New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

The USSC gets it wrong...

Corruptbuddha

Governor
... ruling (5-4) that strip searches for minor offense prisoners isn't unconstitutional.

Here's the part of Kennedy's reasoning that I disagree with:

"But Kennedy focused on the fact that Florence was held with other inmates in the general population. In concurring opinions, Chief Justice John Roberts and Justice Samuel Alito said the decision left open the possibility of an exception to the rule and might not apply to someone held apart from other inmates. Kennedy gave three reasons to justify routine searches — detecting lice and contagious infections, looking for tattoos and other evidence of gang membership and preventing smuggling of drugs and weapons."


None of which matter without 'reasonable suspicion' of the inmate in question hiding stuff in his ass. I think Breyer got it right:

Justice Stephen Breyer said strip searches improperly "subject those arrested for minor offenses to serious invasions of their personal privacy." Breyer said jailers ought to have a reasonable suspicion someone may be hiding something before conducting a strip search.

Also I think the plaintiff in this situation has an excellent case for wrongful imprisonment and I hope he gets a fortune for the false arrest.

Of course, I'm a Libertarian, so any and all egregious attacks on personal liberties is an affront to me.

(Source)
http://abcnews.go.com/Politics/wire...ds-jails-strip-searches-16054456#.T3oxYWFul8E
 
"Florence, who is African-American, had been stopped several times before, and he carried a letter to the effect that the fine, for fleeing a traffic stop several years earlier, had been paid.
His protest was in vain, however, and the trooper handcuffed him and took him to jail."

he was "convicted" of sitting in his car while black.

you just know if he had been white, he wouldn't have been jailed.
 
... ruling (5-4) that strip searches for minor offense prisoners isn't unconstitutional.

Here's the part of Kennedy's reasoning that I disagree with:

"But Kennedy focused on the fact that Florence was held with other inmates in the general population. In concurring opinions, Chief Justice John Roberts and Justice Samuel Alito said the decision left open the possibility of an exception to the rule and might not apply to someone held apart from other inmates. Kennedy gave three reasons to justify routine searches — detecting lice and contagious infections, looking for tattoos and other evidence of gang membership and preventing smuggling of drugs and weapons."


None of which matter without 'reasonable suspicion' of the inmate in question hiding stuff in his ass. I think Breyer got it right:

Justice Stephen Breyer said strip searches improperly "subject those arrested for minor offenses to serious invasions of their personal privacy." Breyer said jailers ought to have a reasonable suspicion someone may be hiding something before conducting a strip search.

Also I think the plaintiff in this situation has an excellent case for wrongful imprisonment and I hope he gets a fortune for the false arrest.

Of course, I'm a Libertarian, so any and all egregious attacks on personal liberties is an affront to me.

(Source)
http://abcnews.go.com/Politics/wire...ds-jails-strip-searches-16054456#.T3oxYWFul8E

Brought this up earlier...and the responses were interesting. I had some righties and libertarians agreeing with the court. I brought up the fact that until 2007, the opposite was standard...strip searches were unnconstitutional without suspicion. Now, they become SOP for non criminal traffic offenses...as security takes precedence.
 
I have to concede that this 5-4 decision probably got it right. In hindsight, we know that the plaintiff shouldn't have been arrested in the first place and posed no threat to the jailers. But, the jailers couldn't have known that at the time. And, society has limited the jail's resources, such that jailers simply don't have the option of seperating people out into two "tracks". Therefore, had Breyer's opinion prevailed, it would've represented a huge "unfunded mandate", even as jails/prisons are having a hard enough time complying with several-decades past worth of judicial mandates.

On the other hand, I like that 4 Justices dissented, essentially making the point that society SHOULD ante up, and provide jails/prisons with the resources necessary, to operate "two tracks".
 
We have too many jails already. We also have too many half-a$$ed reasons for putting people in them.

I understand that people fear criminals, but we can't lock everybody up. It's just not practical.
 
I have to concede that this 5-4 decision probably got it right. In hindsight, we know that the plaintiff shouldn't have been arrested in the first place, and posed no threat to the jailers. But, the jailers couldn't have known that at the time. And, society has limited the jail's resources, such that jailers simply don't have the option of seperating people out into two "tracks". Therefore, had Breyer's opinion prevailed, it would've represented a huge "unfunded mandate", even as jails/prisons are having a hard enough time complying with several-decades past worth of judicial mandates.

On the other hand, I like 4 Justices dissented, essentially making the point that society SHOULD ante up, and provide jails/prisons with the resources necessary, to operate "two tracks".

This decision is a 180 degree turnaround from established practice over the past 30 years. This is a security state creep issue. The previous bar for search was reasonable suspicion...not mere existence.

While my experience is limited to one night's incarceration for drunk and disorderly 35 years ago, it was in a separate holding cell, not with general population.
 
