New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

The 2nd amendment “LIE”

Lobato1

Mayor
The gun lovers that are quoting a couple of words out of context from our 2nd amendment to justify guns is a travesty & a LIE.

Specifically & to the point, our 2nd amendment states:
.

"A well REGULATED militia being necessary to the security of a ‘FREE STATE’, the right of the people to keep and bear arms shall not be infringed”​
.

The reason that our founding fathers wrote this 2nd amendment was that after the Revolutionary War our Country was bankrupt & in debt up to it’s ears with France & could only afford a token Continental Army of much less than “ONE” thousand men in 1789 (according to my reference), to protect tens & tens of thousands of square miles.

.

However the threat from a British invasion was very real because the concept of a republic was a menace to all the European monarchies as was previously proven with the Oliver Cromwell Republic when after Cromwell’s death previous enemies of the English King Charles I, then supported & included sent armies to restore the Stuart monarchy in England with King Charles II, just as they, the previous mortal enemies of the Bourbon King Louis XIV, the Sun King, would later destroy the French Republic to restore the Bourbon monarchy with King Louis XVIII.

.

Therefore, the only practical solution was to use local “REGULATED” militias to engage a foreign invasion in order to give our Country time to raise an army that would then deal with that invasion.

.

Accordingly, our 2nd amendment only makes sense when taken in it’s full context that states once again:

"A well REGULATED militia being necessary to the security of a ‘FREE STATE’, the right of the people to keep and bear arms shall not be infringed”​

A “REGULATED” militia meaning exactly that: "REGULATED"

.

.



My reference on our Continental Army that had less than 1,000 men in 1789:

http://alternatewars.com/BBOW/Stats/US_Mil_Manpower_1789-1997.htm

.

.

My reference on the full text of our 2nd amendment:

https://www.law.cornell.edu/constitution/second_amendment

.

.
Best Regards
Lobato1
.
.
 
Last edited:
1. The people are the militia
2. That the only firearms protected by the second amendment are weapons of suitable use for defending individual states
3. And in defense of the individual citizen.


First let's look at the words of the second amendment
"A well-regulated militia being necessary to the security of a free State, the right of the People to keep and bear arms shall not be infringed."
The second amendment is a two-part amendment

First part
A well-regulated militia being necessary to the security of a free State
This is saying the states have the right to have a militia

Part two
the right of the People to keep and bear arms shall not be infringed
This shows that the people are the makeup of the militia.

Now let's take a look at two words from the first part of the second amendment
WELL REGULATED
Well Regulated in the context it was written in 1792 did not mean what it means today.
In 1792 well regulated meant in working order as to be expected
If it was the founders intended for the militia to be regulated by the federal government
they would have written the second amendment in this manner

A militia well regulated by Congress being necessary to the security of a free State, the right of the People to keep and bear arms shall not be infringed.

After separating ties with the king of England they would not turn around and give power to another centralized government.

The Militia
George Mason is known as the father of the bill of rights it was his belief that the people were the militia
"I ask, sir, what is the militia? It is the whole people, except for a few public officials."
Bear Arms

There is precedence in the courts going as far back as U.S. vs Miller 1939 and U.S. vs Lewis1980 affirming what Miller ruled upon
Opinion of the Court
In order for a firearm to be protected by the second amendment, it must have some reasonable relationship to the preservation or efficiency of a well-regulated militia, in common use of time, and supplied by the citizen.
The United States v. Miller


In U.S. Code it defines what is a militia

10 USC § 311 - Militia: composition and classes
(a) The militia of the United States consists of all able-bodied males at least 17 years of age and, except as provided in section 313 of title 32, under 45 years of age who are, or who have made a declaration of intention to become, citizens of the United States and of female citizens of the United States who are members of the National Guard.
(b) The classes of the militia are—
(1) the organized militia, which consists of the National Guard and the Naval Militia; and
(2) the unorganized militia, which consists of the members of the militia who are not members of the National Guard or the Naval Militia.
In the regular military and the national guard you are not allowed to keep the firearm you carry while on duty.
It is the unorganized militia that the average citizen is a part of.
My summation
The 2nd amendment was written for the primary reason of limiting the power of the Federal Government. When the People have the right to keep and bear arms, the government cannot take over the people in the form of a totalitarian government.
 
