Fast Eddy
Mayor
Your rhetoric seems to suppose that the school system has gotten worse, but the fact is it has gotten better. Despite dropout rates falling (meaning that testing higher grades consists of testing a less elite group than in the past), test scores are up (e.g., compare the NAEP scores from the early 1970s to today).
As for home-school success, it makes sense home schooled kids would do well, since they often have what is essentially a student/teacher ration between 1:1 and, say, 6:1. We could theoretically replicate that in the school system, but it would be hugely expensive.
I've got a bit of a prejudice against home-schooled students based on a very small data set. In college, I knew two home-schooled kids and they both washed out freshman year. In each case, the student was used to mommy pre-digesting all academic material for them and feeding it to them in a way tailor made to fit their learning needs, and you don't get that in college. They also had some severe culture shock when having to deal with their peers, after having had limited socialization, and, in one case, there was the added problem of getting a little too wild when suddenly experiencing the freedom of independent life after an exceedingly sheltered childhood where there'd been few temptations. I'd be interested to see data to track home-schooled kids up through adulthood, to see if that was just an unrepresentative sampling or if the culture shock of going to college really is a problem. Given that there are several universities that essentially re-create the home-school setting for sheltered students (like Patrick Henry College), my guess is that even the parents of these kids often recognize they've raised a hothouse flower.
We keep falling in the world comparison, I don't think anyone would seriously suggest we are trending up on education. To make things look better they keep adjusting the scoring on much of the standardized testing. SAT test scores have constantly been altered to make today's kids look better.
I know quite a few home schooled kids and the results are outstanding. Several kids in my neighborhood just graduated with honors from college. I see no evidence of any social problems with these kids, they are doing just fine.
The teachers Union prevents getting rid of loser teachers and in many cases, sex offenders. What is with all the reports of Female teachers bothering young men, it appears to be an epidemic.