New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Syria

The rebels ! Those few who are Syrian come from the East. On the other side of a desert which cuts them off from the rest of Syria and contact with anywhere else. They are uneducated, poor and religious.

Most of the rebels are not Syrian but from 9 different 7 of which are religious fanatics factions backed by Saudi ...................... One man set this off Prince Bandar bin Sultan bin Abdul Aziz al-Saud, I have been aware of him for a long time but here is a good article I can across the other day

http://english.al-akhbar.com/blogs/sandbox/bandar-ibn-israel

If we care about Syria and Syrians and don't want to see another Iraq we have to back Assad and a secular Syria. Which is not what your Gov want, they want The Brotherhood.

Most of the posts that I see from you seem to advocate non-violence in the region, so why are you now advocating that we choose sides in this bloodbath? The fog of war is clearly being used by whomever is using chemical weapons, and it is entirely possible that agents on both sides are using them. If you want people like fairsheet or other anti-Assad advocates to stand down, I would humbly suggest that you be willing consider the possibility that Assad forces are also complicit. If we are going to get all sides to start talking, you need to stand down too.

God Speed,
David
 
Most of the posts that I see from you seem to advocate non-violence in the region, so why are you now advocating that we choose sides in this bloodbath? The fog of war is clearly being used by whomever is using chemical weapons, and it is entirely possible that agents on both sides are using them. If you want people like fairsheet or other anti-Assad advocates to stand down, I would humbly suggest that you be willing consider the possibility that Assad forces are also complicit. If we are going to get all sides to start talking, you need to stand down too.

God Speed,
David


I am not advocating we take sides but stop, taking sides and stop backing the foreign Jihad.

I am for a secular Syria which is what they have under Assad, a good free education system, a free healthcare system and women are free to be as they will and all minorities are protected.

Assad is fighting a foreign insurgency backed by us. He did not gas his own people.

The West want to put Sharia Law and bastard Fundis in power for their/our own selfish greedy reasons and are playing our usual dirty games to get our spoiled ways.....................
 
I've noted this in past and I know a lot of people either disagree with me or simply aren't picking up what I'm putting down. But....as far as I'm concerned, we ARE the world's policemen, whether we like if or not. So...it's not necessarily about our having the "right", as our having the "obligation".

In order to suggest that we aren't the world's policemen, you either have to make the case that the world currently HAS no policeman, or that some other entity is the world's policeman. And, if you think it's the UN, let's discuss their enforcement capability (or lack thereof).

Good Afternoon~

I would like to make a number of points. The first is that you can't be the policeman of the world or even a region of it if you are a partisan is a fight: you can't take the high ground when you are in the mud.

Second, you can't be the policeman of the world when you have dirty hands. We were a major proliferator of chemical weapons in the region in recent decades, and we are the principle supporter of one of the most aggressive players in the region: so long as it appears that we are doing things to have Israel's back, we are not complicit in the barbarity that is the daily life of the people living there.

Third, the conflict in one form or another is over 1,000 years old and not of our making. There are clearly on good and bad actors here. We can't play a constructive role unless we do so along with the international community. The President has had a good record of trying to stay above the fray and let others deal with the fighting where it is necessary; Libya was a good example despite all the carping by his opponents

Fourth, there is a growing body of assertions that both the insurgents and government are resorting to banned weapons. That needs to be sorted out. Blanket assertions by the administration are obviously counter-productive: the travesty is that the criminals in the crisis are able to avoid responsibility because the major players are making matters worse.

Fifth, we use have chemical weapons in our arsenal that we have used over the last few decades: we used thermobaric weapons in Iraq II. We used napalm to decimate much of Southeast Asia; we currently have a version of it in our arsenals. We use depleted uranium; while it is depleted, the cumulative affect impacts the health of citizens.

Last, there is a difference between being a policeman and a leader. Leadership rotates among players. A good leader works with others and doesn't try to take unilateral command of a situation when there is this kind of chaos; that leader tries to lead by example.

God Speed,
David
 
Last edited:
I am not advocating we take sides but stop, taking sides and stop backing the foreign Jihad.

I am for a secular Syria which is what they have under Assad, a good free education system, a free healthcare system and women are free to be as they will and all minorities are protected.

Assad is fighting a foreign insurgency backed by us. He did not gas his own people.

The West want to put Sharia Law and bastard Fundis in power for their/our own selfish greedy reasons and are playing our usual dirty games to get our spoiled ways.....................

