New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

THEN and NOW ........EXACTLY THE SAME !!!

Raptor

Council Member
Got this from a friend:

There is no doubt in my mind that there are quite a few of us that knew this before and know it now:

General VoNguyen Giap

General Giap was a brilliant, highly respected leader of the North Vietnam military. The following quote
is from his memoirs currently found in the Vietnam war memorial in Hanoi:
'What we still don't understand is why you Americans stopped the bombing of Hanoi . You had us on the
ropes. If you had pressed us a little harder, just for another day or two, we were ready to surrender!
It was the same at the battle of TET. You defeated us! We knew it, and we thought you knew it.
But we were elated to notice your media was helping us. They were causing more disruption in
America than we could in the battlefields. We were ready to surrender. You had won!'

General Giap has published his memoirs and confirmed what most Americans knew. The Vietnam
war was not lost in Vietnam — it was lost at home. The same slippery slope, sponsored by the U.S. media,
is currently underway. It exposes the enormous power of a Biased Media to cut out the heart and will of
the American public.

A truism worthy of note: . . . Do not fear the enemy, for they can take only your life.
Fear the media, for they will distort your grasp of reality and destroy your honor.
 
General Giap has published his memoirs and confirmed what most Americans knew. The Vietnam
war was not lost in Vietnam — it was lost at home. The same slippery slope, sponsored by the U.S. media,
is currently underway. It exposes the enormous power of a Biased Media to cut out the heart and will of
the American public.
Why do you believe the US invasion of South Vietnam was a war that should have been won?
http://www.bbc.com/news/world-asia-23427726
"Was My Lai just one of many massacres in Vietnam War?"
 
One should always support one's allies (within reason). As to My Lai, inappropriate, even atrocious actions on both sides occur and appropriate action to eradicate them is of first priority.
Which "ally" are you saying we supported? France had already pulled out of that war, we replaced them, we didn't support them.
 
Which "ally" are you saying we supported? France had already pulled out of that war, we replaced them, we didn't support them.

We did both. We flew resupply missions over Dien Bien Phu. We flew airstrikes for them. We supplied them with weapons and ammunition.
They drove American tanks....They may well have given up a lot earlier if we hadn't pushed them to hold on.
 
Which "ally" are you saying we supported? France had already pulled out of that war, we replaced them, we didn't support them.

The South Vietnamese, the anti-Communists. Mistakenly, we thought that the Commies would take over the whole region. However the North just took over North Vietnam.
 
The South Vietnamese, the anti-Communists. Mistakenly, we thought that the Commies would take over the whole region. However the North just took over North Vietnam.
What difference, at this point, does it make?

Peaceful Vietnamese make good, strong furniture that I am proud to own.

Reverse things, have Vietnamese invade my country, and I would fight like they did.

There is no way American actions in Vietnam can be justified.

Left alone, they mind their own business.

Commendable.
 
One should always support one's allies (within reason). As to My Lai, inappropriate, even atrocious actions on both sides occur and appropriate action to eradicate them is of first priority.
Do you regard the French and their puppet as our allies?
Should we have murdered, maimed, and displaced millions of innocent Asians in order to support them?


https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vietnam_War#Exit_of_the_French.2C_1950.E2.80.9354

"In January 1950, the People's Republic of China and the Soviet Union recognized the Viet Minh's Democratic Republic of Vietnam, based in Hanoi, as the legitimate government of Vietnam. The following month the United States and Great Britain recognized the French-backed State of Vietnam in Saigon, led by former Emperor Bảo Đại, as the legitimate Vietnamese government."
 
We did both. We flew resupply missions over Dien Bien Phu. We flew airstrikes for them. We supplied them with weapons and ammunition.
They drove American tanks....They may well have given up a lot earlier if we hadn't pushed them to hold on.
You are talking about the "South" Vietnamese? Not the French? Cuz the French left.
 
You are talking about the "South" Vietnamese? Not the French? Cuz the French left.
At which point we reneged on the agreement that would have led to reunification through election rather than reunification via a long, needless, atrociously costly war.
 
The South Vietnamese, the anti-Communists. Mistakenly, we thought that the Commies would take over the whole region. However the North just took over North Vietnam.

They were not "allies." They were a U.S. puppet regime with very little native support.
 
They were not "allies." They were a U.S. puppet regime with very little native support.

WTF are you babbling about ? Our puppet regime are our ultimate ally. And, it's not so much that there wasn't much "native support"....it's just that the murderous commies made it impossible not to support the villages from supporting the commies without the South Vietnamese govt troops.

However, it's also true that without our total commitment it was a mistake to get into Nam 1/2 arsed. Note: we had a heavy commitment, but not a total commitment.
 
WTF are you babbling about ? Our puppet regime are our ultimate ally. And, it's not so much that there wasn't much "native support"....it's just that the murderous commies made it impossible not to support the villages from supporting the commies without the South Vietnamese govt troops.

However, it's also true that without our total commitment it was a mistake to get into Nam 1/2 arsed. Note: we had a heavy commitment, but not a total commitment.

Far more S. Vietnamese supported the Hanoi government and the NLF. That's why the U.S./GVN strategy involved so much torture, mass executions, carpet bombings, free-form zones, and concentration camps.
 
