New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

This was a wrongful death

Bernard_Fokke

Captain Fokke
Supporting Member
If the news report is accurate, yes the teen had no business in the garage, however there was no threat to life and no reason to shoot so Kaarma is, IMHO, (If the facts of the story are correct) guilty of possibly premeditated murder

**********
Markus Kaarma has been charged with deliberate murder in the Sunday killing of Diren Dede, 17, of Hamburg.

But he says Montana's self-defence law allowed him to shoot the boy.

Celal Dede said he would not have allowed his son to study in the US had he been aware of the lenient gun laws.

"I didn't think for one night that everyone here can kill somebody just because that person entered his back yard," Mr Dede told the German news agency dpa.
http://www.bbc.com/news/world-us-canada-27243115
 
a couple of thoughts here . ..

i read this article before work, and refrained from posting about it, because I saw no way to avoid using the phrase "bad kaarma" in my subject line. addtionally . . .

  • what nationality is "kaarma"? at first i was going to guess the last name was made up, that he was the son of flower children. but given his photo that seems highly unlikely
  • if any european parent claims to be unaware that america has lenient gun laws, they have no business earning enough money to send their kids to america. his kid didn't deserve to be shot, but as thief/juvenile delinquent there clearly wasn't a lot of parental guidance involved from his dad in the first place.
 
If the news report is accurate, yes the teen had no business in the garage, however there was no threat to life and no reason to shoot so Kaarma is, IMHO, (If the facts of the story are correct) guilty of possibly premeditated murder

**********
Markus Kaarma has been charged with deliberate murder in the Sunday killing of Diren Dede, 17, of Hamburg.

But he says Montana's self-defence law allowed him to shoot the boy.

Celal Dede said he would not have allowed his son to study in the US had he been aware of the lenient gun laws.

"I didn't think for one night that everyone here can kill somebody just because that person entered his back yard," Mr Dede told the German news agency dpa.
http://www.bbc.com/news/world-us-canada-27243115
Lying in wait. Baiting the scene. Sounds like murder to me.
 
Lying in wait. Baiting the scene. Sounds like murder to me.

it depends on the state, and the state of mind of the prosecutor. they set the bar pretty high for murder.

mr. karma's attorney will plead him out manslaughter, on the explanation that he only intended to "scare" the teen, not actually hit him.
 
it depends on the state, and the state of mind of the prosecutor. they set the bar pretty high for murder.

mr. karma's attorney will plead him out manslaughter, on the explanation that he only intended to "scare" the teen, not actually hit him.


I doubt it as this statement... "Mr Kaarma, a 29-year-old firefighter, has told investigators his home had twice been hit by burglars, and he told a hair stylist he had waited up at night to shoot intruders, prosecutors said."

That shows premeditation and intent.
 
I'm going to assume that: "But he says Montana's self-defence law allowed him to shoot the boy." represents what the guy actually said.

In my mind, a man should be able to come up with a better rational for shooting someone, beyond the fact that the law ALLOWED him to do so.
 
I normally side with the homeowner but thy really left a purse in the garage and the door open?

Maybe the kid just wanted to let them know that the garage door was open and a purse was out there? I can't find anything online about the kid having a criminal record.

Fry the both of them, clear case of premeditated murder.
 
I doubt it as this statement... "Mr Kaarma, a 29-year-old firefighter, has told investigators his home had twice been hit by burglars, and he told a hair stylist he had waited up at night to shoot intruders, prosecutors said."

That shows premeditation and intent.

I put part of the blame for this on our common American perception - held by people ACROSS the spectrum, that when some steals our teevee, he's "violated" us personally.

I don't know if the dude had homeowner's insurance or not. Some might suggest that he shouldn't buy if if he doesn't want to! He has a right to spend his evenings lying in wait, gun in hand, to protect his own shit!

That may be true, but we do have free will and we should be able to weigh the costs of insurance against the "costs" of trying to defend our own stuff. Clearly, this guy has created a whole lotta legal blowback for himself. But, even in the case of an entirely righteous home defense shoot, I'm guessing that over time, the shooter kind of wishes it could've gone down differently.
 
