New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Spelling Bees

Your rhetoric seems to suppose that the school system has gotten worse, but the fact is it has gotten better. Despite dropout rates falling (meaning that testing higher grades consists of testing a less elite group than in the past), test scores are up (e.g., compare the NAEP scores from the early 1970s to today).

As for home-school success, it makes sense home schooled kids would do well, since they often have what is essentially a student/teacher ration between 1:1 and, say, 6:1. We could theoretically replicate that in the school system, but it would be hugely expensive.

I've got a bit of a prejudice against home-schooled students based on a very small data set. In college, I knew two home-schooled kids and they both washed out freshman year. In each case, the student was used to mommy pre-digesting all academic material for them and feeding it to them in a way tailor made to fit their learning needs, and you don't get that in college. They also had some severe culture shock when having to deal with their peers, after having had limited socialization, and, in one case, there was the added problem of getting a little too wild when suddenly experiencing the freedom of independent life after an exceedingly sheltered childhood where there'd been few temptations. I'd be interested to see data to track home-schooled kids up through adulthood, to see if that was just an unrepresentative sampling or if the culture shock of going to college really is a problem. Given that there are several universities that essentially re-create the home-school setting for sheltered students (like Patrick Henry College), my guess is that even the parents of these kids often recognize they've raised a hothouse flower.

We keep falling in the world comparison, I don't think anyone would seriously suggest we are trending up on education. To make things look better they keep adjusting the scoring on much of the standardized testing. SAT test scores have constantly been altered to make today's kids look better.
I know quite a few home schooled kids and the results are outstanding. Several kids in my neighborhood just graduated with honors from college. I see no evidence of any social problems with these kids, they are doing just fine.

The teachers Union prevents getting rid of loser teachers and in many cases, sex offenders. What is with all the reports of Female teachers bothering young men, it appears to be an epidemic.
 
I don't know enough about common core to have a strong feeling about it either way. However, I endorse the overall concept of having a common core, whether or not these particular standards are the right ones.

Interesting. You're so enamored by any centralized governmental control of education (or anything else), you don't care one bit if the content is valuable or not, or whether it even helps the students or hurts them.

Not many outside the most repressive regimes have the rocks to admit their undying fealty to a massive central government regardless of the damage it does, I gotta give you credit there...
 
I'll narrow my initial.. Common core math. It is an inefficient, confusing, and poorly executed curriculum. (you can find myriad feedback with a simple search..)
I surmise that the 'elite teams of educators' were out on that particular day....
I dont know that every state pulled it out of their ass as it were, it seemed more to me that the curriculum(s) were not broken / or inadequate....but their delivery..
As I've mentioned before, I was one of those kids who experienced the downside to different states and districts having their own curricula with no real coordination. As my family moved from place to place, I missed out on important areas of instruction while having huge amounts of time wasted on redundant information. For example, if State A teaches the American Revolution in 4th grade and the Civil War in 5th, and State B reverses that, then you could end up getting the American Revolution twice and never getting the Civil War, if you move. And it's even worse for math, where advanced skills build on basic skills you may have missed because of a move.
 
Arkady is just mad that people of color win this spelling bee and no white people ever win...that's your lefty is a racist moment of the hour!



I thought this was the highlander spelling bee...There can only be one....Ark's kids just cant compete because they aren't allowed to push their kids that hard(lefty code of ethics rule 3.21-C, Trying is acceptable...doing makes other kids feel inferior).
The lady doth protest too much, methinks.
 
As I've mentioned before, I was one of those kids who experienced the downside to different states and districts having their own curricula with no real coordination. As my family moved from place to place, I missed out on important areas of instruction while having huge amounts of time wasted on redundant information. For example, if State A teaches the American Revolution in 4th grade and the Civil War in 5th, and State B reverses that, then you could end up getting the American Revolution twice and never getting the Civil War, if you move. And it's even worse for math, where advanced skills build on basic skills you may have missed because of a move.

Certainly something appreciable. But, in this instance, i think what we are risking here is an entire nation/generation of kids...who will emerge lacking the most basic elements of mathematical skill..or, at best, emerge from the critical years with some concocted asinine methodology for tackling basic mathematics.. rather than the tried and true of rote memorization / repetition of the basics as a threshold to broader concepts
 
We keep falling in the world comparison, I don't think anyone would seriously suggest we are trending up on education. To make things look better they keep adjusting the scoring on much of the standardized testing. SAT test scores have constantly been altered to make today's kids look better.
I know quite a few home schooled kids and the results are outstanding. Several kids in my neighborhood just graduated with honors from college. I see no evidence of any social problems with these kids, they are doing just fine.

The teachers Union prevents getting rid of loser teachers and in many cases, sex offenders. What is with all the reports of Female teachers bothering young men, it appears to be an epidemic.
We have fallen a little in global rankings, but that's not because education in the US got worse. It got better. It's just that education in a number of other countries got better faster.

As for the SAT, it's not a useful comparison, since the percentage of students taking it has grown dramatically over time, so that you're testing a far less elite group today than in the past. If you test the top 20% of people from one year and the top 80% from another, obviously the former group will do better. That's why the NAEP is a much better measure, as are military aptitude tests.