Far more S. Vietnamese supported the Hanoi government and the NLF. That's why the U.S./GVN strategy involved so much torture, mass executions, carpet bombings, free-form zones, and concentration camps.

Atrocities on both sides. However, your inclusion of "carpet bombings", "concentration camps i.e., POW camps", "free-form zones" etc., are the result of all wars. Thus, one-sided descriptions.

Thus, the Hanoi Govt and the NLF torture exceeded the "allied tortures" by a factor of ten or more.

Was our involvement in Nam a mistake ?.......YES, HUGE MISTAKE. Vietnam War did NOT result in Communist take over of SE Asia as we feared.
 
Got this from a friend:

There is no doubt in my mind that there are quite a few of us that knew this before and know it now:

General VoNguyen Giap

General Giap was a brilliant, highly respected leader of the North Vietnam military. The following quote
is from his memoirs currently found in the Vietnam war memorial in Hanoi:
'What we still don't understand is why you Americans stopped the bombing of Hanoi . You had us on the
ropes. If you had pressed us a little harder, just for another day or two, we were ready to surrender!
It was the same at the battle of TET. You defeated us! We knew it, and we thought you knew it.
But we were elated to notice your media was helping us. They were causing more disruption in
America than we could in the battlefields. We were ready to surrender. You had won!'

General Giap has published his memoirs and confirmed what most Americans knew. The Vietnam
war was not lost in Vietnam — it was lost at home. The same slippery slope, sponsored by the U.S. media,
is currently underway. It exposes the enormous power of a Biased Media to cut out the heart and will of
the American public.

A truism worthy of note: . . . Do not fear the enemy, for they can take only your life.
Fear the media, for they will distort your grasp of reality and destroy your honor.

There is no evidence Giap ever said that or even thought it:

http://www.snopes.com/quotes/giap.asp
 
Atrocities on both sides. However, your inclusion of "carpet bombings", "concentration camps i.e., POW camps", "free-form zones" etc., are the result of all wars. Thus, one-sided descriptions.

I did mean "free-fire zones," as I imagine you gathered. Wars are fought by means suitable to the political ends they are made to serve, and the U.S. fights its wars with the intention of inflicting maximum damage on civilian populations.

Thus, the Hanoi Govt and the NLF torture exceeded the "allied tortures" by a factor of ten or more.


S. Vietnamese torture victims, Con Dao prison.


American torture victims, CIA interrogation center.

N. Vietnamese torture victims, Hoa Lo prison ("Hanoi Hilton").

Yes, there were absolutely atrocities on both sides. But to a considerable extent, it's because both sides shared some common political aims. The U.S., of course, aimed to kill off communism and other popular political currents that threatened to undermine the complete American neocolonial domination of Indochina, by punishing the Vietnamese people en masse for supporting these currents. But the N. Vietnamese were fighting their own wars against popular movements--religious and ethnic minority movements fighting for liberation, pro-democracy labor and peasant movements fighting against the dictatorship and its reproduction of capitalist methods of distribution, and a Trotskyist movement centered on Saigon that was fighting for a more inclusive war of general liberation and better conditions for workers, while exposing the Hanoi clique for mounting an ineffective defense of their country by doing things that demobilized the working class as an independent political force. N. Vietnam also fought for years to keep the independent groups (representing all these political interests as well as those of wealthy nationalists) within the NLF so that it could choke their political independence to death and turn the NLF into merely an arm of the N. Vietnamese government. The NLF aped the N. Vietnamese in being willing to show brutality to peasants and workers in order to prove to bourgeois allies like Sihanouk that they could be trusted.

Was our involvement in Nam a mistake ?.......YES, HUGE MISTAKE. Vietnam War did NOT result in Communist take over of SE Asia as we feared.

The U.S. invasion of Vietnam was not a mistake. It was an act of international aggression occasioning a legion of war crimes, culminating in a region-wide massacre by various pro- and anti-U.S. forces from Indonesia, to North and South Vietnam, to Cambodia, by Americans worried not so much about losing control of, say, Thailand, as about a successful communist Vietnam or Indonesia, not ravaged by millions of tons of bombs, serving as an example for workers in places like the U.S.
 
Could be. I just reported info from a normally reliable source. However, it IS true that the Nam War didn't result in a Commie takeover of SE Asia which we DID fear. And, was the reason for our mistaken intervention.

BTW, it's now established (?) that Snopes is a clever liberal organization.

Although it is not to their credit, for years North Vietnam's Politburo, influenced by Chinese foreign policy needs, resisted efforts to take on the United States and their S. Vietnamese puppet government, until S. Vietnamese religious persecution, economic misery, and vicious repression prompted an explosion of popular resistance, forcing the N. Vietnamese to organize to co-opt that resistance lest it threaten to act independently in the interests of the working class and spoil the combined efforts of the bureaucratic cliques ruling Moscow, Beijing, and Hanoi to prevent the spread of the revolution.

If the U.S. had not forced such a vicious dictatorship on S. Vietnam, it might well still be capitalist today--except, of course, that a vicious dictatorship was the only way to prevent peaceful reunification.
 
Back
Top