New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

These People Are NUTS!

This is a fine example of why we should get out of Afghanistan yesterday. I view that country as a hopeless case.

Afghan Dad Kills Daughter On Order Of Mullahs

In front of 300 villagers, Halima's father shot her in the head, stomach and waist - a public execution overseen by local religious leaders in Afghanistan to punish her for an alleged affair.

Halima, aged between 18 and 20 and a mother of two, was killed for bringing "dishonour" on her family in a case that underlines how the country is still struggling to protect women more than 11 years after the fall of the Taliban.

Police in the northwestern province of Badghis said Halima was accused of running off with a male cousin while her husband was in Iran, and her father sought advice from Taliban-backed clerics on how to punish her.

"People in the mosque and village started taunting him about her escape with the cousin," Badghis provincial police chief Sharafuddin Sharaf said.
A local cleric who runs a madrassa told him that she must be punished with death, and the mullahs said she should be executed in public

"A local cleric who runs a madrassa told him that she must be punished with death, and the mullahs said she should be executed in public. The father killed his daughter with three shots as instructed by religious elders and in front of villagers. We went there two days later but he and his entire family had fled."

Amnesty International said the killing, which occurred on April 22 in the village of Kookchaheel, was damning evidence of how little control police have over many areas of the country.

"Violence against women continues to be endemic in Afghanistan and those responsible very rarely face justice," Amnesty's Afghanistan researcher, Horia Mosadiq, said. "Not only do women face violence at the hands of family members for reasons of preserving so-called honour, but frequently women face human rights abuses resulting from verdicts issued by traditional, informal justice systems."

Police in Baghdis, a remote and impoverished province that borders Turkmenistan, said Halima had run away with her cousin to a village 30 kilometres away.

Her father found her after 10 days and brought her back home, where clerics told him he must kill her.

A Badghis-based women's rights activist said he had seen a video of Hamila's execution.

"On the video, she is shot three times in front of 300 to 400 people. Her brother witnesses her death and breaks down in tears," said the activist, who declined to be named. "She is sitting on her knees in the dust, wearing a large chador veil. A mullah announces her funeral prayers first, then her father shoots her from behind with an AK-47 at a distance of about five metres.

"We have learned that a Taliban shadow governor in the region asked the mullahs to issue the death penalty for her. The local religious council first said she should be stoned to death, but since the cousin was not there, they decided she should be shot."

It is not known what happened to the cousin with whom she ran away.

The activist added that Halima's husband had objected to the death sentence and tried to return from Iran before the execution.
 
No matter how hard we try, and no matter how much American treasure we are willing to expend in the effort, I do not believe we will be able to turn Afghanistan into a civilized country.

Does anyone disagree??
 
No matter how hard we try, and no matter how much American treasure we are willing to expend in the effort, I do not believe we will be able to turn Afghanistan into a civilized country.

Does anyone disagree??

Certainly not I. Then again, I've never understood that to be our mission in Afghanistan.
 
There are a lot,of,places in the world we should leave to their own devices. An awful lot of them are in the Middle East.
 
We thought the same about Japan. 1.6 billion Muslims, or so? How do you eat an elephant? One bite at a time.
The religion of the Anti Christ. You forget there's over two billion Christians. You just need to have the stomach and the resolve, otherwise Islam wins.
The Chinese Populations that fell under Islam's sway were all converted in less than two generations. The women were all made concubines, the men were all killed. As far as Islam is concerned there's no co existance allowed, yet the Libs hold Islam and its followers in higher regard than they do the Constitution. Go figure. There are no safe areas, no rear areas away from the conflict, the killing fields. When is America going to realize that? Probably when its too late. The lack of stomach and resolve in the American people are part and parcel of how Barack Obama got elected. He spun a campaign fairy tale that he could make the lion lie down with the lamb, the baby sheep lie down with the wolf and the coyote, al Qaeda go back to its former pastoral occupations; growing enormous fields of opium poppies, decapitating apostates, and stoning female adulterers to death, all by simply turning his beaming countenance toward them and the American people could then luxuriate with him and Tiny Tim and Tiny Tim's ukelele tiptoeing through the tulips rejuvenated by copious quantities of drugs for recreational abuse, of which Mr Obama listed abundant experience with as part of his qualifications for his current office.
 
