New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

The Case For Iran

Guthrie

Mayor
It is commonly held throughout mainstream journalism that the Middle East has spun out of control. I don’t doubt that premise. Yet is the Middle East under control when our US backed dictators have bludgeoned their own populations into silence and obedience? When US backed oppression is succeeding, as it has for the better part of 7 decades, we call it “stability.” The underlying assumption is that if the people of the region are irrelevant then the US through its proxy autocrats are effectively carrying out the policy they have formulated.

Under this framework, murder, terror, torture have no relevance on American policy makers. So for example, a few weeks before Sadaam invaded Kuwait we were told by the Bush administration that Sadaam “was a force for moderation and stability in the region.” This despite the fact that with US backed arms he had killed a about a million Iranians, thousands of Kurds and Shiites, in chemical weapon attacks. Only when he disobeyed US orders did he become the “beast of Baghdad,” literally overnight.

In Iran the situation is much the same. A 1953 CIA coup overturned a democratically and parliamentary based populist party. Its leader, Mossadeq, committed the supreme crime of overseeing a parliament who passed legislation nationalizing Iranian oil. You know, the Iranians had this perverse idea that Iranian oil should benefit Iranians.

After the coup, the US installed the murderous Shah who for over 25 years killed tens of thousands of his own citizens. After shooting 1,000 in the street in 1978, Jimmy Carter sent him new shipments of military weapons and vowed his support for the tyrant. The Shah, in his memoirs, wrote that he was embarrassed by the persistent US support as his regime came tumbling down, as he said it made him feel “like a puppet.” If the shoe fits sir.

After the Shah was gone the US immediately turned to supporting Sadaam while he was invading and gassing Iran. This culminated in July of 1988 with the USS Vicennes shooting down an Iranian civilian airliner near Iranian territorial waters. What was the Vicennes doing there? It was supporting their friend Sadaam in his war against Iran. Medals were given to the commander of the Vicennes instead of a trial and imprisonment. As George Bush the first said at the time, “I don’t care what the facts are but I will never apologize for my country.” Imagine if every country adopted that vile mindset.

Despite a history of American war crimes towards Iran one might be surprised to learn that Iran is quite willing to forgive and forget. In 2003, Iran offered the United States a full peace proposal. Iran offered to recognize the state of Israel, support America in the war on terror and reign in Hezbollah. The Bush administration responded by “belittling” the proposal. According to a former Bush administration official the proposal was “part of a series of efforts by Iran to engage with the Bush Administration” and was a “missed opportunity.”

In fact, prior to these peace overtures, Iran had provided “key intelligence” both on Al-Qaeda and the Taliban. They also aided the toppling of Sadaam Hussein, a fact overlooked here.(2) During this time period Iran was undergoing a reformist movement providing a key opportunity for the US government to isolate hardline elements in Iran. According to the MIT international review, the reformists were rewarded with Iran’s inclusion “in the axis of evil-what amounted to a death sentence for the reformist movement that called for cooperation with the west.”(3) The hardliners quickly moved the reformers out and replaced them with President Ahmadinejad, whose inflammatory statements are at direct odds with the majority of the Iranian population.

In fact a vast majority of Iranians want better relations with the US, more secular political freedoms and a focus on the economy. A vast majority of Iranians also support peace with Israel as part of a broader peace agreement with America.

In July of 2014 the UN confirmed that Iran had complied with its obligations under the interim 6 month agreement with the United States. All of its “sensitive uranium” had been removed and compliance with UN inspectors flawless. According to US officials the 6 month agreement had been a “success” and yet only offered Iran modest returns. (5) Even this year, the President of Iran specifically signaled a desire to renew ties with Washington and forgive forget.(6)

The US has bludgeoned Iran for 7 decades. Period. Renewing diplomatic ties with Iran would strengthen reformist elements, in line with the population, who want to continue to whittle away the Ayatollahs power. Iran can also be a useful ally in helping to stem ISIS, a group that is more of a threat to Iran than the US.

To be clear, I am not calling for militarizing Iran. I am simply stating that the US should work with these peace overture and see where it leads. In the long run it will strengthen Israel, the US and Middle East in general.

Yet these moves will not be followed for one simple reason. The US doesn’t fear Iran for security reasons, they seek to control it as they do the great majority of other nations in the region.


