Arkady
President
It's hard to be patient, so people are looking to poll results, enrollment figures, and other traces of early data to argue that Obamacare is either a success or a failure. Largely these impressions are a reflection of the person's own hopes. Those who thought Obamacare was a good idea want to be vindicated, and they're joined by those, like me, who had their doubts about this particular format for health reform but nonetheless want things to go well for America, so we're eager to see signs in that direction. On the other side, many are eager for signs that costs are rising and the nation is getting sicker. Since it's still so early, the tea leaves inevitably tell you what you were expecting to see. For the optimists, there's the fact the share of people covered by health insurance has risen, since Obamacare passed (after falling for years before that), and health premiums have been rising more slowly than before. For the pessimists, there are the problems the website had in its early days, and anecdotes of insurers deciding not to extend previous policies.
I think there are two huge measures, one related to cost and the other to health, that will tell us if this is a success or failure, and it's still too early to have good data on either.
(1) Before Obamacare, US per capita health spending rose much faster, on average, than was the case in more socialized systems. The result of years of that uncommonly rapid inflation is that we spent around 50% more, per capita, on healthcare than any other country, and about twice as much as was typical for an advanced nation. Healthcare inflation will inevitably continue, but the sign of success is if our inflation rate no longer exceeds what is typical among other advanced nations or, preferably, that we actually have a lower rate of inflation than normal, so that our costs move back towards the pack.
(2) Before Obamacare, our public health stats were mediocre by first-world standards -- typically putting us somewhere between tenth and fiftieth best in the world in major measures of public health, depending on which factor you looked at. For example, we're 31st as measured by lifetime maternal death risk, with roughly similar rankings for infant and childhood mortality, life expectancy, etc. And we'd been sliding for years -- half a century ago, our public health situation had been the envy of the world, but we've since been passed by a few dozen of our peers. Success for Obamacare would be to halt that slide and, preferably, to reverse it, so that we start clawing our way back up the rankings.
As I suggested, it's too early to have much data about that. But, in Massachusetts, a nearly identical reform has been in place for quite a while, thanks in part to Mitt Romney. So, we have a possible preview. And that preview is hopeful. The percentage of people covered by health insurance in Massachusetts did, in fact, climb pretty substantially. The dire warnings of various negative side effects failed to materialize. Most encouragingly, a recent report says there's been a sharp drop in mortality:
http://www.nytimes.com/2014/05/06/h...massachusetts-after-health-care-overhaul.html
That study is particularly convincing, because it controls for demographics -- showing a drop in mortality in Massachusetts relative to demographically paired counties that didn't get healthcare reform. It's all the more impressive since the Massachusetts data tracked closely to the control group for those over 65 -- a demographic that already had socialized medicine nationally. That makes it less likely that some other factor than healthcare reform caused the relative improvement in Massachusetts. The improvement would work out to saving about 17,000 lives per year, at the national level (presumably with comparably large improvements in quality of life). You can think of a life savings of that magnitude as being like stopping a 9/11 magnitude attack every other month throughout the year.
I think there are two huge measures, one related to cost and the other to health, that will tell us if this is a success or failure, and it's still too early to have good data on either.
(1) Before Obamacare, US per capita health spending rose much faster, on average, than was the case in more socialized systems. The result of years of that uncommonly rapid inflation is that we spent around 50% more, per capita, on healthcare than any other country, and about twice as much as was typical for an advanced nation. Healthcare inflation will inevitably continue, but the sign of success is if our inflation rate no longer exceeds what is typical among other advanced nations or, preferably, that we actually have a lower rate of inflation than normal, so that our costs move back towards the pack.
(2) Before Obamacare, our public health stats were mediocre by first-world standards -- typically putting us somewhere between tenth and fiftieth best in the world in major measures of public health, depending on which factor you looked at. For example, we're 31st as measured by lifetime maternal death risk, with roughly similar rankings for infant and childhood mortality, life expectancy, etc. And we'd been sliding for years -- half a century ago, our public health situation had been the envy of the world, but we've since been passed by a few dozen of our peers. Success for Obamacare would be to halt that slide and, preferably, to reverse it, so that we start clawing our way back up the rankings.
As I suggested, it's too early to have much data about that. But, in Massachusetts, a nearly identical reform has been in place for quite a while, thanks in part to Mitt Romney. So, we have a possible preview. And that preview is hopeful. The percentage of people covered by health insurance in Massachusetts did, in fact, climb pretty substantially. The dire warnings of various negative side effects failed to materialize. Most encouragingly, a recent report says there's been a sharp drop in mortality:
http://www.nytimes.com/2014/05/06/h...massachusetts-after-health-care-overhaul.html
That study is particularly convincing, because it controls for demographics -- showing a drop in mortality in Massachusetts relative to demographically paired counties that didn't get healthcare reform. It's all the more impressive since the Massachusetts data tracked closely to the control group for those over 65 -- a demographic that already had socialized medicine nationally. That makes it less likely that some other factor than healthcare reform caused the relative improvement in Massachusetts. The improvement would work out to saving about 17,000 lives per year, at the national level (presumably with comparably large improvements in quality of life). You can think of a life savings of that magnitude as being like stopping a 9/11 magnitude attack every other month throughout the year.
Last edited: