New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

The USSC gets it wrong...

The 10 states that implemented bans since 2001 could be visionary...as they saw the writing on the wall. You seem to be ignoring the previous considerations stated in the article regarding constitutional concerns regarding these searches as stated here: But for decades afterward, courts held that there were constitutional issues involved when someone was being arrested and detained. In 2008, appeals courts began giving correctional officials approval for more invasive searches, even for minor offenses.

This goes to my assertion that the slippery slope towards the constitutional easing of such restrictions began in 2008...and yesterdays ruling is a 180 degree flip from those previous restrictions. Reasonable suspicion has now been replaced by existence, on the federal level. There remains just a very small limited bit of 4th Amendment Constitutional restriction now...and that is if the prison has separate populations.

Sorry...i find it egregious, as the dissenting opinions do.

In conclusion...nothing the Supreme Court has done, prevents individual jurisdictions from passing any rules and laws they like as to strip searches. And, the fact that I think the Supremes found correctly, doesn't mean that I like it. But...in the vein of all my babbling above, The Supremes have to pick and choose when they're going to "just say no". They have to calculate the actual costs of their decisions.

These ideas go to why I said up top, that I like the fact of this one being 5-4, even as I'm generally put off by 5-4 decisions. In this one, the "5" did what needed doing and the "4" made our aspirational case.
 
Back
Top