Last edited:
I think L1 #1 makes a point worth discussion.

If I may split the baby:
the 2nd Amendment may be the most poorly worded sentence in our amended Constitution.

Were it otherwise, why the topic?
- The anti-gunners dote on the first clause
- the pro-gunners dote on the second.

BUT !!

They are a pair. They go together.
 
I think L1 #1 makes a point worth discussion.

If I may split the baby:
the 2nd Amendment may be the most poorly worded sentence in our amended Constitution.

Were it otherwise, why the topic?
- The anti-gunners dote on the first clause
- the pro-gunners dote on the second.

BUT !!

They are a pair. They go together.
No it isn't if you read my post I break it down for you to comprehend.
 
I think L1 #1 makes a point worth discussion.

If I may split the baby:
the 2nd Amendment may be the most poorly worded sentence in our amended Constitution.

Were it otherwise, why the topic?
- The anti-gunners dote on the first clause
- the pro-gunners dote on the second.

BUT !!

They are a pair. They go together.


in heller vs dist. of columbia scotus ruled the right to bear arms is an INDIVIDUAL right not dependent upon membership in any group, militia, etc.

the militia is made up of all abled bodied males 18 years or older.

the well regulated means ready to fight, armed and with knowledge of the weapons used.

the right of the PEOPLE pertains to the citizens right, all citizens...nothing more clear can be said about that,,,attempts can only be made to convolute it...

"shall not be infringed" is self explanatory.

the 2nd is short, one sentence long, and easily understood..
its recent attempts to redefine, reinterpret, weaken or destroy it all together is the very reason it exists.
to prevent those that wish to take our rights away..

its not complicated, and has served us well for over 200 years...
 
I think L1 #1 makes a point worth discussion.

If I may split the baby:
the 2nd Amendment may be the most poorly worded sentence in our amended Constitution.

Were it otherwise, why the topic?
- The anti-gunners dote on the first clause
- the pro-gunners dote on the second.

BUT !!

They are a pair. They go together.
The second amendment never even mentions guns
 
in heller vs dist. of columbia scotus ruled the right to bear arms is an INDIVIDUAL right not dependent upon membership in any group, militia, etc.

the militia is made up of all abled bodied males 18 years or older.

the well regulated means ready to fight, armed and with knowledge of the weapons used.

the right of the PEOPLE pertains to the citizens right, all citizens...nothing more clear can be said about that,,,attempts can only be made to convolute it...

"shall not be infringed" is self explanatory.

the 2nd is short, one sentence long, and easily understood..
its recent attempts to redefine, reinterpret, weaken or destroy it all together is the very reason it exists.
to prevent those that wish to take our rights away..

its not complicated, and has served us well for over 200 years...

There is no second amendment
 
The gun lovers that are quoting a couple of words out of context from our 2nd amendment to justify guns is a travesty & a LIE.

Specifically & to the point, our 2nd amendment states:
.

"A well REGULATED militia being necessary to the security of a ‘FREE STATE’, the right of the people to keep and bear arms shall not be infringed”​
.

The reason that our founding fathers wrote this 2nd amendment was that after the Revolutionary War our Country was bankrupt & in debt up to it’s ears with France & could only afford a token Continental Army of much less than “ONE” thousand men in 1789 (according to my reference), to protect tens & tens of thousands of square miles.

.

However the threat from a British invasion was very real because the concept of a republic was a menace to all the European monarchies as was previously proven with the Oliver Cromwell Republic when after Cromwell’s death previous enemies of the English King Charles I, then supported & included sent armies to restore the Stuart monarchy in England with King Charles II, just as they, the previous mortal enemies of the Bourbon King Louis XIV, the Sun King, would later destroy the French Republic to restore the Bourbon monarchy with King Louis XVIII.

.

