New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

The Quickening -- 33 Weeks?

NightSwimmer

Senator
At what point does a developing cell mass become a thinking human?


When Do We Become Truly Conscious?

The new science of consciousness should change how we think about thorny ethical dilemmas.

By Daniel Bor


It is easy to view consciousness as a kind of magic. In religion it is represented by the mysterious soul, and in science the concept of consciousness at first appears quite alien. But many fields, such as the study of what distinguishes life from nonlife, had their earlier magical states eroded by careful scientific study. Consciousness is in the midst of a similar revolution.

The investigation of our own awareness is a blossoming scientific field, where experiments are illuminating exciting details about this most intimate of scientific subjects. In my book The Ravenous Brain, I describe the latest consciousness science and how we are closing in on establishing a consciousness meter—a way to measure levels of awareness in any being that may be able to experience the world. Consciousness is in many ways the most important question remaining for science.

...

But what does science have to say on this matter? The evidence is clear that a fetus can respond to sights, sounds, and smells, and it can even react to these by producing facial expressions. The evidence is equally clear, however, that these responses are generated by the most primitive parts of the brain, which are unconnected to consciousness, and therefore these actions don’t in any way imply that the fetus is aware. Furthermore, the fetus is deliberately sedated by a series of chemicals produced by the placenta, so even if it had the capacity for consciousness, there is almost no chance that it could ever be conscious in the womb. Consequently, it can’t consciously feel pain.
 
At what point does a developing cell mass become a thinking human?


When Do We Become Truly Conscious?

The new science of consciousness should change how we think about thorny ethical dilemmas.

By Daniel Bor


It is easy to view consciousness as a kind of magic. In religion it is represented by the mysterious soul, and in science the concept of consciousness at first appears quite alien. But many fields, such as the study of what distinguishes life from nonlife, had their earlier magical states eroded by careful scientific study. Consciousness is in the midst of a similar revolution.

The investigation of our own awareness is a blossoming scientific field, where experiments are illuminating exciting details about this most intimate of scientific subjects. In my book The Ravenous Brain, I describe the latest consciousness science and how we are closing in on establishing a consciousness meter—a way to measure levels of awareness in any being that may be able to experience the world. Consciousness is in many ways the most important question remaining for science.

...

But what does science have to say on this matter? The evidence is clear that a fetus can respond to sights, sounds, and smells, and it can even react to these by producing facial expressions. The evidence is equally clear, however, that these responses are generated by the most primitive parts of the brain, which are unconnected to consciousness, and therefore these actions don’t in any way imply that the fetus is aware. Furthermore, the fetus is deliberately sedated by a series of chemicals produced by the placenta, so even if it had the capacity for consciousness, there is almost no chance that it could ever be conscious in the womb. Consequently, it can’t consciously feel pain.

Good link; good article… Thanks, NS!

I agree with Daniel Bor that consciousness science is fascinating and tremendously important. We’ve learned a great deal in the past couple of decades and we’ll learn much more in the near future. And what we learn will be vital to all manner of ethical debates – just as Bor suggests.

As we learn more, I think it’s highly likely that we’ll be driven to the conclusion that ethical treatment of “others” must be driven by an assessment of another’s cognitive capabilities and capacity at least as much as by shared DNA and bonds of empathy. We’ll be driven as we learn more about the continuum of consciousness referenced by Bor and we'll be driven by advances in artificial intelligence. It won’t be an easy cultural/ethical shift, but it’ll be essential. And in any case it’s unavoidable.

I did particularly appreciate the way that Bor noted in his article that we may need to adapt our tests of what he terms “metaconsciousness” – by which he means such things as self-awareness, theory of mind, ability to reason at some level about cause and effect and risk and reward, and so on. It’s good to see an increased recognition that some classic tests, such as the ability of an animal to recognize itself in a mirror, may not necessarily be suitably probative for all species. After all, we humans rely primarily on vision to recognize ourselves and others; many other species do not.

Yep, good article…

Cheers.
 
Good link; good article… Thanks, NS!

I agree with Daniel Bor that consciousness science is fascinating and tremendously important. We’ve learned a great deal in the past couple of decades and we’ll learn much more in the near future. And what we learn will be vital to all manner of ethical debates – just as Bor suggests.

As we learn more, I think it’s highly likely that we’ll be driven to the conclusion that ethical treatment of “others” must be driven by an assessment of another’s cognitive capabilities and capacity at least as much as by shared DNA and bonds of empathy. We’ll be driven as we learn more about the continuum of consciousness referenced by Bor and we'll be driven by advances in artificial intelligence. It won’t be an easy cultural/ethical shift, but it’ll be essential. And in any case it’s unavoidable.

I did particularly appreciate the way that Bor noted in his article that we may need to adapt our tests of what he terms “metaconsciousness” – by which he means such things as self-awareness, theory of mind, ability to reason at some level about cause and effect and risk and reward, and so on. It’s good to see an increased recognition that some classic tests, such as the ability of an animal to recognize itself in a mirror, may not necessarily be suitably probative for all species. After all, we humans rely primarily on vision to recognize ourselves and others; many other species do not.

Yep, good article…

Cheers.

And then there is that intangable, the simple bonds between us, in this instance, of mother and fetus. Which takes us into the real realms of questioning what spirituality is, that which is so often spoken of as somehow supernatural.
 
Back
Top