New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Spelling Bees

Seriously, how many of those words had you even seem before?!

Frankly, I hadn't seen one of them. I'd feel bad, but they're abstruse as hell. Perhaps I could use pococurante, but only if I know the person I use it on has knowledge of a Romance language.
 
Spelling bees seem like a good idea. They encourage kids to pay attention to the spelling of common words and they reward avid readers. At low levels of competition, they're closely tied to reasonable educational goals, making them a decent use of a child's time. Through the mid-1990s, even the highest levels of national competition were testing the kind of vocabulary words that educated people are likely to use in real life, such that the proper spelling of them had some value outside the bounds of spelling contests. But, that has changed. The words tested are so arcane that you may as well be having kids memorize all the numbers in the phone book -- it doubtless has some value in training their memories, but it's impractical as hell.

If you check lists of winning words in national spelling bees in the early-to-mid 20th century, you'll see they used to be things like "intelligible," "fracas," "knack," "meticulous," "vignette," "sycophant," "therapy," "initials," "milieu," and "kamikaze." They're words you've probably found yourself using in everyday conversation. They're words that it would be useful to know how to spell correctly. Now, look at the winning words in recent years:

Succedaneum, prospicience, pococurante, autochthonous, appoggiatura, Ursprache, serrefine, guerdon, Laodicean, stromuhr, cymotrichous, guetapens, knaidel, stichomythia, feuilleton​

Those words are all so obscure that the built-in spell checker in my web browser identified every single one as a misspelling, even though they're all correct. By comparison, it knew every one of the winning words from the first quarter-century of the spelling bee championship, and over three quarters of the words between the 1950s and 1995. I got a perfect 800 on the Verbal SAT (back before they scaled the scores upward), but in that list above, I only know three of the words (prospicience, Ursprache, and feuilleton), and the only one I've ever used is Ursprache. Has anyone here ever used any of them?

I don't fault the spelling bee organizers. They have to go with ridiculous words or the contest would never end, because there's a steady supply of kids who can spell every single "SAT word" without fail. Only by dipping into the arcana of bizarre, obsolescent, and specialized words can you weed your way down to a winner. But I think it's probably a bad sign that so many kids have gotten that good at spelling. It suggests they're spending an inordinate amount of time mastering a skill that will be completely useless to them outside of that brief window of spelling bee competition. That's underscored by the fact such a high percentage of the finalists are home-schooled: educated in a setting where they're free to spend obsessive amounts of time on one pointless skill, to the exclusion of learning other things. I'd much prefer if the popularity of the spelling bee, in the public's mind, gave way to a more diversified "Academic Olympics" approach, so that stage-parents urging their children to dominate the competition would at least be causing them to develop a useful foundation for higher learning.

AND the winners again are of India decent.........NOT American Idol idiots..........
 
Personally, I would've entitled this post:
"Speling Beaz".
Then again, I have one of those West Cohst Edjucayshons.
:)

Seriously, though - I agree that this stuff has become an exercise in useless memorization. I'm sure these kids are quite bright, but if I were their parents I'd prefer that energy units are spent on hard disciplines, sciences, and - especially - application.
Yeah. Imagine the same hours spent learning to code.
 
Frankly, I hadn't seen one of them. I'd feel bad, but they're abstruse as hell. Perhaps I could use pococurante, but only if I know the person I use it on has knowledge of a Romance language.
There's also a threshold beyond which a word is so obscure that even if I know it, I'd feel like an ass using it. I think of it as the itinerant/peripatetic divide. Those two words mean basically the same thing, and they're both words where you're running a risk the other guy won't know what you mean, but you can get away with "itinerant," if you're talking to an educated audience, where "peripatetic" makes you sound like you're trying to show off.
 
spelling bees are outmoded. have been since "spell check" was invented as part of PC composition programs.

if you need further proof of this, any time a difficult word comes up in a spelling be, the kids always ask "use it in a sentence" - illustrating that they have simply memorized the spelling of arcane words and don't really understand their meanings.

the spelling be as industry unto itself. it has permanent employees, sponsors, and a budget in the millions. many people are making a good living off of this, which is why it persists.

but its a lower form of intelligence test than even something like "kids week" on jeopardy

my favorite student competition is the one where teams try to make a robot or device with identical raw materials to complete a certain task. that's a true test of scientific understanding, creativity, and teamwork - and much better predicts success in the real world after school, rather than spelling.

i gave you a big "like"
 
Spelling bees seem like a good idea. They encourage kids to pay attention to the spelling of common words and they reward avid readers. At low levels of competition, they're closely tied to reasonable educational goals, making them a decent use of a child's time. Through the mid-1990s, even the highest levels of national competition were testing the kind of vocabulary words that educated people are likely to use in real life, such that the proper spelling of them had some value outside the bounds of spelling contests. But, that has changed. The words tested are so arcane that you may as well be having kids memorize all the numbers in the phone book -- it doubtless has some value in training their memories, but it's impractical as hell.

