New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Thomas asked the right question

(CNSNews.com) - The U.S. Supreme Court heard oral arguments Wednesday in Dobbs v. Jackson, a case challenging the constitutionality of a Mississippi law that bans most abortions after 15 weeks of pregnancy.

U.S. Solicitor General Elizabeth Prelogar argued against the Mississippi law, saying the Supreme Court, in Roe v. Wade, "correctly recognized that the Constitution protects a woman's fundamental right to decide whether to end a pregnancy before viability.”

She concluded, “If this court renounces the liberty interest recognized in Roe and reaffirmed in Casey, it would be an unprecedented contraction of individual rights and a stark departure from principles of stare decisis," she said. "The court has never revoked a right that is so fundamental to so many Americans and sos central to their ability to participate fully and equally in society. The court should not overrule this central component of women's liberty."

Justice Clarence Thomas pressed Prelogar on what the specific "right" is that she's defending: "Is it specifically abortion? Is it liberty? Is it autonomy? Is it privacy?" Thomas asked.

"The right is grounded in the liberty component of the 14th Amendment, Justice Thomas," Prelogar said. "But I think that it promotes interest in autonomy, bodily integrity, liberty and equality. And I do think that it is specifically the right to abortion here, the right of a woman to be able to control without the state forcing her to continue a pregnancy, whether to carry that baby to term."

Thomas responded: "I understand we're talking about abortion here. But what is confusing is that we -- if we were talking about the 2nd Amendment, I know exactly what we're talking about. If we're talking about the 4th Amendment, I know what we're talking about, because it's written, it's there. What specifically is the right here that we're talking about?" Thomas asked again:

"Well, Justice Thomas, I think that the court in those other contexts with respect to those other amendments has had to articulate what the text means in the bounds of the constitutional guarantees, and it's done through a variety of different tests that implement 1st Amendment rights, 2nd Amendment rights, 4th Amendment rights.

"So I don't think that there is anything unprecedented or anomalous about the right that the court articulated in Roe and Casey -- and the way that it implemented that right by defining the scope of the liberty interest by reference to viability and providing that that is the moment when the balance of interest tips, and when the state can act to prohibit a woman from getting an abortion based on its interest in protecting the fetal life at that point."

"So the right specifically is abortion?" Thomas asked.

"It's the right of a woman prior to viability to control whether to continue with a pregnancy, yes.

"Thank you," said Thomas, ending that portion of his questioning.

Does this woman really believe she is smarter than Justice Thomas. Really?
 
(CNSNews.com) - The U.S. Supreme Court heard oral arguments Wednesday in Dobbs v. Jackson, a case challenging the constitutionality of a Mississippi law that bans most abortions after 15 weeks of pregnancy.

U.S. Solicitor General Elizabeth Prelogar argued against the Mississippi law, saying the Supreme Court, in Roe v. Wade, "correctly recognized that the Constitution protects a woman's fundamental right to decide whether to end a pregnancy before viability.”

She concluded, “If this court renounces the liberty interest recognized in Roe and reaffirmed in Casey, it would be an unprecedented contraction of individual rights and a stark departure from principles of stare decisis," she said. "The court has never revoked a right that is so fundamental to so many Americans and sos central to their ability to participate fully and equally in society. The court should not overrule this central component of women's liberty."

Justice Clarence Thomas pressed Prelogar on what the specific "right" is that she's defending: "Is it specifically abortion? Is it liberty? Is it autonomy? Is it privacy?" Thomas asked.

"The right is grounded in the liberty component of the 14th Amendment, Justice Thomas," Prelogar said. "But I think that it promotes interest in autonomy, bodily integrity, liberty and equality. And I do think that it is specifically the right to abortion here, the right of a woman to be able to control without the state forcing her to continue a pregnancy, whether to carry that baby to term."

Thomas responded: "I understand we're talking about abortion here. But what is confusing is that we -- if we were talking about the 2nd Amendment, I know exactly what we're talking about. If we're talking about the 4th Amendment, I know what we're talking about, because it's written, it's there. What specifically is the right here that we're talking about?" Thomas asked again:

"Well, Justice Thomas, I think that the court in those other contexts with respect to those other amendments has had to articulate what the text means in the bounds of the constitutional guarantees, and it's done through a variety of different tests that implement 1st Amendment rights, 2nd Amendment rights, 4th Amendment rights.

"So I don't think that there is anything unprecedented or anomalous about the right that the court articulated in Roe and Casey -- and the way that it implemented that right by defining the scope of the liberty interest by reference to viability and providing that that is the moment when the balance of interest tips, and when the state can act to prohibit a woman from getting an abortion based on its interest in protecting the fetal life at that point."