(1) http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2006/06/17/AR2006061700727.html



(2) http://web.mit.edu/mitir/2009/online/us-iran.pdf

(3) ibid

(4) http://www.worldpublicopinion.org/pipa/articles/brmiddleeastnafricara/527.php

(5) http://www.reuters.com/article/2014/07/20/us-iran-nuclear-iaea-idUSKBN0FP0LW20140720

(6) http://www.timesofisrael.com/rouhani-iran-wants-friendly-relations-with-all-states/
 
The middle east politics is very hard to follow as it changes every five minutes. I think the US backed Saddam because he was viewed as the lessor of two evils at the time.
 
It is commonly held throughout mainstream journalism that the Middle East has spun out of control. I don’t doubt that premise. Yet is the Middle East under control when our US backed dictators have bludgeoned their own populations into silence and obedience? When US backed oppression is succeeding, as it has for the better part of 7 decades, we call it “stability.” The underlying assumption is that if the people of the region are irrelevant then the US through its proxy autocrats are effectively carrying out the policy they have formulated.

Under this framework, murder, terror, torture have no relevance on American policy makers. So for example, a few weeks before Sadaam invaded Kuwait we were told by the Bush administration that Sadaam “was a force for moderation and stability in the region.” This despite the fact that with US backed arms he had killed a about a million Iranians, thousands of Kurds and Shiites, in chemical weapon attacks. Only when he disobeyed US orders did he become the “beast of Baghdad,” literally overnight.

In Iran the situation is much the same. A 1953 CIA coup overturned a democratically and parliamentary based populist party. Its leader, Mossadeq, committed the supreme crime of overseeing a parliament who passed legislation nationalizing Iranian oil. You know, the Iranians had this perverse idea that Iranian oil should benefit Iranians.

After the coup, the US installed the murderous Shah who for over 25 years killed tens of thousands of his own citizens. After shooting 1,000 in the street in 1978, Jimmy Carter sent him new shipments of military weapons and vowed his support for the tyrant. The Shah, in his memoirs, wrote that he was embarrassed by the persistent US support as his regime came tumbling down, as he said it made him feel “like a puppet.” If the shoe fits sir.

After the Shah was gone the US immediately turned to supporting Sadaam while he was invading and gassing Iran. This culminated in July of 1988 with the USS Vicennes shooting down an Iranian civilian airliner near Iranian territorial waters. What was the Vicennes doing there? It was supporting their friend Sadaam in his war against Iran. Medals were given to the commander of the Vicennes instead of a trial and imprisonment. As George Bush the first said at the time, “I don’t care what the facts are but I will never apologize for my country.” Imagine if every country adopted that vile mindset.

Despite a history of American war crimes towards Iran one might be surprised to learn that Iran is quite willing to forgive and forget. In 2003, Iran offered the United States a full peace proposal. Iran offered to recognize the state of Israel, support America in the war on terror and reign in Hezbollah. The Bush administration responded by “belittling” the proposal. According to a former Bush administration official the proposal was “part of a series of efforts by Iran to engage with the Bush Administration” and was a “missed opportunity.”

In fact, prior to these peace overtures, Iran had provided “key intelligence” both on Al-Qaeda and the Taliban. They also aided the toppling of Sadaam Hussein, a fact overlooked here.(2) During this time period Iran was undergoing a reformist movement providing a key opportunity for the US government to isolate hardline elements in Iran. According to the MIT international review, the reformists were rewarded with Iran’s inclusion “in the axis of evil-what amounted to a death sentence for the reformist movement that called for cooperation with the west.”(3) The hardliners quickly moved the reformers out and replaced them with President Ahmadinejad, whose inflammatory statements are at direct odds with the majority of the Iranian population.

In fact a vast majority of Iranians want better relations with the US, more secular political freedoms and a focus on the economy. A vast majority of Iranians also support peace with Israel as part of a broader peace agreement with America.

In July of 2014 the UN confirmed that Iran had complied with its obligations under the interim 6 month agreement with the United States. All of its “sensitive uranium” had been removed and compliance with UN inspectors flawless. According to US officials the 6 month agreement had been a “success” and yet only offered Iran modest returns. (5) Even this year, the President of Iran specifically signaled a desire to renew ties with Washington and forgive forget.(6)

The US has bludgeoned Iran for 7 decades. Period. Renewing diplomatic ties with Iran would strengthen reformist elements, in line with the population, who want to continue to whittle away the Ayatollahs power. Iran can also be a useful ally in helping to stem ISIS, a group that is more of a threat to Iran than the US.

