New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Suggested Reading...

http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/11...17145&creative=399373&creativeASIN=1118094514

"Why do so many Republicans believe man-made climate change is a hoax? The two most common explanations are that the deniers are uninformed or that they have been bought off by corporate money. Bestselling author Chris Mooney isn't buying either of those arguments. In fact, as he points out, the better educated a conservative is, the more likely he is to dismiss climate change concerns. How can that be?

Part of the answer lies with motivated reasoning—the psychological phenomenon of preferring only evidence that backs up your belief—but in The Republican Brain, Mooney explains that is just the tip of the cognitive iceberg. There is a growing body of evidence that conservatives and liberals don't just have differing ideologies; they have different psychologies. How could the rejection of mainstream science be growing among Republicans, along with the denial of expert consensus on the economy, American history, foreign policy, and much more? Why won't Republicans accept things that most experts agree on? Why are they constantly fighting against the facts? Increasingly, the answer appears to be: it's just part of who they are.

Mooney explores brain scans, polls, and psychology experiments to explain why conservatives today believe more wrong things; appear more likely than Democrats to oppose new ideas; are less likely to change their beliefs in the face of new facts; and sometimes respond to compelling evidence by doubling down on their current beliefs.

The answer begins with some measurable personality traits that strongly correspond with political preferences. For instance, people more wedded to certainty tend to become conservatives; people craving novelty, liberals. Surprisingly, openness to new experiences and fastidiousness are better predictors of political preference than income or education. If you like to keep your house neat and see the world in a relatively black and white way, you're probably going to vote Republican. If you've recently moved to a big city to see what else life has to offer, you're probably going to vote Democrat. These basic differences in openness and curiosity, Mooney argues, fuel an "expertise gap" between left and right that explains much of the battle today over what is true.

Being a good liberal, Mooney also has to explore the implications of these findings for Democrats as well. Are they really wishy-washy flip-floppers? Well, sometimes. Can't they be just as dogmatic about issues close to their hearts, like autism and vaccines, or nuclear power? His research leads to some surprising conclusions.

While the evolutionary advantages of both liberal and conservative psychologies seem obvious, clashes between them in modern life have led to a crisis in our politics. A significant chunk of the electorate, it seems, will never accept the facts as they are, no matter how strong the evidence. Understanding the psychology of the left and the right, Mooney argues, should therefore fundamentally alter the way we approach the he-said-he-said of public debates.

Certain to spark discussion and debate, The Republican Brain also promises to add to the lengthy list of persuasive scientific findings that Republicans reject and deny. "

And thus we form the groups we do because that is who we are instinctively, not rationally. Julian Jaynes wonderful book "The Origin of Consciousness and the bicameral mind" brought up a similar thesis a long time ago in that our brains are patterned in ways that we cannot really escape. The key is understanding which type of brain best suits an ever changing, mordern world filled with risk, reward and change, lots of change. For this simple reason, modern conservatism is likely to remain regardless of the popularity of its tenets. There will always be a sub-section of us that think in a certain way. But does the new world filled with instant information and global interaction support an insular view of life or an open view of life?

I think you know which way I lean. How about you?
 
http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/11...17145&creative=399373&creativeASIN=1118094514

"Why do so many Republicans believe man-made climate change is a hoax? The two most common explanations are that the deniers are uninformed or that they have been bought off by corporate money. Bestselling author Chris Mooney isn't buying either of those arguments. In fact, as he points out, the better educated a conservative is, the more likely he is to dismiss climate change concerns. How can that be?

Part of the answer lies with motivated reasoning—the psychological phenomenon of preferring only evidence that backs up your belief—but in The Republican Brain, Mooney explains that is just the tip of the cognitive iceberg. There is a growing body of evidence that conservatives and liberals don't just have differing ideologies; they have different psychologies. How could the rejection of mainstream science be growing among Republicans, along with the denial of expert consensus on the economy, American history, foreign policy, and much more? Why won't Republicans accept things that most experts agree on? Why are they constantly fighting against the facts? Increasingly, the answer appears to be: it's just part of who they are.

