New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

This was a wrongful death

I put part of the blame for this on our common American perception - held by people ACROSS the spectrum, that when some steals our teevee, he's "violated" us personally.

I don't know if the dude had homeowner's insurance or not. Some might suggest that he shouldn't buy if if he doesn't want to! He has a right to spend his evenings lying in wait, gun in hand, to protect his own shit!

That may be true, but we do have free will and we should be able to weigh the costs of insurance against the "costs" of trying to defend our own stuff. Clearly, this guy has created a whole lotta legal blowback for himself. But, even in the case of an entirely righteous home defense shoot, I'm guessing that over time, the shooter kind of wishes it could've gone down differently.

If a stranger is in my home uninvited, they have "violated" me personally.
 
In the way back when nuckleheads used to steal car stereos, I had my car stereo stolen and my console damaged, right out in front of my apartment. That really pissed me off. But...I'd finally reached that stage in life where I actually had real car insurance. That insurance paid for a new stereo, console, and installation.

That didn't stop me from obsessing over it though. I lay awake at nights pondering schemes to catch that bastard! Then it finally hit me. That thief did me wrong, but I got a new stereo for free! So, why am I letting this jackass continue to "victimize" me by messing with my head?

Silly/sad postcript. When my agent gave me the check for that new stereo, he made it plain that if I wanted the new to be covered, I'd need to give him a receipt for that replacement. Makes sense - not too much to ask, hunh? Alas......I just never got around to it......

So a few months later when that (probably same) bastard stole my NEW stereo?.....I blamed myself.

couple of insurance claims usually brings about cancellation from insurance company.......the thief doesn't care.
 
The goal of a responsible gun owner should be that he never have to fire his gun in anger. It's sorta like that $1500 warranty I bought on the used truck I bought last year. I didn't by the warranty in hopes of having to use it! In fact, the best outcome will be if I never have to use it!

On the other hand, there's a fear among many who aren't disposed toward guns, that SOME people buy with the the conscious or subconscious hope that somewhere along the line, they WILL have an opportunity to fire the gun in anger. You responsible gun owners KNOW I'm right.

That's why I oppose these new SYG regimes. In my state - where we don't have specific SYG laws, I've never heard of a single circumstance - anytime, anywhere - of a righteous shooter landing himself in legal hot water. And, I've never heard of the opposite - someone declining to defend themselve righteously, out of fear of landing in legal hot water.

So...we don't NEED SYG laws. Shooters who fire righteously, are in the clear. The only one the SYG law serves, is the guy who wants official legal "permission" and blanket indemnification for shooting.

those warranty's usually aren't worth the paper they are printed on...........fine print is a killer
 
Hmmm looks like a reasonably intelligent Kid.... I see no signs of Downs or other obvious tells that one would normally look for in someone who is mentally disabled or retarded.

So what part of private property and tresspassing did this kid not understand when he
decided to study at the college level here in the US?

His death is his own fault.

You cannot have it both ways.

If the news report is what???? Is What???? Accurate? So now you think this man went out to the college campus, found the kid and then dragged him back there to shoot him I guess right?

You know what I think? I think he was looking for Bomb making materials.

Now let's talk about that shall we?


_74580641_74580636.jpg


Hmmm Can't help but notice the symbols of Islam there....now why does that not surprise me eh?

As far as entrappment is concerned I see no substantive difference whatsoever between what the homeowner did and what police do every day of the week with bait cars, officer/hookers, online posers as underaged girls, or anyone of a numbe of other white lie/fibs designed to bring out the crook, addict, or even murderer in people. Don't fuxcking steal, don' t fuxcking play the knockout game and don't fuxcking rape and kill people if you want to keep breathing......but I guess for some it's just too much to ask.

JO

thx for the info and picture...that brings a whole new issue to this shooting........
 
