New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Theological Authority

Arkady

President
One thing I find interesting is how people resolve contradictions within the Bible. For example, if God says one thing in the Old Testament and Jesus says another in the New, how do you decide which is the real rule? If God gives you a long list of crimes, taboos, and social infractions and orders you to stone to death anyone who commits them, but Jesus says only he without sin can cast the first stone, how do you decide which to disobey?

Similarly, if Jesus says that not one jot of the old Judaic Law will fall away, but Paul tells you that all sorts of the old Judiaic Laws can now be ignored (go ahead and eat pork, and don't worry about slicing off your foreskin), how do you decide which is right?

I suppose you could do it by adhering to the internal textual logic. Jesus outranks Paul, since Paul was entirely human and Jesus was a demigod. Meanwhile, the Father was a god and the Sonwas a demigod, so the Father outranks the Son (even by Jesus' own admission, his father was greater than him). So, you could treat Paul as correct except when contradicted by either of the other two, and Jesus as correct except when contradicted by God the Father.

Or you could do it legalistically, by taking the view that each later pronouncement amended the former rule. So, Jesus trumps God the Father, and Paul trumps Jesus (and Joseph Smith trumps Paul, if you add in the Book of Mormon).

Our you could give up trying to find a consistent rule and just pick and choose which stuff you like, and assume that stuff must be correct. But, once you do that, you give up any special status for your beliefs, since you're basically just constructing a belief system from a big buffet, which is little different than an atheist constructing his beliefs without any recourse to supposedly higher authority.
 
All I know is that, if I click the banner ad at the top of this page, then I will learn 7 Biblical truths about investing. ;)
 
One thing I find interesting is how people resolve contradictions within the Bible. For example, if God says one thing in the Old Testament and Jesus says another in the New, how do you decide which is the real rule? If God gives you a long list of crimes, taboos, and social infractions and orders you to stone to death anyone who commits them, but Jesus says only he without sin can cast the first stone, how do you decide which to disobey?

Similarly, if Jesus says that not one jot of the old Judaic Law will fall away, but Paul tells you that all sorts of the old Judiaic Laws can now be ignored (go ahead and eat pork, and don't worry about slicing off your foreskin), how do you decide which is right?

I suppose you could do it by adhering to the internal textual logic. Jesus outranks Paul, since Paul was entirely human and Jesus was a demigod. Meanwhile, the Father was a god and the Sonwas a demigod, so the Father outranks the Son (even by Jesus' own admission, his father was greater than him). So, you could treat Paul as correct except when contradicted by either of the other two, and Jesus as correct except when contradicted by God the Father.

Or you could do it legalistically, by taking the view that each later pronouncement amended the former rule. So, Jesus trumps God the Father, and Paul trumps Jesus (and Joseph Smith trumps Paul, if you add in the Book of Mormon).

Our you could give up trying to find a consistent rule and just pick and choose which stuff you like, and assume that stuff must be correct. But, once you do that, you give up any special status for your beliefs, since you're basically just constructing a belief system from a big buffet, which is little different than an atheist constructing his beliefs without any recourse to supposedly higher authority.
Hi, I am very unorthodox, but I love to discuss religion, and I will give you the answers whether anyone appreciates my twist or not.

There are many ways to resolve the contradictions, and some are not meant to be resolved, so there is no overall rule or guidelines, but it still can be done.

You are correct about the Biblical hierarchy as there are those who outrank higher than others, and some who go below others.

As like you said - God (the Father) outranks Jesus (the Son).
So too Jesus outranks Moses and Paul, and outranks everyone else.
The Bible also shows a connection, like:
Jesus is the second Adam
Paul was the second Moses.

Moses taught a watered-down message, and so did Paul, but Jesus explained that Moses did that because the people wanted the law watered-down, Matthew 19:7-8, and that is why Paul did it too.

Apparently you really had it already figured out, so I do not see why you did not lay claim to it? as I have done.
 
My thoughts......... and I will take the position of assuming that God "spoke" to people although I don't know that exactly that is what happened, but it makes it easier for this narrative, so work with me.

