New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

The Alternative Minimum Tax...

Because they make it all on investments...like the ...uh...Stock Market?

You proposing a hike in the investment income tax, Lukey? :)
 
Didn't you ask this last week, and wasn't it already answered? The answer is that investment income is taxed separately. Romney and Buffet mostly pay at the 15% long-term capital gains rate, and that isn't subject to AMT. They may, in fact, pay AMT on the rest of their income, but that's a small minority of what they earn. I'd be strongly in favor of getting rid of separate capital gains taxes (and separate taxes on dividends, interest, inheritance, gifts received, etc.), and just treating it all as regular income, for tax purposes. To make that work, you'd need to only count the gain portion of a capital gain as regular income, and you'd need to index the basis against inflation (so people aren't paying a high tax rate on a gain that's mostly just inflation), but once you did that you'd have a much simpler and more efficient tax system. This would also remove some of the inefficient distortions that happen when people have a tax incentive to treat income as a capital gain. That famously happens with hedge fund managers, who are essentially paid millions of dollars of salary for their management services, and yet get to treat it as long-term capital gains taxed at 15%, resulting in them paying lower taxes than many people earning a fraction as much. It also happens with CEOs and the like, who sometimes earn some nominal salary (Steve Jobs was paid $1, some years), and mostly make their money in capital gains on company stock, subject to taxes. Treating all income the same would make our tax system more progressive, simpler, less prone to distorting the economy, but since it would raise the taxes on the people who own our politicians, it's unlikely to happen.
 
Didn't you ask this last week, and wasn't it already answered? The answer is that investment income is taxed separately. Romney and Buffet mostly pay at the 15% long-term capital gains rate, and that isn't subject to AMT. They may, in fact, pay AMT on the rest of their income, but that's a small minority of what they earn. I'd be strongly in favor of getting rid of separate capital gains taxes (and separate taxes on dividends, interest, inheritance, gifts received, etc.), and just treating it all as regular income, for tax purposes. To make that work, you'd need to only count the gain portion of a capital gain as regular income, and you'd need to index the basis against inflation (so people aren't paying a high tax rate on a gain that's mostly just inflation), but once you did that you'd have a much simpler and more efficient tax system. This would also remove some of the inefficient distortions that happen when people have a tax incentive to treat income as a capital gain. That famously happens with hedge fund managers, who are essentially paid millions of dollars of salary for their management services, and yet get to treat it as long-term capital gains taxed at 15%, resulting in them paying lower taxes than many people earning a fraction as much. It also happens with CEOs and the like, who sometimes earn some nominal salary (Steve Jobs was paid $1, some years), and mostly make their money in capital gains on company stock, subject to taxes. Treating all income the same would make our tax system more progressive, simpler, less prone to distorting the economy, but since it would raise the taxes on the people who own our politicians, it's unlikely to happen.

So why is it taxed differently?
 
The typical explanation for taxing capital gains differently is that it wouldn't make sense to tax those gains, especially long-term capital gains, at a high rate, when most of the gain is inflation. For example, if you buy a stock at $10 and sell it twenty years later at $25, it's a bit unfair to tax a full $15 of "income," when probably $8 of those dollars were just needed just to cover inflation (something worth $10 in 1990 would probably cost you $18 in 2010). So, a "rough and ready" way to handle that is to charge 15% for those long-term capital gains, with the idea that that's equivalent to charging 32% for only the post-inflation gain. However, that's a really, really dumb "rough and ready" solution, since most people don't hold capital assets for anywhere near that long, and since it winds up being far less progressive. It would be much better to index the principal against inflation and then treat the gain as regular income. So, you'd only tax $7 of gain, but you'd throw it in with money earned any other way.
 
The typical explanation for taxing capital gains differently is that it wouldn't make sense to tax those gains, especially long-term capital gains, at a high rate, when most of the gain is inflation. For example, if you buy a stock at $10 and sell it twenty years later at $25, it's a bit unfair to tax a full $15 of "income," when probably $8 of those dollars were just needed just to cover inflation (something worth $10 in 1990 would probably cost you $18 in 2010). So, a "rough and ready" way to handle that is to charge 15% for those long-term capital gains, with the idea that that's equivalent to charging 32% for only the post-inflation gain. However, that's a really, really dumb "rough and ready" solution, since most people don't hold capital assets for anywhere near that long, and since it winds up being far less progressive. It would be much better to index the principal against inflation and then treat the gain as regular income. So, you'd only tax $7 of gain, but you'd throw it in with money earned any other way.

So, then, do you support the Buffet Rule tax or not?
 
The typical explanation for taxing capital gains differently is that it wouldn't make sense to tax those gains, especially long-term capital gains, at a high rate, when most of the gain is inflation. For example, if you buy a stock at $10 and sell it twenty years later at $25, it's a bit unfair to tax a full $15 of "income," when probably $8 of those dollars were just needed just to cover inflation (something worth $10 in 1990 would probably cost you $18 in 2010). So, a "rough and ready" way to handle that is to charge 15% for those long-term capital gains, with the idea that that's equivalent to charging 32% for only the post-inflation gain. However, that's a really, really dumb "rough and ready" solution, since most people don't hold capital assets for anywhere near that long, and since it winds up being far less progressive. It would be much better to index the principal against inflation and then treat the gain as regular income. So, you'd only tax $7 of gain, but you'd throw it in with money earned any other way.