Therefore, the only practical solution was to use local “REGULATED” militias to engage a foreign invasion in order to give our Country time to raise an army that would then deal with that invasion.

.

Accordingly, our 2nd amendment only makes sense when taken in it’s full context that states once again:

"A well REGULATED militia being necessary to the security of a ‘FREE STATE’, the right of the people to keep and bear arms shall not be infringed”​

A “REGULATED” militia meaning exactly that: "REGULATED"

.

.



My reference on our Continental Army that had less than 1,000 men in 1789:

http://alternatewars.com/BBOW/Stats/US_Mil_Manpower_1789-1997.htm

.

.

My reference on the full text of our 2nd amendment:

https://www.law.cornell.edu/constitution/second_amendment

.

.
Best Regards
Lobato1
.
.
Your post is cogent and well-written but is completely free of the reasoning that established case law has granted us.
The precedents established by the Supreme Court allow Americans to defend their lives with personally owned guns. That’s the jumping off point you need to begin with and work from.
 
The gun lovers that are quoting a couple of words out of context from our 2nd amendment to justify guns is a travesty & a LIE.

Specifically & to the point, our 2nd amendment states:
.

"A well REGULATED militia being necessary to the security of a ‘FREE STATE’, the right of the people to keep and bear arms shall not be infringed”​
.

The reason that our founding fathers wrote this 2nd amendment was that after the Revolutionary War our Country was bankrupt & in debt up to it’s ears with France & could only afford a token Continental Army of much less than “ONE” thousand men in 1789 (according to my reference), to protect tens & tens of thousands of square miles.

.

However the threat from a British invasion was very real because the concept of a republic was a menace to all the European monarchies as was previously proven with the Oliver Cromwell Republic when after Cromwell’s death previous enemies of the English King Charles I, then supported & included sent armies to restore the Stuart monarchy in England with King Charles II, just as they, the previous mortal enemies of the Bourbon King Louis XIV, the Sun King, would later destroy the French Republic to restore the Bourbon monarchy with King Louis XVIII.

.

Therefore, the only practical solution was to use local “REGULATED” militias to engage a foreign invasion in order to give our Country time to raise an army that would then deal with that invasion.

.

Accordingly, our 2nd amendment only makes sense when taken in it’s full context that states once again:

"A well REGULATED militia being necessary to the security of a ‘FREE STATE’, the right of the people to keep and bear arms shall not be infringed”​

A “REGULATED” militia meaning exactly that: "REGULATED"

.

.



My reference on our Continental Army that had less than 1,000 men in 1789:

http://alternatewars.com/BBOW/Stats/US_Mil_Manpower_1789-1997.htm

.

.

My reference on the full text of our 2nd amendment:

https://www.law.cornell.edu/constitution/second_amendment

.

.
Best Regards
Lobato1
.
.
Gun banners seem to latch onto that one word--REGULATED--far more than any other word including militia.

Do you think "regulated" means "controlled?" Now seriously. Ask yourself, "Would the founders REALLY want government controlling the individuals' firearms? Is that the proper context?"

People in this thread and in many others have tried to educate gun banners on the proper 18th century meaning of the word "regulated." It means "to make regular." And in this context it means "to make regular or to make similar to a regular military." But I have yet to see this convince a single gun banner. Why? Do you need another example? Okay, try this:

We hold these truths to be self-evident, that all men are created equal, that they are endowed by their Creator with certain unalienable rights, that among these are life, liberty and the pursuit of happiness.​

What is the "pursuit of happiness?" The pursuit of whatever makes you happy?

No.

"Happiness" takes the same root as the word "happenstance" which is more like "chance" than it is of today's connotation of "being happy." So that sentence in the Declaration of Independence deals not with making people happy but the pursuit of good fortune. It is a response to the mercantilistic (what we would today call "socialist") locking out of people because they were not well connected with government officials. The "pursuit of happiness" is the pursuit of "just give me a chance." It is an embrace of capitalism and a rejection of government control. It is a VERY capitalistic sentence. And so. . .

"Well regulated militia?"