If you check lists of winning words in national spelling bees in the early-to-mid 20th century, you'll see they used to be things like "intelligible," "fracas," "knack," "meticulous," "vignette," "sycophant," "therapy," "initials," "milieu," and "kamikaze." They're words you've probably found yourself using in everyday conversation. They're words that it would be useful to know how to spell correctly. Now, look at the winning words in recent years:

Succedaneum, prospicience, pococurante, autochthonous, appoggiatura, Ursprache, serrefine, guerdon, Laodicean, stromuhr, cymotrichous, guetapens, knaidel, stichomythia, feuilleton​

Those words are all so obscure that the built-in spell checker in my web browser identified every single one as a misspelling, even though they're all correct. By comparison, it knew every one of the winning words from the first quarter-century of the spelling bee championship, and over three quarters of the words between the 1950s and 1995. I got a perfect 800 on the Verbal SAT (back before they scaled the scores upward), but in that list above, I only know three of the words (prospicience, Ursprache, and feuilleton), and the only one I've ever used is Ursprache. Has anyone here ever used any of them?

I don't fault the spelling bee organizers. They have to go with ridiculous words or the contest would never end, because there's a steady supply of kids who can spell every single "SAT word" without fail. Only by dipping into the arcana of bizarre, obsolescent, and specialized words can you weed your way down to a winner. But I think it's probably a bad sign that so many kids have gotten that good at spelling. It suggests they're spending an inordinate amount of time mastering a skill that will be completely useless to them outside of that brief window of spelling bee competition. That's underscored by the fact such a high percentage of the finalists are home-schooled: educated in a setting where they're free to spend obsessive amounts of time on one pointless skill, to the exclusion of learning other things. I'd much prefer if the popularity of the spelling bee, in the public's mind, gave way to a more diversified "Academic Olympics" approach, so that stage-parents urging their children to dominate the competition would at least be causing them to develop a useful foundation for higher learning.

My manager from a few years ago is Indian and her daughter won the national spelling bee a few years ago (I want to say 2012). My son and her son played together so I knew them pretty well. One thing is, the winner almost always has a photographic memory as this girl that I know did. So it isn't just hard work that wins, it is talent or genetics or whatever it is that gives a person such a gift.
 
spelling bees are outmoded. have been since "spell check" was invented as part of PC composition programs.

if you need further proof of this, any time a difficult word comes up in a spelling be, the kids always ask "use it in a sentence" - illustrating that they have simply memorized the spelling of arcane words and don't really understand their meanings.

the spelling be as industry unto itself. it has permanent employees, sponsors, and a budget in the millions. many people are making a good living off of this, which is why it persists.

but its a lower form of intelligence test than even something like "kids week" on jeopardy

my favorite student competition is the one where teams try to make a robot or device with identical raw materials to complete a certain task. that's a true test of scientific understanding, creativity, and teamwork - and much better predicts success in the real world after school, rather than spelling.

i gave you a big "like"
It's funny that this particular academic contest is the one that developed the mainstream cachet. I'd love it if it were, instead, engineering contests, or academic decathlons, or something else where mastery of the skill or skills might be seen as having a more direct connection with future success. Even a wide-ranging Trivial-Pursuit-style contest would probably lend itself to more well-rounded kids. The kind of study you'd have to do to dominate Trivial Pursuit or Jeopardy would span enough topics and a wide enough data set that you'd almost have to become well-educated, in the general sense, to win.
 
It's funny that this particular academic contest is the one that developed the mainstream cachet. I'd love it if it were, instead, engineering contests, or academic decathlons, or something else where mastery of the skill or skills might be seen as having a more direct connection with future success. Even a wide-ranging Trivial-Pursuit-style contest would probably lend itself to more well-rounded kids. The kind of study you'd have to do to dominate Trivial Pursuit or Jeopardy would span enough topics and a wide enough data set that you'd almost have to become well-educated, in the general sense, to win.


there are engineering contests of all sorts.. solar cars.. robotics.. take yer pick.

the take away i get from all this is...our kids are not well educated... such that thes spelling bees, hovever obscure, seem to be more bothersome, than useful...

not a good thing..
 