Nicely explained Ark.

one of the arguements made against this is that it makes LTGC calculations "too complicated"... except it doesn't. Anyone who has "dollar cost averaged" into a mutual fund or a stock is already keeping track of their basis costs and when the item was purchased. Adding a simple inflation adjustment calculation isn't a problem really.

Two other approaches that make some sense are

  • Reduce the difference between LTCG rates and "marginal income rates" to be based on the marginal income rates rather than an absolute rate. After all we want to encourage EVERYONE to invest in Capital formation, not just the higher tax earners. Right now, someone who is in the 35% marginatl tax bracket benefits 20% from LTCG holding whereas someone in the 10% rate LOSES money.

    So instead you could simply say that LTCG is a 10% marginal tax rate reduction.
  • increase the holding period for LTGC. The claim is that LTGC is there to provide incentive in investing in GDP growth. But a 1 year holding period basically means it is a tax shield for the wealthy but does little to create capital asset pools for things like startups and capital investment ventures.

    Setting it to say 3 years would change tht behaviour

I would in fact prefer a combination of the two. And I don't think the data is there to suggest that this would reduce the level of capital gains asset formation. IN fact I htink the data is to the conrary. That it would have no efect.



Note the one thing you missed is that one of the big exemptions that folks like Buffet make their money on is what is known as "carried interest".. It is the "carried interst" exemption that turns what otherwise would be "ordinary income" into "Long term Capital Gains". Getting rid of the "carried interest" exemption http://money.cnn.com/2010/06/10/news/companies/sloan_carried_interest.fortune/index.htm would work as well.
 
Does inflation drive up asset prices? I am not convinced. If you make this argument then how do you explain capital losses? Inflation drives up the cost of money which in a long term investment portfolio would be offset by owning short term securities or bonds. I am of the opinion that we should be taxing true long term gains at a very low rate in order to encourage the longer viewpoint and relieve the burdens on CEOs to make short term gains. Our system of taxation could be used to get us off the quarterly results nightmare every single CEO faces solely from the pressure of stockholders. Take the incentive for short term gains out of the stock market and before you know it, we start doing things with a longer view and maybe companies like Google, GE, Exxon and Microsoft could justify a new Bell Labs or two...I have been chasing quarterly targets for over 30 years now. It is a stupid waste of time and effort to look short term. We need to make CEOS focus on long term asset appreciation and market penetration. Lets get the tax code on their side for once. Make any investment held more than 5 years a higher rate than what you pay if you hold it 7 or 10 years. As for short term gains, make them identical to marginal rates for income.
 
Nicely explained Ark.

one of the arguements made against this is that it makes LTGC calculations "too complicated"... except it doesn't. Anyone who has "dollar cost averaged" into a mutual fund or a stock is already keeping track of their basis costs and when the item was purchased. Adding a simple inflation adjustment calculation isn't a problem really.

Two other approaches that make some sense are

  • Reduce the difference between LTCG rates and "marginal income rates" to be based on the marginal income rates rather than an absolute rate. After all we want to encourage EVERYONE to invest in Capital formation, not just the higher tax earners. Right now, someone who is in the 35% marginatl tax bracket benefits 20% from LTCG holding whereas someone in the 10% rate LOSES money.

    So instead you could simply say that LTCG is a 10% marginal tax rate reduction.
  • increase the holding period for LTGC. The claim is that LTGC is there to provide incentive in investing in GDP growth. But a 1 year holding period basically means it is a tax shield for the wealthy but does little to create capital asset pools for things like startups and capital investment ventures.

    Setting it to say 3 years would change tht behaviour

I would in fact prefer a combination of the two. And I don't think the data is there to suggest that this would reduce the level of capital gains asset formation. IN fact I htink the data is to the conrary. That it would have no efect.



Note the one thing you missed is that one of the big exemptions that folks like Buffet make their money on is what is known as "carried interest".. It is the "carried interst" exemption that turns what otherwise would be "ordinary income" into "Long term Capital Gains". Getting rid of the "carried interest" exemption http://money.cnn.com/2010/06/10/news/companies/sloan_carried_interest.fortune/index.htm would work as well.

So how much of my income is the result of inflation? I make about ten times what I made in my first fulltime professional job, but adjusted for inflation, it's more like six times. If I cannot adjust my income for inflation and only pay for the non-inflation portion, why should the investor be able to adjust the cost of his assets for inflation and only pay his capital gains tax on the non-inflation portion?
 
And you make a good argument for ignoring inflation except as it relates to indexing the tax brackets...the AMT suffers from the lack of indexing if I remember correctly.
 
And you make a good argument for ignoring inflation except as it relates to indexing the tax brackets...the AMT suffers from the lack of indexing if I remember correctly.

Doesn't it really make a good argument for a flat tax with minimal deductions?
 
Back
Top