New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

The first Amendment

I am glad you clearified that.
US Congress cant, and THAt was the gist of TP
No that's not quite it. Again - since Congress provides fudning for many schools, it can conditionally (conditioned on the funding) regulate those schools. That is how for example Garfield HS in Seattle was forced to allow military recruiters on campus against objections of the local parents and school board. Because Garfield takes "hot breakfast" money from the Feds, the Feds get to say alot about what goes on on campus.

And no the Gist of your TP was about the 1st Amendment. NOT about the 10th Amendment or Article IV... which is what my point aobut "(acutually Congress cannot but states can...)". So no your top post was not about the caveat I made... not even close.

You really need to learn about how The Constitution functions and its history before you engage in these sorts of discussions.

A good starting place is the annoted version of the US Constitution that Cornell Law has online: http://www.law.cornell.edu/anncon/html/index.html

Please read that so that we can have an intersting and informed conversation about Constitutional issues and not this sort of randomized nonsense.
 
(not a single-payer system, by the way)

It will be
Based on what?

Do you realize that not even France is "single payer"? That even in France there is supplemental insurance available?

Your comment betray's a profound ignorance of how the Constitution works. Neither Congress nor the States can ban private contracting of behaviour that is not criminal. This goes back to the earliest days of the Constitution and the earliest sessions of the Supreme Court.

That you don't seem to understand the implications of that on Single Payer is rather disappointing.
 
No that's not quite it. Again - since Congress provides fudning for many schools, it can conditionally (conditioned on the funding) regulate those schools. That is how for example Garfield HS in Seattle was forced to allow military recruiters on campus against objections of the local parents and school board. Because Garfield takes "hot breakfast" money from the Feds, the Feds get to say alot about what goes on on campus.

And no the Gist of your TP was about the 1st Amendment. NOT about the 10th Amendment or Article IV... which is what my point aobut "(acutually Congress cannot but states can...)". So no your top post was not about the caveat I made... not even close.

You really need to learn about how The Constitution functions and its history before you engage in these sorts of discussions.

A good starting place is the annoted version of the US Constitution that Cornell Law has online: http://www.law.cornell.edu/anncon/html/index.html

Please read that so that we can have an intersting and informed conversation about Constitutional issues and not this sort of randomized nonsense.

Again you throw a court opinion at me, and again I say court opinions about the 1st have no bearing on the question I ask in my TP.
You insist that I am denying the constitutionality of the 1st which is not only incorrect, but of not importance to the original question that I ask.
You are arguing apples, while I am asking about oranges.

I did not get a response to this,

IF within the 1st was "Congress shall make no laws governing a right turn on a red light" can congress then pass a law that says 'You cannot turn on a red light"?
The answer to that is "no" because if they did the 1st would have to be rewriten
But can the State?
the answer to that is "yes"
I am not arguing that because the 1st says Congress (meaning the US Congress) shall make no law...doesnt mean that the States cannot make such laws.
as a matter of fact, it uses that particular wording so States CAN make their own laws
 
Well first off, the Court is what defines what the law means. But no I'm not throwing a court opinion at you, I'm throwing functional precedent and implementation.

You are arguing simplistic textualism taken out of context. Your example:
IF within the 1st was "Congress shall make no laws governing a right turn on a red light" can congress then pass a law that says 'You cannot turn on a red light"?
The answer to that is "no" because if they did the 1st would have to be rewriten
is wrong. Because if that is set WITHIN the Constitution, then a law that governs commerce for example, and only by indirection afects Right On Red (say the licensing requirements for Interstate Trucking Licenses) does allow Congress to pass regulations that affect Right On Red behaviour.

IF within the 1st was "Congress shall make no laws governing a right turn on a red light" can congress then pass a law that says 'You cannot turn on a red light"?
The answer to that is "no" because if they did the 1st would have to be rewriten
But can the State?
the answer to that is "yes"
Also wrong. Because again the 1st Amendment sits within the framing contexts of the 5th and 14th Amendment's "due process" clauses as well as the Supremacy Clause and the 14th Amendment's "incorporation clause".

The net COMBINATION of which basically precludes a state from also infringing on Right Turn On Red since doing so would violate the rights granted to drivers by the Supreme Law of the Land (Supremacy clause) without a Due Process hearing (Ams 5 and 14) and would do so in a manner that treated drivers who got licenses in different states differently (Equal Protection Clause).

And since there were no "red lights" at ratification (1789) or ratification of Am 14 (1868) then states had no "incoroporated rights" to regulate such activity.

That's where your lack of understanding of how the Constitution works IN THE AGGREGATE is getting you in deep kimchee.


The reason STATES can regulate schools and not Congress, is that at the time of ratification of the TENTH AMENDMENT (not the 1st) State's and not the Fed had regulatory authority over schools. And thus school regulation is not one of the "powers delegated to the United States".

But that does not change that states are constrained by the 1st Amendment as well.. due to Am 5 and Am 14 "Due Process" clauses as well as the explicit "incorporation clause" of the 14th Amendment.


So it has nothing to do with the fact that Am 1 speaks of "Congress shall make no law"... and rather has to do with The 10th Amendment and delegated vs. incorporated powers.

Again. Please read the annotated Constitution before engaging in these simplistic "analysises".

\
 
The reason STATES can regulate schools and not Congress

Exactly what I have been trying to say.
States can regulate schools, congress cannot.
Because Congress has said,
Congress Shall make no laws...........
Thats exactly what I am talking about.
And thats ALL I am talking about.
 
The reason STATES can regulate schools and not Congress

Exactly what I have been trying to say.
States can regulate schools, congress cannot.
Because Congress has said,
Congress Shall make no laws...........
And that is wrong... the reason States can regulate SCHOOLS and Congress cannot has nothing to do with the 1st ammendment

It is purely an issue of the 10th Amendment and "incorporated powers"... namely Public Education is a STATE POWER that was retained at ratification AS A STATE POWER.

Thats exactly what I am talking about.
And thats ALL I am talking about.
No its not. Because it has nothing to do with the Phrase "Congress shall make no law"..

Your analysis is simply wrong.
 
Back
Top