as seen on tv
Senator
The US constitution says that states may not assess levies or taxes on "internet commerce", as this would be violate your right to shop for the best deal. Harry Reid has a plan to end all that nonsense.
The senate has just passed a bill to allow states to collect sales tax on something you buy out of state, but have shipped to you. Not just electronics and books (‘the Amazon tax”), but medicine, food, clothing – life’s little necessities. Even stuff you download may not be safe. The iTunes store could be compelled to assess a levy for every 99 cent download you make.
States are spending more than they collect in taxes. I totally get this. But that’s mostly a function of so many people being unemployed and reduced incomes among those lucky enough to have jobs. Income and property taxes are “progressive” – that is, the wealthy(er) pay a higher share than the ne’er do wells. Not so with internet/sales taxes. It’s hard to make the case that a 99 cent iTunes download is a valid target of state revenue agents. Maybe it can be construed as a luxury tax? If you’re well off enough to own an iPhone in these hard times, and have 99 cents to spare, you’re not paying your fair share toward those less fortunate?
The rationale for sales taxes – the real kind, on actual stuff you bought in person – was that physical stores require roads, police and fire protection, water and sewer services, etc. Taxes on the stuff you buy at the store – sales taxes, store income taxes, real estate taxes, etc. are a way to pay for the “costs” incurred by having convenient shopping in well regulated, properly zoned business districts.
No such rationale exists when politicians insist on a “piece of the action” for out of state purchases. None of those ancillary "real store" state-level expenses exist. The way Harry Reid sees it, if you ever went online to buy a book, a red flannel shirt, or download a Jonas Brothers tune, you’ve ripped off the government by failing to pay tax.
Delaware, and some other states, have the apparent solution. It’s called “tax free shopping”. Sort of like a duty-free zone, but right here in the US, instead of a special cordoned off airport mall. You can drive across the state line from Maryland (where sales tax is “very high”) to Delaware, where there isn’t any. This strategy doesn’t work if you’re making a quick run for tee-shirts or milk. But if you’ve had your eye on a flat screen TV, some IKEA furniture, or a new car, it works wonders. You save A LOT.
So what’s next, Mr. Reid? Are you going to author legislation to place checkpoints on I-95, to stop vehicles suspected of carrying Samsung and Apple products purchased out of state, and issue fines and collect taxes, on the spot? On what rationale? (Random thought – could I start a company that trains dogs to sniff out and “alert” the presence of undeclared high end electronics? Police departments will be eager for this, I believe).
Don’t laugh, and say it can’t happen. The District of Colombia already does this, with cars crossing the Rosslyn Bridge from Virginia back to DC. They make you open your trunk to see if you’re carrying liquor into Georgetown. And you KNOW who lives in Georgetown, don’t you? Millionaire democrats and their congressional aides (at least the ones who don’t live in low-tax Virginia) the guys who know a bargain when they see one, but profess to see no hypocrisy in their tax dodging actions.
Want to guess how many of these same legislators also have unregistered guns in their homes? DC has “very strict” gun laws, you know.
Full disclosure – you’re actually allowed a small – very small – amount of liquor to bring back from Virginia into DC. I think it’s something like one six pack or 2 bottles of wine. Enjoy.
