plenty of people in other lines of work), but that's the cap for NCAA purposes. If the season lasts about four months, that's an work-week of 12 hours, averaged over the course of the year. Thus, that $70,000 value, for their effort, is equivalent to a 40-hour-workweek pay of $233,333 per year. In other words, the value those student athletes are getting, in tuition and room and board, can be equivalent to the hourly pay rate of a partner at a law firm or a doctor in residence, for someone in his teens or early 20s with no college degree or work experience.

Even that doesn't quite get at the extent of the value student athletes are getting. They all get some of the best personal training and nutrition advice in the world, access to world-class healthcare, and elite fitness facilities. Often they get special dorms that are a step or two up from what the rest of the student body has. For those with a chance of going pro, they also get coaching that brings that dream closer to reality. And they tend to get extraordinary tutoring that simply isn't available to less valued fellow students. I went to a university that combined elite academics and elite athletics -- one of the rare ones that actually forces the athletes to take real classes. The athletes were sometimes the best people to talk to when you were having trouble with the material, because they'd been given one-on-one tutoring by grad students in special study halls to stay on top of the material ("academic support"). In addition to the tutoring, they also had special academic advisers that helped them keep track of assignments, credit requirements, etc. Hiring that kind of individual attention would be an additional cost of thousands of dollars for an ordinary student.

So, I just can't get worked up about the "plight of the student athlete." If you want to get concerned about the failings of our higher education system, focus on those who come from poor families but can't run a 4.4 40 and don't have a sweet jump shot. Don't focus on those who, however briefly, are given an incredible deal that most students would drool over.
 
Last edited:
You're right, when you make a rational, fact-based analysis of something without throwing in all the racial hysterics and the baseless victim mentality, you do sound like a conservative...
 
The trouble is, most program's graduations rates are very low -- so you get access to an education that you don't receive in full.
 
As long as I'm posting about college costs, I'll mention an issue where I come down on the side more common for conservatives.

Often, in liberal outlets, you'll hear sports writers and cultural commentators fretting about the plight of the scholarship athlete in college sports.... usually with a side order of racial guilt. For example, Slate's Josh Levin says college sports are fundamentally unjust, since the athletes get such a small slice of the multi-billion-dollar industry they make possible. He goes on to call the NCAA the nation's worst workplace, since at least they pay you something at Wal-Mart:

http://www.slate.com/articles/sport..._block_their_former_players_from_getting.html

I just can't see it. Sure, student athletes make a lot of fortunes possible and don't get paid for their work. But let's look at what they do get. For starters, they typically get full tuition and room and board, often at a university they could never get into without the special consideration given to athletes. For any athlete who takes his education seriously (and even some who don't) that has huge value. Someone playing at Duke, for example, would be getting the equivalent of just under $60,000 per year in assorted costs.

In fact, that doesn't even cover the real value. For starters, to earn enough to pay that $60,000 cost, you'd need to earn considerably more than $60,000 before taxes, whereas student athletes aren't taxed on the value of those scholarships. Between state and federal income taxes, you'd need to be earning around $70,000 to be getting equivalent value. How many other opportunities does someone with only a high school diploma have for a job paying 70,000?

What does the athlete need to do for that value? They can only practice with the team a maximum of 20 hours per week during the season, and 8 hours per week in the off-season. Sure, they typically put in more effort on their own (as do plenty of people in other lines of work), but that's the cap for NCAA purposes. If the season lasts about four months, that's an work-week of 12 hours, averaged over the course of the year. Thus, that $70,000 value, for their effort, is equivalent to a 40-hour-workweek pay of $233,333 per year. In other words, the value those student athletes are getting, in tuition and room and board, can be equivalent to the hourly pay rate of a partner at a law firm or a doctor in residence, for someone in his teens or early 20s with no college degree or work experience.

Even that doesn't quite get at the extent of the value student athletes are getting. They all get some of the best personal training and nutrition advice in the world, access to world-class healthcare, and elite fitness facilities. Often they get special dorms that are a step or two up from what the rest of the student body has. For those with a chance of going pro, they also get coaching that brings that dream closer to reality. And they tend to get extraordinary tutoring that simply isn't available to less valued fellow students. I went to a university that combined elite academics and elite athletics -- one of the rare ones that actually forces the athletes to take real classes, and the athletes were sometimes the best people to talk to when you were having trouble with the material, because they'd been given one-on-one tutoring by grad students in special study halls to stay on top of the material ("academic support"). In addition to the tutoring, they also had special academic advisers that helped them keep track of assignments, credit requirements, etc. Hiring that kind of individual attention would be an additional cost of thousands of dollars for an ordinary student.

