New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

The Garner situation in a nutshell

MrMike

Bless you all
And this is only my opinion

1) Garner should have complied with the officers request (I hear he was out on bail/had 30+ arrests for things like assault/larceny/resisting arrest etc, so he should know the routine well enough).

2) It can be argued that the officers used too much force on him (that is debatable) however there's no doubt Garners health played a significant role in his demise plus see item 1 (if he had complied, none of this would have happened).

3) Race had nothing to do with the Garner arrest and his subsequent death. Those that claim it is racially motivated are merely doing so out of utter ignorance/or for gain/position.
 
And this is only my opinion

1) Garner should have complied with the officers request (I hear he was out on bail/had 30+ arrests for things like assault/larceny/resisting arrest etc, so he should know the routine well enough).

2) It can be argued that the officers used too much force on him (that is debatable) however there's no doubt Garners health played a significant role in his demise plus see item 1 (if he had complied, none of this would have happened).

3) Race had nothing to do with the Garner arrest and his subsequent death. Those that claim it is racially motivated are merely doing so out of utter ignorance/or for gain/position.
A police officer used a choke hold that had been officially forbidden and it resulted in the death of an unarmed man. I don't know whether race played a role. I do know that the you could make a damned strong case for felony murder, when someone willfully carries out an illegal violent act that results in a death.
 
Sorry, but when I heard of the supposed "choke hold" watched and listened to the video and heard Garner say out loud that he couldn't breath (during the supposed illegal choke out), I knew he wasn't actually choked as described.

From watching the video I think emotion, pressure (chest) and the overall impact of the take-down was enough to cause Garner to pass the tipping point due to his obviously poor condition. His post arrest treatment (good/bad) by medical staff had nothing to do with the arrest.

If people want to argue Garner shouldn't have been arrested for selling cigarettes as he was doing, that's a completely different debate topic. However, the guy wasn't a saint and he could be alive today had he merely complied with officer instructions.

A police officer used a choke hold that had been officially forbidden and it resulted in the death of an unarmed man. I don't know whether race played a role. I do know that the you could make a damned strong case for felony murder, when someone willfully carries out an illegal violent act that results in a death.
 
i agree that race had nothing to with this. he was a career criminal who thought he could get away with resisting arrest since the officers were much smaller.

that said,resising arrest doesn't necessarily give you permission to use a chokehold, shoot someone, etc.

there's a protocol here: (a) tasers; (b) pepper spray; (c) call for additional backup
 
Sorry, but when I heard of the supposed "choke hold" watched and listened to the video and heard Garner say out loud that he couldn't breath (during the supposed illegal choke out), I knew he wasn't actually choked as described.

From watching the video I think emotion, pressure (chest) and the overall impact of the take-down was enough to cause Garner to pass the tipping point due to his obviously poor condition. His post arrest treatment (good/bad) by medical staff had nothing to do with the arrest.

If people want to argue Garner shouldn't have been arrested for selling cigarettes as he was doing, that's a completely different debate topic. However, the guy wasn't a saint and he could be alive today had he merely complied with officer instructions.
There's a reason the choke hold was forbidden in the first place. It's very dangerous. And yet the cop took it upon himself to break the rules and do it anyway. And his victim said he couldn't breathe, and then died. If you want to think that the dangerous choke-hold and the death that followed it were unrelated, and that the victim was lying when he said he couldn't breathe, that's about your emotional issues, not any sane response to the evidence.
 
i agree that race had nothing to with this. he was a career criminal who thought he could get away with resisting arrest since the officers were much smaller.

that said,resising arrest doesn't necessarily give you permission to use a chokehold, shoot someone, etc.

there's a protocol here: (a) tasers; (b) pepper spray; (c) call for additional backup
We don't know whether race had anything to do with it. However, as you point out, there's proper police procedure, and this cop didn't follow it, and that resulted in someone dying. It's amazing that there may be no repercussions for that.
 
If he was in a complete choke, he wouldn't have been speaking. I suspect his heart was already failing at that point and he was feeling the acute initial symptoms of his heart failure.


There's a reason the choke hold was forbidden in the first place. It's very dangerous. And yet the cop took it upon himself to break the rules and do it anyway. And his victim said he couldn't breathe, and then died. If you want to think that the dangerous choke-hold and the death that followed it were unrelated, and that the victim was lying when he said he couldn't breathe, that's about your emotional issues, not any sane response to the evidence.
 