Certainly not I. Then again, I've never understood that to be our mission in Afghanistan.

If our mission was to evict Al Qaeda from Afghanistan, then we've already done that, and should declare 'Mission Accomplished'; there are practically NO Al Qaeda operatives left in Afghanistan.

If our mission was to track down and either kill or capture Osama bin Laden, then we've already done that, and should declare "Mission Accomplished"; Osama bin Laden is 'sleeping with the fishes', as they used to say in the old gangster movies.

If our mission was to turn Afghanistan into a civilized country, then we should declare "Mission: Impossible", declare victory, and get the hell out.

[Seven more American soldiers died in Afghanistan yesterday, five from an IED and two from 'friendly' fire. Let's stop wasting American lives in that hell-hole.]
 
No matter how hard we try, and no matter how much American treasure we are willing to expend in the effort, I do not believe we will be able to turn Afghanistan into a civilized country.

Does anyone disagree??

Hey, LeRoy, back in '03 I got into an argument with a Civil Affairs Captain when I was passing through Bagram. He was complaining about how tough the "Nation building mission" was; I snorted when I heard him say that, and said "This ain't a nation, it's a loose collection of tribal [Unwelcome language removed]....", and he turned and asked me if I had a better idea. I said, "Yeah, take every male over the age of 14 and put a bullet through the back of their heads. Then tell the women and the survivng male children that this is their second chance and if they [Unwelcome language removed] it up again, we'll be coming back...." I had to go stand on the carpet for that one....
 
We thought the same about Japan. 1.6 billion Muslims, or so? How do you eat an elephant? One bite at a time.
The religion of the Anti Christ. You forget there's over two billion Christians. You just need to have the stomach and the resolve, otherwise Islam wins.
The Chinese Populations that fell under Islam's sway were all converted in less than two generations. The women were all made concubines, the men were all killed. As far as Islam is concerned there's no co existance allowed, yet the Libs hold Islam and its followers in higher regard than they do the Constitution. Go figure. There are no safe areas, no rear areas away from the conflict, the killing fields. When is America going to realize that? Probably when its too late. The lack of stomach and resolve in the American people are part and parcel of how Barack Obama got elected. He spun a campaign fairy tale that he could make the lion lie down with the lamb, the baby sheep lie down with the wolf and the coyote, al Qaeda go back to its former pastoral occupations; growing enormous fields of opium poppies, decapitating apostates, and stoning female adulterers to death, all by simply turning his beaming countenance toward them and the American people would luxuriate tiptoeing with him and Tiny Tim and Tiny Tim's ukelele through the tulips rejuvenated by copious quantities of drugs for recreational abuse, of which Mr Obama listed abundant experience with as part of his qualifications for his current office.

I think only a copious amount of drugs could explain this post.

We are NOT at war with Islam. Even George W. Bush understood that, and said so several times, probably in part to TRY to get through the skulls of people like you.

Liberals do NOT hold "Islam and its followers in higher regard than the Constitution". It is nonsense. Personally, I don't think YOU have much regard for the Constitution, since it guarantees freedom of religion. Including for Muslims.

Mr. Obama did not spin any campaign fairy tales. In fact, he vowed to FOCUS on the war in Afghanistan, which he said was the 'real' war. [As opposed to the tragic blunder of Iraq.]
 
Hey, LeRoy, back in '03 I got into an argument with a Civil Affairs Captain when I was passing through Bagram. He was complaining about how tough the "Nation building mission" was; I snorted when I heard him say that, and said "This ain't a nation, it's a loose collection of tribal [Unwelcome language removed]....", and he turned and asked me if I had a better idea. I said, "Yeah, take every male over the age of 14 and put a bullet through the back of their heads. Then tell the women and the survivng male children that this is their second chance and if they [Unwelcome language removed] it up again, we'll be coming back...." I had to go stand on the carpet for that one....

