New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Supreme Coiurt issues

degsme

Council Member
Ok so its somewhat unfortunate that the conservatives on this board have been unable to emotionally cope with losing the election without resorting to uncivil behaviour - but there are still some issues that would be interesting to get feedback from on from both sides of the issue

Specifically the Supreme Court of the USA and what you see changing in the next 4 years

its pretty clear that Ginsburg is likely to retire. Her health is not the best and while Holmes and Stevens both made it to 90 as justices - I don't think Ginsburg is likely to risk getting replaced by a conservative. So if her health doesn't fail, I predict she will retire after the 2015 court session

The real question is what happens with one of The Five:
  • Roberts is 57. So the likelihood of death or disability is low but non-zero. One of my good friends had his first heart attack at age 51. No evidence that I know of that Roberts has a family history of medical problems, but the actuarial tables do apply http://www.ssa.gov/OACT/STATS/table4c6.html He basically has 1% chance of dying any year during the next 4 years. So that's 0.99[sup]3.5[/sup] = 4.5% chance
  • Scalia is now 76, so his is 5%/yr = 16.5% cummulative chance
  • Thomas is 64 so his is 1.6% = 5.5% cummulative chance (but it actually is higher given his health issues (Diabetes IIRC)
  • Kennedy is now 76, so his is the same as Scalias or a 16.5% cumulative chance
  • Alito is 62 so his is 1.4% = 5% cumulative chance.

Now this is using a 3.5 year death rate - because they would need to die with at least 6mo left in Obama's term to make it through the appointment process

So the total rate is .955 x .835 x .945 x .835 x .95 = 59.8%

That means that there is a 40.2% chance that ANY ONE of those men will die in the time period. And there is a higher chance of a disabling disease. That said they have access to the best medical and food choices available, so their survival rates are going to be higher than average, So we can armwave that as a push.

So there is a roughly 40% chance that Obama will get to nominate a replacement for one of the conservative justices in the court.


Hows that for dem apples?
 
Thomas and Scalia should be impeached. Scalia shows signs of mental instability, and Thomas definitely has conflict of interest issues.
 
Well I don't completely disagree with you, but the political cost of an impeachment is not worth it. Again 40%+ chance Obama gets to fix this.
 
Back
Top