Havelock
Mayor
"You may mean well, but it makes you sound ignorant."
So says Dr. Jesse Bering in his recent article on Slate (quote above is linked). The article prompted a flurry of comments – many folks complained that Bering's article was yet another example of PC word police run amok. Others said that Bering's stance needlessly alienates people of good will and is thus not a fight worth having. Quite a few of the respondents were anxious to point out to Jesse that simply because something is a “preference” doesn't necessarily imply that it's freely chosen from among a number of equally free choices. A few gave Bering a hearty “Hear, Hear!” and said it was about time someone took up this particular banner.
The point of Bering's article, you see, is that a person's sexual desires are not in any sense freely or consciously chosen and the term “sexual preference” is often used by those opposed to gay rights to wrongly imply that homosexuality is a choice. Therefore, everyone of good will needs to drop “sexual preference” and use only the term “sexual orientation” in order to counter the homophobes and to be more scientifically accurate.
Now, for those who may have missed it in my previous posts, I'm generally a big fan of Dr. Bering's work. I've cited him before and likely will have occasion to do so again. But in this case... I don't know.
I certainly agree with his main point: a person's sexuality not a choice as such. We don't choose what does or doesn't turn us on and a tried and true tool for denigrating sexual minorities is to suggest that they've willfully turned away from wholesome, normal pleasures because they're wicked or defective or whatever. That's wrong and it deserves to be countered vigorously. Is declaring the term “sexual preference” out of bounds the best way to do that? I don't know. Fact is, I have a couple of problems with making too big a deal out of “sexual orientation” as opposed to “sexual preference.”
First, while I, along with the vast majority of folks who've examined the evidence, accept the fact that a person's sexual desires are for all practical purposes generally innate and immutable, I think it's a mistake to make too much of that fact as it relates to fundamental rights and liberties. I mean, I recognize the political utility of establishing once and for all in the public mind that sexuality is not chosen, it simply is. But the inevitable counter argument is something along the lines of “So what? If a desire to murder were found to be innate and immutable, does that mean we can't discriminate against murderers?” And that argument is undeniably correct in the sense that we can't and shouldn't avoid discussing the basic ethical assumptions and conclusions related to whatever behavior is in the dock. Focusing too much on the fact that a given “sexual orientation” is innate can distract from the more basic ethical arguments, it seems to me.
Besides, no one argues that a person's religious beliefs are innate and immutable and yet we accord that characteristic the highest protection against discrimination.
Second, while I agree that civil rights legislation ought to be extended to protect individuals from discrimination based on sexual orientation and that laws that discriminate on the basis of sexual orientation ought to be subject to so-called strict scrutiny, I think we need to make sure everyone shares a common understanding of exactly what “sexual orientation” encompasses. Too many people simply assume that sexual orientation is essentially a binary state of being – or at best a sliding scale between two and only two anchors. Reality is a little more complicated, as usual.
Bering, to his credit, recognizes a broader definition of “sexual orientation” in his essay, albeit only briefly and sort of in passing. It's tangential to the purpose of his article. But to the extent that we identify the concept of sexual orientation mainly as a tool to be used in pursuit of Gay rights, we tend to lose sight of that larger meaning. Or at the very least we tend to get bogged down in ultimately distracting and ill-focused arguments about what constitutes a “real” sexual orientation and is therefore worthy of being protected.
And I've had those arguments, believe me. For example, not long ago I was on a committee tasked with coming up with a mission statement, among other things. The committee chair decided it would be good to incorporate a statement specifically reflecting our organization's tolerance for diversity in sexual orientation and prepared some draft language for the committee to review. Well, after a too-long, uncomfortable, and ultimately fruitless discussion, we couldn't decide on language that included everyone the group thought ought to be officially celebrated and also excluded everyone the group thought ought not to be officially tolerated. So in the end we didn't include any language about sexual orientation at all. It was a mess – and a stupid waste of time.
Bottom line: I'm all for more precision and accuracy in our language, particularly our political language. I'm also in favor of making it harder for bigots to hide behind language that obscures their true agenda. But while I understand and agree with Jesse Bering's reasons for arguing in favor of saying “sexual orientation” instead of “sexual preference”, he seems to be infusing a fairly innocuous word choice with a lot more meaning than most people recognize it should have or intend it to have. All in all, it's an argument that I fear is likely to generate more heat than light and not only because it seems kind of fussy.