In the earliest days of man's self awareness and seeking of a Creator, that Creator found a few humans with whom he could communicate. He gave them rules for safety (having the toilet area down stream from the drinking area of the river and not to eat pork - since eating raw meat was common and pork needed to be cooked good to remove the worms). God, in his best communication form gave out the rules of Earth. The physics and science of what made Earth habitable for people hadn't yet been discovered by these humans that couldn't even figure out how to put a simple thought on paper. So God gave some sense to those that had enough sense to figure out what he was telling them.

The numbers of humans grew and they started writing things down and they started making laws about how to govern themselves and the common sense things that God had instilled into the early humans became actual written laws. Thou shall not eat pork. Thou shall not drink water downstream from the toilet hole. And some of the moral ideas that God instilled regarding the sanctity of life also found their way into their laws. Thou shall not kill. Thou shall not steal. The list of laws grew and grew and pretty soon no one could do much of anything without breaking one of God's laws. Some people wouldn't care about laws so in order to make them care, they were told that God said they should be stoned if they broke the laws.

Who knows whether or not God told anyone to do stoning. But if on some occasion someone was hiding part of the goods they were supposed to turn in to be divided out and those people died a sudden and unexpected death............ God was given the credit/ blame since they had "sinned".

God........... who created us all........... realizes that things are really getting screwed up by all of these laws. So he does something very important. He creates ( or calls up- depending upon whether you believe Jesus was always there or not) a son that is half human. The son will tell people that no...........it's not so much about these laws which were created in the beginning to help you deal with nature's unchangeable laws............ but it's about love. I, God loved you so much that I gave you a beautiful earth and now I love you enough to send my only son to tell you that it's more about love than it is about laws. The laws are important. They won't just go away. If you eat raw pork you'll probably get sick and die. If you put your toilet up stream from your drinking water you will no doubt get sick and die. But loving each other --is ultimately more important than these laws...... and if enforcing the laws causes you to be mean to each other then you're going down a wrong path.

So God sent his Son and the Son was there to not just show them about love but to show them that there was something there beyond death. When the Son died, he came back to prove to them that death is not the end. Now, if they believed that the Son was really God's son and had a true message from God, and if they believed that Son really did die (go to the after place) and come back............. then if they forgot and just hunted that wild pig and then tore him up and ate him right there on the spot..........and got sick and died......... that their life would continue in some after place called heaven.
Belief that Son died and returned and that Son was actually sent by God with his message is important to having that life in the after place that was promised.
The end.

There is not so much contradiction in the Bible as there was a learning process of the people who wrote the Bible. God had to first give the rules. People abused the rules - killing people who broke them. God sent his Son to show that [1]death is not the end; [2] love is more important than rules.

That's how I see it anyway.
 
I think it's more likely that the brightest in the bunch simply figured out that their less intellectually endowed brethren were more easily swayed to take good advice if they were told that it was God's idea, rather than their own.
 
My thoughts......... and I will take the position of assuming that God "spoke" to people although I don't know that exactly that is what happened, but it makes it easier for this narrative, so work with me.

In the earliest days of man's self awareness and seeking of a Creator, that Creator found a few humans with whom he could communicate. He gave them rules for safety (having the toilet area down stream from the drinking area of the river and not to eat pork - since eating raw meat was common and pork needed to be cooked good to remove the worms). God, in his best communication form gave out the rules of Earth. The physics and science of what made Earth habitable for people hadn't yet been discovered by these humans that couldn't even figure out how to put a simple thought on paper. So God gave some sense to those that had enough sense to figure out what he was telling them.

The numbers of humans grew and they started writing things down and they started making laws about how to govern themselves and the common sense things that God had instilled into the early humans became actual written laws. Thou shall not eat pork. Thou shall not drink water downstream from the toilet hole. And some of the moral ideas that God instilled regarding the sanctity of life also found their way into their laws. Thou shall not kill. Thou shall not steal. The list of laws grew and grew and pretty soon no one could do much of anything without breaking one of God's laws. Some people wouldn't care about laws so in order to make them care, they were told that God said they should be stoned if they broke the laws.