I put part of the blame for this on our common American perception - held by people ACROSS the spectrum, that when some steals our teevee, he's "violated" us personally.

I don't know if the dude had homeowner's insurance or not. Some might suggest that he shouldn't buy if if he doesn't want to! He has a right to spend his evenings lying in wait, gun in hand, to protect his own shit!

That may be true, but we do have free will and we should be able to weigh the costs of insurance against the "costs" of trying to defend our own stuff. Clearly, this guy has created a whole lotta legal blowback for himself. But, even in the case of an entirely righteous home defense shoot, I'm guessing that over time, the shooter kind of wishes it could've gone down differently.

I've been ripped off a few times over the years but never laid in wait with a gun, I did lay in wait but the ambush was going to be a serious ass kicking. Luckily the thief never returned and yes I felt violated but not to the point of killing.

These SYG, Castle Doctrine laws are poorly understood by the average person.

Again IMHO they should only be used with deadly force if you can't escape and your life is in immediate danger otherwise(IMO) you are in the wrong killing some one.
 
I've been ripped off a few times over the years but never laid in wait with a gun, I did lay in wait but the ambush was going to be a serious ass kicking. Luckily the thief never returned and yes I felt violated but not to the point of killing.

These SYG, Castle Doctrine laws are poorly understood by the average person.

Again IMHO they should only be used with deadly force if you can't escape and your life is in immediate danger otherwise(IMO) you are in the wrong killing some one.

In the way back when nuckleheads used to steal car stereos, I had my car stereo stolen and my console damaged, right out in front of my apartment. That really pissed me off. But...I'd finally reached that stage in life where I actually had real car insurance. That insurance paid for a new stereo, console, and installation.

That didn't stop me from obsessing over it though. I lay awake at nights pondering schemes to catch that bastard! Then it finally hit me. That thief did me wrong, but I got a new stereo for free! So, why am I letting this jackass continue to "victimize" me by messing with my head?

Silly/sad postcript. When my agent gave me the check for that new stereo, he made it plain that if I wanted the new to be covered, I'd need to give him a receipt for that replacement. Makes sense - not too much to ask, hunh? Alas......I just never got around to it......

So a few months later when that (probably same) bastard stole my NEW stereo?.....I blamed myself.
 
it depends on the state, and the state of mind of the prosecutor. they set the bar pretty high for murder.

mr. karma's attorney will plead him out manslaughter, on the explanation that he only intended to "scare" the teen, not actually hit him.
I don't know of any state where you can open fire without some sort of threat to someone's life; trespassing in an unoccupied garage doesn't rise to that level. Maybe if he was standing over a person's bed while they slept, then maybe.
 
The goal of a responsible gun owner should be that he never have to fire his gun in anger. It's sorta like that $1500 warranty I bought on the used truck I bought last year. I didn't by the warranty in hopes of having to use it! In fact, the best outcome will be if I never have to use it!

On the other hand, there's a fear among many who aren't disposed toward guns, that SOME people buy with the the conscious or subconscious hope that somewhere along the line, they WILL have an opportunity to fire the gun in anger. You responsible gun owners KNOW I'm right.

That's why I oppose these new SYG regimes. In my state - where we don't have specific SYG laws, I've never heard of a single circumstance - anytime, anywhere - of a righteous shooter landing himself in legal hot water. And, I've never heard of the opposite - someone declining to defend themselve righteously, out of fear of landing in legal hot water.

So...we don't NEED SYG laws. Shooters who fire righteously, are in the clear. The only one the SYG law serves, is the guy who wants official legal "permission" and blanket indemnification for shooting.
 
The goal of a responsible gun owner should be that he never have to fire his gun in anger. It's sorta like that $1500 warranty I bought on the used truck I bought last year. I didn't by the warranty in hopes of having to use it! In fact, the best outcome will be if I never have to use it!

On the other hand, there's a fear among many who aren't disposed toward guns, that SOME people buy with the the conscious or subconscious hope that somewhere along the line, they WILL have an opportunity to fire the gun in anger. You responsible gun owners KNOW I'm right.

