New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Stopped-watch wisdom

Arkady

President
This isn't an immediately political post, but has applications to politics. I've been reading "The Rise and Fall of the Third Reich," and one thing that's striking is how Hitler seems to go from a political genius to a complete imbecile part way through the history of the era. Early on, he defies all conventional wisdom and most of his advisers again and again and is constantly proven right. For years, Germany had been too scared to engage in open rearmament or to repudiate Versailles sanctions, but Hitler calculated England, France, etc. wouldn't punish Germany if they made that move. And he was right. He made a similar call with regard to the re-occupation of the Rhineland, bluffing his way through a military maneuver that could have had his regime wiped out almost overnight by the French. The German generals were on the verge of mutiny, sure that France would call the bluff, but Hitler had them pegged. Then he did it again with the Anschluss against Austria -- again almost triggering a military coup by those who thought such a move was suicidal, yet again being proven right. Then he did it again, first for all of Sudetenland, then for Czechoslovakia as a whole. It's like he had some supernatural ability to read the minds of the leaders of other countries, even when nearly all other observers were predicting things would play out some other way. He made outlandishly optimistic predictions, and boldly aggressive moves, and each time he was right.

Then, it's like his crystal ball shattered. He wrongly thought France and England would stay on the sidelines if he moved into Poland. He wrongly thought the US was too isolationist to get involved (failing to foresee the act of his own ally, Japan). He badly overestimated the help Italy would provide. He blundered suicidally into a Russian winter. After having raised Germany from its knees, to make the world tremble, in a few short years, looking like a once-an-epoch-political-genius, he then fell to total defeat just as quickly, looking like a raging nincompoop as he stumbled from one idiotic move to another.

At first glance, it's almost as if the man had suffered some sort of brain damage. But when you think about it more clearly, he was just a guy making the same basic strategic call over and over again (to favor the hyper-aggressive move, based on overwhelming optimism and confidence), and that one move worked great several times in a row, then stopped working. He was a bit like a stopped watch, which always reads the same, and sometimes that's going to be the actual time, by sheer coincidence.

I think that line of analysis is probably a good one to consider when looking at other historical figures and even modern politicians. Given the very low "sample size" of major tests of political wisdom any given figure is going to face, we're always going to be stuck with a level of uncertainty about how brilliant (or stupid) a person is, based on outcomes. A lot of people are going to be like stopped watches. They're going to make the same call over and over again, and so blind luck (or misfortune) may end up looking like great wisdom (or foolishness), based on great (or terrible) outcomes, when in fact it was nothing of the sort.

I've just started to think about this in the political context, but I've kept it in mind for many years when it comes to investments. A lot of investment advisers look brilliant if you look at their pronouncement in isolation -- for example, some guy who called the 2008 financial collapse perfectly and would have saved you big bucks if you'd just listened to him. But a lot of time they're "stopped watch" advisers -- like habitual bears, who have been shrieking about a pending stock collapse every year since 1980, so they're bound to be right occasionally, and yet you'd be foolish to listen to them. With investing, it's easier to distinguish between the real thinkers and the stopped watches, since the sample sizes are bigger, so you can look back and figure out who is just making the same (occasionally correct) call over and over, and who varies his advice from situation to situation and yet manages to be correct more often than not. With politics, I think the "sample sizes" are going to tend to be smaller, and so it'll be tougher to figure out who is genuinely brilliant, and who is a one-trick-pony whose trick just happens to be working at the moment. And likewise, with historical figures, it's possible that even with a full range of an historical life, we may have just coincidentally seen some successful person put into scenarios where his one trick happened to work, and he'd have failed just as spectacularly if he'd ever been put in some other scenario.
 
Last edited:
in a few short years, looking like a once-an-epoch-political-genius, he then fell to total defeat just as quickly, looking like a raging nincompoop as he stumbled from one idiotic move to another.

Hmm, that description reminds me of someone...

images
 
Hmm, that description reminds me of someone...

images
It reminds me of a bunch of politicians, pundits, strategists, etc. Karl Rove, for example, has at times been seem as incredibly smart -- a guy who took a lazy, dim-bulb, spoiled rich kid and won two elections with him, using an innovative "play to the base" approach of focusing on high turnout among true believers rather than the traditional game of capturing the center. At one point he looked like a preternaturally gifted political adviser. But then he seemed like a wildly out-of-touch crackpot who'd helped lead his party into a dead-end strategy that risks falling into permanent minority status in national elections. It wasn't that he'd lost his touch. It's just that a strategy can look brilliant in one circumstance and dumb in another.

Alan Greenspan's another example. The national press had practically made him a secular saint in the late 1990s. The conservative financial press, in particular --looking for someone not named "Clinton" to thank for that epic economic success-- was practically attributing magical abilities to "the Maestro." Then we got the horrendous Bush years, with Greenspan still at the helm, and the guy started looking more like a one-trick pony, whose anti-inflation preoccupation and faith in the wisdom of the unregulated financial markets may have looked brilliant in the roaring nineties, but came to look like nincompoopery under difference circumstances.
 
some professional historians advise reading eric hoffer's "true believer" as an anodyne to any text which promotes the concept that hitler was some sort of genius/mastermind.

the premise of "true believer" is people with problems will readily accept any "externalization" of their troubles, and fall in line behind a leader who assures them that they're not responsible for their situation, and everything will be fixed if they simply follow his extremist plan. This sort of charismatic leader could be a religious leader, a political leader, an author, a philospher . . . .

the willingness of people to externalize their problems of course extends beyond those who saluted the nazi flag.

in the middle east, 7 centuries of stagnation of islamic nations suddenly became Israel's fault after the Jewish state was recognized by the UN. they were told that their poverty and lack of freedom was israels fault, not the governments of their own nations.

and recently, the people of ferguson - who are 85% black, but only 12% of whom turned out to vote in the last municipal election, have been told by activists that they are not responsible for their mayor, their city council, or police. they've also been told that michael brown did nothing wrong, even though he is on tape brutalizing some store clerk in the commission of a robbery, and both eyewitnesses and forensic evidence affirm he was attempting to take officer wilson's gun away.

"people of ferguson - none of this is your fault. it's all officer wilson. or whitey in general. or those foreign store clerks. or the jews. it's not your fault that you have an overwhelming community majority, yet you don't vote, and your town is overrun with drugs and crime, and your schools suck. you aren't responsible for your own decisions and actions. now go burn some stuff !!"

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_True_Believer
 
Back
Top