Cheers.
So says Dr. Jesse Bering in his recent article on Slate (quote above is linked). The article prompted a flurry of comments – many folks complained that Bering's article was yet another example of PC word police run amok. Others said that Bering's stance needlessly alienates people of good will and is thus not a fight worth having. Quite a few of the respondents were anxious to point out to Jesse that simply because something is a “preference” doesn't necessarily imply that it's freely chosen from among a number of equally free choices. A few gave Bering a hearty “Hear, Hear!” and said it was about time someone took up this particular banner.
The point of Bering's article, you see, is that a person's sexual desires are not in any sense freely or consciously chosen and the term “sexual preference” is often used by those opposed to gay rights to wrongly imply that homosexuality is a choice. Therefore, everyone of good will needs to drop “sexual preference” and use only the term “sexual orientation” in order to counter the homophobes and to be more scientifically accurate.
Now, for those who may have missed it in my previous posts, I'm generally a big fan of Dr. Bering's work. I've cited him before and likely will have occasion to do so again. But in this case... I don't know.
I certainly agree with his main point: a person's sexuality not a choice as such. We don't choose what does or doesn't turn us on and a tried and true tool for denigrating sexual minorities is to suggest that they've willfully turned away from wholesome, normal pleasures because they're wicked or defective or whatever. That's wrong and it deserves to be countered vigorously. Is declaring the term “sexual preference” out of bounds the best way to do that? I don't know. Fact is, I have a couple of problems with making too big a deal out of “sexual orientation” as opposed to “sexual preference.”
First, while I, along with the vast majority of folks who've examined the evidence, accept the fact that a person's sexual desires are for all practical purposes generally innate and immutable, I think it's a mistake to make too much of that fact as it relates to fundamental rights and liberties. I mean, I recognize the political utility of establishing once and for all in the public mind that sexuality is not chosen, it simply is. But the inevitable counter argument is something along the lines of “So what? If a desire to murder were found to be innate and immutable, does that mean we can't discriminate against murderers?” And that argument is undeniably correct in the sense that we can't and shouldn't avoid discussing the basic ethical assumptions and conclusions related to whatever behavior is in the dock. Focusing too much on the fact that a given “sexual orientation” is innate can distract from the more basic ethical arguments, it seems to me.
Besides, no one argues that a person's religious beliefs are innate and immutable and yet we accord that characteristic the highest protection against discrimination.
Second, while I agree that civil rights legislation ought to be extended to protect individuals from discrimination based on sexual orientation and that laws that discriminate on the basis of sexual orientation ought to be subject to so-called strict scrutiny, I think we need to make sure everyone shares a common understanding of exactly what “sexual orientation” encompasses. Too many people simply assume that sexual orientation is essentially a binary state of being – or at best a sliding scale between two and only two anchors. Reality is a little more complicated, as usual.
Bering, to his credit, recognizes a broader definition of “sexual orientation” in his essay, albeit only briefly and sort of in passing. It's tangential to the purpose of his article. But to the extent that we identify the concept of sexual orientation mainly as a tool to be used in pursuit of Gay rights, we tend to lose sight of that larger meaning. Or at the very least we tend to get bogged down in ultimately distracting and ill-focused arguments about what constitutes a “real” sexual orientation and is therefore worthy of being protected.
And I've had those arguments, believe me. For example, not long ago I was on a committee tasked with coming up with a mission statement, among other things. The committee chair decided it would be good to incorporate a statement specifically reflecting our organization's tolerance for diversity in sexual orientation and prepared some draft language for the committee to review. Well, after a too-long, uncomfortable, and ultimately fruitless discussion, we couldn't decide on language that included everyone the group thought ought to be officially celebrated and also excluded everyone the group thought ought not to be officially tolerated. So in the end we didn't include any language about sexual orientation at all. It was a mess – and a stupid waste of time.
Bottom line: I'm all for more precision and accuracy in our language, particularly our political language. I'm also in favor of making it harder for bigots to hide behind language that obscures their true agenda. But while I understand and agree with Jesse Bering's reasons for arguing in favor of saying “sexual orientation” instead of “sexual preference”, he seems to be infusing a fairly innocuous word choice with a lot more meaning than most people recognize it should have or intend it to have. All in all, it's an argument that I fear is likely to generate more heat than light and not only because it seems kind of fussy.
Cheers.