If he was in a complete choke, he wouldn't have been speaking. I suspect his heart was already failing at that point and he was feeling the acute initial symptoms of his heart failure.
You don't need to have your windpipe completely closed in order to be at risk. For example, with a bad asthma attack, it's like trying to breathe through a narrow straw. You can still talk, but your lips will start turning blue, the world will swim before your eyes, and your heart will race. A girl at my school died of an asthma attack, and just a few seconds before she blacked out, she was pleading to be taken to the hospital. So, I don't have any doubt that a person could be starting to die from a choke hold and yet still be able to talk.

His heart giving out can be a symptom of suffocation. For example, people who die of sleep apnea often die from the heart not being able to take the strain, as it elevates blood pressure and pulse to try to get oxygen to the tissues, while breathing is blocked. Reggie White, for example, died of a cardiac arythmia that was probably brought on by sleep apnea.
 
We don't know whether race had anything to do with it. However, as you point out, there's proper police procedure, and this cop didn't follow it, and that resulted in someone dying. It's amazing that there may be no repercussions for that.
He died from positional asphyxia. This is possible ANY time a suspect is lying prone on a flat surface.

Besides the banned chokehold used by Officer Daniel Pantaleo, who brought Mr. Garner down, throwing a beefy arm around his neck, there was lethal danger in the way Mr. Garner was subdued — on his stomach, with a pile of cops on his back.
This breaks a basic rule of safe arrests, especially for people who, like Mr. Garner, are overweight and have medical problems like asthma. When the New York medical examiner’s office ruled Mr. Garner’s death a homicide, it cited “compression of neck (choke hold), compression of chest and prone positioning during physical restraint by police.”
As early as 1995, a Department of Justice bulletin on “positional asphyxia” quoted the New York Police Department’s guidelines on preventing deaths in custody. “As soon as the subject is handcuffed, get him off his stomach. Turn him on his side or place him in a seated position.”
As Michael Baden, a former chief medical examiner of New York City, told The Times: “Obese people especially, lying face down, prone, are unable to breathe when enough pressure is put on their back. The pressure prevents the diaphragm from going up and down, and he can’t inhale and exhale.”

http://www.nytimes.com/2014/12/05/o...-pantaleo-and-lethal-police-tactics.html?_r=0

That means, without the chokehold being used in any capacity, Garner may have died from the prone position plus the stress of the encounter and his physical ailments.
He was not choked to death and DID NOT die of immediate use of the choke hold.
 
He died from positional asphyxia. This is possible ANY time a suspect is lying prone on a flat surface.

Besides the banned chokehold used by Officer Daniel Pantaleo, who brought Mr. Garner down, throwing a beefy arm around his neck, there was lethal danger in the way Mr. Garner was subdued — on his stomach, with a pile of cops on his back.
This breaks a basic rule of safe arrests, especially for people who, like Mr. Garner, are overweight and have medical problems like asthma. When the New York medical examiner’s office ruled Mr. Garner’s death a homicide, it cited “compression of neck (choke hold), compression of chest and prone positioning during physical restraint by police.”
As early as 1995, a Department of Justice bulletin on “positional asphyxia” quoted the New York Police Department’s guidelines on preventing deaths in custody. “As soon as the subject is handcuffed, get him off his stomach. Turn him on his side or place him in a seated position.”
As Michael Baden, a former chief medical examiner of New York City, told The Times: “Obese people especially, lying face down, prone, are unable to breathe when enough pressure is put on their back. The pressure prevents the diaphragm from going up and down, and he can’t inhale and exhale.”

http://www.nytimes.com/2014/12/05/o...-pantaleo-and-lethal-police-tactics.html?_r=0

That means, without the chokehold being used in any capacity, Garner may have died from the prone position plus the stress of the encounter and his physical ailments.
He was not choked to death and DID NOT die of immediate use of the choke hold.
Did the official autopsy rule out a role for the choke hold?
 
Did the official autopsy rule out a role for the choke hold?
As part of the trauma he suffered during the process of gaining compliance, I can't imagine it would not be part of the medical examiner's findings.
 
There's a reason the choke hold was forbidden in the first place. It's very dangerous. And yet the cop took it upon himself to break the rules and do it anyway. And his victim said he couldn't breathe, and then died. If you want to think that the dangerous choke-hold and the death that followed it were unrelated, and that the victim was lying when he said he couldn't breathe, that's about your emotional issues, not any sane response to the evidence.

There was negligence in the use of the "choke" hold and maybe even the EMS response. It does not rise to the level of murder or even manslaughter. Especially not racially motivated.

Do you know how many perps while being arrested claim some kind of duress such as breathing? Many.
 