The dumbed down school system is easily beat by home schooled kids, they actually learn at home. Its not just spelling they learn, home school kids finish higher in their test scores on literally all subjects.
We have teachers today that don't know their subjects, but are allowed to teach. The math and science classes are sinking to new lows, just look at the national ranking, third word countries are now ahead of us.
Much of the problem is the teachers union, it needs to be abolished and tenure eliminated, then maybe we could once again get good public schools. Vouchers are the way to go to make things competitive.
 
The dumbed down school system is easily beat by home schooled kids, they actually learn at home. Its not just spelling they learn, home school kids finish higher in their test scores on literally all subjects.
We have teachers today that don't know their subjects, but are allowed to teach. The math and science classes are sinking to new lows, just look at the national ranking, third word countries are now ahead of us.
Much of the problem is the teachers union, it needs to be abolished and tenure eliminated, then maybe we could once again get good public schools. Vouchers are the way to go to make things competitive.


I'll add... common core curriculum...need to be eliminated.
 
My manager from a few years ago is Indian and her daughter won the national spelling bee a few years ago (I want to say 2012). My son and her son played together so I knew them pretty well. One thing is, the winner almost always has a photographic memory as this girl that I know did. So it isn't just hard work that wins, it is talent or genetics or whatever it is that gives a person such a gift.
I've never met anyone with a true photographic memory. I'm not sure it even exists. I know some people have eidetic memories, but my understanding is even that is extremely rare, and I've never met one. But, I do realize that some people have some absurd memory skills. If you ever read up on the feats performed at the World Memory Championship, it's mind-blowing. For example, in one hour, someone memorized 2660 random numbers. Someone else memorized 59 decks of playing cards, all shuffled together (3068 cards total) only being able to view each card once. On IQ tests, I do reasonably well with "digit span" (being read random numbers and having to recite them back backwards), but I only get to around 15 digits before I lose track, so the idea of memorizing random stuff in the thousands that way is just something I can't fathom.

My own memory is considered somewhat freakish by people who know me, in both a good and bad way. In the bad way, I am astonishingly awful at remembering names and faces. I regularly offend people by not recognizing them after several meetings. It's almost like face blindness. I have to consciously memorize a face to remember it later, whereas most people seem to do it subconsciously, with no effort. And I can be introduced to someone and somehow have forgotten his name just seconds later.

But, my memory excels in two ways. First, sometimes, unpredictably, it becomes near-photographic for short periods of time. I can close my eyes and picture exactly where on a page a particular piece of text was that I read 30 years ago, and recall it verbatim, and recall who was in the room with me when I read it, and what they were doing and where I was sitting and what we'd talked about a couple minutes earlier and what was playing on the radio. Second, once something gets into my long-term memory, it seldom leaves, and is easy for me to recall accurately. This makes me absurdly good at trivia games. This drives my brother up the wall -- he likes trivia, too, and is quite smart and well-educated (Phi Beta Kappa, summa cum laude MBA from an elite school), but when we play a game like trivial pursuit, it isn't even close.
 
Last edited:
The dumbed down school system is easily beat by home schooled kids, they actually learn at home. Its not just spelling they learn, home school kids finish higher in their test scores on literally all subjects.
We have teachers today that don't know their subjects, but are allowed to teach. The math and science classes are sinking to new lows, just look at the national ranking, third word countries are now ahead of us.
Much of the problem is the teachers union, it needs to be abolished and tenure eliminated, then maybe we could once again get good public schools. Vouchers are the way to go to make things competitive.
Your rhetoric seems to suppose that the school system has gotten worse, but the fact is it has gotten better. Despite dropout rates falling (meaning that testing higher grades consists of testing a less elite group than in the past), test scores are up (e.g., compare the NAEP scores from the early 1970s to today).

As for home-school success, it makes sense home schooled kids would do well, since they often have what is essentially a student/teacher ration between 1:1 and, say, 6:1. We could theoretically replicate that in the school system, but it would be hugely expensive.

I've got a bit of a prejudice against home-schooled students based on a very small data set. In college, I knew two home-schooled kids and they both washed out freshman year. In each case, the student was used to mommy pre-digesting all academic material for them and feeding it to them in a way tailor made to fit their learning needs, and you don't get that in college. They also had some severe culture shock when having to deal with their peers, after having had limited socialization, and, in one case, there was the added problem of getting a little too wild when suddenly experiencing the freedom of independent life after an exceedingly sheltered childhood where there'd been few temptations. I'd be interested to see data to track home-schooled kids up through adulthood, to see if that was just an unrepresentative sampling or if the culture shock of going to college really is a problem. Given that there are several universities that essentially re-create the home-school setting for sheltered students (like Patrick Henry College), my guess is that even the parents of these kids often recognize they've raised a hothouse flower.
 