This decision is a 180 degree turnaround from established practice over the past 30 years. This is a security state creep issue. The previous bar for search was reasonable suspicion...not mere existence.

While my experience is limited to one night's incarceration for drunk and disorderly 35 years ago, it was in a separate holding cell, not with general population.

I don't agree. I don't think you could make the case that this is a 180 degree decision, based on current practice. You're assuming that your experience of 35 years ago, prior to our nation's love affair with a "conservative" approach to criminal justice, holds true today and that the only reason jails don't offer up special accomodations, is out of meaness. There's more to it. A lot of it has to do with the fact that they simply don't HAVE those special accomodations, because the Norquistians aren't willing to pay for them.
 
I don't agree. I don't think you could make the case that this is a 180 degree decision, based on current practice. You're assuming that your experience of 35 years ago, prior to our nation's love affair with a "conservative" approach to criminal justice, holds true today and that the only reason jails don't offer up special accomodations, is out of meaness. There's more to it. A lot of it has to do with the fact that they simply don't HAVE those special accomodations, because the Norquistians aren't willing to pay for them.

I'm assuming nothing. I am working off legal information that up to 2008, reasonable suspicion was the constitutional bar for strip searches. That bar has been not just lowered, but completely removed. Now, existence is the bar. This is a complete turnaround from the circumstance previously.

And prisons, along with war, are among the things the right supports.
 
The War on the Fourth Amendment has been ongoing for some time now. It began in earnest with Prohibition and gained ground in the 1970's with Richard Nixon's War on Drugs.

After 2008, the Fourth Amendment might just as well have been excised from the Constitution altogether. Whatever, perhaps we'll finally feel "safe" when we're all behind bars.
 
I am a libertarian too but where does the rights of the inmates to NOT get a shiv in the back from an armed "suspect" come into play. If they aren't going to be strip searched, keep them out of the general population (probably a pretty good idea anyway in my view).
 
I am a libertarian too but where does the rights of the inmates to NOT get a shiv in the back from an armed "suspect" come into play. If they aren't going to be strip searched, keep them out of the general population (probably a pretty good idea anyway in my view).

Just an absurd proposition to continue arguing that folks are carrying hidden shivs around in their daily life and present a danger to the prison population for paying traffic fines. Other arms are found during normal searches.

And the tales of general population v. a holding tank seem a bit disingenuous to me. Yes, events occur, but procedure can eliminate them. Prison have cells.
 
Translation: Who cares? It's "the other". They'll never come for me!

If I am ever in jail, trust me - I will want EVERYONE in the room with me subject to being strip searched. We know what the left wants here - more rights for prisoners. I support that in some areas but until you have everyone segregated from each other you have to tool your rules for the violent crazed wacko contingent that is in every prison.
 
I'm assuming nothing. I am working off legal information that up to 2008, reasonable suspicion was the constitutional bar for strip searches. That bar has been not just lowered, but completely removed. Now, existence is the bar. This is a complete turnaround from the circumstance previously.

And prisons, along with war, are among the things the right supports.

Actually, you ARE assuming something which is not true. It is not true that prior to this ruling, there was no constitutional bar to strip searches upon entering someone into the jail environment. I think you may be confusing this one with rules around strip searches in a non-jail context.

There would be two practical problems with The Court ruling as the dissent suggests. First of all - per my earlier point - The Court would be imposing a significant unfunded mandate upon the umpteen different prisons/jails. And as I suggested, we'd be naive to assume that the prisons/jails currently have the necessary resources to handle a "two track" process, whereby one set of inductees goes in one direction and the other goes in another.

The second problem..which would be virtually insurmountable, is that The Supreme Court would have to define for all the various other jurisdictions, EXACTLY what case/circumstances would require the prison/jail to send people in one direction or another.
 
Actually, you ARE assuming something which is not true. It is not true that prior to this ruling, there was no constitutional bar to strip searches upon entering someone into the jail environment. I think you may be confusing this one with rules around strip searches in a non-jail context.

There would be two practical problems with The Court ruling as the dissent suggests. First of all - per my earlier point - The Court would be imposing a significant unfunded mandate upon the umpteen different prisons/jails. And as I suggested, we'd be naive to assume that the prisons/jails currently have the necessary resources to handle a "two track" process, whereby one set of inductees goes in one direction and the other goes in another.

The second problem..which would be virtually insurmountable, is that The Supreme Court would have to define for all the various other jurisdictions, EXACTLY what case/circumstances would require the prison/jail to send people in one direction or another.

The information I have read indicates that my statements are correct. That prior to 2008, the overriding consideration was reasonable suspicion. I'm therefore operating not from assumption, but from what I believe at this time to be the truth. If that is an error, it is an error based on the information I've read so far.



