New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Terrorism Methods

And what policy would you implement that would stop your proposed terrorist scenario?

I'm not sure -- the point of my post is that I haven't thought of any good ideas. I'm opening things to general discussion. I suppose we could make such things somewhat less likely if we didn't flood the world with military weapons the way we do. We're the world's leading arms exporter, by a margin, and the more ubiquitous we make such weapons abroad, the more likely that some will find their way back here to kill huge numbers of Americans. Historically, we've had a bad habit of arming some really awful groups, including the mujahadin, Contra death squads, and even the Iranians (during the Reagan adminsitration's infamous Iran/Contra dealings). But, even if we were more judicious in sending weapons around the world, and encouraged our allies to be more cautious, Russia and China are also major arms exporters:

1e81b94e13e64eab941ea4efbcf2f553_6.jpg

So, I'm not convinced that would do much to help prevent a scenario like that.
 
Yes. And as you now see, you were wrong to say that. The Chinese do have one.



By the way, did you realize yet that was an obvious typo?

So you murder crew you want looks for a 1935 copy of the American M2? Doubt it.

Obvious typo...anybody else but your dumb @ss. How about we talk about 120mm Mortars, that start off a 305 lbs...as if some one carrying around this equipment which would be an Iranian HM-16..So no you white supremacist,you are still the idiot here.
 
So you murder crew you want looks for a 1935 copy of the American M2?

As you know, I don't want that "murder crew." I'm concerned that such a crew (or even a lone wolf) may use this tactic, and I'm opening the door to thoughts about what we can do to prevent it. But, yes, that Chinese mortar is one possibility. It was in wide distribution during the Vietnam war, and you can find parts for it being sold online today.

But, again, the exact choice of mortar isn't particularly important when it comes to the feasibility of the attack I discussed. All you need is something that'll chuck an impact explosive at least a few hundred yards with decent accuracy, with a blast radius of 5 meters or above. There are a wide array of mortars and rounds from 50 mm up to 120 that would work for that.

How about we talk about 120mm Mortars

Sure. As you suggest, your best bet in the 120 mm range would probably be the Iranian HM 16. It only takes a 3-man crew in the field, and only weighs 305 pounds. Mortars are designed to be broken down into smaller pieces. I don't know the exact construction of the HM 16, but the Soltam K6, which weighs in at 319 pounds breaks down into a 110 pound cannon assembly, a 70 pound bipod assembly, a 136 pound baseplate, and a 2.5 pound sight unit. Assuming the HM 16 was proportional at 305 pounds, that would mean the heaviest component would be just 130 pounds. There are backpacks designed to hold up to 150 pounds, so you could hike that a reasonable distance, if you were at leisure to move things one piece at a time and then assemble it on-sight.

The task would be pretty similar to what I do regularly with my telescope. The scope itself weighs about 100 pounds with the spotter scope, and the various other pieces come in at about 80 total. I regularly carry that to viewing sites solo, including up hills and over rough terrain. It takes me two trips -- one for the scope and one for the tripod and the rest of the equipment. But it's not too difficult. A 120 mm mortar would be more or less the same process -- slightly heavier per trip, but also less delicate, so you wouldn't need to worry as much about knocking it out of alignment or shattering something if you didn't set it down gently.

Still, if I were going to carry out the attack with a 120 mm mortar, I'd just mount it in a pickup truck. The recoil would be a problem for accuracy if you just left it sitting on the shocks when you fire, but if you were in no hurry to set up, you could just bring jacks with you, jacking the truck's frame up (and using that to level the platform in the process). A single person could then very easily maneuver the mortar into firing position -- basically, just weld the base plate into the truck's bed, drape something over the mortar until you're ready, so nobody sees it, park the truck in a nearby parking lot, maneuver the truck until the rough aiming is done, deploy the jacks to keep the truck's frame steady and perfectly level, then you're ready to fire. It's not clear why you'd need even a second person to make this plan work. If you watch videos of people firing 120 mm mortars, once the mortar is actually set up, only two people are handling it, and that's in the interest of speed, rather than necessity -- a single person could do each task in turn.
 
We still have no idea whether the Vegas attack was terrorism or not. But it certainly reveals a vulnerability to terrorism. Shortly after 9/11, I had a morbid discussion with some friends about ways that even a single terrorist could kill dozens or even thousands of people with almost no expertise. It was a chilling conversation because even with that group, none of whom had military training or other special knowledge, we kept coming up with lone-wolf, high-death-toll plans that would be almost impossible to prevent.