Mooney explores brain scans, polls, and psychology experiments to explain why conservatives today believe more wrong things; appear more likely than Democrats to oppose new ideas; are less likely to change their beliefs in the face of new facts; and sometimes respond to compelling evidence by doubling down on their current beliefs.

The answer begins with some measurable personality traits that strongly correspond with political preferences. For instance, people more wedded to certainty tend to become conservatives; people craving novelty, liberals. Surprisingly, openness to new experiences and fastidiousness are better predictors of political preference than income or education. If you like to keep your house neat and see the world in a relatively black and white way, you're probably going to vote Republican. If you've recently moved to a big city to see what else life has to offer, you're probably going to vote Democrat. These basic differences in openness and curiosity, Mooney argues, fuel an "expertise gap" between left and right that explains much of the battle today over what is true.

Being a good liberal, Mooney also has to explore the implications of these findings for Democrats as well. Are they really wishy-washy flip-floppers? Well, sometimes. Can't they be just as dogmatic about issues close to their hearts, like autism and vaccines, or nuclear power? His research leads to some surprising conclusions.

While the evolutionary advantages of both liberal and conservative psychologies seem obvious, clashes between them in modern life have led to a crisis in our politics. A significant chunk of the electorate, it seems, will never accept the facts as they are, no matter how strong the evidence. Understanding the psychology of the left and the right, Mooney argues, should therefore fundamentally alter the way we approach the he-said-he-said of public debates.

Certain to spark discussion and debate, The Republican Brain also promises to add to the lengthy list of persuasive scientific findings that Republicans reject and deny. "

And thus we form the groups we do because that is who we are instinctively, not rationally. Julian Jaynes wonderful book "The Origin of Consciousness and the bicameral mind" brought up a similar thesis a long time ago in that our brains are patterned in ways that we cannot really escape. The key is understanding which type of brain best suits an ever changing, mordern world filled with risk, reward and change, lots of change. For this simple reason, modern conservatism is likely to remain regardless of the popularity of its tenets. There will always be a sub-section of us that think in a certain way. But does the new world filled with instant information and global interaction support an insular view of life or an open view of life?

I think you know which way I lean. How about you?

Mr. Wooli,

It's alway funny to see how liberal twist themselves into knots to explain why they are alway on the fringe of American thought.
 
It is not a man made hoax, not a hoax nor is it man made...but with over 6 billion people and the fact that we are going to have to put an end to processed foods, even tho so tasty...we are going to need longer growing season... Thus theneed for warmer temperature, so there fore it is not a man made hoax not even man made...so there...food for thought. But I am sure lefty wants agenda and nothing else...see reply below.
 
I've noticed a huge difference between liberals and conservatives when it comes to how their brains work. To put it bluntly, liberals are more open-minded and honest about their beliefs, while conservatives are more dogmatic and more likely to lie even to themselves.

I'd call myself a liberal, but my views differ from those of a typical liberal on a number of major topics, so I've had a lot of experience arguing issues with people on both sides of the aisle. What I've noticed is that conservatives are almost impossible to budge on any issue, or even to get to accommodate exceptions or nuances within their position. If anything, this inflexibility and dogmatism gets worse the more educated they are. With liberals, by comparison, a well-constructed, well-informed argument will often result in at least a little movement. And the more educated the liberal, the more open he's likely to be to honestly considering the flaws within his position.

Some of the topics I find myself arguing about with liberals include: (1) how important a factor Obama's race is in conservative hatred for him (I think it's a minor factor for most conservatives), (2) whether vaccines cause autism and whether kids should be getting them, (3) whether the government should be encouraging more use of nuclear power, (4) whether the government should be subsidizing solar and wind power, (5) whether the government should mandate mpg standards, (6) whether race-based affirmative action is a productive policy, (7) whether we should have invaded Afghanistan, (8) how successful gun control would be at saving lives, (8) whether NAFTA and the WTO were good or bad for the economy, (9) the proper form of multiculturalism in society, (10) standardized testing in education, and (11) GM crops. On all of those topics I've had wonderfully productive debates with liberals.... debates that resulted in meaningful changes in my opinions and those of the other parties.