...The Supreme Court’s decision continued a trend that began after the Sept. 11, 2001, attacks of giving jailers more leeway in searching those picked up even for the most minor offenses, such as expired licenses or noisy mufflers.


At the same time, at least 10 states have forbidden strip searches without reasonable suspicion. And the Federal Bureau of Prisons does not subject those arrested for misdemeanor or civil contempt offenses to visual body-cavity searches without their consent or reasonable suspicion that they may be hiding contraband. They are kept from the general prison population....


In 1979, the Supreme Court said that prisons could conduct body-cavity searches of inmates after visits with outsiders, on the theory that those from the outside world might attempt to bring contraband to the prisoner.

But for decades afterward, courts held that there were constitutional issues involved when someone was being arrested and detained. In 2008, appeals courts began giving correctional officials approval for more invasive searches, even for minor offenses.


http://www.washingtonpost.com/polit...r-offenses/2012/04/02/gIQAsZB4qS_story_1.html


 
Just an absurd proposition to continue arguing that folks are carrying hidden shivs around in their daily life and present a danger to the prison population for paying traffic fines. Other arms are found during normal searches.

And the tales of general population v. a holding tank seem a bit disingenuous to me. Yes, events occur, but procedure can eliminate them. Prison have cells.

If you are saying that a bigger affront to personal liberty is putting suspects for minor infractions in the general population of a prison, then I agree 100%.
 
The information I have read indicates that my statements are correct. That prior to 2008, the overriding consideration was reasonable suspicion. I'm therefore operating not from assumption, but from what I believe at this time to be the truth. If that is an error, it is an error based on the information I've read so far.



...The Supreme Court’s decision continued a trend that began after the Sept. 11, 2001, attacks of giving jailers more leeway in searching those picked up even for the most minor offenses, such as expired licenses or noisy mufflers.


At the same time, at least 10 states have forbidden strip searches without reasonable suspicion. And the Federal Bureau of Prisons does not subject those arrested for misdemeanor or civil contempt offenses to visual body-cavity searches without their consent or reasonable suspicion that they may be hiding contraband. They are kept from the general prison population....


In 1979, the Supreme Court said that prisons could conduct body-cavity searches of inmates after visits with outsiders, on the theory that those from the outside world might attempt to bring contraband to the prisoner.

But for decades afterward, courts held that there were constitutional issues involved when someone was being arrested and detained. In 2008, appeals courts began giving correctional officials approval for more invasive searches, even for minor offenses.


http://www.washingtonpost.com/polit...r-offenses/2012/04/02/gIQAsZB4qS_story_1.html



I'm afraid you're arguing this one "backwards", or at least on the wrong plane. The fact that some or many jurisdictions forbade strip searches under certain circumstances, is not dispositive as to the constitutionality of it all. For after all, if these searches WERE unconstituional (federal), than ALL jurisidictions would've needed to forbid them, not just some jurisdictions.

And on that note - in the current case under discussion, The Supreme Court hasn't ruled as to the constitutionality of those laws or rules that forbid certain strip searches. And, they've not suggested that individual jurisdictions may not pass such laws or rules. Instead, what they've ruled is that absent such laws or rules, we can't assume (federal) constitutional protection. In other words, if the people of any particular state are concerned with the issue of strip searches, they're free to prevail upon their electeds to legislate accordingly. This Supreme Court ruling doesn't change that.
 
I'm afraid you're arguing this one "backwards", or at least on the wrong plane. The fact that some or many jurisdictions forbade strip searches under certain circumstances, is not dispositive as to the constitutionality of it all. For after all, if these searches WERE unconstituional (federal), than ALL jurisidictions would've needed to forbid them, not just some jurisdictions.

And on that note - in the current case under discussion, The Supreme Court hasn't ruled as to the constitutionality of those laws or rules that forbid certain strip searches. And, they've not suggested that individual jurisdictions may not pass such laws or rules. Instead, what they've ruled is that absent such laws or rules, we can't assume (federal) constitutional protection. In other words, if the people of any particular state are concerned with the issue of strip searches, they're free to prevail upon their electeds to legislate accordingly. This Supreme Court ruling doesn't change that.

The 10 states that implemented bans since 2001 could be visionary...as they saw the writing on the wall. You seem to be ignoring the previous considerations stated in the article regarding constitutional concerns regarding these searches as stated here: But for decades afterward, courts held that there were constitutional issues involved when someone was being arrested and detained. In 2008, appeals courts began giving correctional officials approval for more invasive searches, even for minor offenses.

This goes to my assertion that the slippery slope towards the constitutional easing of such restrictions began in 2008...and yesterdays ruling is a 180 degree flip from those previous restrictions. Reasonable suspicion has now been replaced by existence, on the federal level. There remains just a very small limited bit of 4th Amendment Constitutional restriction now...and that is if the prison has separate populations.

Sorry...i find it egregious, as the dissenting opinions do.
 
Back
Top