Yes! I'm all in favor of it! But I know what that means. I know what they meant when they wrote it. I am familiar with the style of 18th century writers and I know how that context has changed though the centuries. And I know the efforts of gun banners to try to change the context in which it was written.

And I never ever see gun banners put as much effort into understanding the Constitution as constitutionalists do. They seem to just latch onto key words like "regulated" and "militia" and assume they mean "controlled" and "National Guard" and that's good enough to go charging off into the forest.

Take some advice: Drop the preoccupation with "well regulated." It doesn't serve your purpose and it makes you look lazy--like you can't be bothered with things like the truth.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Nice to see you, Lobato1!

The NRA encourages parents to expose children as young as five to the AR-15.

r1275_fea_ar15_g-72ec4d47-16aa-40e6-bfa2-ede071e8f54c.jpg


I sincerely doubt this is what the Framers had in mind when they drew up the 2nd amendment.

https://www.rollingstone.com/politi...became-mass-shooters-weapon-of-choice-w451452
 
Last edited:
The gun lovers that are quoting a couple of words out of context from our 2nd amendment to justify guns is a travesty & a LIE.

Specifically & to the point, our 2nd amendment states:
.

"A well REGULATED militia being necessary to the security of a ‘FREE STATE’, the right of the people to keep and bear arms shall not be infringed”​
.

The reason that our founding fathers wrote this 2nd amendment was that after the Revolutionary War our Country was bankrupt & in debt up to it’s ears with France & could only afford a token Continental Army of much less than “ONE” thousand men in 1789 (according to my reference), to protect tens & tens of thousands of square miles.

.

However the threat from a British invasion was very real because the concept of a republic was a menace to all the European monarchies as was previously proven with the Oliver Cromwell Republic when after Cromwell’s death previous enemies of the English King Charles I, then supported & included sent armies to restore the Stuart monarchy in England with King Charles II, just as they, the previous mortal enemies of the Bourbon King Louis XIV, the Sun King, would later destroy the French Republic to restore the Bourbon monarchy with King Louis XVIII.

.

Therefore, the only practical solution was to use local “REGULATED” militias to engage a foreign invasion in order to give our Country time to raise an army that would then deal with that invasion.

.

Accordingly, our 2nd amendment only makes sense when taken in it’s full context that states once again:

"A well REGULATED militia being necessary to the security of a ‘FREE STATE’, the right of the people to keep and bear arms shall not be infringed”​

A “REGULATED” militia meaning exactly that: "REGULATED"

.

.



My reference on our Continental Army that had less than 1,000 men in 1789:

http://alternatewars.com/BBOW/Stats/US_Mil_Manpower_1789-1997.htm

.

.

My reference on the full text of our 2nd amendment:

https://www.law.cornell.edu/constitution/second_amendment

.

.
Best Regards
Lobato1
.
.

Lobato -- what is well regulated in the amendment?
What is stated as a right in the amendment?
 
The bottom line is, the NRA is all about selling more guns and any law that might prevent 1 gun sale is against all their principles. I mean doesn't violence like this promote more gun sales as people want to protect themselves more? Now a .45 isn't strong enough, gotta go get an AR-15 to match the firepower - right? What has been the % spike in sales since Florida/ I am not blaming people as they need to do what they need to do for themselves and their families protection.I too look at what I own and wonder myself.

Bottom line nothing significant will happen until fall 2018, then the elections will tell if the US is serious about gun control or not - pretty simple. Before the people even left the WH the NRA went against what Trump said that he would consider - age limits on gun purchases.
 
The gun lovers that are quoting a couple of words out of context from our 2nd amendment to justify guns is a travesty & a LIE.

Specifically & to the point, our 2nd amendment states:
.

"A well REGULATED militia being necessary to the security of a ‘FREE STATE’, the right of the people to keep and bear arms shall not be infringed”​
.

The reason that our founding fathers wrote this 2nd amendment was that after the Revolutionary War our Country was bankrupt & in debt up to it’s ears with France & could only afford a token Continental Army of much less than “ONE” thousand men in 1789 (according to my reference), to protect tens & tens of thousands of square miles.

