New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Ticket to hell??

JV, you have a wonderful way of laying it all out.

Just my opinion, but I think of the passage of Thomas, who had seen and heard Jesus, and the miracles, and knew Him, would not believe that Jesus had risen from the dead. It seems to be a pure illustration and a deliberate lesson of Jesus' patience for those who doubt or don't believe. Thomas in that moment has no faith. And Jesus, who has been crucified, died and has risen, after going through all of that, is willing to let Thomas touch His wounds if that's what it takes for Thomas to believe. He doesn't reject Thomas because of what Thomas needs in order to believe. But rather, after Thomas is satisfied, (and we don't know if he ever touches the wounds or if his eyes are opened) He continues to include Thomas in the things He promised. This is the same Jesus who ascends to heaven and sits in judgement of all of us. He continued to count among His own, someone who had to see to believe.
 

Well, what isn't nonsense to you then?

You asked in your top post what happened to all those souls who did not know Christ ---- with the obvious implication to me that you are saying "what kind of God would send an innocent woman or child to hell just because they never heard of Jesus and therefore did not become a follower?"

And I answered it quite directly from Biblical sources that say clearly what you have implied is absolutely false. So don't drum that up as an excuse to doubt.
 
JV-12, why is it there are CLEAR, DIRECT references to "Heaven" and "Hell" in the Bible....

but we have to "de-code" passages to find "Purgatory"?
 
Well, what isn't nonsense to you then?

You asked in your top post what happened to all those souls who did not know Christ ---- with the obvious implication to me that you are saying "what kind of God would send an innocent woman or child to hell just because they never heard of Jesus and therefore did not become a follower?"

And I answered it quite directly from Biblical sources that say clearly what you have implied is absolutely false. So don't drum that up as an excuse to doubt.

JV, I think the problem is that gabriel started this thread to sort of raise the curtain on some cruelty or hypocrisy of God, and is probably disappointed that he's not getting the answers he expected. It's got to be hard to keep up the mean-angry-God-who-sends-innocent-people-to-hell thing when the answers you're giving him tell him that this just isnt' the truth. That's why it's nonsense.
 
JV, I think the problem is that gabriel started this thread to sort of raise the curtain on some cruelty or hypocrisy of God, and is probably disappointed that he's not getting the answers he expected. It's got to be hard to keep up the mean-angry-God-who-sends-innocent-people-to-hell thing when the answers you're giving him tell him that this just isnt' the truth. That's why it's nonsense.

Thanks, Gigi. In my opinion, you get it pretty well as do so many others. Gabriel, on the other hand, so wants it to be nonsense. So he sidesteps the reasons he is wrong and searches only for those things that, in some ways, appear to support his wish of denying Christ. Why someone would want to want the savior of the world to go away is beyond me.
 
JV-12, why is it there are CLEAR, DIRECT references to "Heaven" and "Hell" in the Bible....

but we have to "de-code" passages to find "Purgatory"?

Because it is obvious to me that if God made it clear that purgatory was a place of mercy for those who are lukewarm, careless and selfish, then the nature of man would be to do "just enough" to get in. It would stifle good works and God's work. Most strive for heaven or strive to avoid hell which is far more noble than just being lazy about it.

Not unlike why he does not tell us when the world will end. It would be saturated with fools who would party on up until a month before the second coming and then "get right with God" at least in their own little heads.
 
Because it is obvious to me that if God made it clear that purgatory was a place of mercy for those who are lukewarm, careless and selfish, then the nature of man would be to do "just enough" to get in. It would stifle good works and God's work. Most strive for heaven or strive to avoid hell which is far more noble than just being lazy about it.

Not unlike why he does not tell us when the world will end. It would be saturated with fools who would party on up until a month before the second coming and then "get right with God" at least in their own little heads.

I don't know why so many deny purgatory. It is a fact of God's mercy.
 
Because it is obvious to me that if God made it clear that purgatory was a place of mercy for those who are lukewarm, careless and selfish, then the nature of man would be to do "just enough" to get in. It would stifle good works and God's work. Most strive for heaven or strive to avoid hell which is far more noble than just being lazy about it.

Not unlike why he does not tell us when the world will end. It would be saturated with fools who would party on up until a month before the second coming and then "get right with God" at least in their own little heads.


So God had to LIE about Purgatory's existance, so that we wouldn't get "slack"? But He left enough "hints" in the Bible that the Roman Catholic Church (alone) was able to decipher that indicated that it DID exist...and they promoted the idea....

an idea that God didn't want anybody finding out about?!?!?!??
 
So God had to LIE about Purgatory's existance, so that we wouldn't get "slack"? But He left enough "hints" in the Bible that the Roman Catholic Church (alone) was able to decipher that indicated that it DID exist...and they promoted the idea....

an idea that God didn't want anybody finding out about?!?!?!??


