New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Storm chasers

Should storm chasing be outlawed?

  • 1. Yes. It is too dangerous

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • 2. Outlawed unless one has a license

    Votes: 0 0.0%

  • Total voters
    7
  • Poll closed .

Jen

Senator
Should storm chasing be outlawed or is it a valuable service that people put themselves in harm's way in order that we get information that will help give us more time to get to safety when tornadoes and other storms are on their way to us?

PRO (allowing storm chasing)
  • In this most recent Oklahoma F3 tornado there was a 19 minute window of opportunity to get to safety before the storm struck. Storm chasers have given us information that allowed for that large window of time.
  • We know more now about the directions, wind speed, directional speed, formation of tornadoes than we would know if it weren't for those willing to get out there in the storm and record it for us.
  • People would be out there chasing storms even if the practice was frowned upon or legally banned.
CON (disallowing storm chasing)
  • Death of some chasers is inevitable
  • Some people are out there just seeking glory, not information
  • Too many people out there chasing storms makes it more dangerous for all
 
Storm chasing should not be outlaw...

I can live with the storm chaser should be licensed and carry insurance...

Besides that I feel if someone is that stupid to chase a twister, well let'em...
 
It's a Darwinian thing, survival of the fittest (Read as smartest) Smart people get to cover so they can survive only an idiot with a death wish would stand out in a tornado, hurricane, typhoon with a mike and try to give a spiel and weather coverage.

A couple of years ago I saw Geraldo on a beach in Texas during a hurricane, he got flattened by a sneaker wave.

The camera crew was in hysterics and a couple of firemen had to drag his wet sorry ass out to safety while they were laughing at him.

It's only a matter of time before one of these people gets taken out right on live network TV.
 
Should storm chasing be outlawed or is it a valuable service that people put themselves in harm's way in order that we get information that will help give us more time to get to safety when tornadoes and other storms are on their way to us?

I can't vote for any of the poll choices. What I'd suggest is that licenses be offered to those (professional, semi-professional) storm chasers that have a news- or research-driven purpose to be out there and that such licensing require a specific degree of safety training and, possibly, proof of liability insurance. Others are free to do as they like but if they impede the efforts of first responders or if they find themselves in need of assistance by first responders they are liable to be fined. Those with a license would be indemnified against such fines.

That's my ruling!
 
I can't vote for any of the poll choices. What I'd suggest is that licenses be offered to those (professional, semi-professional) storm chasers that have a news- or research-driven purpose to be out there and that such licensing require a specific degree of safety training and, possibly, proof of liability insurance. Others are free to do as they like but if they impede the efforts of first responders or if they find themselves in need of assistance by first responders they are liable to be fined. Those with a license would be indemnified against such fines.

That's my ruling!


That is a wise ruling, Havelock.
Answer #2 mentions the license, but your answer went a step further.
 
I'm good with a license. The test should be that applicants must stand their ground as a tornado passes over. If they pop out the other side intact, they get their license.
 
If we're going to outlaw storm chasing, then I think that we should also consider skydiving, mountain climbing and motorcycle driving while we're at it.

Oh yeah... And cliff diving... And scuba... And etc. etc. etc.

Hell. Let's just outlaw getting up off the sofa and be done with it. ;)
 
It's a Darwinian thing, survival of the fittest (Read as smartest) Smart people get to cover so they can survive only an idiot with a death wish would stand out in a tornado, hurricane, typhoon with a mike and try to give a spiel and weather coverage.

A couple of years ago I saw Geraldo on a beach in Texas during a hurricane, he got flattened by a sneaker wave.

The camera crew was in hysterics and a couple of firemen had to drag his wet sorry ass out to safety while they were laughing at him.

It's only a matter of time before one of these people gets taken out right on live network TV.


I saw that Geraldo thing. It was funny because he got taken out by the wave because he was being stupid.

Someone said that storm chasers do that because humans are at the top of the food chain and have no natural predators, so we create one in the storm that we chase.

I would hope that at least one storm chaser out there is doing it purely for scientific research in order to help us learn how to keep away from the storms and how to survive them better, but that's probably too much to hope.

Jen
 
Looks like I'm a prime candidate for a Darwin award. I've chased storms when I lived in tornado country. Regretted doing it one time because the situation and weird lighting effects blowing around kind of freaked me out.
 
Looks like I'm a prime candidate for a Darwin award. I've chased storms when I lived in tornado country. Regretted doing it one time because the situation and weird lighting effects blowing around kind of freaked me out.


I don't think I could do it. I'm calm during those storms, but if I were out in a car I might not be so calm. I have a daredevil son who would do it in a heartbeat.
 
Looks like I'm a prime candidate for a Darwin award. I've chased storms when I lived in tornado country. Regretted doing it one time because the situation and weird lighting effects blowing around kind of freaked me out.

No you don't qualify...You survived it, first place Darwin awards are usually posthumous. :)
 
I saw that Geraldo thing. It was funny because he got taken out by the wave because he was being stupid.

Someone said that storm chasers do that because humans are at the top of the food chain and have no natural predators, so we create one in the storm that we chase.

I would hope that at least one storm chaser out there is doing it purely for scientific research in order to help us learn how to keep away from the storms and how to survive them better, but that's probably too much to hope.

Jen



Storm chasers = Adrenalin junkies :)
 
Should storm chasing be outlawed or is it a valuable service that people put themselves in harm's way in order that we get information that will help give us more time to get to safety when tornadoes and other storms are on their way to us?

PRO (allowing storm chasing)
  • In this most recent Oklahoma F3 tornado there was a 19 minute window of opportunity to get to safety before the storm struck. Storm chasers have given us information that allowed for that large window of time.
  • We know more now about the directions, wind speed, directional speed, formation of tornadoes than we would know if it weren't for those willing to get out there in the storm and record it for us.
  • People would be out there chasing storms even if the practice was frowned upon or legally banned.
CON (disallowing storm chasing)

  • Death of some chasers is inevitable
  • Some people are out there just seeking glory, not information
  • Too many people out there chasing storms makes it more dangerous for all

Much is learned from those who invest their energies in risky pursuits... storm chasers... researchers seeking cures/protection against super bugs (SARS, etc).. etc.. without their efforts we'd know less... I view it as a benefit..
 
Much is learned from those who invest their energies in risky pursuits... storm chasers... researchers seeking cures/protection against super bugs (SARS, etc).. etc.. without their efforts we'd know less... I view it as a benefit..


I am certain there is benefit to it, PhilFish. There was a 19 minute notice of the tornado that hit May 31. It has now been upgraded to an F5. Tornado chasers helped give us information that was needed to give us that kind of fore-notice and no doubt saved lives.

afbcdn_sphotos_d_a.akamaihd.net_hphotos_ak_ash3_601105_10151407462561636_320073950_n.jpg​
 
I am happy they do what they do. I live in one of the worst areas of the country for Tornado's and lived through the April 27, 2011 outbreak that left North Alabama without power for almost a week. The work they have done has saved so many lives. Sad to see them lose theirs in the process.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Jen
Back
Top