As for the reports of female teachers bothering young men, they serve a valuable role in the for-profit corporate media. They attract viewers/subscribers/clicks/etc., and thus help turn a profit for the shareholders. Determining whether it's an epidemic of increasing activity or just an epidemic of increasing coverage would require serious analysis, rather than just taking an impression from what's on the news.
 
Interesting. You're so enamored by any centralized governmental control of education (or anything else), you don't care one bit if the content is valuable or not, or whether it even helps the students or hurts them.

Not many outside the most repressive regimes have the rocks to admit their undying fealty to a massive central government regardless of the damage it does, I gotta give you credit there...
No. You've misunderstood. You were doubtless the product of some wretched red-state educational system that churns out graduates who lack even the most basic reading comprehension skills. It's sad, but I can't really blame you. We don't get to choose such things.

Anyway, nothing I wrote implies that I don't care whether the content is valuable or not. I very much do. If the choice were between valuable content that is done in a chaotic district-by-district way or valueless content that's taught consistently nationally, obviously I'd choose the former. But I believe a nationally-administered process will tend to come up with a curriculum of higher average value, and I also believe that there are efficiencies and other benefits to be had from coordinating the material at that level.

What I'm saying is that I don't know enough about common core to take a stance on whether the content is good or not. If it isn't, then by all means improve it. But the solution, if the content needs work, is to fix it, not to return to a haphazard state-by-state or district-by-district system with no serious effort to coordinate curricula at the national level.
 
Certainly something appreciable. But, in this instance, i think what we are risking here is an entire nation/generation of kids...who will emerge lacking the most basic elements of mathematical skill..or, at best, emerge from the critical years with some concocted asinine methodology for tackling basic mathematics.. rather than the tried and true of rote memorization / repetition of the basics as a threshold to broader concepts
I'm open-minded about it. If there have been studies showing that the common-core approach is better or worse than what it's supplanting, in terms of forming a basis for higher math instruction and in terms of providing useful math skills for everyday life, I'd very much like to see them, since that strikes me as the important question. I'm results-oriented. I don't start with the assumption that new is worse, nor that new is better.
 
No. You've misunderstood. You were doubtless the product of some wretched red-state educational system that churns out graduates who lack even the most basic reading comprehension skills. It's sad, but I can't really blame you. We don't get to choose such things.

Haha, speaking of reading comprehension, you failed to comprehend the many, many times I've stated that I was born and raised in California (and still live there). So you're right that the education system in my state sucks, but it's primarily because it's been run by people just like you for decades.
 
Haha, speaking of reading comprehension, you failed to comprehend the many, many times I've stated that I was born and raised in California (and still live there). So you're right that the education system in my state sucks, but it's primarily because it's been run by people just like you for decades.
No -- that wouldn't be a lack of reading comprehension. No doubt I understood it when I read it. Rather, it would just be the fact that I categorize your personal details as not being worth retaining.

As for California, the state of Nixon, Reagan, Deukmejian, Pete Wilson, and Schwarzenegger, I certainly wouldn't want to try to defend the quality of the educational system there. Although it's not an utter train wreck like the most conservative states (e.g., Mississsippi and Louisiana), it does look like a basket case next to liberal states like Massachusetts, Vermont, and Connecticut.
 
No -- that wouldn't be a lack of reading comprehension. No doubt I understood it when I read it. Rather, it would just be the fact that I categorize your personal details as not being worth retaining.

And that after you just bragged about your prodigious memory in another thread.

I see you...
 
And that after you just bragged about your prodigious memory in another thread.

I see you...
Reread the other thread. You'll see that I spoke of a terrible memory as to personal information about people -- names and faces, in particular. I have a hard time remembering all sorts of personal information about people -- especially people I consider inconsequential, like you. When it comes to world events, history, science, etc., my brain tags the information as important and saves it, whereas when it comes to trivia about people I hold in slight regard, it falls away almost immediately.
 
Reread the other thread. You'll see that I spoke of a terrible memory as to personal information about people -- names and faces, in particular. I have a hard time remembering all sorts of personal information about people -- especially people I consider inconsequential, like you. When it comes to world events, history, science, etc., my brain tags the information as important and saves it, whereas when it comes to trivia about people I hold in slight regard, it falls away almost immediately.

"Inconsequential", yet you respond to virtually every post I make on your threads (and off them). LOL. How can you be so elitist and yet so obtuse?

I see you...
 
"Inconsequential", yet you respond to virtually every post I make on your threads (and off them). LOL. How can you be so elitist and yet so obtuse?

I see you...
I have to admit to being a bit lazy. Ideally I'd respond to the smartest posts, which are the most challenging. But it's awfully tempting to kick over the weakest arguments, instead. There isn't as much to be proud of in knocking down a house of cards than in knocking down a more substantial edifice, but it sure takes less time and effort. So, to my shame, I often find myself posting responses to the weaker posters here.
 
For what it's worth and at the risk of blowing all sorts of memes to smithereens, it's just been announced that the American high school graduation rate has just hit an ALL TIME high. It's in the 81%+ range now. For sure, that ain't good enough. But...an all time record ain't too bad.
 
For what it's worth and at the risk of blowing all sorts of memes to smithereens, it's just been announced that the American high school graduation rate has just hit an ALL TIME high. It's in the 81%+ range now. For sure, that ain't good enough. But...an all time record ain't too bad.

If they continue lowering the standards, they could hit 95%, and then won't we all be proud! :rolleyes:
 
Back
Top