.

However the threat from a British invasion was very real because the concept of a republic was a menace to all the European monarchies as was previously proven with the Oliver Cromwell Republic when after Cromwell’s death previous enemies of the English King Charles I, then supported & included sent armies to restore the Stuart monarchy in England with King Charles II, just as they, the previous mortal enemies of the Bourbon King Louis XIV, the Sun King, would later destroy the French Republic to restore the Bourbon monarchy with King Louis XVIII.

.

Therefore, the only practical solution was to use local “REGULATED” militias to engage a foreign invasion in order to give our Country time to raise an army that would then deal with that invasion.

.

Accordingly, our 2nd amendment only makes sense when taken in it’s full context that states once again:

"A well REGULATED militia being necessary to the security of a ‘FREE STATE’, the right of the people to keep and bear arms shall not be infringed”​

A “REGULATED” militia meaning exactly that: "REGULATED"

.

.



My reference on our Continental Army that had less than 1,000 men in 1789:

http://alternatewars.com/BBOW/Stats/US_Mil_Manpower_1789-1997.htm

.

.

My reference on the full text of our 2nd amendment:

https://www.law.cornell.edu/constitution/second_amendment

.

.
Best Regards
Lobato1
.
.
Just to add to and modify that a bit:

The emphasis on regulated militias to defend the state wasn't just an attempt to do so without the expense of a large standing army. If you read the contemporaneous writings of a number of the founders, they saw a large standing army as the death of liberty. It was an early line of thought similar to Eisenhower's famous comments about the military industrial complex. The founders wanted to make a go of it without any significant standing army, with the idea that a network of well-regulated militias would be our first line of defense against aggression, with a regular army only being formed, similar to what happened with the Revolution, when a war was actually imminent.

So, our whole second amendment debate isn't just wildly out of context in the sense that the arms the founders were picturing were so very different from the arms today, but also in the sense that the whole premise for having well-regulated militias is no longer operative. We've had a large, standing army basically non-stop since 1940. In fact, we have a military so wildly bloated that it costs twice as much as all our potential adversaries' militaries combined. Part of the future the Founders feared has come to pass. We have a military that now savagely distorts our politics and which winds up feeding itself through an uninterrupted series of wars of aggression. We no longer use those militias as a first line of defense. In fact, we don't have well-regulated militias in any meaningful sense, unless you mean the national guards. Instead, the Founders' insistence on the idea that a well-regulated militia is necessary is, absurdly, used as an argument for why regulating the militia is illegitimate.
 
The bottom line is, the NRA is all about selling more guns and any law that might prevent 1 gun sale is against all their principles. I mean doesn't violence like this promote more gun sales as people want to protect themselves more? Now a .45 isn't strong enough, gotta go get an AR-15 to match the firepower - right? What has been the % spike in sales since Florida/ I am not blaming people as they need to do what they need to do for themselves and their families protection.I too look at what I own and wonder myself.

Bottom line nothing significant will happen until fall 2018, then the elections will tell if the US is serious about gun control or not - pretty simple. Before the people even left the WH the NRA went against what Trump said that he would consider - age limits on gun purchases.

The NRA is not about selling guns. I've been an NRA member for 30 years, a life member for more than a decade and a half, and the NRA has never sold me a gun, nor indicated I should buy one. An from a gun-owners standpoint, the current push to ban AR-15s and other semi-autos is just what was needed to drive us to the polls. Mid-terms were looking soft until this.
 
Just to add to and modify that a bit:

The emphasis on regulated militias to defend the state wasn't just an attempt to do so without the expense of a large standing army. If you read the contemporaneous writings of a number of the founders, they saw a large standing army as the death of liberty. It was an early line of thought similar to Eisenhower's famous comments about the military industrial complex. The founders wanted to make a go of it without any significant standing army, with the idea that a network of well-regulated militias would be our first line of defense against aggression, with a regular army only being formed, similar to what happened with the Revolution, when a war was actually imminent.