Gordon, you sure ask a lot of questions, but I must say I am not impressed with the integrity of your position. It lacks honest scholarship. You just keep snipping away at the edges, but ignore the awful truth.
 
So God had to LIE about Purgatory's existance, so that we wouldn't get "slack"? But He left enough "hints" in the Bible that the Roman Catholic Church (alone) was able to decipher that indicated that it DID exist...and they promoted the idea....

an idea that God didn't want anybody finding out about?!?!?!??

It wasn't "the Roman Catholic Church alone" Gordon. It was all of Christianity until some people decided they didn't want to believe some things anymore. So they left and villianized Catholicism over those very things. As a result, it's in many of those offshoots, rather than in the original faith of Catholicism, that it's believed God is so likely to send non Christians (and Catholics) and sinners to hell. The more fundamental the religion is, it seems to me that the more God's power is limited to individual, specific sentences He spoke to us and the less merciful He is. Yet it's Catholics who seem to get this reputation for making God such a hard case. But really, throughout much of the reformation, Purgatory is replaced with simple belief that God is up there, Jesus is Christ, and that's about it requirement-wise. And if you don't get it and "believe on" it, you're doomed.

But backing up even further, Purgatory is something that comes from Jewish tradition, like much of Catholicism. OF course the Jews believe something different about that place in death where you wait until the Messiah frees you from it. But we do believe that in death, Jesus (the Messiah) descended to the dead and opened the gates of heaven for those souls waiting for him. There is discussion in passages in the Old Testament about the souls in death waiting. With Purgatory, again, you go from that state of being in death into heaven.

What we believe is God loves us very much and wants us with Him for eternity. He specifically told us what's important to Him as far as how we treat ourselves and everyone else. It matters to Him what we experience at the hands of each other and what we do to ourselves. Everything He tells us to do really boils down to submitting our own will to His. Doing His will instead of our own. It's through striving to do what He told us to do and striving to surrender our will to His, that acts of love, mercy, charity, friendship, etc.. .for our fellow humans come. If God reveals ALL of the mercy He's willing to extend each person ahead of time, we're gonna bank on it. It's just the way we are. Most of us are gonna go for the C and count on the curve. And that's going to affect what we do to ourselves and what we do to and don't do for each other. what we do here is very important to God. In heaven, everyone's wil is perfectly harmonious to God's. On earth, you work toward achieving that. But if you die before achieving that but still loving God, you have to continue that purification. You go to this state in death where your journey continues. God isn't rejecting you. He's recognizing that you still need to prepare for heaven.


And then, too, like we were talking about earlier, there are people who don't know God, but who have done all the things and treated their fellow humans the way God wants us to. They know who God is the instant they see Him. Their soul knows that's their home, that's Who they came from. Someone who didn't believe on earth doesn't necessarily go to Purgatory. In fact, it's believers who will be judged moreso than the people who didn't know God on earth.

If you look into purification in the Bible, you'll find the discussion of it and the warnings of the necessity for it.
 
Gordon, you sure ask a lot of questions, but I must say I am not impressed with the integrity of your position. It lacks honest scholarship. You just keep snipping away at the edges, but ignore the awful truth.

Sorry, JV...but calling me "stupid" even in a rhetorically flourished way like "you lack honest scholarship"....doesn't answer my point on how you logically contradicted yourself.

You said--


God didn't specifically declare Purgatory real in the Bible because it would allow people to not strive for Heaven or seek to avoid Hell.

BUT, since the Roman Catholic Church DOES endorse the idea of Purgatory and claim it as dogma, it thereby CONTRADICTS God...who wanted to keep Purgatory "secret" or whatever so that people wouldn't become spiritual "slackers".


The logical flaw is obvious. God wanted Purgatory left "unknown"...and the RCC violated that and made it popular.
 
Ticket to hell??

Oh...I thought you were talking about Obama Biden 12
 
gigi, I am specifically discussing JV-12's "explanation" for why Purgatory was not specifically and clearly noted in the Bible.
 
If the only way to heaven is thru christ, what happened to all those folks who died without ever hearing about him?

it's a tricky issue. e.g. we all know Pastor Jerry Falwell professed to be born again, yet we all know that he's burning in hell, too.
 
gigi, I am specifically discussing JV-12's "explanation" for why Purgatory was not specifically and clearly noted in the Bible.

Yes, I understand that Gordon. I think I discussed that in my long post. Sometimes I have to circle the airport a couple of times to illustrate the point.

ETA, if you look into purification.....you'll see this in the Bible.
 
If the only way to heaven is thru christ, what happened to all those folks who died without ever hearing about him?

and how about those unbaptized babies? the Church used to say they were stuck in Limbo, which is closer to the gates of Hell than the gates of Heaven, but now they're not so sure.
 
Back
Top