New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

The 'contraception issue' in a nutshell...

Corruptbuddha

Governor
...lies in two simple facts:

1: A religious entity that accepts government money must abide by the rules set up by the government. Thus, if the Catholics wish to live by their anti-abortion/anti-contraception rules, they mustn't accept government monies.

2: Women who choose to be part of the Catholic Church and yet wish to use contraception, need to leave the Church. The hypocrisy in this case lies with the women who profess to be Catholics and yet don't wish to live by Catholic dogma. if you disagree with the Pope...leave the Church.

Or at least, that's how I see it.
 
...lies in two simple facts:

1: A religious entity that accepts government money must abide by the rules set up by the government. Thus, if the Catholics wish to live by their anti-abortion/anti-contraception rules, they mustn't accept government monies.

2: Women who choose to be part of the Catholic Church and yet wish to use contraception, need to leave the Church. The hypocrisy in this case lies with the women who profess to be Catholics and yet don't wish to live by Catholic dogma. if you disagree with the Pope...leave the Church.

Or at least, that's how I see it.

Actually a pretty fair assessment.

One of course that leaves the HRCC in the USA dramatically weakend.
 
I got no problem with your points there CB. Problem being, well over half of Catholics think that birth control is fine.

If they all leave at once, Bingo Night is going to be a ghost town! :D
 
I think it'd be fair to say that most Catholic men support the use of contraception too.
 
True, but what gets me is how anyone can be (or at least call themselves) a member of a Church and not live by it's tenets.

It doesn't make sense to me.
 
True, but what gets me is how anyone can be (or at least call themselves) a member of a Church and not live by it's tenets.

It doesn't make sense to me.

If people didn't make changes to their religion, we'd all still be talking about Mother Earth and Father Sky.
 
So, the 75% are trying to (spiritually) have their cake and eat it too?

Why would a person who adheres to any religion do that?

If you don't believe in a religion, you don't believe.

Move on.
 
Yes.

If that entity doesn't take government money, they don't have to abide due to religious freedoms.

Which means those employee would know of that restriction on hire.

One would think so anyway.
 
Nope.

What you suggest is allowing an organization to impose it's religous dogma on it's employees or introducing a financial penalty for not adhering to that dogma.

So much for the employees Freedom of Religon, eh?
 
Not true...I know some people who go to play bingo hoping to hit it big ($25) as their evening entertainment who aren't Catholic.
 
...lies in two simple facts:

1: A religious entity that accepts government money must abide by the rules set up by the government. Thus, if the Catholics wish to live by their anti-abortion/anti-contraception rules, they mustn't accept government monies.

2: Women who choose to be part of the Catholic Church and yet wish to use contraception, need to leave the Church. The hypocrisy in this case lies with the women who profess to be Catholics and yet don't wish to live by Catholic dogma. if you disagree with the Pope...leave the Church.

Or at least, that's how I see it.

I left but that was just one of many reasons for me.

If family planning is ok and not contraception when they are both used to avoid pregnancy, it makes no sense. That is why 50% or more Catholic women use contraception.
 
Dude...that's over half of the people that call themselves Christians...
 
So, the 75% are trying to (spiritually) have their cake and eat it too?

Why would a person who adheres to any religion do that?

If you don't believe in a religion, you don't believe.

Move on.

Well I have no understanding of the appeal of that irrationality either. But once you buy into the irrationality of faith, why would you think you would apply rationality to it?
 
Back
Top