So, I just can't get worked up about the "plight of the student athlete." If you want to get concerned about the failings of our higher education system, focus on those who come from poor families but can't run a 4.4 40 and don't have a sweet jump shot. Don't focus on those who, however briefly, are given an incredible deal that most students would drool over.

Good post. We always keep our arms open to the birth of another con...LOL
 
The trouble is, most program's graduations rates are very low -- so you get access to an education that you don't receive in full.

True. But any education has value, so even if a student fails to make the most of his opportunity, he's still a step up on less physically gifted people who didn't get that opportunity.
 
In fact, that doesn't even cover the real value. For starters, to earn enough to pay that $60,000 cost, you'd need to earn considerably more than $60,000 before taxes, whereas student athletes aren't taxed on the value of those scholarships. Between state and federal income taxes, you'd need to be earning around $70,000 to be getting equivalent value. How many other opportunities does someone with only a high school diploma have for a job paying 70,000?

Ever been to North Dakota...tons of jobs there payomh high wages...the problem is you think that just because you have a High school education you cant get jobs paying 70,000....and in part you are correct. Let me tell you how it works for those who want to get ahead...they start a business and pay college graduates 70,000 to work for them.


But as far as the plight of the student athlete... I think Arkady is just jonesing and hasnt paid off his school loan... which the federal govt could have done for him had they not spent all the money on failed green energy , GM and illegal immigrants....it is funny listening to wealthy Democrats complain about school loans and taxes ...and that is what Arkady does.
 
Ever been to North Dakota...tons of jobs there payomh high wages...the problem is you think that just because you have a High school education you cant get jobs paying 70,000....and in part you are correct. Let me tell you how it works for those who want to get ahead...they start a business and pay college graduates 70,000 to work for them.


But as far as the plight of the student athlete... I think Arkady is just jonesing and hasnt paid off his school loan... which the federal govt could have done for him had they not spent all the money on failed green energy , GM and illegal immigrants....it is funny listening to wealthy Democrats complain about school loans and taxes ...and that is what Arkady does.

I paid off my student loan years ago -- sometime around 2006-- as I've mentioned in a few threads recently. When I complain about the student loan situation, I do so on behalf of my fellow citizens, not myself. In fact, my own situation is better if we ignore the problem than if we address it, since addressing it might involve higher taxes for high earners like me. But I do what I think is right for America, not necessarily what's best for my personal self interest. It's called patriotism.

As for the idea of starting a business, that will hopefully become a more realistic option in coming years with Obamacare. Healthcare exchanges should eventually make health insurance more affordable for entrepreneurs and small businesses -- helping to lower one of the high hurdles to striking out on your own to start a business.
 
I certainly don't cry any rivers for those scholarship athletes except for ONE thing. In order to forestall any possible hint of corruption, the NCAA limits these athletes ability to earn their own dough, to an unrealistically low number.
 
I certainly don't cry any rivers for those scholarship athletes except for ONE thing. In order to forestall any possible hint of corruption, the NCAA limits these athletes ability to earn their own dough, to an unrealistically low number.

I don't think that student athletes should be paid, simply because there is a great deal of revenue being generated by marketing the sports. I do think that an athlete who achieves celebrity should own the marketing rights to their own name and image.
 
I don't think that student athletes should be paid, simply because there is a great deal of revenue being generated by marketing the sports. I do think that an athlete who achieves celebrity should own the marketing rights to their own name and image.

For the record, I'm not suggesting that they should be paid. BUT...the non-athletic scholarship sudent, should she choose to, can get herself a side job earning as much as she likes. The scholar athletes are limited to a remarkably pissant number.
 
For the record, I'm not suggesting that they should be paid. BUT...the non-athletic scholarship sudent, should she choose to, can get herself a side job earning as much as she likes. The scholar athletes are limited to a remarkably pissant number.

There are things that need to be fixed, but I just don't buy into the "poor, abused student athlete" story. College football is not a job.
 
There are things that need to be fixed, but I just don't buy into the "poor, abused student athlete" story. College football is not a job.

