New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Then & Now

Zam-Zam

Senator
How things have changed:

During World War II, the United States military censored press reports coming back from the front. That is a violation of the First Amendment, but the Roosevelt administration didn’t care, and reporters could be prosecuted for failing to submit articles.

Today, we have the total opposite. Live time coverage of the battlefield and rank enemy propaganda being reported as fact by Americans.

Examples: Iran does not “control” shipping in Hormuz. It attacks vessels with drones. That panics insurance companies, who are telling shipping operations they will not be reimbursed for any damage.

The US military could take control of the waterway any time it wants. But that would require close-quarter combat, something the American people would not support.

Lucky break for Iran.

The fact that the media actively distributes Iranian propaganda is a scandal; perhaps a low point in the history of journalism.

Very disturbing.




 
That's an easy thing to say. What is more difficult would be to dispute a single point articulated and to back up your opposing view with properly sourced facts and/or sound logic.

If you have it in you to do the latter, it has yet to be demonstrated.
The easiest point to refute would be that the media is distributing Iranian propaganda. Which is completely nonsensical.

Iran controls the straits at the moment. They are not allowing ships to pass through. This is an undisputable fact.

Why is he even discussing WWII journalists? He fails to make any connection to the war or modern day journalists. It is extraneous. He must be paid by the word.
 
The easiest point to refute would be that the media is distributing Iranian propaganda. Which is completely nonsensical.

Iran controls the straits at the moment. They are not allowing ships to pass through. This is an undisputable fact.

Why is he even discussing WWII journalists? He fails to make any connection to the war or modern day journalists. It is extraneous. He must be paid by the word.

You're doing a little better there, but I disagree with your analysis.

Let's go point-by-point with what O'Reilly actually said:

Live time coverage of the battlefield and rank enemy propaganda being reported as fact by Americans.

Here is an AI-generated fake photo that has been spread on social media:

1775739268040.png


The NY Times agrees:

Cascade of A.I. Fakes About War With Iran Causes Chaos Online​





It appears Mr. O'Reilly is spot-on with that one.


His next point:

Iran does not “control” shipping in Hormuz. It attacks vessels with drones. That panics insurance companies, who are telling shipping operations they will not be reimbursed for any damage.

If a kid is on a building throwing rocks at anyone who enters a parking lot, the kid isn't actually controlling the parking lot, he's just being a nuisance to anyone who enters it. He can be removed by one cop.

Similarly, the Iranian regime can fly drones to attack shipping vessels in the straits without actually controlling the straits, and they do. Boots on the ground, as in the Marines, could prevent the regime from doing that, but that is a step most Americans likely would not support.

Another point for O'Reilly.


As for discussing WWII, that is merely used for contrast and comparison. Nothing wrong with that.

And he's right:

U.S. Censorship and War Propaganda During World War II​




I give you an A for effort nonetheless, that was an improvement over the "Me no like" previous attempt.
 
You're doing a little better there, but I disagree with your analysis.

Let's go point-by-point with what O'Reilly actually said:

Live time coverage of the battlefield and rank enemy propaganda being reported as fact by Americans.

Here is an AI-generated fake photo that has been spread on social media:

View attachment 86965


The NY Times agrees:

Cascade of A.I. Fakes About War With Iran Causes Chaos Online​





It appears Mr. O'Reilly is spot-on with that one.


His next point:

Iran does not “control” shipping in Hormuz. It attacks vessels with drones. That panics insurance companies, who are telling shipping operations they will not be reimbursed for any damage.

If a kid is on a building throwing rocks at anyone who enters a parking lot, the kid isn't actually controlling the parking lot, he's just being a nuisance to anyone who enters it. He can be removed by one cop.

Similarly, the Iranian regime can fly drones to attack shipping vessels in the straits without actually controlling the straits, and they do. Boots on the ground, as in the Marines, could prevent the regime from doing that, but that is a step most Americans likely would not support.

Another point for O'Reilly.


As for discussing WWII, that is merely used for contrast and comparison. Nothing wrong with that.

And he's right:

U.S. Censorship and War Propaganda During World War II​




I give you an A for effort nonetheless, that was an improvement over the "Me no like" previous attempt.
Are ships passing freely through Iran?
No
Why?
Because Iran is threatening to attack them.

You aren't going to be able redefine the word "control" to exclude what Iran is doing.
 
Are ships passing freely through Iran?
No
Why?
Because Iran is threatening to attack them.

You aren't going to be able redefine the word "control" to exclude what Iran is doing.