That's just so different from my discussions with conservatives. In a few cases, when talking with smart conservatives, my own positions have changed, at least a bit, to accommodate new data they exposed me to or new ways of thinking of things that I hadn't thought of before. In fact, on some of those issues where I differ with a lot of liberals, it's due to earlier shifts in my position in response to good points raised by conservatives. But in those debates with conservatives, the open-mindedness is almost never mutual. They seem to have absolutely no interest in the chance of learning and changing themselves, only in teaching and changing others. When they acquire a new piece of information, which contradicts their theory, they immediately try to figure out how to invalidate it, without any honest effort to consider whether the contradiction is due to a flaw in the theory, not a flaw in the fact.

The amazing thing is how greater intellectual capacity doesn't help conservatives to evolve, the way it does liberals. Among conservatives, the greater the intellect, the greater the vigor they bring to the mental gymnastics of trying to reason around any data or argument that could undermine the position they started with. It becomes a matter of impressive intellectual gamesmanship in defense of the theory, and never a matter of looking back at the theory to see if it actually deserves to be defended.

I guess it's not quite as hopeless as that. Long-term, after all, the liberals have been winning. A position that would have been radically liberal 100 years ago (women should have the right to vote) is commonplace now. Few people argue in favor of racial segregation any more, or anti-miscegenation laws, etc. And economically the centrist position is far to the left of where it was before the New Deal. More recently, you can also see the progress in the form of ending discrimination against gays, which is happening much quicker than most of us predicted. With that kind of big-picture march to the left, conservatives must not be nearly as inflexible as they can seem in day-to-day interactions. Or maybe it's just generational turnover, so that even if you can't convince a conservative, you can at least win over his kids and grandkids.
 
Romney has already surrendered on Climate Change...the Deniers have no "hero" this year.

:)



“I don’t speak for the scientific community, of course,’’ (Mitt) Romney said. “But I believe the world’s getting warmer. I can’t prove that, but I believe based on what I read that the world is getting warmer. And number two, I believe that humans contribute to that … so I think it’s important for us to reduce our emissions of pollutants and greenhouse gases that may well be significant contributors to the climate change and the global warming that you’re seeing."



http://articles.boston.com/2011-06-04/news/29685848_1_global-warming-climate-change-greenhouse-gases
 
http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/11...17145&creative=399373&creativeASIN=1118094514

"Why do so many Republicans believe man-made climate change is a hoax? The two most common explanations are that the deniers are uninformed or that they have been bought off by corporate money. Bestselling author Chris Mooney isn't buying either of those arguments. In fact, as he points out, the better educated a conservative is, the more likely he is to dismiss climate change concerns. How can that be?

Part of the answer lies with motivated reasoning—the psychological phenomenon of preferring only evidence that backs up your belief—but in The Republican Brain, Mooney explains that is just the tip of the cognitive iceberg. There is a growing body of evidence that conservatives and liberals don't just have differing ideologies; they have different psychologies. How could the rejection of mainstream science be growing among Republicans, along with the denial of expert consensus on the economy, American history, foreign policy, and much more? Why won't Republicans accept things that most experts agree on? Why are they constantly fighting against the facts? Increasingly, the answer appears to be: it's just part of who they are.

Mooney explores brain scans, polls, and psychology experiments to explain why conservatives today believe more wrong things; appear more likely than Democrats to oppose new ideas; are less likely to change their beliefs in the face of new facts; and sometimes respond to compelling evidence by doubling down on their current beliefs.

The answer begins with some measurable personality traits that strongly correspond with political preferences. For instance, people more wedded to certainty tend to become conservatives; people craving novelty, liberals. Surprisingly, openness to new experiences and fastidiousness are better predictors of political preference than income or education. If you like to keep your house neat and see the world in a relatively black and white way, you're probably going to vote Republican. If you've recently moved to a big city to see what else life has to offer, you're probably going to vote Democrat. These basic differences in openness and curiosity, Mooney argues, fuel an "expertise gap" between left and right that explains much of the battle today over what is true.