Who knows whether or not God told anyone to do stoning. But if on some occasion someone was hiding part of the goods they were supposed to turn in to be divided out and those people died a sudden and unexpected death............ God was given the credit/ blame since they had "sinned".

God........... who created us all........... realizes that things are really getting screwed up by all of these laws. So he does something very important. He creates ( or calls up- depending upon whether you believe Jesus was always there or not) a son that is half human. The son will tell people that no...........it's not so much about these laws which were created in the beginning to help you deal with nature's unchangeable laws............ but it's about love. I, God loved you so much that I gave you a beautiful earth and now I love you enough to send my only son to tell you that it's more about love than it is about laws. The laws are important. They won't just go away. If you eat raw pork you'll probably get sick and die. If you put your toilet up stream from your drinking water you will no doubt get sick and die. But loving each other --is ultimately more important than these laws...... and if enforcing the laws causes you to be mean to each other then you're going down a wrong path.

So God sent his Son and the Son was there to not just show them about love but to show them that there was something there beyond death. When the Son died, he came back to prove to them that death is not the end. Now, if they believed that the Son was really God's son and had a true message from God, and if they believed that Son really did die (go to the after place) and come back............. then if they forgot and just hunted that wild pig and then tore him up and ate him right there on the spot..........and got sick and died......... that their life would continue in some after place called heaven.
Belief that Son died and returned and that Son was actually sent by God with his message is important to having that life in the after place that was promised.
The end.

There is not so much contradiction in the Bible as there was a learning process of the people who wrote the Bible. God had to first give the rules. People abused the rules - killing people who broke them. God sent his Son to show that [1]death is not the end; [2] love is more important than rules.

That's how I see it anyway.
I liked everything that you said above Jen.

My perception is that people like myself who know about the existence of God (and I would say you too) then we go to the Bible to understand things which we already know, as in we already know God so we try to understand it.

Other people go to the Bible as if they can find God inside of the Bible - and then discover that God is not in there.

I find the Bible to be like an "Operating Manual" for a car, in that the Bible is just explaining how things operate. Therefore if one does not have the car then the manual means nothing, and if one does not know God first then the Bible means nothing (or very little).

The Bible is still great as literature, and for history, and for lots of guidance, and the Bible can lead a person to God, but God is not inside of that book.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Jen
The Bible is somewhat like a user's manual. It is a handbook for living one's life as a member of a primitive tribe of nomads in the Middle Eastern desert thousands of years ago.
 
I liked everything that you said above Jen.

My perception is that people like myself who know about the existence of God (and I would say you too) then we go to the Bible to understand things which we already know, as in we already know God so we try to understand it.

Other people go to the Bible as if they can find God inside of the Bible - and then discover that God is not in there.

I find the Bible to be like an "Operating Manual" for a car, in that the Bible is just explaining how things operate. Therefore if one does not have the car then the manual means nothing, and if one does not know God first then the Bible means nothing (or very little).

The Bible is still great as literature, and for history, and for lots of guidance, and the Bible can lead a person to God, but God is not inside of that book.

Exctly, JP. It's a user's manual. Its usefulness is different depending upon whether you "have the car" or are just reading it for literary value. Thanks for the good added insight. And I agree that God is not inside the Bible.
 
One thing I find interesting is how people resolve contradictions within the Bible. For example, if God says one thing in the Old Testament and Jesus says another in the New, how do you decide which is the real rule? If God gives you a long list of crimes, taboos, and social infractions and orders you to stone to death anyone who commits them, but Jesus says only he without sin can cast the first stone, how do you decide which to disobey?


Similarly, if Jesus says that not one jot of the old Judaic Law will fall away, but Paul tells you that all sorts of the old Judiaic Laws can now be ignored (go ahead and eat pork, and don't worry about slicing off your foreskin), how do you decide which is right?