I seem to distinctly recall George W. Bush saying during the 2000 campaign that he didn't believe in 'nation building'.............
 
Agree 100%. I would not waste another dollar or another drop of American blood on these f**king animals. Let the Taliban have the country back; they deserve it.
 
I seem to distinctly recall George W. Bush saying during the 2000 campaign that he didn't believe in 'nation building'.............

Well, personally, I'm a big fan of it; I think we should start with the U.S. and practice it dilligently for about the next 50yrs or so, before we even think of exporting the concept....
 
If our mission was to evict Al Qaeda from Afghanistan, then we've already done that, and should declare 'Mission Accomplished'; there are practically NO Al Qaeda operatives left in Afghanistan.

If our mission was to track down and either kill or capture Osama bin Laden, then we've already done that, and should declare "Mission Accomplished"; Osama bin Laden is 'sleeping with the fishes', as they used to say in the old gangster movies.

If our mission was to turn Afghanistan into a civilized country, then we should declare "Mission: Impossible", declare victory, and get the hell out.

[Seven more American soldiers died in Afghanistan yesterday, five from an IED and two from 'friendly' fire. Let's stop wasting American lives in that hell-hole.]


We've already declared "Mission Accomplished". We are in the process of leaving. We will be out of there soon, but we can't bug out overnight.
 
but but ....errr not all Afghan people are like this


Probably not, but we still need to leave. We've accomplished our mission in Afghanistan. It's time to bring our troops home -- and that's exactly what we're in the process of doing.
 
If you say so


http://thecable.foreignpolicy.com/p..._to_extend_us_troop_presence_in_afghanistan_s



A little more for ya

Fact 1: It is not the case that all US troops will be removed from Afghanistan at the end of 2014.

In June 2011, President Obama announced his plan to begin the withdrawal of US troops from Afghanistan. But the president did not say that all US troops would leave Afghanistan by the end of 2014. What he did say was 10,000 troops would be removed by the end of the summer 2011, with 23,000 additional troops leaving at the end of the summer of 2012. After that, according to the President:

our troops will continue coming home at a steady pace as Afghan security forces move into the lead. Our mission will change from combat to support. By 2014, this process of transition will be complete, and the Afghan people will be responsible for their own security.

Notice that the President did not say that our mission in Afghanistan will end by 2014, only that it will cease to be a "combat" mission and become a "support" mission. White House Press Secretary Jay Carney has since confirmed that President Obama never said US troops would be completely withdrawn by the end of 2014.

What you should be asking yourself is, "what is a support mission?", "how many troops will be required for it?", and "how long will it last?" We will get to these questions shortly. First, it's important to highlight one thing:

Fact 2: There is currently no end date for the war in Afghanistan.

Nowhere in the President's June 2011 speech did he mention a deadline for the full withdrawal of US troops from Afghanistan, and no date for full withdrawal has been specified since then. In fact, the Strategic Partnership Agreement, which was struck between the United States and Afghanistan in June 2012, provides for a US military presence after 2014, although the magnitude of the presence was not specified.

On November 15, 2012, it was reported that Afghanistan and the United States had begun negotiations for a bilateral security agreement, which will govern the US military presence in Afghanistan post-2014, including how many troops are left in Afghanistan, and for how long.

Fact 3: There is no set plan for removing the remaining 68,000 troops left in Afghanisan.

Not only are there currently twice as many US troops in Afghanistan today as there were when President Obama took office, but the administration has yet to outline a specific plan for removing the 68,000 troops that remain, except that most of them will be removed by the end of 2014. A decision about a scheduled for the removal of these troops will not be made until after a decision is made about the number of residual troops the US will leave in Afghanistan post-2014. However, it has been reported that General John Allen wants to keep over 60,000 US troops until the fall of 2013.