Being a good liberal, Mooney also has to explore the implications of these findings for Democrats as well. Are they really wishy-washy flip-floppers? Well, sometimes. Can't they be just as dogmatic about issues close to their hearts, like autism and vaccines, or nuclear power? His research leads to some surprising conclusions.

While the evolutionary advantages of both liberal and conservative psychologies seem obvious, clashes between them in modern life have led to a crisis in our politics. A significant chunk of the electorate, it seems, will never accept the facts as they are, no matter how strong the evidence. Understanding the psychology of the left and the right, Mooney argues, should therefore fundamentally alter the way we approach the he-said-he-said of public debates.

Certain to spark discussion and debate, The Republican Brain also promises to add to the lengthy list of persuasive scientific findings that Republicans reject and deny. "

And thus we form the groups we do because that is who we are instinctively, not rationally. Julian Jaynes wonderful book "The Origin of Consciousness and the bicameral mind" brought up a similar thesis a long time ago in that our brains are patterned in ways that we cannot really escape. The key is understanding which type of brain best suits an ever changing, mordern world filled with risk, reward and change, lots of change. For this simple reason, modern conservatism is likely to remain regardless of the popularity of its tenets. There will always be a sub-section of us that think in a certain way. But does the new world filled with instant information and global interaction support an insular view of life or an open view of life?

I think you know which way I lean. How about you?

I really like that the linked writer appears to put his analysis in the context of "Republicans" vs. "Democrats", as opposed to the more common screedery around "conservatives" vs. "liberals".

We know exactly who're Republicans and who're Democrats. These are objective descriptors. Conservatives and liberals on the other hand, are individual matters of perspective and opinion, rendering virtually any other person's analysis or opinion as to the contast between them, useless to me.

As to the difference between those who choose to indentify as Republicans or choose to identify as Democrats?....who knows whether this writer's point-by-points are on point or not...but, one thing we (Democrats) need to acknowledge and accept, is that there IS a profound difference. And therefore, some Democrats shouldn't be as taken aback as some Democrats are, about the fact that Obama and the current Democratic Party aren't taking the tack of simply trying to out-Limbaugh, or out-Rove, or out-GOP the GOP at their own games. Since GOPs and Dems are so different from one another, much of what works for one, doesn't work for the other.
 
I read it. It was a fine amalgam of self-congratulation and derisive generalization of "the other". Further, it makes no sense.

The fact that a conservative can be educated would indicate that he is capable of digesting thoughts and ideas, discarding some in favor of others, weighing possibilities and forming reasoned judgments based on persuasiveness of fact. Adherence to hardwired dogma doesn't lend itself to education, and yet there are many, many very well-educated conservatives. How could this be if their psychology precludes open consideration of alternative facts?

It is my experience that the lefty is as fully capable of doctrinaire rigidity as is the conservative. One must seek out individuals who are reasonable and who seek discussion in good faith. There are lots of great folks out there in both camps.
 
I read it. It was a fine amalgam of self-congratulation and derisive generalization of "the other". Further, it makes no sense.

The fact that a conservative can be educated would indicate that he is capable of digesting thoughts and ideas, discarding some in favor of others, weighing possibilities and forming reasoned judgments based on persuasiveness of fact. Adherence to hardwired dogma doesn't lend itself to education, and yet there are many, many very well-educated conservatives. How could this be if their psychology precludes open consideration of alternative facts?

It is my experience that the lefty is as fully capable of doctrinaire rigidity as is the conservative. One must seek out individuals who are reasonable and who seek discussion in good faith. There are lots of great folks out there in both camps.

Well...I've not read the book, but I think your point is well taken in terms of individuals. For instance from my perspective as a Democrat, I can think of a variety of Republicans for whom I have tremendous respect. And, I'm not talking "they're not so bad". I'm talking Republicans who actually follow through on the positive promises suggested by Republicanism.

