New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Sweden

If you listen to conservative media, Europe has descended into a nightmare of violence as a result of being too hospitable to Muslims. This vision is offered up as a way to scare people into turning their backs on refugees, and in order to justify various policies like Muslim bans. The propaganda is supported by way of anecdotes: foreign news is filtered to select a handful of scary events for American consumption. But what does the bigger picture look like?

Well, the best statistic for comparison is the homicide rate, since it doesn't have as much of a definition issue as other stats like aggravated assault, meaning comparisons across countries tend to be meaningful. In 2015, the last year for which data is currently available, there were 103 murders in Sweden. That works out to a rate of 1.05/100k. Here in the US, our rate is 4.9. In fact, even the very best US state, New Hampshire, has a rate that's higher than the rate of Sweden.

Mother Jones put together some charts showing changes in Swedish crime rates. What you'll see is that the great Muslim conflagration just doesn't show up in the numbers:

blog_sweden_murder_1964_2014.jpg


blog_sweden_crime_against_persons_2008_2016_0.jpg

There are, of course, going to be isolated incidents and regional crime waves and gang wars from which to cherry pick a scary story for American consumption. But looking at the big picture, Sweden is enviably peaceful, at least by US standards.

You'll also hear conservatives run the same rhetorical gambit on Germany, but the result is similar. In Germany, the murder rate is far below what it is in the US, and the overall trend has been of improvement:

https://de.statista.com/statistik/d...rdopfer-in-deutschland-entwicklung-seit-1987/

There's a pretty obvious reason why the ethnicity and details of criminals in Sweden are no longer kept. The numbers were skyrocketing with middle-eastern immigrants committing crimes, so they simply stopped taking the data, to protect their ideology.

They can try to cover up the fact all they want. The truth is, they ARE doing a good humanitarian act, it just costs a price.

The question is, is it moral to impose that price onto a population even if they don't want it?
 
Do you see how you're playing along with the "argument by anecdote" strategy of the right-wing hatemongers? Yes, with millions upon millions of people, there will be incidents. And with enough resources thrown at it, there will be a successful operation to gather those incidents into a narrative for propaganda. But that doesn't show us the big picture. The big picture shows up in the statistics. And the statistics show Sweden remains FAR safer than the US, and that the overall trend since the early 90s, even as immigration has risen, has been for violent crime to fall.
welcome to "arks world" . . . were facts that refute the central thesis are labeled as "anecdotes" in attempt to deny reality.
 
If you listen to conservative media, Europe has descended into a nightmare of violence as a result of being too hospitable to Muslims. This vision is offered up as a way to scare people into turning their backs on refugees, and in order to justify various policies like Muslim bans. The propaganda is supported by way of anecdotes: foreign news is filtered to select a handful of scary events for American consumption. But what does the bigger picture look like?

Well, the best statistic for comparison is the homicide rate, since it doesn't have as much of a definition issue as other stats like aggravated assault, meaning comparisons across countries tend to be meaningful. In 2015, the last year for which data is currently available, there were 103 murders in Sweden. That works out to a rate of 1.05/100k. Here in the US, our rate is 4.9. In fact, even the very best US state, New Hampshire, has a rate that's higher than the rate of Sweden.

Mother Jones put together some charts showing changes in Swedish crime rates. What you'll see is that the great Muslim conflagration just doesn't show up in the numbers:

blog_sweden_murder_1964_2014.jpg


blog_sweden_crime_against_persons_2008_2016_0.jpg

There are, of course, going to be isolated incidents and regional crime waves and gang wars from which to cherry pick a scary story for American consumption. But looking at the big picture, Sweden is enviably peaceful, at least by US standards.

You'll also hear conservatives run the same rhetorical gambit on Germany, but the result is similar. In Germany, the murder rate is far below what it is in the US, and the overall trend has been of improvement:

https://de.statista.com/statistik/d...rdopfer-in-deutschland-entwicklung-seit-1987/
Shitistics.

You already know how you've tried to deceive. No sense in trying to convince you. You'll just say, "If you have any better data, please feel free to share it." As if you've built anything substantial with the dog shit presented. You made a pool of cat piss, called it a house, and challenged anybody to come up with a better house. But you don't even have a house. You have a puddle of cat piss.

And so the rest of this post is for everyone else not you.

