New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

The Question Is,

And how would you know that is the truth? Because it feels right?

What you have defined above is close to deism, as far as I am concerned. Nothing short of real danger. Or it is the gospel according to MaryAnne.

You have come to the conclusion that God has never manifested himself to mankind in any meaningful way, and therefore, we are free to define God's wishes, God's laws, God's message however we choose. That should work out swimmingly with little chance for conflict.

Truth? Not a chance. Jesus Christ did not come down to earth to be humiliated and tortured because it did not matter to God the Father what we thought or what we did. Simple as that.

Deism is a danger??? Jefferson was a deist. The Masons are deist. One need not have a massive organization to have faith. or a belief in The Creator. I see the danger exactly opposite of what you see. The danger is a religious organization demanding their way be the way for all others.
 
Deism is a danger??? Jefferson was a deist. The Masons are deist. One need not have a massive organization to have faith. or a belief in The Creator. I see the danger exactly opposite of what you see. The danger is a religious organization demanding their way be the way for all others.

Do you believe in God, the creator of humanity and eternal life? Then deism is a real danger. Far more deadly than agnosticism.

You know what message the devil loves to promote to willing ears? "Do as thou wilt." That is precisely what deism says. Ignorance is surely not bliss.
 
Do you believe in God, the creator of humanity and eternal life? Then deism is a real danger. Far more deadly than agnosticism.

You know what message the devil loves to promote to willing ears? "Do as thou wilt." That is precisely what deism says. Ignorance is surely not bliss.

You have a very bad memory. I linked the 4 different positions that Americans have regarding God. I told you I believed in the Distant God. Belief in The Creator...is belief in God.

You obviously believe in the authoritarian and bitter God.
 
You have a very bad memory. I linked the 4 different positions that Americans have regarding God. I told you I believed in the Distant God. Belief in The Creator...is belief in God.

You obviously believe in the authoritarian and bitter God.

Yeah, dynamite. We have TIME magazine as a real authority on theology defining God and truth for us. And you are one of the first to jump!

Who is Jesus Christ, Craig? Shall we let TIME magazine be our eternal guide on that one, too?

So you are a self-described deist? That is just lovely. You know what? The devil loves deism almost as much as atheism. Do as thou wilt, he pleads. And have a good time while you are here. What a lovely theology. So full of mercy and charity and sacrifice.
 
Yeah, dynamite. We have TIME magazine as a real authority on theology defining God and truth for us. And you are one of the first to jump!

Who is Jesus Christ, Craig? Shall we let TIME magazine be our eternal guide on that one, too?

So you are a self-described deist? That is just lovely. You know what? The devil loves deism almost as much as atheism. Do as thou wilt, he pleads. And have a good time while you are here. What a lovely theology. So full of mercy and charity and sacrifice.

You're extremely judgmental and prone to leaping to poorly considered conclusions. Time ran a survey...not an article. They reported what the citizenry stated. Sorry that offends you so much. Perhaps you should join a Monastery where you can practice your faith in peace and not have to deal with such dangers as other's belief in God.
 
You're extremely judgmental and prone to leaping to poorly considered conclusions. Time ran a survey...not an article. They reported what the citizenry stated. Sorry that offends you so much. Perhaps you should join a Monastery where you can practice your faith in peace and not have to deal with such dangers as other's belief in God.

Well I may be judgmental but I am not naïve. TIME magazine has a history of disparaging Christianity, Catholicism in particular, and sowing the seeds of doubt. A long history. So do you think all of a sudden they have no agenda on religion with this article? Do you think the act of TIME choosing what facts or stories to report on religion and which to ignore may have an effect on forming opinions of their readers? I will answer that for you --- Yes, it surely does!

So TIME chose to report on a particular survey, what of it? My understanding is that they said Americans generally have one of four ideas of who God is --- they see God as either authoritarian, benevolent, critical or distant. Yeah, so what of it? What is the point, TIME? What is the point, Craig?

As I said, TIME has an agenda and it has always been to cause doubt and drive Christians into a secular way of thinking and less “God-ordered.” This survey serves no meaningful purpose, unless you want to provide one for me? Christianity does not define God in such a base and oversimplistic way. God can be all four of those attributes and much more. So, again, what is the point?

And looking at your two signature statements below, did you care to expound on any of that? Or are we to guess once again? So we guess (because you are too reluctant to be very dogmatic on anything) and that makes us judgmental. Very convenient.
 
Deism is a danger??? Jefferson was a deist. The Masons are deist. One need not have a massive organization to have faith. or a belief in The Creator. I see the danger exactly opposite of what you see. The danger is a religious organization demanding their way be the way for all others.

Bingo, Craig. And I do not like my faith being besmirched by those who have a political agenda. I know what Jesus asked us to do,and hate was not there.

Do not get me wrong,I am not Miss Perfect. I do have a very strong sense of right and wrong. Took me years to quit thinking what others may say.
 