I was responding to this quote from you: "If we care about Syria and Syrians and don't want to see another Iraq we have to back Assad and a secular Syria."
 
I was responding to this quote from you: "If we care about Syria and Syrians and don't want to see another Iraq we have to back Assad and a secular Syria."

Oh I didn't mean as in fight with him ........... I mean morally. We would also have more say in the humanitarian crisis that has and will come about and how to aid the country come to terms with its self. but dream on eh?

Syrian Soldiers, who after taking money from Saudi defected to the other side are leaving the so called rebels, there is no retribution they are being allowed to go home unhindered, so say Sunni Syrians ..............
 
Good Afternoon~

I would like to make a number of points. The first is that you can't be the policeman of the world or even a region of it if you are a partisan is a fight: you can't take the high ground when you are in the mud.

Second, you can't be the policeman of the world when you have dirty hands. We were a major proliferator of chemical weapons in the region in recent decades, and we are the principle supporter of one of the most aggressive players in the region: so long as it appears that we are doing things to have Israel's back, we are not complicit in the barbarity that is the daily life of the people living there.

Third, the conflict in one form or another is over 1,000 years old and not of our making. There are clearly on good and bad actors here. We can't play a constructive role unless we do so along with the international community. The President has had a good record of trying to stay above the fray and let others deal with the fighting where it is necessary; Libya was a good example despite all the carping by his opponents

Fourth, there is a growing body of assertions that both the insurgents and government are resorting to banned weapons. That needs to be sorted out. Blanket assertions by the administration are obviously counter-productive: the travesty is that the criminals in the crisis are able to avoid responsibility because the major players are making matters worse.

Fifth, we use have chemical weapons in our arsenal that we have used over the last few decades: we used thermobaric weapons in Iraq II. We used napalm to decimate much of Southeast Asia; we currently have a version of it in our arsenals. We use depleted uranium; while it is depleted, the cumulative affect impacts the health of citizens.

Last, there is a difference between being a policeman and a leader. Leadership rotates among players. A good leader works with others and doesn't try to take unilateral command of a situation when there is this kind of chaos; that leader tries to lead by example.

God Speed,



David


Your feelings around this one are popular. But with all due respect, your point-by-point only highlights the extent to which you don't get it.
 
Your feelings around this one are popular. But with all due respect, your point-by-point only highlights the extent to which you don't get it.
Your feelings around this one are popular. But with all due respect, your point-by-point only highlights the extent to which you don't get it.

I'm not saying that we can't play a leadership role much like an ex addict can counsel others. I am saying that our history and partisan views prevent us from being a world cop that decides what or who is right or wrong.

What don't I get?
 
I'm not saying that we can't play a leadership role much like an ex addict can counsel others. I am saying that our history and partisan views prevent us from being a world cop that decides what or who is right or wrong.

What don't I get?


For sure, your position on this one isn't unique. In fact, I'll concede that yours is probably in the sigificant majority. BUT....to save us both from a series of long rambling screeds, please allow me to ask you one simple question - one I've posed elsewhere herein (to nary a reponse!).

If not the U.S. as the "world's policeman", who do you propose in the alternative? And before you answer...please consider what you know will be my responses, in order that we can avoid the hamster wheel.
 
For sure, your position on this one isn't unique. In fact, I'll concede that yours is probably in the sigificant majority. BUT....to save us both from a series of long rambling screeds, please allow me to ask you one simple question - one I've posed elsewhere herein (to nary a reponse!).

If not the U.S. as the "world's policeman", who do you propose in the alternative? And before you answer...please consider what you know will be my responses, in order that we can avoid the hamster wheel.

Forgive the delay; I've been thinking about how to respond and paying more attention to domestic stuff. There is a difference between leading from the front and going it alone. Leadership means getting other people to join together to accomplish something. While Putan is given a lot of credit, the President has done a fine job of addressing the issue by getting the world community to focus on solutions to weapons of mass destruction. I only hope that his legacy is that he laid the groundwork for the elimination of these weapons system entirely: that means taking on Israel's arsenal.

Supporting a partisan in the region makes it extremely difficult to be trusted to be the cop on the beat. Allow me to make a point. Israel is currently forcing Bedouins in the Negev into camps and replacing them in their settlements and homes with Zionist colonists. It is obscene, yet there is no press coverage of it and there is nary a peep from us. If the US wants to play a real leadership role with the support of the countries in the region, it must speak truth to the power of Zionism. The same can be said for Saudi suppression of human rights but with less emphasis.

God Speed,
David
 
Back
Top