New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Suggested Reading...

Hey, Mr. Open Minded. . .

Have you read "Woodrow Wilson and the Roots of Modern Liberalism?"

Of course not. Because you never step outside your comfort zone like a good little open minded liberal.

Ask me if I've ever read anything from Wilson, Lippmann, Bernays, Alinsky, etc.
 
I think I looked it up, costs like 100 bucks or something like that...you got a cheap copy you can lend me so I can figure out how Hegel and Wilson destroyed paradise?
 
I think I looked it up, costs like 100 bucks or something like that...you got a cheap copy you can lend me so I can figure out how Hegel and Wilson destroyed paradise?

Yeah. I think you told me that before. Then I think I told you I bought a used paperback for less than $30 and you can do the same. I write in the margins. You can't have my copy. There. Now we're all caught up again to today.
 
It's Friday night and you're drunk.

Ordinarily not a bad thing. The thing that makes it bad is the fact that it's Friday night, you're drunk, . .and you're posting here.
 
I've noticed a huge difference between liberals and conservatives when it comes to how their brains work. To put it bluntly, liberals are more open-minded and honest about their beliefs, while conservatives are more dogmatic and more likely to lie even to themselves.

I'd call myself a liberal, but my views differ from those of a typical liberal on a number of major topics, so I've had a lot of experience arguing issues with people on both sides of the aisle. What I've noticed is that conservatives are almost impossible to budge on any issue, or even to get to accommodate exceptions or nuances within their position. If anything, this inflexibility and dogmatism gets worse the more educated they are. With liberals, by comparison, a well-constructed, well-informed argument will often result in at least a little movement. And the more educated the liberal, the more open he's likely to be to honestly considering the flaws within his position.

Some of the topics I find myself arguing about with liberals include: (1) how important a factor Obama's race is in conservative hatred for him (I think it's a minor factor for most conservatives), (2) whether vaccines cause autism and whether kids should be getting them, (3) whether the government should be encouraging more use of nuclear power, (4) whether the government should be subsidizing solar and wind power, (5) whether the government should mandate mpg standards, (6) whether race-based affirmative action is a productive policy, (7) whether we should have invaded Afghanistan, (8) how successful gun control would be at saving lives, (8) whether NAFTA and the WTO were good or bad for the economy, (9) the proper form of multiculturalism in society, (10) standardized testing in education, and (11) GM crops. On all of those topics I've had wonderfully productive debates with liberals.... debates that resulted in meaningful changes in my opinions and those of the other parties.

That's just so different from my discussions with conservatives. In a few cases, when talking with smart conservatives, my own positions have changed, at least a bit, to accommodate new data they exposed me to or new ways of thinking of things that I hadn't thought of before. In fact, on some of those issues where I differ with a lot of liberals, it's due to earlier shifts in my position in response to good points raised by conservatives. But in those debates with conservatives, the open-mindedness is almost never mutual. They seem to have absolutely no interest in the chance of learning and changing themselves, only in teaching and changing others. When they acquire a new piece of information, which contradicts their theory, they immediately try to figure out how to invalidate it, without any honest effort to consider whether the contradiction is due to a flaw in the theory, not a flaw in the fact.

The amazing thing is how greater intellectual capacity doesn't help conservatives to evolve, the way it does liberals. Among conservatives, the greater the intellect, the greater the vigor they bring to the mental gymnastics of trying to reason around any data or argument that could undermine the position they started with. It becomes a matter of impressive intellectual gamesmanship in defense of the theory, and never a matter of looking back at the theory to see if it actually deserves to be defended.

I guess it's not quite as hopeless as that. Long-term, after all, the liberals have been winning. A position that would have been radically liberal 100 years ago (women should have the right to vote) is commonplace now. Few people argue in favor of racial segregation any more, or anti-miscegenation laws, etc. And economically the centrist position is far to the left of where it was before the New Deal. More recently, you can also see the progress in the form of ending discrimination against gays, which is happening much quicker than most of us predicted. With that kind of big-picture march to the left, conservatives must not be nearly as inflexible as they can seem in day-to-day interactions. Or maybe it's just generational turnover, so that even if you can't convince a conservative, you can at least win over his kids and grandkids.

Why is a liberal ranting about racism on a thread about global warming? tell you what ...let start a project to end racism, you ultra lefty and I, of the party that wants an accoutant to be President/conservative . How about it?
 
Interesting. I may have to read this one.

I've noticed the closed minded dogmatism over and over again amongst my conservative friends and here in PJ.

The right wing, particularly the hard right, Limbaugh loony, Fox News hard right, is definantly impervious to facts.

You see it over and over again. Argue your case with facts and references and they just shout the same drivel louder. Sometimes it gets to the point where you feel like you're talking to a six year old.
 
I'm perfectly willing to listen to a conservative argument that is made resonably and supported by facts.

We don't see that very often. And it's a rarity from conservative poster here on PJ.
 
I'm perfectly willing to listen to a conservative argument that is made resonably and supported by facts.

We don't see that very often. And it's a rarity from conservative poster here on PJ.