Three options were being considered in March 2012:
1.The drawdown plan said to be favored by Vice President Joe Biden would drawdown troops rapidly, to perhaps 20,000, by the end of 2013.
2.A more gradual drawdown plan calls for removing 10,000 troops by the end of December 2012, leaving 58,000 troops. An additional 10,000 to 20,000 would be removed by June 2013, leaving between 48,000 and 38,000 troops in Afghanistan, still more than were in the country when President Obama took office.
3.Military commanders are said to favor delaying further cuts until the end of 2013, including Lt. Gen. Curtis Scaparrotti, who was the second-in-command of US forces in Afghanistan until June 2012 and is now the Director of the Joint Staff.

Fact 4: Reports indicate that the Pentagon wants to keep between 6,000 and 20,000 US troops in Afghanistan until at least 2024.

On November 12, 2012, Defense Secretary Leon Panetta told reporters that the Obama administration would come to a decision within the next few weeks about the magnitude of the US post-2014 military presence in Afghanistan. Panetta would not comment on the troop levels being considered. Since then, it has been reported that General John Allen, head of the ISAF, has submitted three plans for an enduring US presence in Afghanistan:
1.With 6,000 troops, the focus of the US mission would be on counterterrorism missions, and logistical and training support for Afghan forces would be limited;
2.With 10,000 troops, the US could expand training and logistical support from the 6,000 troop plan;
3.With 20,000 troops, US convential forces could be used to patrol certain areas.

All of these options include troop commitments smaller than the 25,000 troops the Pentagon is said to have favored since Obama's drawdown announcement.

However, just days after General Allen's recommendations made news, the Wall Street Journal reported that President Obama requested three additional proposals in which troop levels did not exceed 10,000. The plans sumbitted by the Pentagon included:
1.A 3,000 troop option, which Pentagon officials strongly warned against;
2.A 6,000 troop option, assumed to be the same as the 6,000 troop option described above;
3.A 9,000 troop option, assumed to be similiar to the 10,000 troop option above.

Out of these three options, the Pentagon is said to favor the 9,000 troop option, while the White House is said to favor the 6,000 troop option.

Keep in mind that there were only 34,000 troops there when Obama took office. If 20,000 troops are kept in Afghanistan after 2014, that means that the net withdrawal would be a mere 14,000 troops. Furthermore, before 2007, troop levels were at roughly 20,000 or less. So leaving 20,000 troops in Afghanistan would be to merely return to 2006 troop levels. Leaving 9,000 or 10,000 troops would be a return to 2003 troop levels.

If the Pentagon gets its way, the US will be at war in Afghanistan for at least 12 additional years--that's one more year than we've been at war to this point. That means that we wouldn't even be at the half-way mark today, let alone nearing the end!

Fact 5: The "support" mission will not necessarily be small, nor will it be free of combat missions.

A "support" mission sure sounds more reassuring than a combat mission, right? Sounds like only a few troops will remain behind to support the Afghan security forces?

Any close reading of the US public position on its post-2014 mission in Afghanistan immediately dispells such consoling thoughts. Just look at the plans General John Allen has proposed for the US enduring presence, listed above. Each of the Pentagon's proposals include a counterinsurgency element. In fact, the 6,000 troop plan, which the White House is said to favor, prioritizes direct counterinsurgency missions over logistical support and training for the Afghan security forces, even though it is supposedly for the latter reason that US officials claim an enduring presence is necessary. Meanwhile, the plan involving the largest amount of troops adds a patrol capacity, which is clearly a combat, not a support, capacity. It is likely that a combat capacity is emphasized in the Pentagon's plans due to a recognition that the Afghan security forces, even after a decade of training, are far from ready to take over security for the country.

Further, the US "support" mission in Iraq serves as an example and a warning for the continued US military presence in Afghanistan. The combat mission in Iraq supposedly ended in August 2010, at which point troop levels were brought down to 50,000. In October 2011, over a year later, there were still about 45,000 troops left in Iraq. Furthermore, these supposedly non-combat troops would engage in combat missions and were described as having a "combat capacity" by administration officials, including former Secretary of Defense Robert Gates, in which they engage in "targeted counterterrorism operations" and work and fight alongside Iraqi security forces. In light of this, "support" seems to be nothing more than a euphemism for extended combat.