Last edited:
I'll add... common core curriculum...need to be eliminated.
Why?

I don't know enough about common core to have a strong feeling about it either way. However, I endorse the overall concept of having a common core, whether or not these particular standards are the right ones. I think it's terribly inefficient to have every state, or even every school district, pulling its own curriculum out of its ass. We'd be much better off having elite teams of educators coming up with a coordinated curriculum at the national level. This would reduce the number of gaps in important material being taught and it would be a huge benefit to students who move from area to area during their schooling. It would also allow businesses and colleges to have some reasonable assumptions they could make about what high school graduates have learned, rather than there being huge differences from area to area.
 
Spelling bees seem like a good idea. They encourage kids to pay attention to the spelling of common words and they reward avid readers. At low levels of competition, they're closely tied to reasonable educational goals, making them a decent use of a child's time. Through the mid-1990s, even the highest levels of national competition were testing the kind of vocabulary words that educated people are likely to use in real life, such that the proper spelling of them had some value outside the bounds of spelling contests. But, that has changed. The words tested are so arcane that you may as well be having kids memorize all the numbers in the phone book -- it doubtless has some value in training their memories, but it's impractical as hell.

If you check lists of winning words in national spelling bees in the early-to-mid 20th century, you'll see they used to be things like "intelligible," "fracas," "knack," "meticulous," "vignette," "sycophant," "therapy," "initials," "milieu," and "kamikaze." They're words you've probably found yourself using in everyday conversation. They're words that it would be useful to know how to spell correctly. Now, look at the winning words in recent years:

Succedaneum, prospicience, pococurante, autochthonous, appoggiatura, Ursprache, serrefine, guerdon, Laodicean, stromuhr, cymotrichous, guetapens, knaidel, stichomythia, feuilleton​

Those words are all so obscure that the built-in spell checker in my web browser identified every single one as a misspelling, even though they're all correct. By comparison, it knew every one of the winning words from the first quarter-century of the spelling bee championship, and over three quarters of the words between the 1950s and 1995. I got a perfect 800 on the Verbal SAT (back before they scaled the scores upward), but in that list above, I only know three of the words (prospicience, Ursprache, and feuilleton), and the only one I've ever used is Ursprache. Has anyone here ever used any of them?

I don't fault the spelling bee organizers. They have to go with ridiculous words or the contest would never end, because there's a steady supply of kids who can spell every single "SAT word" without fail. Only by dipping into the arcana of bizarre, obsolescent, and specialized words can you weed your way down to a winner. But I think it's probably a bad sign that so many kids have gotten that good at spelling. It suggests they're spending an inordinate amount of time mastering a skill that will be completely useless to them outside of that brief window of spelling bee competition. That's underscored by the fact such a high percentage of the finalists are home-schooled: educated in a setting where they're free to spend obsessive amounts of time on one pointless skill, to the exclusion of learning other things. I'd much prefer if the popularity of the spelling bee, in the public's mind, gave way to a more diversified "Academic Olympics" approach, so that stage-parents urging their children to dominate the competition would at least be causing them to develop a useful foundation for higher learning.
I've heard of talking horses and flying pigs, but never spelling bees.
 
Arkady is just mad that people of color win this spelling bee and no white people ever win...that's your lefty is a racist moment of the hour!

Sriram Hathwar and Ansun Sujoe made history by becoming co-champions at the 87th annual Scripps National Spelling Bee on Thursday a t the Gaylord National Resort & Convention Center in National Harbor, Maryland

I thought this was the highlander spelling bee...There can only be one....Ark's kids just cant compete because they aren't allowed to push their kids that hard(lefty code of ethics rule 3.21-C, Trying is acceptable...doing makes other kids feel inferior).
 
Why?

I don't know enough about common core to have a strong feeling about it either way. However, I endorse the overall concept of having a common core, whether or not these particular standards are the right ones. I think it's terribly inefficient to have every state, or even every school district, pulling its own curriculum out of its ass. We'd be much better off having elite teams of educators coming up with a coordinated curriculum at the national level. This would reduce the number of gaps in important material being taught and it would be a huge benefit to students who move from area to area during their schooling. It would also allow businesses and colleges to have some reasonable assumptions they could make about what high school graduates have learned, rather than there being huge differences from area to area.


I'll narrow my initial.. Common core math. It is an inefficient, confusing, and poorly executed curriculum. (you can find myriad feedback with a simple search..)
I surmise that the 'elite teams of educators' were out on that particular day....
I dont know that every state pulled it out of their ass as it were, it seemed more to me that the curriculum(s) were not broken / or inadequate....but their delivery..
 
Back
Top