So, our whole second amendment debate isn't just wildly out of context in the sense that the arms the founders were picturing were so very different from the arms today, but also in the sense that the whole premise for having well-regulated militias is no longer operative. We've had a large, standing army basically non-stop since 1940. In fact, we have a military so wildly bloated that it costs twice as much as all our potential adversaries' militaries combined. Part of the future the Founders feared has come to pass. We have a military that now savagely distorts our politics and which winds up feeding itself through an uninterrupted series of wars of aggression. We no longer use those militias as a first line of defense. In fact, we don't have well-regulated militias in any meaningful sense, unless you mean the national guards. Instead, the Founders' insistence on the idea that a well-regulated militia is necessary is, absurdly, used as an argument for why regulating the militia is illegitimate.

I asked the to poster this and I'll ask you the same.
What is regulated in the amendment?
What is stated as a right?
 
1. The people are the militia
2. That the only firearms protected by the second amendment are weapons of suitable use for defending individual states
3. And in defense of the individual citizen.


First let's look at the words of the second amendment

The second amendment is a two-part amendment

First part

This is saying the states have the right to have a militia

Part two

This shows that the people are the makeup of the militia.

Now let's take a look at two words from the first part of the second amendment
WELL REGULATED
Well Regulated in the context it was written in 1792 did not mean what it means today.
In 1792 well regulated meant in working order as to be expected
If it was the founders intended for the militia to be regulated by the federal government
they would have written the second amendment in this manner



After separating ties with the king of England they would not turn around and give power to another centralized government.

The Militia
George Mason is known as the father of the bill of rights it was his belief that the people were the militia

Bear Arms

There is precedence in the courts going as far back as U.S. vs Miller 1939 and U.S. vs Lewis1980 affirming what Miller ruled upon
Opinion of the Court
In order for a firearm to be protected by the second amendment, it must have some reasonable relationship to the preservation or efficiency of a well-regulated militia, in common use of time, and supplied by the citizen.
The United States v. Miller


In U.S. Code it defines what is a militia

10 USC § 311 - Militia: composition and classes
(a) The militia of the United States consists of all able-bodied males at least 17 years of age and, except as provided in section 313 of title 32, under 45 years of age who are, or who have made a declaration of intention to become, citizens of the United States and of female citizens of the United States who are members of the National Guard.
(b) The classes of the militia are—
(1) the organized militia, which consists of the National Guard and the Naval Militia; and
(2) the unorganized militia, which consists of the members of the militia who are not members of the National Guard or the Naval Militia.
In the regular military and the national guard you are not allowed to keep the firearm you carry while on duty.
It is the unorganized militia that the average citizen is a part of.
My summation
The 2nd amendment was written for the primary reason of limiting the power of the Federal Government. When the People have the right to keep and bear arms, the government cannot take over the people in the form of a totalitarian government.
To be clear, then, is your view that people 45 or over, and women, are not constitutionally guaranteed a right to bear arms, since they aren't members of the militia and thus their gun ownership can have nothing to do with having well-regulated militias?
 
The bottom line is, the NRA is all about selling more guns and any law that might prevent 1 gun sale is against all their principles. I mean doesn't violence like this promote more gun sales as people want to protect themselves more? Now a .45 isn't strong enough, gotta go get an AR-15 to match the firepower - right? What has been the % spike in sales since Florida/ I am not blaming people as they need to do what they need to do for themselves and their families protection.I too look at what I own and wonder myself.

Bottom line nothing significant will happen until fall 2018, then the elections will tell if the US is serious about gun control or not - pretty simple. Before the people even left the WH the NRA went against what Trump said that he would consider - age limits on gun purchases.

The assault weapons ban expired in 2004....and Bush and the Republicans refused to extend it.
My Sen Rob Portman (R-OH) has received $3.6 million from the NRA. Blood money.
 
The assault weapons ban expired in 2004....and Bush and the Republicans refused to extend it.
My Sen Rob Portman (R-OH) has received $3.6 million from the NRA. Blood money.

The assault weapons ban had no impact on crime, so renewing it would have been stupid.
 
Back
Top