That's why I oppose these new SYG regimes. In my state - where we don't have specific SYG laws, I've never heard of a single circumstance - anytime, anywhere - of a righteous shooter landing himself in legal hot water. And, I've never heard of the opposite - someone declining to defend themselve righteously, out of fear of landing in legal hot water.

So...we don't NEED SYG laws. Shooters who fire righteously, are in the clear. The only one the SYG law serves, is the guy who wants official legal "permission" and blanket indemnification for shooting.

Frankly I hope that I never ever have to pop a cap on anything but a paper target.
 
If the news report is accurate, yes the teen had no business in the garage, however there was no threat to life and no reason to shoot so Kaarma is, IMHO, (If the facts of the story are correct) guilty of possibly premeditated murder

**********
Markus Kaarma has been charged with deliberate murder in the Sunday killing of Diren Dede, 17, of Hamburg.

But he says Montana's self-defence law allowed him to shoot the boy.

Celal Dede said he would not have allowed his son to study in the US had he been aware of the lenient gun laws.

"I didn't think for one night that everyone here can kill somebody just because that person entered his back yard," Mr Dede told the German news agency dpa.
http://www.bbc.com/news/world-us-canada-27243115

Hmmm looks like a reasonably intelligent Kid.... I see no signs of Downs or other obvious tells that one would normally look for in someone who is mentally disabled or retarded.

So what part of private property and tresspassing did this kid not understand when he
decided to study at the college level here in the US?

His death is his own fault.

You cannot have it both ways.

If the news report is what???? Is What???? Accurate? So now you think this man went out to the college campus, found the kid and then dragged him back there to shoot him I guess right?

You know what I think? I think he was looking for Bomb making materials.

Now let's talk about that shall we?


_74580641_74580636.jpg


Hmmm Can't help but notice the symbols of Islam there....now why does that not surprise me eh?

As far as entrappment is concerned I see no substantive difference whatsoever between what the homeowner did and what police do every day of the week with bait cars, officer/hookers, online posers as underaged girls, or anyone of a numbe of other white lie/fibs designed to bring out the crook, addict, or even murderer in people. Don't fuxcking steal, don' t fuxcking play the knockout game and don't fuxcking rape and kill people if you want to keep breathing......but I guess for some it's just too much to ask.

JO
 
Last edited:
If the news report is accurate, yes the teen had no business in the garage, however there was no threat to life and no reason to shoot so Kaarma is, IMHO, (If the facts of the story are correct) guilty of possibly premeditated murder

**********
Markus Kaarma has been charged with deliberate murder in the Sunday killing of Diren Dede, 17, of Hamburg.

But he says Montana's self-defence law allowed him to shoot the boy.

Celal Dede said he would not have allowed his son to study in the US had he been aware of the lenient gun laws.

"I didn't think for one night that everyone here can kill somebody just because that person entered his back yard," Mr Dede told the German news agency dpa.
http://www.bbc.com/news/world-us-canada-27243115
What little bit of information that was in the source does not give enough information to say what it is. Does Montana have a law that forbids setting a trap? What exactly was the boy doing in the mans garage? Hell it's my garage I should be able to leave anything inside it I want to an expect no one will bother it.
 
The goal of a responsible gun owner should be that he never have to fire his gun in anger. It's sorta like that $1500 warranty I bought on the used truck I bought last year. I didn't by the warranty in hopes of having to use it! In fact, the best outcome will be if I never have to use it!

On the other hand, there's a fear among many who aren't disposed toward guns, that SOME people buy with the the conscious or subconscious hope that somewhere along the line, they WILL have an opportunity to fire the gun in anger. You responsible gun owners KNOW I'm right.

That's why I oppose these new SYG regimes. In my state - where we don't have specific SYG laws, I've never heard of a single circumstance - anytime, anywhere - of a righteous shooter landing himself in legal hot water. And, I've never heard of the opposite - someone declining to defend themselve righteously, out of fear of landing in legal hot water.