You are conflating "attacking" with "controlling." The are two separate and distinct things.

The Japanese attacked Pearl Harbor. The did not control Pearl Harbor.
 
You're doing a little better there, but I disagree with your analysis.

Let's go point-by-point with what O'Reilly actually said:

Live time coverage of the battlefield and rank enemy propaganda being reported as fact by Americans.

Here is an AI-generated fake photo that has been spread on social media:

View attachment 86965


The NY Times agrees:

Cascade of A.I. Fakes About War With Iran Causes Chaos Online​





It appears Mr. O'Reilly is spot-on with that one.


His next point:

Iran does not “control” shipping in Hormuz. It attacks vessels with drones. That panics insurance companies, who are telling shipping operations they will not be reimbursed for any damage.

If a kid is on a building throwing rocks at anyone who enters a parking lot, the kid isn't actually controlling the parking lot, he's just being a nuisance to anyone who enters it. He can be removed by one cop.

Similarly, the Iranian regime can fly drones to attack shipping vessels in the straits without actually controlling the straits, and they do. Boots on the ground, as in the Marines, could prevent the regime from doing that, but that is a step most Americans likely would not support.

Another point for O'Reilly.


As for discussing WWII, that is merely used for contrast and comparison. Nothing wrong with that.

And he's right:

U.S. Censorship and War Propaganda During World War II​




I give you an A for effort nonetheless, that was an improvement over the "Me no like" previous attempt.
Ah yes, let's harken back to good Ole days when journalists were jailed and the 1st Amendment was an afterthought. Is that when America was great?
 
You are conflating "attacking" with "controlling." The are two separate and distinct things.

The Japanese attacked Pearl Harbor. The did not control Pearl Harbor.
The threat of violence is a means of control.

Ships are not passing through the strait due to the threat of violence.
 
You are conflating "attacking" with "controlling." The are two separate and distinct things.

The Japanese attacked Pearl Harbor. The did not control Pearl Harbor.

If a ship enters the Straight they are subject to attack. Since the news is that only 3 ships went through yesterday, because Iran said they could transit the straight....they have control.

The Japanese bombed the harbor and left. If they had continued to attack and prevented the US from refloating those ships and repairing the damage....then they would have had control.

You suggest putting troops on the ground....where? How many? The straight is about 20 miles across. How much of Iran would we have to occupy to keep their missiles and drones from being able to attack ships?
 
Ah yes, let's harken back to good Ole days when journalists were jailed and the 1st Amendment was an afterthought. Is that when America was great?

I'm not arguing that point. Whether you approve of President's Roosevelt's actions or not is your business.

The point is, that's how it was. It's recorded history.
 
How things have changed:

During World War II, the United States military censored press reports coming back from the front. That is a violation of the First Amendment, but the Roosevelt administration didn’t care, and reporters could be prosecuted for failing to submit articles.

Today, we have the total opposite. Live time coverage of the battlefield and rank enemy propaganda being reported as fact by Americans.

Examples: Iran does not “control” shipping in Hormuz. It attacks vessels with drones. That panics insurance companies, who are telling shipping operations they will not be reimbursed for any damage.

The US military could take control of the waterway any time it wants. But that would require close-quarter combat, something the American people would not support.

Lucky break for Iran.

The fact that the media actively distributes Iranian propaganda is a scandal; perhaps a low point in the history of journalism.

Very disturbing.




What a bunch of babbling non sense
 
So anyone who threatens you...controls you?

If that be the case, you are easily controlled.
Now you are painting with too broad of brush.

It is a means of control. Results vary. Like the Americans trying to control the Iranian nuclear program through violence, but the Iranians have not ceded control.

Shipping in the straits is still clearly controlled by Iran.
 
Now you are painting with too broad of brush.

It is a means of control. Results vary. Like the Americans trying to control the Iranian nuclear program through violence, but the Iranians have not ceded control.

Shipping in the straits is still clearly controlled by Iran.

Me? This is your statement:

The threat of violence is a means of control.

I responded to that.
 
I'm not arguing that point. Whether you approve of President's Roosevelt's actions or not is your business.

The point is, that's how it was. It's recorded history.
In 1941 the media consisted of radio broadcasts and newspapers. We censored the mail from servicemen and women as well as what embedded reporters wrote.

Now it is quite a different world. Every person with access to a cellphone can report what they see and with AI they can even create news and content. We are unable to keep the Iranians from sending stories into our social media without someone bringing a lawsuit.
 
Back
Top