To be clear, I am not calling for militarizing Iran. I am simply stating that the US should work with these peace overture and see where it leads. In the long run it will strengthen Israel, the US and Middle East in general.

Yet these moves will not be followed for one simple reason. The US doesn’t fear Iran for security reasons, they seek to control it as they do the great majority of other nations in the region.


(1) http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2006/06/17/AR2006061700727.html



(2) http://web.mit.edu/mitir/2009/online/us-iran.pdf

(3) ibid

(4) http://www.worldpublicopinion.org/pipa/articles/brmiddleeastnafricara/527.php

(5) http://www.reuters.com/article/2014/07/20/us-iran-nuclear-iaea-idUSKBN0FP0LW20140720

(6) http://www.timesofisrael.com/rouhani-iran-wants-friendly-relations-with-all-states/
Ok, that's only one post. You're going to have to hop to it if you're going to meet your America-hating quota. Chop-chop!
 
Ok, that's only one post. You're going to have to hop to it if you're going to meet your America-hating quota. Chop-chop!

US "war crimes" - check
Bush-bashing - check
CIA evil deeds - check
Genocidal Islamists are simply "misunderstood" - check

He's actually doing pretty well so far...:cool:
 
The middle east politics is very hard to follow as it changes every five minutes. I think the US backed Saddam because he was viewed as the lessor of two evils at the time.

What was the greater evil in 1989 or 1990 after the war with Iran was over? Well according to Bush we had to support Sadaam because of our duty to “support American exporters.”


Unless Hitler is alive, its hard to imagine Sadaam being the lesser of two evils then anyone.
 
What was the greater evil in 1989 or 1990 after the war with Iran was over? Well according to Bush we had to support Sadaam because of our duty to “support American exporters.”


Unless Hitler is alive, its hard to imagine Sadaam being the lesser of two evils then anyone.


and listen to the racist...a racist knows evil because he is evil!
 
I'd like to think that Guthrie...named after woody guthrie whose parents were klan members..and woody who wrote songs that were racist himself...could have a view point of his own..but I am sure the caucus told him what to say here.
 
US "war crimes" - check
Bush-bashing - check
CIA evil deeds - check
Genocidal Islamists are simply "misunderstood" - check

He's actually doing pretty well so far...:cool:
The purpose of my writing is to enlist Iran in aiding America counter the ISIS threat, of which I have written dozens of times here are genocidal maniacs. You hardly need me to tell you that they are genocidal maniacs.



I am not sure when I said any Islamist was misunderstood. What I did say is there is growing consensus within the Iranian people for ending conflict with Israel and the United States and that I think the US should pursue that path as a way for increases in American and Israeli security. The US understands this full well. There is no misunderstanding. What there is a difference of goals. The US seeks to control Iran, as trhey have done/attempted to do so since the 1950s. A documentary record you simply cant fathom a defense for.



The writing was also critical of the Ayatollah and hardliners in Iran. That is my point, strengthen the reformers who want peace with the US.



This is neither anti-American, or anti-Semitic. Your feeble attempts at labeling it as such indicate your inability to, once again, to discuss an issue on actual terms.



Neither of you have yet to even attempt to do so, once in any post of mine, now numbering in the 100s.



As always, when the partisan angles are taken out of a writing, you both have nothing to add.
 
Most of the old Guthrie songs were about socialism, disguised within a pop tune.
This land is your land this land is my land..... A good socialist message.
 
you left out the part where the Iranian regime is developing nuclear weapons to "erase the mistake that is israel", and that their control over the (recently departed) shi'ite government in Iraq is a major reason for the rise of ISIS, which felt the shi'ites were trying to do away with sunnis
 
I'd like to think that Guthrie...named after woody guthrie whose parents were klan members..and woody who wrote songs that were racist himself...could have a view point of his own..but I am sure the caucus told him what to say here.
Woody Guthrie singing and playing with a black man. The song he is singing is about John, Henry a black folk hero. Yeah, huge racist. Now you go back to your lying. Thanks for your usual dense moronic contributions of nothingness.

