New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

The first Amendment

Assuming that was just some childish gibbering, and you meant Obamacare, then you needn't fear that a slightly more activist government in the healthcare arena will mean censorship of that sort. Keep in mind, we already have a substantial portion of our population that is covered by a single-payer socialized healthcare system: Medicare. Add in Medicaid, and we've long been covering an even bigger portion than that with something that is considerably more socialized than the private-insurer healthcare system implemented under Obamacare. And Medicare isn't even the most socialized part of our healthcare system. I should know. I was born in a government-owned hospital, on the taxpayer dime, under the care of a doctor who worked directly for the federal government. That didn't mean my mother wasn't allowed to have a Bible. When that level of EXTREMELY socialized care didn't result in the kind of censorship you fear, why would a mere mandate to buy private health insurance do so?

While this has nothing to do with my post,
the concern isnt medicare OR medicaid in re to single payer.
The concern is one of state run single payer systems that will destroy Medicare and Medicaid.
Not a concern of mine mind you, but others worry about Medicare being destroyed
 
While this has nothing to do with my post,
the concern isnt medicare OR medicaid in re to single payer.
The concern is one of state run single payer systems that will destroy Medicare and Medicaid.
Again making assertions you cannot factually back up.

This has WHAT to do with Am 1 rights exactly?
 
Most of the examples on this thread are consistant to how courts have read the 1st, including the SCOTUS.
The threads purpose was not any of the courts opinions, rather the question of whether the US CONGRESS shall make or shall not make laws is regards to FOS, ect.
The answer, is a resonding "no"
And its not a "resounding no".... as you claim. Precisely because its a balance of rights issue. For example, my speech rights are somewhat infringed when I sit in the audience at graduation. Why? Because if I get up and start disrupting the Valedictorian's speech, I will be ejected from that public place.

Why? Balance of speech rights and the right of the rest of the audience to expect non-disruption

Same applies to religious observance. The Valedictorian is acting momentarily in a partial government capacity and is thus forbidden from acting in a manner that "establishes" a "state religon". Because in doing so the Valedictorian would violate my religious rights as an audience member.

You are making sh!t up when you say that the result is a "resounding NO" to congressional or state regulation. Either you are disengenuous or you don't understand complex multitiered logic.
 
And its not a "resounding no".... as you claim. Precisely because its a balance of rights issue. For example, my speech rights are somewhat infringed when I sit in the audience at graduation. Why? Because if I get up and start disrupting the Valedictorian's speech, I will be ejected from that public place.

Why? Balance of speech rights and the right of the rest of the audience to expect non-disruption

Same applies to religious observance. The Valedictorian is acting momentarily in a partial government capacity and is thus forbidden from acting in a manner that "establishes" a "state religon". Because in doing so the Valedictorian would violate my religious rights as an audience member.

I agree with that.
Next?
 
Again, I ask,
Can the US CONGRESS pass a law for or against religous FOS, ect?
The answer once again is no.
Why?
Because the 1st says they cant.
What you are attempting to do is extrapolate what I ask into a question of how courts interpret the 1st.
Its fine with me how the courts read the 1st, but again that isnt the question.
 
And its not a "resounding no".... as you claim. Precisely because its a balance of rights issue. For example, my speech rights are somewhat infringed when I sit in the audience at graduation. Why? Because if I get up and start disrupting the Valedictorian's speech, I will be ejected from that public place.

Why? Balance of speech rights and the right of the rest of the audience to expect non-disruption

Same applies to religious observance. The Valedictorian is acting momentarily in a partial government capacity and is thus forbidden from acting in a manner that "establishes" a "state religon". Because in doing so the Valedictorian would violate my religious rights as an audience member.

I agree with that.
Next?
Since the state can regulate what is and is not disruptive in a school setting, it can regulate what types of religious observance are and are not disruptive in a religiously neutral manner.

Thus the state CAN Constittionally prohibit certain types of prayer and religious observance. Something you claim there is a "resounding No" about.

What it means also is that your "The top post is supposed to be a simple question" is a case of you making things "too simplistic" contrary to Einstein's admonition that things should be as simple AS POSSIBLE but NO SIMPLER - you tried to make them simpler because it serves your ideological ends.

You are simply wrong in this case.
 
Lets say the US Congress wants to pass a law that says
"Prayers are not allowed in schools"
They would have to amend the 1st, because the 1st specifically says they cannot make such a law.
 
Why is the answer "no"?

Because the 1st says they cant.
Its really that simple
And that's just not true. Congress can and has passed laws governing press freedoms. And they have been upheld sometimes with solid logic sometimes not. For example, while NYTimes v Pentagon cut back on earlier prior restraint rulings, there still is a restraint of the press if it will "aide the enemy"... IE Treason laws still stand and still apply to and limit press freedoms (this has been at issue WRT various Gitmo stories).

So yes Congress CAN write laws that impinge on press freedoms.

BUT it must do so very carefully - and frankly much more carefully since the liberals have held sway in the courts than when conservatives did.
 
14th Amendment's "incorporation clause" makes Am 1 apply equally to states or Congress.

So your point of generalizing that Congress cannot in ANY WAY ban or regulate prayer in schools is wrong.
[/B]
Now am I wrong?
I cannot parse this in a way that makes sense of it. please clarify
 
Lets say the US Congress wants to pass a law that says
"Prayers are not allowed in schools"
They would have to amend the 1st, because the 1st specifically says they cannot make such a law.
That's a specific law that you have arbitrarily constructed. It is not a generalized example of all such laws.

Congress COULD PASS a law that says

  • Any classroom behaviour that disrupts the secular education process is forbidden
  • Any religious observances in schools that are done by those in a position of authority are banned
  • Any religious observances that disrupt the secular educatin process is forbidden

(actually Congress cannot but states can - since regulation of schools is a State's right, but is subject to the incorporation clause nevertheless).... Each of the above has the effect of banning some forms of school prayer. All are fully consistent with the 1st Amendment protections.
 
Lets say the US Congress wants to pass a law that says
"Prayers are not allowed in schools"
They would have to amend the 1st, because the 1st specifically says they cannot make such a law.

Yes, I think that an outright law saying that private individuals cannot pray in a private manner while on public school grounds would be struck down by a court as a violation of the first amendment, on either free speech or free expression grounds, or both. On the other hand, a rule that banned disruptive speech, religious or otherwise, during instructional time would be upheld.
 
While this has nothing to do with my post,
the concern isnt medicare OR medicaid in re to single payer.
The concern is one of state run single payer systems that will destroy Medicare and Medicaid.
Not a concern of mine mind you, but others worry about Medicare being destroyed

Medicare is essentially a single-payer system -- as is the military healthcare system, which is the other one I was talking about. For someone to be worried that Obamacare (not a single-payer system, by the way) will destroy those others is a bit odd.
 
That's a specific law that you have arbitrarily constructed. It is not a generalized example of all such laws.

Congress COULD PASS a law that says

  • Any classroom behaviour that disrupts the secular education process is forbidden
  • Any religious observances in schools that are done by those in a position of authority are banned
  • Any religious observances that disrupt the secular educatin process is forbidden

(actually Congress cannot but states can - since regulation of schools is a State's right, but is subject to the incorporation clause nevertheless).... Each of the above has the effect of banning some forms of school prayer. All are fully consistent with the 1st Amendment protections
.
I am glad you clearified that.
US Congress cant, and THAt was the gist of TP
 
All religious institutions were being zoned out of the muslim neighborhood... that was easy.
 
Back
Top