As a half-of-America group though, I think Republicans have a fundamental problem. Their core constituency - by definition (capital vs. labor) is inherently smaller than the Democrats'. So, in order to form coalitions sufficient to win elections, Republicans have to cobble together a rather inconvenient and perhaps incoherent mish-mash. For instance, the fellow whose #1 issue is his obsession with undocumented immigration, will sign on to the GOP, even as he's not a member of their core constituency. And heck...the same thing happens with the Democrats, but they don't need to make quite the reaches the Republicans do.
 
I think that's somewhat accurate regarding cobbled-together constituencies. I think conservatives are growing fewer (not rightists, mind you, but conservatives).

I also think that the larger issue top posted (and expounded upon by Arkady) conflates the individual with the group...much as it does the personal/private with the public. For example, I am a very conservative Christian with an admitted heavily traditionalist bent. Many would take that and drive hard toward the above conclusion. However, I'm also a chemist, a science buff, a history addict, and lean heavily libertarian in terms of preferred social order. Assumptions and extrapolations don't work here. I've never even tried marijuana and would punish my kids into the Stone Age if they got a whiff of it - yet I favor it's legalization. So it goes...

I'm neither special nor unique. People like me are inconvenient to the narrative. Conservatives are supposed to be comparatively stupid, ambling about with knuckles scraping as we walk...just waiting to unveil the latest bigotry or some new anti-science superstition. Politically, we've made too great a litmus test of specific issues as definitive indicator or intellect (let alone basic decency).
 
That was a brilliant post. I could not agree with you more. On the nuclear issue, I was against it like every good liberal up until I met and knew a safety officer for HydroQuebec who was in France to study their nuclear plants. He was so intelligent and spent so much time teaching me how it all fits that I realized I had made a decision without all the facts. Now, the Fukishima plant changes everything but to your point, a new fact happens and we adapt. Conservatives stick to their guns no matter what. Principle means so much to them. Keep driving over the cliff no matter what happens...
 
I'm neither special nor unique. People like me are inconvenient to the narrative. Conservatives are supposed to be comparatively stupid, ambling about with knuckles scraping as we walk...just waiting to unveil the latest bigotry or some new anti-science superstition. Politically, we've made too great a litmus test of specific issues as definitive indicator or intellect (let alone basic decency).

Conservatives aren't stupid. It is the rabble that must be cobbled together by the Republican Party in order to win elections who are stupid. They may call themselves "conservatives", but they wouldn't know conservatism if it slapped them in the face. They are obsessed with fear and oppressed by ignorance -- and I am old enough to remember when they (at least, the ones in the Southeast) called themselves Democrats, rather than "conservatives" or Republicans.
 
That was a brilliant post. I could not agree with you more. On the nuclear issue, I was against it like every good liberal up until I met and knew a safety officer for HydroQuebec who was in France to study their nuclear plants. He was so intelligent and spent so much time teaching me how it all fits that I realized I had made a decision without all the facts. Now, the Fukishima plant changes everything but to your point, a new fact happens and we adapt. Conservatives stick to their guns no matter what. Principle means so much to them. Keep driving over the cliff no matter what happens...

I live close to San Onofre, currently shut down on account of leaks, so I'm going to be a bit harder to convince than most.
 
I've noticed a huge difference between liberals and conservatives when it comes to how their brains work. To put it bluntly, liberals are more open-minded and honest about their beliefs, while conservatives are more dogmatic and more likely to lie even to themselves.

I'd call myself a liberal, but my views differ from those of a typical liberal on a number of major topics, so I've had a lot of experience arguing issues with people on both sides of the aisle. What I've noticed is that conservatives are almost impossible to budge on any issue, or even to get to accommodate exceptions or nuances within their position. If anything, this inflexibility and dogmatism gets worse the more educated they are. With liberals, by comparison, a well-constructed, well-informed argument will often result in at least a little movement. And the more educated the liberal, the more open he's likely to be to honestly considering the flaws within his position.