As far as entrappment is concerned I see no substantive difference whatsoever between what the homeowner did and what police do every day of the week with bait cars, officer/hookers, online posers as underaged girls, or anyone of a numbe of other white lie/fibs designed to bring out the crook, addict, or even murderer in people. Don't fuxcking steal, don' t fuxcking play the knockout game and don't fuxcking rape and kill people if you want to keep breathing......but I guess for some it's just too much to ask.

The kid wasn't a college student, he was a high-school exchange student.

This is the important stuff from the OP article (IMHO):

On the night of the shooting, Mr Kaarma and his partner Janelle Pflager left their garage door open, and Ms Pflager left her purse in the garage in order to bait intruders, she told police.

They set up motion sensors and a video monitor, prosecutors said.

When the sensors went off just after midnight and they saw a man on the monitor screen, Mr Kaarma went outside and fired a shotgun into the garage without warning several times.

The difference here is that cops don't arrest you until you actually steal the bait car. You don' get arrested as a john until you're actually down to pay for sex. You don't get arrested until you actually show up to meet the "underage girl." The cops don't shoot to kill any of those perps either. The kid in Montana hasn't even been accused of actually taking anything and having spent some time in Germany it's not uncommon for neighbors to look out for each other for example in case like, oh, I don't know, like when they see someone's purse sitting in an open garage?

Even if the kid did intend to steal, I don't have any sympathy for homeowners who invite criminal activity on their property.
 
those warranty's usually aren't worth the paper they are printed on...........fine print is a killer

I guess we'll see shortly! There's noise coming from my diff. that I KNOW means I need my traction-loc clutch pack replaced!
 
If a stranger is in my home uninvited, they have "violated" me personally.

Yeah...but what if you came home one night and found that some jackalope had made off with your teevee, like 2-3 hours before? Seriously...do ya feel violated?
 
couple of insurance claims usually brings about cancellation from insurance company.......the thief doesn't care.

Maybe you need a new insurance carrier. Usually what happens is that before they cancel you, they admonish you as to what you must do to keep your coverage - which usually involves contracting with one of those ripoff alarm "program" outfits.

Although....in perfect candor, I have to say that in the 27 years of owning my home, I've never filed a homeowners claim. And by God if I have my way, I'll NEVER buy an alarm!
 
If the news report is accurate, yes the teen had no business in the garage, however there was no threat to life and no reason to shoot so Kaarma is, IMHO, (If the facts of the story are correct) guilty of possibly premeditated murder

**********
Markus Kaarma has been charged with deliberate murder in the Sunday killing of Diren Dede, 17, of Hamburg.

But he says Montana's self-defence law allowed him to shoot the boy.

Celal Dede said he would not have allowed his son to study in the US had he been aware of the lenient gun laws.

"I didn't think for one night that everyone here can kill somebody just because that person entered his back yard," Mr Dede told the German news agency dpa.
http://www.bbc.com/news/world-us-canada-27243115

all the perp needs to do is say, "I was afraid for my life," and he'll get off....even if he's lying. thanks to SYG, the law pushed by ALEC/NRA/GOP.
 
Maybe you need a new insurance carrier. Usually what happens is that before they cancel you, they admonish you as to what you must do to keep your coverage - which usually involves contracting with one of those ripoff alarm "program" outfits.

Although....in perfect candor, I have to say that in the 27 years of owning my home, I've never filed a homeowners claim. And by God if I have my way, I'll NEVER buy an alarm!

they all the same...........dad (90) had same home owners for 40+ years......filed one small claim...cancelled............file a claim and watch how fast they drop ya.
 