I suppose you could do it by adhering to the internal textual logic. Jesus outranks Paul, since Paul was entirely human and Jesus was a demigod. Meanwhile, the Father was a god and the Sonwas a demigod, so the Father outranks the Son (even by Jesus' own admission, his father was greater than him). So, you could treat Paul as correct except when contradicted by either of the other two, and Jesus as correct except when contradicted by God the Father.

Or you could do it legalistically, by taking the view that each later pronouncement amended the former rule. So, Jesus trumps God the Father, and Paul trumps Jesus (and Joseph Smith trumps Paul, if you add in the Book of Mormon).

Our you could give up trying to find a consistent rule and just pick and choose which stuff you like, and assume that stuff must be correct. But, once you do that, you give up any special status for your beliefs, since you're basically just constructing a belief system from a big buffet, which is little different than an atheist constructing his beliefs without any recourse to supposedly higher authority.

All adherents do this. For example, you got the pro lifers who hate abortion but support the death penalty. Conversely, you have pro-abortion advocates who protest the death penalty.

It seems the Thou Shall Not Kill rule has a lot of exceptions.
 
All adherents do this. For example, you got the pro lifers who hate abortion but support the death penalty. Conversely, you have pro-abortion advocates who protest the death penalty.

It seems the Thou Shall Not Kill rule has a lot of exceptions.
I simply must dispute with the above quote.

The word in the 10 commandment is correctly translated as "murder" and not as "kill" so the commandment rightly says "Do not murder." see link = Jewish Bible - Exodus 20:13.

And there really is a significant difference between killing and murdering.

As such there is a big difference between an abortion and the death penalty.

The death penalty needs to be judged as a person who needs or deserves to be executed.

The issue of an abortion can be debated as to whether the Doctor is killing or murdering? and whether the mother or the 2 parents are killing or murdering? while some people claim that it is neither murder or killing.

It was the old King James version (KJV) of the Bible published in 1611, which made the inaccurate translation of "Thou shalt not kill" as popularly known, and few people ever research the text to find the more accurate words - but I have done so.
 
I simply must dispute with the above quote.

The word in the 10 commandment is correctly translated as "murder" and not as "kill" so the commandment rightly says "Do not murder." see link = Jewish Bible - Exodus 20:13.

And there really is a significant difference between killing and murdering.

As such there is a big difference between an abortion and the death penalty.

The death penalty needs to be judged as a person who needs or deserves to be executed.

The issue of an abortion can be debated as to whether the Doctor is killing or murdering? and whether the mother or the 2 parents are killing or murdering? while some people claim that it is neither murder or killing.

It was the old King James version (KJV) of the Bible published in 1611, which made the inaccurate translation of "Thou shalt not kill" as popularly known, and few people ever research the text to find the more accurate words - but I have done so.

There is no difference between murder by the state, and murder by the individual.
 
My thoughts......... and I will take the position of assuming that God "spoke" to people although I don't know that exactly that is what happened, but it makes it easier for this narrative, so work with me.

In the earliest days of man's self awareness and seeking of a Creator, that Creator found a few humans with whom he could communicate. He gave them rules for safety (having the toilet area down stream from the drinking area of the river and not to eat pork - since eating raw meat was common and pork needed to be cooked good to remove the worms). God, in his best communication form gave out the rules of Earth. The physics and science of what made Earth habitable for people hadn't yet been discovered by these humans that couldn't even figure out how to put a simple thought on paper. So God gave some sense to those that had enough sense to figure out what he was telling them.

The numbers of humans grew and they started writing things down and they started making laws about how to govern themselves and the common sense things that God had instilled into the early humans became actual written laws. Thou shall not eat pork. Thou shall not drink water downstream from the toilet hole. And some of the moral ideas that God instilled regarding the sanctity of life also found their way into their laws. Thou shall not kill. Thou shall not steal. The list of laws grew and grew and pretty soon no one could do much of anything without breaking one of God's laws. Some people wouldn't care about laws so in order to make them care, they were told that God said they should be stoned if they broke the laws.