"So the right specifically is abortion?" Thomas asked.

"It's the right of a woman prior to viability to control whether to continue with a pregnancy, yes.

"Thank you," said Thomas, ending that portion of his questioning.

Does this woman really believe she is smarter than Justice Thomas. Really?
This woman is a moron. She has just been smoked by one of the most brilliant men to sit on that panel.
 
Prelogar said. "But I think that it promotes interest in autonomy, bodily integrity, liberty and equality.

When Brandon's VAX Mandate goes to the US. Supremes, these same progressive fascists will argue that autonomy, bodily integrity, liberty, and equality are racist white supremacist conspiracy theories.
 
Last edited:
She sure seems smarter. Her answers were awesome. Thomas got schooled.

;-)
In fact, what Thomas did was pin her down and make her own the fact that she is arguing specifically for a thing NOT mentioned anywhere in the Constitution (abortion). Initially (and repeatedly) in her argument, she did the usual dance of amorphous ambiguity - bobbing and weaving from “liberty” to “autonomy” to “equality”, etc. Thomas, by continually pressing for clarity and specificity, coaxed her into owning the central claim that she was avoiding: “abortion” is the basis or “right”.

Only the most ungifted of rubes and/or lying ideological hack would be unable to see/unwilling to admit this.

Thomas did well indeed. Prelogar was - for lack of a better term - owned in this exchange.

Now then, back to your 24x7 braindead hackery…
 
In fact, what Thomas did was pin her down and make her own the fact that she is arguing specifically for a thing NOT mentioned anywhere in the Constitution (abortion). Initially (and repeatedly) in her argument, she did the usual dance of amorphous ambiguity - bobbing and weaving from “liberty” to “autonomy” to “equality”, etc. Thomas, by continually pressing for clarity and specificity, coaxed her into owning the central claim that she was avoiding: “abortion” is the basis or “right”.

Only the most ungifted of rubes and/or lying ideological hack would be unable to see/unwilling to admit this.

Thomas did well indeed. Prelogar was - for lack of a better term - owned in this exchange.

Now then, back to your 24x7 braindead hackery…

You have to be dimwitted to think that colloquy led to any revelations.

You should know that the Constitution does not expressly mention most of the things that come before the courts in constitutional law. The internet? Not mentioned. Hanging chads? Not mentioned. AR-15’s? Not mentioned. Indeed, most of the things/processes the courts analyze aren’t even mentioned in the Constitution because they didn’t even exist when the Constitution was drafted. Thomas was merely harping on what smart people already know. But it seems to strike you as a revelation.

The abortion right is based on the liberty right that is the cornerstone of the Constitution. Does that right prohibit the government from forcing pregnant women to carry their pregnancies to term? You say no. Thomas says no. Most people say yes.

People like you inject your policy preferences into it and you get all confused. For example, do you think the government can lawfully prevent people from having heart surgery? Have broken bones fixed?
 
You have to be dimwitted to think that colloquy led to any revelations.

You should know that the Constitution does not expressly mention most of the things that come before the courts in constitutional law. The internet? Not mentioned. Hanging chads? Not mentioned. AR-15’s? Not mentioned. Indeed, most of the things/processes the courts analyze aren’t even mentioned in the Constitution because they didn’t even exist when the Constitution was drafted. Thomas was merely harping on what smart people already know. But it seems to strike you as a revelation.

The abortion right is based on the liberty right that is the cornerstone of the Constitution. Does that right prohibit the government from forcing pregnant women to carry their pregnancies to term? You say no. Thomas says no. Most people say yes.

People like you inject your policy preferences into it and you get all confused. For example, do you think the government can lawfully prevent people from having heart surgery? Have broken bones fixed?
Ahhh…things unforseseen, un-invented, and “unmentioned”’in the constitution. A boon to lefty when arguing for children to be butchered…a curse when lefty seeks to eliminate guns that aren’t muskets.

The world is dishonest lefty’s oyster, eh?
 
Ahhh…things unforseseen, un-invented, and “unmentioned”’in the constitution. A boon to lefty when arguing for children to be butchered…a curse when lefty seeks to eliminate guns that aren’t muskets.

The world is dishonest lefty’s oyster, eh?

Your pathetic dodge is noted, as always.

Ya got no game.
 
Republican mindset is fetus first, women last, yet if men could get pregnant, abortion would be a Sacrament.
 
Yep, lefty wants it both ways again.
Lesson to kids: don’t eat Lead Paint Chip Nachos.

Answer my questions or consider yourself vanquished. Again.

Your dodging is pathetic. At least try to validate your position. Your noise is boring.
 
Back
Top