We don't know whether race had anything to do with it. However, as you point out, there's proper police procedure, and this cop didn't follow it, and that resulted in someone dying. It's amazing that there may be no repercussions for that.

just because the grand jury muffed it,that doen't equate "no repercussion". some likely ones:

1 - retraining all 22,000 NYC officers
2 - civil suit by the widow; court settlement
3 - diblasio has announced he WONT make it illegal to use chokeholds, which seems to undercut his previous outrage.
 
There was negligence in the use of the "choke" hold and maybe even the EMS response. It does not rise to the level of murder or even manslaughter. Especially not racially motivated.

Do you know how many perps while being arrested claim some kind of duress such as breathing? Many.
I don't know New York criminal law, but the theory I was talking about was "felony murder." The rule, under the common law, is that when an offender accidentally kills someone during the commission of a felony, he can be charged with murder. So, if the choke hold wasn't a legitimate police action, it instead could be argued to be aggravated assault, and, if so, then the death could be an accidental death during the commission of a felony, and thus the felony-murder rule comes into play. It would be a bit like a bank robber who accidentally runs over and kills someone when fleeing the scene... even though he may have had no intention of killing anyone, he could still be charged with murder.
 
I don't know New York criminal law, but the theory I was talking about was "felony murder." The rule, under the common law, is that when an offender accidentally kills someone during the commission of a felony, he can be charged with murder. So, if the choke hold wasn't a legitimate police action, it instead could be argued to be aggravated assault, and, if so, then the death could be an accidental death during the commission of a felony, and thus the felony-murder rule comes into play. It would be a bit like a bank robber who accidentally runs over and kills someone when fleeing the scene... even though he may have had no intention of killing anyone, he could still be charged with murder.

There is a law on the books in NY that states that using a choke hold by anybody is a felony?
 
just because the grand jury muffed it,that doen't equate "no repercussion". some likely ones:

1 - retraining all 22,000 NYC officers
2 - civil suit by the widow; court settlement
3 - diblasio has announced he WONT make it illegal to use chokeholds, which seems to undercut his previous outrage.

3 - chokeholds were already against NYC police policy. only the legislature can make chokeholds illegal.
 
There is a law on the books in NY that states that using a choke hold by anybody is a felony?
I don't know NY criminal law, as I said. However, I would guess that aggravated assault laws aren't set up based on particular holds or moves, but rather based on more general definitions triggered by their being a illegal violence that causes serious harm. If the choke hold was outlawed, then it would be illegal violence, and in this case caused serious harm.
 
The grand jury already reviewed the evidence and issued a no-bill.

It's academic now...

I don't know NY criminal law, as I said. However, I would guess that aggravated assault laws aren't set up based on particular holds or moves, but rather based on more general definitions triggered by their being a illegal violence that causes serious harm. If the choke hold was outlawed, then it would be illegal violence, and in this case caused serious harm.
 
And this is only my opinion

1) Garner should have complied with the officers request (I hear he was out on bail/had 30+ arrests for things like assault/larceny/resisting arrest etc, so he should know the routine well enough).

2) It can be argued that the officers used too much force on him (that is debatable) however there's no doubt Garners health played a significant role in his demise plus see item 1 (if he had complied, none of this would have happened).

3) Race had nothing to do with the Garner arrest and his subsequent death. Those that claim it is racially motivated are merely doing so out of utter ignorance/or for gain/position.

1) How many of those arrest resulted in a conviction ? Garner makes it clear in the video that he is being unfairly target by this officer and police in general. Which would definitely be a contributing factor in his demeanor.

2) Excessive force is not debatable if they killed him. Actually killing someone is pretty much the definition of excessive force. Does the coroner's say that it played a significant role or does it say he died due to compression of the neck and chest ?

3) If he was being continuously harassed as he claimed he had in the video then race my have played a role the targeting of Garner by officers. Again how many of his arrest resulted in convictions ? After all we know with stop and frisk that the NYPD is using race as a reason as a deciding factor in minorities for stops and arrest.
 
There's a reason the choke hold was forbidden in the first place. It's very dangerous. And yet the cop took it upon himself to break the rules and do it anyway. And his victim said he couldn't breathe, and then died. If you want to think that the dangerous choke-hold and the death that followed it were unrelated, and that the victim was lying when he said he couldn't breathe, that's about your emotional issues, not any sane response to the evidence.
The so-called "choke-hold" (which is actually a sleeper hold, and exerts pressure against the carotid artery, rather than the windpipe) was banned because it scared the hell out of observers who didn't understand what they were looking at. Remember Rodney King? If one of those cops had been allowed to slap one on him and make him take a little nap, they wouldn't have ended up on video whaling on a guy with batons. :cool: As for it being "very dangerous", I end up in a similar hold about once a week and I'm still here.
 
Back
Top