Who knows whether or not God told anyone to do stoning. But if on some occasion someone was hiding part of the goods they were supposed to turn in to be divided out and those people died a sudden and unexpected death............ God was given the credit/ blame since they had "sinned".

God........... who created us all........... realizes that things are really getting screwed up by all of these laws. So he does something very important. He creates ( or calls up- depending upon whether you believe Jesus was always there or not) a son that is half human. The son will tell people that no...........it's not so much about these laws which were created in the beginning to help you deal with nature's unchangeable laws............ but it's about love. I, God loved you so much that I gave you a beautiful earth and now I love you enough to send my only son to tell you that it's more about love than it is about laws. The laws are important. They won't just go away. If you eat raw pork you'll probably get sick and die. If you put your toilet up stream from your drinking water you will no doubt get sick and die. But loving each other --is ultimately more important than these laws...... and if enforcing the laws causes you to be mean to each other then you're going down a wrong path.

So God sent his Son and the Son was there to not just show them about love but to show them that there was something there beyond death. When the Son died, he came back to prove to them that death is not the end. Now, if they believed that the Son was really God's son and had a true message from God, and if they believed that Son really did die (go to the after place) and come back............. then if they forgot and just hunted that wild pig and then tore him up and ate him right there on the spot..........and got sick and died......... that their life would continue in some after place called heaven.
Belief that Son died and returned and that Son was actually sent by God with his message is important to having that life in the after place that was promised.
The end.

There is not so much contradiction in the Bible as there was a learning process of the people who wrote the Bible. God had to first give the rules. People abused the rules - killing people who broke them. God sent his Son to show that [1]death is not the end; [2] love is more important than rules.

That's how I see it anyway.

The way I see it is that if God wanted to tell us something he could cut out the demigods and tell us direct. He should not make rules knowing that his subjects will break those rules and then requiring a blood sacrifice to atone for breaking the rules he knew would be broken. Even less explicable is why would God sacrifice his own son to atone for someone breaking rules which he (God) had made and knew would be broken?

My personal beliefe is that if there is a God he will speak directly to me and say something like, "RedCloud if you don't shape up, I'm going to burn your ass!" That way, I can get the ungarbled word without having to go to church and pay tithes to hear the likes of Jimmy Swaggart, Ted Haggard, or Pat Robertson tell me what God wants me to do.

Self delusion is a wonderful crutch for many people.
 
The way I see it is that if God wanted to tell us something he could cut out the demigods and tell us direct. He should not make rules knowing that his subjects will break those rules and then requiring a blood sacrifice to atone for breaking the rules he knew would be broken. Even less explicable is why would God sacrifice his own son to atone for someone breaking rules which he (God) had made and knew would be broken?

My personal beliefe is that if there is a God he will speak directly to me and say something like, "RedCloud if you don't shape up, I'm going to burn your ass!" That way, I can get the ungarbled word without having to go to church and pay tithes to hear the likes of Jimmy Swaggart, Ted Haggard, or Pat Robertson tell me what God wants me to do.

Self delusion is a wonderful crutch for many people.

Okay, Red Cloud. But say you are God, and that little .6 mm springtail on your desk is the "human" you created............. exactly how are you going to communicate with it?

The "rules" made are those of mathematics and physics that allow for the earth to stay in orbit around the sun and for life to be sustained on that earth. God's rules are simple. Man's rules are not so simple. Man, not understanding the message from the bigness that is God to the smallness of us...... with our limited experience....... put in the "blood sacrifice" rule thing. That sacrifice was not demanded of God, but we humans need some sort of ritual to allow us to forgive ourselves. So the sacrifice ritual is ours, not God's. God sent his son so that he (God) could actually communicate with us. And his son died and returned to show us that death is not the end of everything for us..... there is more beyond it. God knows we will break the rules. And it's okay because we don't know much beyond our own existence, and we have learned to survive most of the rule breaking.