Yeah...but what if you came home one night and found that some jackalope had made off with your teevee, like 2-3 hours before? Seriously...do ya feel violated?

yeah.and will feel violated probably rest of my life..............of course with my hounds.....the jackalope will probably be in the yard and funeral home needed to pick up the body........
 
all the perp needs to do is say, "I was afraid for my life," and he'll get off....even if he's lying. thanks to SYG, the law pushed by ALEC/NRA/GOP.

the guy that waited in his basement and shot two teens that broke into his home while he waited........got LIFE ...........86 your ignorance☻
 
the guy that waited in his basement and shot two teens that broke into his home while he waited........got LIFE ...........86 your ignorance☻
Don't waste your time with her Dawg, she's just here to spew lies and hate....
 
the guy that waited in his basement and shot two teens that broke into his home while he waited........got LIFE ...........86 your ignorance☻

Now that was a miscarriage of justice. Those kids, especially the Brady boy, had been breaking into that guys house for years and the cops knew that but left him to fend for himself anyway and then acted surprised when the homeowner finally snapped. Those kids got what they deserved.
 
Now that was a miscarriage of justice. Those kids, especially the Brady boy, had been breaking into that guys house for years and the cops knew that but left him to fend for himself anyway and then acted surprised when the homeowner finally snapped. Those kids got what they deserved.
Dude, that seems a little extreme..... breaking and entering and criminal trespass are not to minimized sure, but I'm not sure that an execution was the appropriate level of force to respond with. That seems like it would warrant an educational-beat-down, more likely.
 
If the news report is accurate, yes the teen had no business in the garage, however there was no threat to life and no reason to shoot so Kaarma is, IMHO, (If the facts of the story are correct) guilty of possibly premeditated murder

**********
Markus Kaarma has been charged with deliberate murder in the Sunday killing of Diren Dede, 17, of Hamburg.

But he says Montana's self-defence law allowed him to shoot the boy.

Celal Dede said he would not have allowed his son to study in the US had he been aware of the lenient gun laws.

"I didn't think for one night that everyone here can kill somebody just because that person entered his back yard," Mr Dede told the German news agency dpa.
http://www.bbc.com/news/world-us-canada-27243115


I certainly think that he used an unreasonable amount of force. On the other hand, the person had absolutely no business being on his property or in his garage. If you are going to tresspass, you take a big risk. And, in this case - the risk was he would be shot and he was. I do believe you have the right to defend your property - with a gun as well as just your person. If you don't want to risk your person... don't try to steal someone's property. When you make a colossal mistake in judgement like that - you could possibly be forfeiting your life.
 
Now that was a miscarriage of justice. Those kids, especially the Brady boy, had been breaking into that guys house for years and the cops knew that but left him to fend for himself anyway and then acted surprised when the homeowner finally snapped. Those kids got what they deserved.

apparently that part was left out of the TV report..of course it was and now I know why. thx
 
Dude, that seems a little extreme..... breaking and entering and criminal trespass are not to minimized sure, but I'm not sure that an execution was the appropriate level of force to respond with. That seems like it would warrant an educational-beat-down, more likely.

many of these teens are coming armed these days to break/enter..........evidently the ol' guy was in fear, but his actions and statements is what busted him for murder......said the girl was breathing hard or something as that and he did a clean kill shot to her head.......(my words of his) and it was like the next day before he had a neighbor call 9/11......IMO....Murder as well...............
 
Dude, that seems a little extreme..... breaking and entering and criminal trespass are not to minimized sure, but I'm not sure that an execution was the appropriate level of force to respond with. That seems like it would warrant an educational-beat-down, more likely.

I hear what you're saying and I would normally agree with you but he knew the kids were responsible for the earlier break ins and he had had guns stolen so he had every reason to believe they were armed and in his case he didn't bait his garage, those thieves were well inside his home.

I admit that my opinion in this case is at odds with the law but I don't care, those were definitely special circumstances.
 
I hear what you're saying and I would normally agree with you but he knew the kids were responsible for the earlier break ins and he had had guns stolen so he had every reason to believe they were armed and in his case he didn't bait his garage, those thieves were well inside his home.

I admit that my opinion in this case is at odds with the law but I don't care, those were definitely special circumstances.[/quote

Ok, but he's going to do time for this, regardless. "Self-defense" is a bitch of a defense to prove under any circumstances, let alone after he said all this stupid shit.
 
Back
Top