Do you believe in God, the creator of humanity and eternal life? Then deism is a real danger. Far more deadly than agnosticism.

You know what message the devil loves to promote to willing ears? "Do as thou wilt." That is precisely what deism says. Ignorance is surely not bliss.

Jesus said,"Go and sin no more!" I prefer his words.

You see,JV, I have no desire to decide what you should think. I could care less.
 
No. I'm merely calling you out for your blatant hypocrisy.


And what do you mean by that NS?

Do you mean because I ask someone for evidence of their claims I am being a hypocrite, because I claim to have evidence for my claims?

I can only guess what you mean. I can also only guess what you use for a basis for calling yourself a Christian, too, because I have missed the evidence in the words I have read of yours. (still willing to learn, however)
 
Jesus said,"Go and sin no more!" I prefer his words.

You see,JV, I have no desire to decide what you should think. I could care less.

You mean you prefer certain words of Jesus, but not all.

If you could not care less what I think, then fine, do as you please. But that is not what Jesus asked of us. He prefers courage over letting others walk off a cliff by not interfering.
 
I no longer call myself a Christian. It doesn't feel right. Your feelings are your own business.


Well that did not take long. At least someone was moved by the converations on these boards to draw new conclusions.

My feelings are my own business. Whatever that is supposed to mean? Is everyone afraid now to consider others' opinions? Kind of flies in the face of the purpose of this board, does it not?
 
Well I may be judgmental but I am not naïve. TIME magazine has a history of disparaging Christianity, Catholicism in particular, and sowing the seeds of doubt. A long history. So do you think all of a sudden they have no agenda on religion with this article? Do you think the act of TIME choosing what facts or stories to report on religion and which to ignore may have an effect on forming opinions of their readers? I will answer that for you --- Yes, it surely does!

So TIME chose to report on a particular survey, what of it? My understanding is that they said Americans generally have one of four ideas of who God is --- they see God as either authoritarian, benevolent, critical or distant. Yeah, so what of it? What is the point, TIME? What is the point, Craig?

As I said, TIME has an agenda and it has always been to cause doubt and drive Christians into a secular way of thinking and less “God-ordered.” This survey serves no meaningful purpose, unless you want to provide one for me? Christianity does not define God in such a base and oversimplistic way. God can be all four of those attributes and much more. So, again, what is the point?

And looking at your two signature statements below, did you care to expound on any of that? Or are we to guess once again? So we guess (because you are too reluctant to be very dogmatic on anything) and that makes us judgmental. Very convenient.

I think you base your opinions on ignorance. I think you run down anything or anyone that doesn't adhere to your dogmatism. I know you judge and condemn others that believe differently than you. The Time survey disturbs because it paints a different picture than you do. It paints a broad belief and different povs than you have. Therefore...it's a danger to you, just as reveling the truth of a miracle is dangerous to you. Therefore you need to say Time is anti Catholic. It's transparent...and you use this method regularly.

My quotes are a challenge to you, obviously. You've commented on them, before. First of all...there aren't mine. There are Lenny Bruce's. Now...am I in agreement with them? Yes, I am. And? Is not the crucifix a death machine, just as the electric chair? Why yes, it is. And did not the Creator make your body? Why yes, He did.
 
I can interpret the empirical signs God has given to His creation. That is one way I am certain.

So basically, Maryanne "doesn't know the truth"...but "you do"? And how are your "empirical signs" any different from "feeling it's right"???
 
Craig, MA, NS....we must count ourselves very fortunate...

to be in the company of JV-12, who not only knows for a fact God exists, Jesus was his Son, and can "prove it empirically"...

but who also can indisputably prove the ignorance of everyone who has doubted or disbelieved in the past 2000 years. Poor ol' Bertrand Russell wouldn't have stood a chance....and even believers like C.S. Lewis who expressed doubt must have be right morons.
 
You mean you prefer certain words of Jesus, but not all.

If you could not care less what I think, then fine, do as you please. But that is not what Jesus asked of us. He prefers courage over letting others walk off a cliff by not interfering.

As Ronald Reagan would say,There you go again," putting words I did not say. Honestly,your imagination has run amuck.
 
And how would you know that is the truth? Because it feels right?

What you have defined above is close to deism, as far as I am concerned. Nothing short of real danger. Or it is the gospel according to MaryAnne.

You have come to the conclusion that God has never manifested himself to mankind in any meaningful way, and therefore, we are free to define God's wishes, God's laws, God's message however we choose. That should work out swimmingly with little chance for conflict.

Truth? Not a chance. Jesus Christ did not come down to earth to be humiliated and tortured because it did not matter to God the Father what we thought or what we did. Simple as that.

JV, as a devout Atheist, if I had to choose between your gospel and that of MaryAnne's, I would choose the Gospel of MaryAnne. In my opinion the only valid point you made is that her beliefs border on Deism. I agree and think that is in her favor.
 
Back
Top