If you are feeling particularly froggy and would like to join in exposing Arkady's lies then answer this:

HOW is Arkady's use of Sweden's national crime statistics relevant to the local crime spree of arson and destruction by Muslims? (Hint: Yes, it's a trick question.)

Bonus points if you can then answer WHY. Try listing his assumptions that lead directly to his conclusions without ever passing through any kind of scientific method.
 
welcome to "arks world" . . . were facts that refute the central thesis are labeled as "anecdotes" in attempt to deny reality.

It amazes me that we have prime examples of how Muslim immigrants affect the societies they infiltrate, and yet the left is dumb and blind to it
 
No. They don't appear to be obsessed with Muslim crime. You do, though.

I do? Funny, this is your thread. I didn't bring it up, you did.

Or are you implying that my attempts at rational discussion about it means that I am "obsessed"?

You may want to check your criteria and let me know what the rules for this subject are.
 
I do? Funny, this is your thread. I didn't bring it up, you did.

Or are you implying that my attempts at rational discussion about it means that I am "obsessed"?

You may want to check your criteria and let me know what the rules for this subject are.
If you'd care to discuss it rationally, that would be an excellent start. But, instead, what you want is to go anecdote hunting to support your prejudices. With a great big world out there and Google at your fingertips, I have no doubt you can find a steady chain of incidents to support your fear of Muslims -- or gingers, or left-handed people, or any other group you might care to become obsessively fearful of in the future. But anecdotes are worthless. Statistics give us the big picture. And, statistically, Sweden is a very safe place (at least by US standards).
 
If you'd care to discuss it rationally, that would be an excellent start. But, instead, what you want is to go anecdote hunting to support your prejudices. With a great big world out there and Google at your fingertips, I have no doubt you can find a steady chain of incidents to support your fear of Muslims -- or gingers, or left-handed people, or any other group you might care to become obsessively fearful of in the future. But anecdotes are worthless. Statistics give us the big picture. And, statistically, Sweden is a very safe place (at least by US standards).

Well sure. You can say that any incident is an anecdote. Fort Hood, the Miami Nightclub bombing, the Boston Marathon bombing, all can be considered anecdotes. However, string enough anecdotes together and you get a trend.

But sure, you can find any made up statistic and claim it the definitive truth. Like with your homicide data. If murder by Muslims was the only issue, then you might have a point. Just like in the US. Sure, the people the left sacrifices to allow Muslims free access is just a drop in the proverbial bucket, but they were Americans, whose safety is supposed to be our government's primary priority.
 
It amazes me that we have prime examples of how Muslim immigrants affect the societies they infiltrate, and yet the left is dumb and blind to it
this would be the same left which rants against evangelical conservatism, but applauds muslim extremism.

the modern era equivalent of the "self hating jew"?
 
Well sure. You can say that any incident is an anecdote. Fort Hood, the Miami Nightclub bombing, the Boston Marathon bombing, all can be considered anecdotes. However, string enough anecdotes together and you get a trend.

I can string anecdotes together all day long, but the length of the anecdote chain would just be evidence of the effort I was willing to put in gathering anecdotes.

If it helps, think of it in terms of an attack on some group you're more sympathetic to. For example, let's take US soldiers. I can string together a long list of examples of current and former US soldiers who have committed terrible acts. Micah Johnson, George Hennard, Michael McDermott, Robert Flores, Nidal Hasan, Wade Michael Page, Radcliffe Haughton, Aaron Alexis, Ivan Lopez-Lopes, Tim McVeigh, John Allen Mohammed, etc. At what point have I strung enough anecdotes together to get a trend?

The question is meaningless. Anecdotes don't make a trend. They're just anecdotes. To assess a question in a more meaningful way, we need statistics. Maybe US military personnel really are more likely to do horrible things than other people. Maybe Muslims are. Maybe not. Anecdotes won't resolve that one way or the other.

On the topic of immigration, I don't have good statistics about Muslim immigrants in particular. I have, however, seen statistics about immigrants in general. It turns out immigrants in general are less likely than the native population to commit violent crimes:

https://www.wsj.com/articles/the-mythical-connection-between-immigrants-and-crime-1436916798

It's possible the same isn't true in Sweden, since Swedish violent crime rates were so incredibly low that even a fairly peaceful immigrant group may still be relatively more violent than them. But here in the US, where the native population is world-famous for its violent tendencies, immigrants have tended to reduce our violence rates.
 