Seeing as you failed to respond to my post, your surrender of not being able to do so is accepted.



 
you left out the part where the Iranian regime is developing nuclear weapons to "erase the mistake that is israel", and that their control over the (recently departed) shi'ite government in Iraq is a major reason for the rise of ISIS, which felt the shi'ites were trying to do away with sunnis
There's not nearly enough Jew-hate and America-hate in those aspects, so they go unmentioned. Guthrie has a sheet of music and mustn't deviate.
 
you left out the part where the Iranian regime is developing nuclear weapons to "erase the mistake that is israel", and that their control over the (recently departed) shi'ite government in Iraq is a major reason for the rise of ISIS, which felt the shi'ites were trying to do away with sunnis
Well, according to the CIA ISIS was created as a result of the Iraqi invasion and US support for Maliki. Incidentally, they also predicted it and told Bush such before hand.


Well according to the CIA, Iranian influence over Maliki was basically non-existent. In fact, he was hand picked by the US government to take office. (http://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2014/04/28/what-we-left-behind)


I am not saying that figuratively. Bush literally hand picked him to take office despite the fact that he had historical ties to terrorist groups. Read the link above and you can hear CIA and Administration officials discussing it rather frankly.


Well according to the US government Iran has complied with terminating nuclear style uranium enrichment, as I cited a direct quote above.


As for the Ayatollahs inflammatory remarks I specifically mentioned them in the article, and showed that they are at odds with the actual view of the citizens of the country and considering they have dozens of times offered peace with the US and Israel, something the US government acknowledges were serious proposals(including reigning in Hamas and Hezbollah) we can take the ayatollahs comments for what they are. Monsterous and anti-semtic no doubt, but meant to stir up anti-Israeli sentiment to divert the populations focus from the failure of the Ayatollah. Again, not my conclusion, but the conclusion of the US government.


I know, I know, those pesky little facts.


FYI, those numbers at the bottom of the page correlate with citations. Just thought I should mention since you have never used on.
 
There's not nearly enough Jew-hate and America-hate in those aspects, so they go unmentioned. Guthrie has a sheet of music and mustn't deviate.
Yes advocating for strengthening Israel’s security, verbatim, as I did, is some real “jew hate.” Advocating supporting the internal groups in Iran who want to make peace with America and Israel is some real anti-Americanism and jew hate.


I hate America and Jews so much I want them to be more secure!!!!
 
Yes advocating for strengthening Israel’s security, verbatim, as I did, is some real “jew hate.” Advocating supporting the internal groups in Iran who want to make peace with America and Israel is some real anti-Americanism and jew hate.


I hate America and Jews so much I want them to be more secure!!!!
Ostensibly, it's a stable, nuclear Iran that you argue for...that Iran pledges to glassify Israel is of no significance. :-/
 
Ostensibly, it's a stable, nuclear Iran that you argue for...that Iran pledges to glassify Israel is of no significance. :-/
First, thank you for an actual comment.


No, Iran has already disabled any possibility of a nuclear weapons as verified by the UN, US and all of Europe. I cited as such.


What I advocate is a nuclear free Iran, as they have offered full peace with Israel and the US, no non-monitored nuclear technology and not of a near high enough grade for weapons, terminating support for Hezbollah and Hamas, and helping in the war on terror. This is their offer.



By doing so, hardliners in Iran would be weakened and eventually give way to the reformist majority who want closer ties with Israel and the US, etc.
 
It is commonly held throughout mainstream journalism that the Middle East has spun out of control. I don’t doubt that premise. Yet is the Middle East under control when our US backed dictators have bludgeoned their own populations into silence and obedience? When US backed oppression is succeeding, as it has for the better part of 7 decades, we call it “stability.” The underlying assumption is that if the people of the region are irrelevant then the US through its proxy autocrats are effectively carrying out the policy they have formulated.

Under this framework, murder, terror, torture have no relevance on American policy makers. So for example, a few weeks before Sadaam invaded Kuwait we were told by the Bush administration that Sadaam “was a force for moderation and stability in the region.” This despite the fact that with US backed arms he had killed a about a million Iranians, thousands of Kurds and Shiites, in chemical weapon attacks. Only when he disobeyed US orders did he become the “beast of Baghdad,” literally overnight.