Me neither. On the flipside though, I don't listen much to those who whine that Universities pay too much to their coaches and for their facilities. My alma mater's entire athletic budget for men, women, and every sport, is covered by the revenue from men's basketball and football.
 
I paid off my student loan years ago -- sometime around 2006-- as I've mentioned in a few threads recently. When I complain about the student loan situation, I do so on behalf of my fellow citizens, not myself. In fact, my own situation is better if we ignore the problem than if we address it, since addressing it might involve higher taxes for high earners like me. But I do what I think is right for America, not necessarily what's best for my personal self interest. It's called patriotism.

As for the idea of starting a business, that will hopefully become a more realistic option in coming years with Obamacare. Healthcare exchanges should eventually make health insurance more affordable for entrepreneurs and small businesses -- helping to lower one of the high hurdles to striking out on your own to start a business.

Surely you are not talking about the affordable care act that sucks so bad the admin postponed implementation a year so the mid term election won't be affected
 
There are things that need to be fixed, but I just don't buy into the "poor, abused student athlete" story. College football is not a job.

I beg to differ. I was a scholarship athlete in one of the top engineering schools in the country. My "salary" was $15 a month in "laundry" expenses which went to beer. My living expenses, room and board, were covered. My "bonus" was a couple of bachelors degrees.

My "labor" was spring practice, fall practice, games, and off season physical training, 15 -18 hours a week in classes and 20 or 30 cracking the books. I also had "medical benefits" because when I blew out a knee the surgery was covered.

In other words you don't know what the phuck (as in physics ) you're talking about....which I suppose is your job, and I must say you do it very well.
 
Last edited:
I beg to differ. I was a scholarship athlete in one of the top engineering schools in the country. My "salary" was $15 a month in "laundry" expenses which went to beer. My living expenses, room and board, were covered. My "bonus" was a couple of bachelors degrees.

My "labor" was spring practice, fall practice, games, and off season physical training, 15 -18 hours a week in classes and 20 or 30 cracking the books. I also had "medical benefits" because when I blew out a knee the surgery was covered.

In other words you don't know what the **** you're talking about.

I think I do. I never played college football, but my brother did. You weren't an employee. You were a scholarship student, just as my daughter is now.
 
all of which fails to consider the risks of permanant physical injury, etc.

Indeed, the "cheap labor" http://www.cbsnews.com/8301-400_162...athletes-denied-$6.2-billion-over-four-years/ aspect of this does make you sound like a con.

If someone had offered me that deal -- a full ride, extra tutoring, world class training, and all I had to do in return is play a game I loved and risk physical injury, I would have jumped at the chance. I never had that option though, just like most people, because I didn't have the talent. If someone has the talent and doesn't think it's a good deal, he's free to refuse to play and do what I did and pay his own way, if he can even get into the school without the special consideration given to athletes. Student athletes have extra options, so if you're going to feel bad for someone, let it be someone who lacks those extra options.
 
well, that you prefer the status quo as a minimum is no longer in doubt arky.

I see the not so free education -- given the work required to earn the degree -- and the rest as more akin to bonuses and/or contract conditions of the non-compensation kind for services rendered.

Questions of "feeling bad for someone" aren't really to the point as much as just compensation is in the context of a money-making machine, given the cheap price they pay for the exploitation of talent money would otherwise have to buy -- like in the pros.

You find their compensation fair, and I don't. I see it as kinda analogous to the paid v unpaid internship, times "X" on the compensation end of things, which coincidentally, many of those whining the loudest about the plight of the college athlete, seemingly have no problem with. Imagine that.

If the numbers alone won't convince you, I'll assume all the roads are closed to that destination.
 
well, that you prefer the status quo as a minimum is no longer in doubt arky.

I see the not so free education -- given the work required to earn the degree -- and the rest as more akin to bonuses and/or contract conditions of the non-compensation kind for services rendered.

Questions of "feeling bad for someone" aren't really to the point as much as just compensation is in the context of a money-making machine, given the cheap price they pay for the exploitation of talent money would otherwise have to buy -- like in the pros.

You find their compensation fair, and I don't. I see it as kinda analogous to the paid v unpaid internship, times "X" on the compensation end of things, which coincidentally, many of those whining the loudest about the plight of the college athlete, seemingly have no problem with. Imagine that.

If the numbers alone won't convince you, I'll assume all the roads are closed to that destination.

If that's what you want from college sports, then the sports should just be separated from the colleges altogether. You're advocating for a professional farm league.
 
Back
Top