One of the easiest plans looked very similar to what just happened in Vegas. The idea was to bring a bunch of high-rate-of-fire rifles to a high-rise building with a clear view of Times Square on New Year's Eve, and just randomly fire into the crowd. Even with no marksmanship skill, you could kill dozens before the police could hope to take you out. And the trampling would kill or maim dozens more. And it's almost impossible to do anything about it. Sure, you could identify likely venues where this could happen and force high-rise hotels nearby to screen guests for weapons. But, while I would have thought of Times Square, I may not have thought of a Vegas event; many locations would remain vulnerable. It wouldn't even need to be a special event. This is just rush hour:

rush-hour-times-square-22150715.jpg


That's not even the worst of the scenarios we came up with. Here's one that would let a lone nut kill thousands of people on live TV at relatively low cost and a good chance of him making it out of there alive. First, buy a surplus mortar, in the 60 mm range, along with a couple dozen anti-personnel rounds. These are dirt cheap and widely available all over the world, so the only trick would be smuggling them into the US. It may even be possible to buy them here.

Now, just set it up in a location half a mile from a stadium, and fire into the venue. With a little practice beforehand, you could work out the ranging and apply it exactly using GPS to hit within a few few dozen feet of where you were aiming. In the field, soldiers don't always have good info on their exact coordinates and those of their target and the relative altitude of each, etc., but if you planned it out in advance, you could all of those precisely, allowing even the first shot to be pretty accurate. After that, live coverage could allow you to fine tune your aim.... or you could use a web cam perched nearby with a cell phone to see just where your shots were landing so you could walk them in. Fire for a minute, then drive away before anyone knows what happened.

To picture that, here's Michigan stadium. It holds over 115,000 fans, packed tightly:

300px-Michigan_Stadium_2011.jpg


Here's what a 60 mm mortar looks like:

300px-M224_mortar_firing.jpg

The whole thing weighs just 40 pounds, and each round weighs around 3 pounds, so a sturdy person could carry the weapon and two dozen rounds, without too much effort, and for a two-person team it would be easy.

That will fire between 76, and 3,816 yards effectively. If you set up 1000 yards away, well within range, to give yourself an easy shot, you could be way the hell out here, far beyond the radius of any enhanced security:

View attachment 37454

A 60-mm HE M49A4 will cover about a 33-foot blast radius lethally (other 60 mm rounds go from about half that to about twice that, so I'm taking the middle). Here's what that radius looks like superimposed on the stadium:

View attachment 37455
Roughly 1200 people would be inside that circle and would be dead, from a single hit -- with severe injuries all around it. That's 1200 dead with a single shot. Land just three shots in the stadium before it empties, and you've carried out the deadliest terrorist attack in history.... on live TV. The weapon is designed to fire 30 shots in one minute, so even throwing away the first few for ranging, it would be hard not to kill far more people than died on 9/11.

And that's with a fairly small and cheap mortar -- a plan you could pull off for $10,000 or so solo or with a two-man team. With a four-man team and about twice the funds, you could go with a 120 mm mortar, mounted to a pickup truck. The 120 mm HE shells have a lethality radius of 225 feet, so dropping one at midfield would kill about 40,000 people at a shot, and any shot landing anywhere in that stadium would kill at least 10,000. And after firing 15 shots in a minute, you could just drive away.

How do you defend against that? A 60 mm mortar has a range of up to 2.1 miles, and a 120 mm mortar has a range of up to 4.5 miles. You simply cannot police a range that far around every event. And there are hundreds of thousands of these mortars available all around the world for cheap. Even if you couldn't get your hands on one, something home-made would be easy. There are home-made devices that chuck pumpkins as far as 4700 feet -- chucking a bunch of home-made pipe bombs with one of those would be child's play.

You and your friends' creepiness aside...

You could rent a truck like the one used in Nice and make a hard hook, driving over a 5 foot chain link fence, and find yourself a bull in a china shop of 22,000 packed spectators at that Vegas concert.

There would be hundreds if not many thousands dead by just driving over and stampedeing people. A bomb in the truck would be the coup de grace.

Your mortar plans are complicated and complication leads to errors.
 
You and your friends' creepiness aside...

You could rent a truck like the one used in Nice and make a hard hook, driving over a 5 foot chain link fence, and find yourself a bull in a china shop of 22,000 packed spectators at that Vegas concert.

There would be hundreds if not many thousands dead by just driving over and stampedeing people. A bomb in the truck would be the coup de grace.

Your mortar plans are complicated and complication leads to errors.
The truck plan is simple, but could also be derailed pretty easily with barriers, like those huge concrete planters they tend to have at the entrance to such locations. So far, ramming attacks have tended to have low death tolls -- I think the deadliest killed 86, but most kill less than ten. The bomb would kill a lot more, of course. But the attack I'm talking about would kill over 1000 per strike -- and would do it on live TV. It would be highly likely it would have a final death toll that made it far and away the deadliest terrorist attack in history. And, unlike most attack plans, the killer would have a damned good chance of walking away from it. It would also be cheap. 60mm mortar rounds go for about $600, so $12,000 for 20 of them, and the mortar itself would cost about $10,000. And that's for new, state-of-the-art equipment. Presumably you could find something a lot cheaper if you went with some third-world knockoff of WWII technology, which would be perfectly fine for the low level of precision needed for such an attack.
 
Back
Top