Corruptbuddha
Governor
... ruling (5-4) that strip searches for minor offense prisoners isn't unconstitutional.
Here's the part of Kennedy's reasoning that I disagree with:
"But Kennedy focused on the fact that Florence was held with other inmates in the general population. In concurring opinions, Chief Justice John Roberts and Justice Samuel Alito said the decision left open the possibility of an exception to the rule and might not apply to someone held apart from other inmates. Kennedy gave three reasons to justify routine searches — detecting lice and contagious infections, looking for tattoos and other evidence of gang membership and preventing smuggling of drugs and weapons."
None of which matter without 'reasonable suspicion' of the inmate in question hiding stuff in his ass. I think Breyer got it right:
Justice Stephen Breyer said strip searches improperly "subject those arrested for minor offenses to serious invasions of their personal privacy." Breyer said jailers ought to have a reasonable suspicion someone may be hiding something before conducting a strip search.
Also I think the plaintiff in this situation has an excellent case for wrongful imprisonment and I hope he gets a fortune for the false arrest.
Of course, I'm a Libertarian, so any and all egregious attacks on personal liberties is an affront to me.
(Source)
http://abcnews.go.com/Politics/wire...ds-jails-strip-searches-16054456#.T3oxYWFul8E
Here's the part of Kennedy's reasoning that I disagree with:
"But Kennedy focused on the fact that Florence was held with other inmates in the general population. In concurring opinions, Chief Justice John Roberts and Justice Samuel Alito said the decision left open the possibility of an exception to the rule and might not apply to someone held apart from other inmates. Kennedy gave three reasons to justify routine searches — detecting lice and contagious infections, looking for tattoos and other evidence of gang membership and preventing smuggling of drugs and weapons."
None of which matter without 'reasonable suspicion' of the inmate in question hiding stuff in his ass. I think Breyer got it right:
Justice Stephen Breyer said strip searches improperly "subject those arrested for minor offenses to serious invasions of their personal privacy." Breyer said jailers ought to have a reasonable suspicion someone may be hiding something before conducting a strip search.
Also I think the plaintiff in this situation has an excellent case for wrongful imprisonment and I hope he gets a fortune for the false arrest.
Of course, I'm a Libertarian, so any and all egregious attacks on personal liberties is an affront to me.
(Source)
http://abcnews.go.com/Politics/wire...ds-jails-strip-searches-16054456#.T3oxYWFul8E