Some of the topics I find myself arguing about with liberals include: (1) how important a factor Obama's race is in conservative hatred for him (I think it's a minor factor for most conservatives), (2) whether vaccines cause autism and whether kids should be getting them, (3) whether the government should be encouraging more use of nuclear power, (4) whether the government should be subsidizing solar and wind power, (5) whether the government should mandate mpg standards, (6) whether race-based affirmative action is a productive policy, (7) whether we should have invaded Afghanistan, (8) how successful gun control would be at saving lives, (8) whether NAFTA and the WTO were good or bad for the economy, (9) the proper form of multiculturalism in society, (10) standardized testing in education, and (11) GM crops. On all of those topics I've had wonderfully productive debates with liberals.... debates that resulted in meaningful changes in my opinions and those of the other parties.

That's just so different from my discussions with conservatives. In a few cases, when talking with smart conservatives, my own positions have changed, at least a bit, to accommodate new data they exposed me to or new ways of thinking of things that I hadn't thought of before. In fact, on some of those issues where I differ with a lot of liberals, it's due to earlier shifts in my position in response to good points raised by conservatives. But in those debates with conservatives, the open-mindedness is almost never mutual. They seem to have absolutely no interest in the chance of learning and changing themselves, only in teaching and changing others. When they acquire a new piece of information, which contradicts their theory, they immediately try to figure out how to invalidate it, without any honest effort to consider whether the contradiction is due to a flaw in the theory, not a flaw in the fact.

The amazing thing is how greater intellectual capacity doesn't help conservatives to evolve, the way it does liberals. Among conservatives, the greater the intellect, the greater the vigor they bring to the mental gymnastics of trying to reason around any data or argument that could undermine the position they started with. It becomes a matter of impressive intellectual gamesmanship in defense of the theory, and never a matter of looking back at the theory to see if it actually deserves to be defended.

I guess it's not quite as hopeless as that. Long-term, after all, the liberals have been winning. A position that would have been radically liberal 100 years ago (women should have the right to vote) is commonplace now. Few people argue in favor of racial segregation any more, or anti-miscegenation laws, etc. And economically the centrist position is far to the left of where it was before the New Deal. More recently, you can also see the progress in the form of ending discrimination against gays, which is happening much quicker than most of us predicted. With that kind of big-picture march to the left, conservatives must not be nearly as inflexible as they can seem in day-to-day interactions. Or maybe it's just generational turnover, so that even if you can't convince a conservative, you can at least win over his kids and grandkids.

Here is an article on the subject by the same author, and it poses some interesting questions:

Politically and strategically, meanwhile, the evidence presented here leaves liberals and progressives in a rather awkward situation. We like evidence—but evidence also suggests that politics doesn’t work in the way we want it to work, or think it should. We may be the children of the Enlightenment—convinced that you need good facts to make good policies—but that doesn’t mean this is equally true for all of humanity, or that it is as true of our political opponents as it is of us.

Nevertheless, this knowledge ought to be welcomed, for it offers a learning opportunity and, frankly, a better way of understanding politics and our opponents alike. For instance, it can help us see through the scientific-sounding arguments of someone like Rick Santorum, who has been talking a lot about climate science lately—if only in order to bash it.

On global warming, Santorum definitely has an argument, and he has “facts” to cite. And he is obviously intelligent and capable—but not, apparently, able to see past his ideological biases. Santorum’s argument ultimately comes down to a dismissal of climate science and climate scientists, and even the embrace of a conspiracy theory, one in which the scientists of the world are conspiring to subvert economic growth (yeah, right).
​

http://truth-out.org/index.php?opti...cated-conservatives-deny-science--and-reality

If logic, reason and reality aren't going to work, what options do we have?
 
We have the age old solution of: Just tell them to shut the f up or we will kick their asses. At some point, somebody has to tell the guy at the helm that we are about to hit a
censored.gif
censored.gif
censored.gif
censored.gif
ing iceberg.
 
Back
Top