Per a previous agreement between the US and Iraqi governments, all US troops were supposed to leave Iraq at the end of 2011. That didn't stop the Obama administration from trying to pressure the Iraqi government to extend the deadline, allowing the US to leave up to 10,000 troops indefinitely. Fortunately, this plan has been abandoned, and all but about 150 US troops attached to the US Embassy left on time. But a similar fight over keeping to a deadline for withdrawal may erupt in the future over Afghanistan--whenever a deadline is, in fact, established.

Fact 6: Obama's "surge" is not over.

In September 2012, it was widely reported that Obama's "troop surge" in Afghanistan was over, leaving 68,000 troops in the country. But when President Obama took office, there were only roughly 34,000 US troops in Afghanistan. In two "surges", Obama added to this figure over 66,000 additional troops. By reducing the US troop presence by 33,000, his drawdown plan has removed only half the number of troops that he sent to Afghanistan, not all.

Fact 7: There are less than 100 al Qaeda left in Afghanistan--but there are over 600,000 Afghan and international forces there to fight them.

In June 2010, Leon Panetta said that there were less than 100 members of al Qaeda left in Afghanistan. According to the latest Brookings Institute Afghanistan Index, there are about 108,000 international troops in Afghanistan under NATO and Operation Enduring Freedom; 344,108 Afghan Security Forces; 90,000 private Defense Department contractors; and 2,000 private contractors training the Afghan Army. Additionally, there are 150,000 Pakistani troops on the Afghanistan-Pakistan border. That's a grand total of 694,108 versus 100. Seems a bit overkill.

Fact 8: The lack of a timetable for withdrawal is a key obstacle in peace negotiations with the Taliban.

Taliban spokesmen have made it quite clear that peace requires a willingness by the US to leave; but the US military has done just the opposite through its negotiations with the Afghan government to keep tens of thousands of US troops in Afghanistan indefinitely.

Fact 9: There is elite support for an expedited withdrawal.

Elite groups ranging from the Afghanistan Study Group, which was endorsed by a large number of national security and Middle East experts, to the New York Times have come out in support of an accelerated US military withdrawal from--and oppose an extended military stay in--Afghanistan.

Congress has also expressed support for a quicker withdrawal. On November 30, 2011, the US Senate adopted a measure by voice vote in favor of an accelerated US military withdrawl from Afghanistan. In May 2012, 90 Members of Congress joined Rep. Barbara Lee in calling upon President Obama to expedite the withdrawal. And in November 2012, the Senate voted 62-33 in favor of a measure that calls upon President Obama to continue withdrawing US troops at a steady pace, to end all regular US combat missions in Afghanistan no later than December 31, 2014, and to "take all possible steps" to end such operations earlier.

Fact 10: There is popular support for ending the war now.

Although polls of American public opinion on US withdrawal from Afghanistan tend to conflate the withdrawal of all "combat" troops with the withdrawal of all troops, majorities are still shown to oppose an indefinite US military presence in Afghanistan. A March 2012 Gallop poll reported 50% of Americans in favor of withdrawing all US troops before 2014, with an additional 24% favoring a full withdrawal by the end of 2014. An October 2012 Pew poll found an even greater majority in favor of a quick withdrawal: 60% of Americans said they wanted US troops removed from Afghanistan as soon as possible, while only 35% support leaving US troops there "until the situation stabalizes."

What is perhaps most interesting about some of these polls is that they seem to reflect a general confusion over President Obama's plan for withdrawal from Afghanistan. The Pew poll, for example, reported that 73% of Democrats supported a quick withdrawal from Afghanistan instead of waiting. Yet, 66% of Democrats say that President Obama is handling the removal of US troops "about right."

Also interestingly, the Pew poll reported 25% of Republicans said that President Obama is removing troops too slowly.
http://countdowntodrawdown.org/facts.php
 
I opposed this war from the start, and the inevitability of this kinda stuff occurrring was a minor consideration as to why
 
Back
Top