The only rule we should not break is denying that there is a God. Not because it will make God hate us - he won't. But because if we do that.................then death really is the end and our spirit (that is scientifically there whether we think it is or not) will continue in a place where God does not exist. With God gone, there is also no hope for things to get better, no chance of that. There is no love......... there is nothing good. Is there fire? Who knows? Nobody. But God IS love and hope and everything (not just some things EVERYTHING) good. The absence of that is pretty awful.

I hope you seek God at some point. Just seek. Don't worry about rules. Just think that IF there is a God you want to find out. The rest will take care of itself if you honestly seek.
 
Okay, Red Cloud. But say you are God, and that little .6 mm springtail on your desk is the "human" you created............. exactly how are you going to communicate with it?

The "rules" made are those of mathematics and physics that allow for the earth to stay in orbit around the sun and for life to be sustained on that earth. God's rules are simple. Man's rules are not so simple. Man, not understanding the message from the bigness that is God to the smallness of us...... with our limited experience....... put in the "blood sacrifice" rule thing. That sacrifice was not demanded of God, but we humans need some sort of ritual to allow us to forgive ourselves. So the sacrifice ritual is ours, not God's. God sent his son so that he (God) could actually communicate with us. And his son died and returned to show us that death is not the end of everything for us..... there is more beyond it. God knows we will break the rules. And it's okay because we don't know much beyond our own existence, and we have learned to survive most of the rule breaking.

The only rule we should not break is denying that there is a God. Not because it will make God hate us - he won't. But because if we do that.................then death really is the end and our spirit (that is scientifically there whether we think it is or not) will continue in a place where God does not exist. With God gone, there is also no hope for things to get better, no chance of that. There is no love......... there is nothing good. Is there fire? Who knows? Nobody. But God IS love and hope and everything (not just some things EVERYTHING) good. The absence of that is pretty awful.

I hope you seek God at some point. Just seek. Don't worry about rules. Just think that IF there is a God you want to find out. The rest will take care of itself if you honestly seek.

Jen, unless you have "been there and done that" then I put no more credence in your views than I do Billy Graham's or the Pope's.

"...our spirit (that is scientifically there) ..." will earn you an easy million dollars if you can prove it. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/James_Randi

As for seeking, I have sought but did not find-in spite of what Matthew 7:7 might claim. I need more proof than just a "fuzzy" feeling which can be brought on by self induced euphoria.

Having said all this, I do not begrudge anyone from clinging to any belief which helps them get through the day. What I do resent is when they try to convince me or my grandchildren that I need that same crutch. My strength comes from within. If I don't have it there then, By Zeus, I just don't have it!
 
Jen, unless you have "been there and done that" then I put no more credence in your views than I do Billy Graham's or the Pope's.

"...our spirit (that is scientifically there) ..." will earn you an easy million dollars if you can prove it. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/James_Randi

As for seeking, I have sought but did not find-in spite of what Matthew 7:7 might claim. I need more proof than just a "fuzzy" feeling which can be brought on by self induced euphoria.

Having said all this, I do not begrudge anyone from clinging to any belief which helps them get through the day. What I do resent is when they try to convince me or my grandchildren that I need that same crutch. My strength comes from within. If I don't have it there then, By Zeus, I just don't have it!

I have no desire to push anything down your throat, Red Cloud. I hate it when anyone does that to me and I won't do it to anyone else. I will answer your posts because I like you but if I come across as pressuring........ it's not intentional. We each have to go through life our own unique way and I respect yours as I can see that you respect mine though you disagree with it. It's all good. :)
 
I have no desire to push anything down your throat, Red Cloud. I hate it when anyone does that to me and I won't do it to anyone else. I will answer your posts because I like you but if I come across as pressuring........ it's not intentional. We each have to go through life our own unique way and I respect yours as I can see that you respect mine though you disagree with it. It's all good. :)

Noted and agree.
 
Noted and agree.

Oops! BTW, how would I communicate with the little Springtail you mentioned? I wouldn't. If I wanted it to survive I would furnish the environment in which it could. Otherwise, the little bugger would be on its own--as are we.
 
Back
Top