I changed my mind on cap-and-trade. Conservatives made a sound argument, and cap-and-trade worked, so I'm sold.
 
Have you even read any Sunstein? You'd love it. His stuff is filled with condescending jargon about how stupid Americans are and how our internal "Homer Simpson" needs to be guided to prevent hurting himself and others.

Right up your alley.
 
What topic has a conservative changed your mind on?

Conservatives convinced President Obama that he wouldn't get health-care reform passed without an individual mandate to purchase private market insurance. I never fell for that argument myself. I would have preferred the "public option" plan. Unfortunately the insurance lobby has a great deal of clout on Capitol Hill, so it was the best compromise available.

Equally unfortunate that conservative "principles" change with the breeze.
 
I've noticed a huge difference between liberals and conservatives when it comes to how their brains work. To put it bluntly, liberals are more open-minded and honest about their beliefs, while conservatives are more dogmatic and more likely to lie even to themselves.

I'd call myself a liberal, but my views differ from those of a typical liberal on a number of major topics, so I've had a lot of experience arguing issues with people on both sides of the aisle. What I've noticed is that conservatives are almost impossible to budge on any issue, or even to get to accommodate exceptions or nuances within their position. If anything, this inflexibility and dogmatism gets worse the more educated they are. With liberals, by comparison, a well-constructed, well-informed argument will often result in at least a little movement. And the more educated the liberal, the more open he's likely to be to honestly considering the flaws within his position.

Some of the topics I find myself arguing about with liberals include: (1) how important a factor Obama's race is in conservative hatred for him (I think it's a minor factor for most conservatives), (2) whether vaccines cause autism and whether kids should be getting them, (3) whether the government should be encouraging more use of nuclear power, (4) whether the government should be subsidizing solar and wind power, (5) whether the government should mandate mpg standards, (6) whether race-based affirmative action is a productive policy, (7) whether we should have invaded Afghanistan, (8) how successful gun control would be at saving lives, (8) whether NAFTA and the WTO were good or bad for the economy, (9) the proper form of multiculturalism in society, (10) standardized testing in education, and (11) GM crops. On all of those topics I've had wonderfully productive debates with liberals.... debates that resulted in meaningful changes in my opinions and those of the other parties.

That's just so different from my discussions with conservatives. In a few cases, when talking with smart conservatives, my own positions have changed, at least a bit, to accommodate new data they exposed me to or new ways of thinking of things that I hadn't thought of before. In fact, on some of those issues where I differ with a lot of liberals, it's due to earlier shifts in my position in response to good points raised by conservatives. But in those debates with conservatives, the open-mindedness is almost never mutual. They seem to have absolutely no interest in the chance of learning and changing themselves, only in teaching and changing others. When they acquire a new piece of information, which contradicts their theory, they immediately try to figure out how to invalidate it, without any honest effort to consider whether the contradiction is due to a flaw in the theory, not a flaw in the fact.

The amazing thing is how greater intellectual capacity doesn't help conservatives to evolve, the way it does liberals. Among conservatives, the greater the intellect, the greater the vigor they bring to the mental gymnastics of trying to reason around any data or argument that could undermine the position they started with. It becomes a matter of impressive intellectual gamesmanship in defense of the theory, and never a matter of looking back at the theory to see if it actually deserves to be defended.

I guess it's not quite as hopeless as that. Long-term, after all, the liberals have been winning. A position that would have been radically liberal 100 years ago (women should have the right to vote) is commonplace now. Few people argue in favor of racial segregation any more, or anti-miscegenation laws, etc. And economically the centrist position is far to the left of where it was before the New Deal. More recently, you can also see the progress in the form of ending discrimination against gays, which is happening much quicker than most of us predicted. With that kind of big-picture march to the left, conservatives must not be nearly as inflexible as they can seem in day-to-day interactions. Or maybe it's just generational turnover, so that even if you can't convince a conservative, you can at least win over his kids and grandkids.

Don't break your arm patting yourself on the back there Arkady. As for liberal policies "winning" - yeah, just look how well they are working in Europe right now.
 
No one in their right mind denies that the climate is changing. But the conservatives are at least open minded enough to entertain the possibility that it is out of our control. The planet warmed in the middle ages and we weren't burning fossil fuels then and there was only a fraction of the number of people that there are now. Even if we accept that man is contributing some to it, to tie one hand behind our backs (economically speaking) while the developing nations that keep taking our jobs and productive capacity to pursue some possibly fruitless strategy to arrest something that is likely not controllable is simply a pie in the sky leftist pipe dream. All we get for our efforts is Solyndra, ethanol driving up food prices, exploding Volts and more lost jobs to China, India and Brazil...
 
We could bring those jobs back home, if only we could convince the massive and powerful labor unions to accept $1.00 per hour wages.

Silly Liberals!
 
We could bring those jobs back home, if only we could convince the massive and powerful labor unions to accept $1.00 per hour wages.

Silly Liberals!

Or give the federal government more power to control the economy (and we know how well that works).
 
Well, you might be but Arkady isn't.

So I'll ask you the same question: On what issue has a conservative changed your mind?
 
Back
Top