Last edited:
this would be the same left which rants against evangelical conservatism, but applauds muslim extremism.

the modern era equivalent of the "self hating jew"?
Which "left" applauds Muslim extremism, exactly? Seriously -- I know a huge number of lefties and never have heard a single one applaud Muslim extremism. Is it possible you're imagining this?
 
I'm not positive, but I think if ark every ran into a muslim who wanted to kill him over secularism, he might have an epiphany
I have a problem with anyone who wants to kill anyone else over an ideology. If I met up with a Christian or a Jew who wanted to kill me because of my secularism, I'd have a problem with that person, too. But wouldn't I have to be a complete bigot to jump from that to having a problem with all Christians or Jews?
 
I can string anecdotes together all day long, but the length of the anecdote chain would just be evidence of the effort I was willing to put in gathering anecdotes.

If it helps, think of it in terms of an attack on some group you're more sympathetic to. For example, let's take US soldiers. I can string together a long list of examples of current and former US soldiers who have committed terrible acts. Micah Johnson, George Hennard, Michael McDermott, Robert Flores, Nidal Hasan, Wade Michael Page, Radcliffe Haughton, Aaron Alexis, Ivan Lopez-Lopes, Tim McVeigh, John Allen Mohammed, etc. At what point have I strung enough anecdotes together to get a trend?

The question is meaningless. Anecdotes don't make a trend. They're just anecdotes. To assess a question in a more meaningful way, we need statistics. Maybe US military personnel really are more likely to do horrible things than other people. Maybe Muslims are. Maybe not. Anecdotes won't resolve that one way or the other.

On the topic of immigration, I don't have good statistics about Muslim immigrants in particular. I have, however, seen statistics about immigrants in general. It turns out immigrants in general are less likely than the native population to commit violent crimes:

https://www.wsj.com/articles/the-mythical-connection-between-immigrants-and-crime-1436916798

It's possible the same isn't true in Sweden, since Swedish violent crime rates were so incredibly low that even a fairly peaceful immigrant group may still be relatively more violent than them. But here in the US, where the native population is world-famous for its violent tendencies, immigrants have tended to reduce our violence rates.

Apparently the federal government considers it enough of a trend
I can string anecdotes together all day long, but the length of the anecdote chain would just be evidence of the effort I was willing to put in gathering anecdotes.

If it helps, think of it in terms of an attack on some group you're more sympathetic to. For example, let's take US soldiers. I can string together a long list of examples of current and former US soldiers who have committed terrible acts. Micah Johnson, George Hennard, Michael McDermott, Robert Flores, Nidal Hasan, Wade Michael Page, Radcliffe Haughton, Aaron Alexis, Ivan Lopez-Lopes, Tim McVeigh, John Allen Mohammed, etc. At what point have I strung enough anecdotes together to get a trend?

The question is meaningless. Anecdotes don't make a trend. They're just anecdotes. To assess a question in a more meaningful way, we need statistics. Maybe US military personnel really are more likely to do horrible things than other people. Maybe Muslims are. Maybe not. Anecdotes won't resolve that one way or the other.

On the topic of immigration, I don't have good statistics about Muslim immigrants in particular. I have, however, seen statistics about immigrants in general. It turns out immigrants in general are less likely than the native population to commit violent crimes:

https://www.wsj.com/articles/the-mythical-connection-between-immigrants-and-crime-1436916798

It's possible the same isn't true in Sweden, since Swedish violent crime rates were so incredibly low that even a fairly peaceful immigrant group may still be relatively more violent than them. But here in the US, where the native population is world-famous for its violent tendencies, immigrants have tended to reduce our violence rates.

Well, apparent rational dicussion isn't going to work here. So let me end with this, you are not the one in Germany, France, England, or Sweden looking at economic collapse and the loss of your culture.

Please have fun explaining to them how, statistically, they are so much better off importing all of these Muslim immigrants. I'm sure you can reason with those bigots.
 
you are not the one in Germany, France, England, or Sweden looking at economic collapse and the loss of your culture.
Yes. Nobody is. There's no sign of economic collapse or the loss of culture in Germany, France, England, or Sweden. Ironically, if you actually read German, French, or English papers (I don't speak Swedish, so I can't comment on that), they're fairly concerned about possible economic collapse and the loss of culture here in the US, after our national meltdown last November.
 
Back
Top