In Iran the situation is much the same. A 1953 CIA coup overturned a democratically and parliamentary based populist party. Its leader, Mossadeq, committed the supreme crime of overseeing a parliament who passed legislation nationalizing Iranian oil. You know, the Iranians had this perverse idea that Iranian oil should benefit Iranians.

After the coup, the US installed the murderous Shah who for over 25 years killed tens of thousands of his own citizens. After shooting 1,000 in the street in 1978, Jimmy Carter sent him new shipments of military weapons and vowed his support for the tyrant. The Shah, in his memoirs, wrote that he was embarrassed by the persistent US support as his regime came tumbling down, as he said it made him feel “like a puppet.” If the shoe fits sir.

After the Shah was gone the US immediately turned to supporting Sadaam while he was invading and gassing Iran. This culminated in July of 1988 with the USS Vicennes shooting down an Iranian civilian airliner near Iranian territorial waters. What was the Vicennes doing there? It was supporting their friend Sadaam in his war against Iran. Medals were given to the commander of the Vicennes instead of a trial and imprisonment. As George Bush the first said at the time, “I don’t care what the facts are but I will never apologize for my country.” Imagine if every country adopted that vile mindset.

Despite a history of American war crimes towards Iran one might be surprised to learn that Iran is quite willing to forgive and forget. In 2003, Iran offered the United States a full peace proposal. Iran offered to recognize the state of Israel, support America in the war on terror and reign in Hezbollah. The Bush administration responded by “belittling” the proposal. According to a former Bush administration official the proposal was “part of a series of efforts by Iran to engage with the Bush Administration” and was a “missed opportunity.”

In fact, prior to these peace overtures, Iran had provided “key intelligence” both on Al-Qaeda and the Taliban. They also aided the toppling of Sadaam Hussein, a fact overlooked here.(2) During this time period Iran was undergoing a reformist movement providing a key opportunity for the US government to isolate hardline elements in Iran. According to the MIT international review, the reformists were rewarded with Iran’s inclusion “in the axis of evil-what amounted to a death sentence for the reformist movement that called for cooperation with the west.”(3) The hardliners quickly moved the reformers out and replaced them with President Ahmadinejad, whose inflammatory statements are at direct odds with the majority of the Iranian population.

In fact a vast majority of Iranians want better relations with the US, more secular political freedoms and a focus on the economy. A vast majority of Iranians also support peace with Israel as part of a broader peace agreement with America.

In July of 2014 the UN confirmed that Iran had complied with its obligations under the interim 6 month agreement with the United States. All of its “sensitive uranium” had been removed and compliance with UN inspectors flawless. According to US officials the 6 month agreement had been a “success” and yet only offered Iran modest returns. (5) Even this year, the President of Iran specifically signaled a desire to renew ties with Washington and forgive forget.(6)

The US has bludgeoned Iran for 7 decades. Period. Renewing diplomatic ties with Iran would strengthen reformist elements, in line with the population, who want to continue to whittle away the Ayatollahs power. Iran can also be a useful ally in helping to stem ISIS, a group that is more of a threat to Iran than the US.

To be clear, I am not calling for militarizing Iran. I am simply stating that the US should work with these peace overture and see where it leads. In the long run it will strengthen Israel, the US and Middle East in general.

Yet these moves will not be followed for one simple reason. The US doesn’t fear Iran for security reasons, they seek to control it as they do the great majority of other nations in the region.


(1) http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2006/06/17/AR2006061700727.html



(2) http://web.mit.edu/mitir/2009/online/us-iran.pdf

(3) ibid

(4) http://www.worldpublicopinion.org/pipa/articles/brmiddleeastnafricara/527.php

(5) http://www.reuters.com/article/2014/07/20/us-iran-nuclear-iaea-idUSKBN0FP0LW20140720

(6) http://www.timesofisrael.com/rouhani-iran-wants-friendly-relations-with-all-states/

The Iranians proffered extensive high level contacts with the Bush Administration after 9/11 in an attempt to mend fences, but Bush replied by calling them evil.

Bush sure knows evil.
 
The purpose of my writing is to enlist Iran in aiding America counter the ISIS threat, of which I have written dozens of times here are genocidal maniacs. You hardly need me to tell you that they are genocidal maniacs.

Did you think they were "genocidal maniacs" when they were calling themselves the "Arab Spring" and you and the other Obama worshipping lefties were cheering for their "revolution"?
 
Back
Top