So...we don't NEED SYG laws. Shooters who fire righteously, are in the clear. The only one the SYG law serves, is the guy who wants official legal "permission" and blanket indemnification for shooting.


While I tend to agree on the SYG laws you are forgetting one very important thing. Those laws would never had existed if it wasn't for the stooooopid fuxcking "Duty to retreat " laws that did , btw....cost a lot of people their lives. Funny how you guys verbally diddle the history and the facts to make moral platitudes appear that really have no foundation in reality. I never heard of this or I never heard of that.....total bulxlshit really.

Along with this unbelievably farcical and pretentious blithering right here:

On the other hand, there's a fear among many who aren't disposed toward guns, that SOME people buy with the the conscious or subconscious hope that somewhere along the line, they WILL have an opportunity to fire the gun in anger. You responsible gun owners KNOW I'm right.

To pretend that there are not dysfunctional people out there buying baseball bats, getting driver's licenses or even purchasing meat cleavers is just beyond the limits of immature thinking. The world is full of risk unless you want to grow up in a pen like mass produced pigs.....even then you would have to deal with the human version of PETA that would find danger in something....somewhere.
 
If the news report is accurate, yes the teen had no business in the garage, however there was no threat to life and no reason to shoot so Kaarma is, IMHO, (If the facts of the story are correct) guilty of possibly premeditated murder

**********
Markus Kaarma has been charged with deliberate murder in the Sunday killing of Diren Dede, 17, of Hamburg.

But he says Montana's self-defence law allowed him to shoot the boy.

Celal Dede said he would not have allowed his son to study in the US had he been aware of the lenient gun laws.

"I didn't think for one night that everyone here can kill somebody just because that person entered his back yard," Mr Dede told the German news agency dpa.
http://www.bbc.com/news/world-us-canada-27243115
Sort of off on a tangent here, but when I lived in Germany, it was near the height of America's violent crime problem, and there'd been this horrible rash of killings, in Florida, of German tourists. It was huge news there -- Germans have about three times as much vacation per year than Americans, on average, and a lot of disposable income, so they spend a whole lot of time traveling to places like Florida, and since many had grown up admiring and envying Americans, the idea that we had near-third-world-level violence problems hadn't occurred to a lot of them. The nature of the crimes was pretty horrific, too. Here's one account:

Barbara Jensen Meller, a 39-year-old physical therapist from Berlin, arrived in Miami Friday with her two young children and her mother. After picking up a red Ford Taurus from Alamo Rent-A-Car, she was heading from Miami International Airport to a Miami Beach hotel when apparently she became lost and pulled off Interstate 95 just north of downtown.

In a technique favored by smash-and-grab robbers, her car was rear-ended, and when Jensen got out to inspect the damage, at least two men attacked her and grabbed her purse. As they fled, they ran over Jensen with their car, crushing her head. Her horrified children and mother looked on.
​

The Germans ended up issuing official travel advisories for the US, similar to what you see in the US for people traveling somewhere like Beruit, to make sure that tourists understood what they were getting themselves into. Heading to Florida, wasn't like heading to a more civilized sun-and-fun destination somewhere like Spain, Greece, or Cyprus. Even with the warnings, though, German tourists kept getting killed:

The police said late today that they had arrested a 19-year-old man and charged him with murder and attempted robbery.

Mr. Rakebrand, a 33-year-old agricultural engineer from a small town near Hamburg, was on his way from Miami International Airport to a hotel in Miami Beach when two men in a light-colored van began ramming his car from behind. The police said his wife had just been reading a packet of safety tips for tourists when the ramming began, and she told her husband not to stop.

When he continued driving on, the van pulled alongside, and one of the men inside fired a single shot, hitting him in the back and making him lose control of the red Toyota he had just rented from Alamo Rent a Car
​
 
Teen guilty of stupid (Possible attempted theft) rated an ass whipping at most, not a killing and I agree that the kids dad must be stone stupid about firearms in the US

and apparently the dad doesn't know difference between back-yard and basement......
the guy that laid in wait and killed to teens that broke in got LIFE.
 
Back
Top